Advertisement

Journal of Banking Regulation

, Volume 16, Issue 2, pp 106–129 | Cite as

Greed, recklessness and/or dishonesty? An investigation into the culture of five UK banks between 2004 and 2009

  • Alison Lui
Original Article

Abstract

The author uses a multiple case study approach to examine five UK banks. The banks are Northern Rock, the Royal Bank of Scotland, Barclays, Lloyds Banking Group and HSBC. The author feels that it is appropriate to use a multiple case study here because it will be interesting to study the micro aspects of regulation and corporate governance of five UK banks. The banks have to comply with the same regulations and laws on a macro level, and therefore it is essential to examine the differences between these banks on a micro level through reviewing annual reports and financial ratios. The case study is longitudinal, spanning across 2004–2009. In accordance with the aims of a case study, the author will describe the effects of the financial crisis 2007 on five UK banks. This case study provides an opportunity to examine the weaknesses and failures of corporate governance of five UK banks at a micro level. The author has two hypotheses at the beginning of the study. First, banks moved from a customer-driven culture to a sales-driven one. Second, the banking culture during the 2004–2009 period was one of greed, recklessness and dishonesty. With the caveat that one should not make generalisations, there is evidence from the case study that both hypotheses are correct to a certain extent.

Keywords

banks corporate governance culture micro-regulation recklessness greed 

References

  1. Darke, P., Shank, G. and Broadbent, G. (1998) Successfully completing case study research: Combining rigour, relevance and pragmatism. Information Systems Journal 8 (4): 273–289.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Yin, R. (ed.) (2003) Case Study Research: Design and Methods. 3rd edn. London, UK: Sage Publications.Google Scholar
  3. Mulbert, P. (2009) Corporate governance of banks. European Business Organization Law Review 10 (3): 411–436.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Caprio, G. and Levine, R. (2002) Corporate governance of banks: Concepts and international observations. The World Bank, IMF and Brookings Institution Conference, Building the Pillars of Financial Sector Governance: The Roles of Public and Private Sectors, Washington; 5 April 2002, The World Bank, Washington DC.Google Scholar
  5. Adams, R. and Mehran, H. (2003) Is corporate governance different for bank holding companies? Economic Policy Review 9 (1): 123–142.Google Scholar
  6. Macey, J. and O’Hara, M. (2003) The corporate governance of banks. Economic Policy Review 9 (1): 91–107.Google Scholar
  7. Acharya, V.V., Philippon, T. and Richardson, M. (eds.) (2009) The financial crisis of 2007–2009: Causes and remedies. In: Restoring Financial Stability: How to Repair a Failed System. New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons, pp. 1–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Onado, M. (2009) The rise and fall of Northern Rock. In: F Bruni and D. Llewellyn (eds.) The Failure of Northern Rock: A Multi-dimensional Case Study. Vienna, Austria: The European Money and Finance Forum.Google Scholar
  9. Financial Services Authority (2011) The Failure of the Royal Bank of Scotland: Financial Services Authority Board Report. London: Financial Services Authority.Google Scholar
  10. The Parliamentary Commission on Banking Standards (2013) An accident waiting to happen: The failure of HBOS. In: Committee JS (ed.) London: HMSO.Google Scholar
  11. Masters, B. and Schafer, D. (2012) Letters come back to haunt HBOS. The Financial Times, http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/367d728c-3e35-11e2-91cb-00144feabdc0.html#axzz2EHziFljx, accessed 6 December 2012.
  12. Cecil, N. and Prynn, J. (2007) Northern Rock crisis sparks banking panic. Evening Standard, 17 September.Google Scholar
  13. Financial Services Authority (2008) Internal Audit on Northern Rock’s Collapse, 26th March 2008. London: Financial Services Authority.Google Scholar
  14. Alexander, K. (2006) Corporate governance and banks: The role of regulation in reducing the principal-agent problem. Journal of Banking Regulation 7 (1): 17–40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Bruni, F. and Llewellyn, D. (eds.) (2009) The Failure of Northern Rock: A Multi-dimensional Case Study. Vienna, Austria: SUERF Studies.Google Scholar
  16. Northern Rock Plc (2004) Northern Rock Annual Report and Accounts. London: Northern Rock Plc.Google Scholar
  17. Shin, H. (2009) Reflections on Northern Rock: The bank run that heralded the global financial crisis. Journal of Economic Perspectives 23 (1): 101–119.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Choudhry, M. (2011) Effective bank corporate governance: Observations from the market crash and recommendations for policy. Journal of Applied Finance & Banking 1 (1): 179–211.Google Scholar
  19. Northern Rock Plc (2007) Northern Rock Annual Report and Accounts. London: Northern Rock Plc.Google Scholar
  20. Grant Thornton (2012) Corporate Governance Review of 2012: The Chemistry of Governance. A Catalyst for Change. London.Google Scholar
  21. Northern Rock Plc (2008) Northern Rock Annual Report and Accounts. London: Northern Rock Plc.Google Scholar
  22. Milne, A. and Wood, G. (2008) Shattered on the rock? British financial stability from 1866 to 2007. Journal of Banking Regulation 10 (2): 89–127.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Hansard (2008) House of Lords, Vol. 705, col. 1443 (26 November).Google Scholar
  24. House of Commons Treasury Committee (2008) The Run on the Rock. London: HMSO.Google Scholar
  25. Dowd, K. (2009) Moral hazard and the financial crisis. Cato Journal 29 (1): 141–167.Google Scholar
  26. Burke, R., Cooper, C. and Martin, G. (eds.) (2011) Corporate Reputation: Managing Opportunities and Threats. England: Gower Publishing.Google Scholar
  27. O’Neill, O. (2002) Reith Lecture 2002. In: 4 BR, editor. A Licence to Deceive, London: BBC.Google Scholar
  28. Ratnovski, L. and Huang, R. (2009) Why are Canadian Banks More Resilient? International Monetary Fund, Working Paper/09/152, http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1442254.
  29. Moosa, I. (2010) Basel II as a casualty of the global financial crisis. Journal of Banking Regulation 11 (2): 95–114.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Kemal, M. (2011) Post-merger profitability: A case of Royal Bank of Scotland (RBS). International Journal of Business and Social Science 2 (5): 157–162.Google Scholar
  31. Royal Bank of Scotland Plc (2004) Annual Report and Accounts 2004. London, UK.Google Scholar
  32. Royal Bank of Scotland Plc (2005) Annual Report and Accounts 2005. London, UK.Google Scholar
  33. BBC (2009) RBS reports record corporate loss, http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/7911722.stm, accessed 25 August 2012.
  34. Royal Bank of Scotland Plc (2008) Annual Report and Accounts 2008. London, UK.Google Scholar
  35. Financial Services Authority (2013) RBS fined £87.5 million for significant failings in relation to LIBOR, http://www.fsa.gov.uk/library/communication/pr/2013/011.shtml, accessed 8 March 2012.
  36. Quinn, J. (2012) Stephen Hester: Banking culture change ‘will take a generation’. The Telegraph, 29 September.Google Scholar
  37. Ellis, V. and Taylor, M. (2010) Banks, bailouts and bonuses: A personal account of working in Halifax Bank of Scotland during the financial crisis. Work, Employment & Society 24 (4): 803–813.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Moore, P. (2010) Corporate Governance and Regulation of Banks. Thirsk, Yorkshire.Google Scholar
  39. Vickers, J. (2008) The financial crisis and competition policy: Some economics. Global Competition Policy 1: 1–10.Google Scholar
  40. Tyrie, A. (2012) Letter from Andrew Tyrie to Lord Turner of Ecchinswell, 13 September, http://www.parliament.uk/documents/commons-committees/treasury/A-Tyrie-MP-to-Lord-Turner-(HBOS-Final-Notice).pdf.
  41. Gardener, E., Howcroft, B. and Williams, J. (1999) The new retail banking revolution. The Service Industries Journal 19 (2): 83–100.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Moore, P. (2009b) House of Commons Treasury Select Committee Written Evidence Banking Crisis, http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200809/cmselect/cmtreasy/144/144w201.htm, accessed 10 October 2012.
  43. Treanor, J. (2012) Former HBOS chairman ‘lived in cloud cuckoo land’ before bank’s near collapse. The Guardian, http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2012/dec/04/former-hbos-chairman-lord-stevenson-mps?fb=native&CMP=FBCNETTXT9038, accessed 6 December 2012.
  44. HBOS Plc (2004) Annual Report and Accounts 2004: Making growth work harder for shareholders. London, UK.Google Scholar
  45. HBOS Plc (2005) Annual Report and Accounts 2005: Clear objectives, decisions, advantage. London, UK.Google Scholar
  46. HBOS Plc (2006) Annual Report and Accounts 2006. London, UK.Google Scholar
  47. HBOS Plc (2007) Annual Report and Accounts 2007. London, UK.Google Scholar
  48. HBOS Plc (2008) Annual Report and Accounts 2008. London, UK.Google Scholar
  49. HBOS Plc (2009) Annual Report and Accounts 2009. London, UK.Google Scholar
  50. Lloyds Banking Group Plc (2009) Annual Report and Accounts 2009: Creating the UK’s Best Financial Services Provider. London, UK.Google Scholar
  51. Lloyds Banking Group Plc (2010) Annual Report and Accounts 2010: Creating the UK’s Best Financial Services Provider. London, UK.Google Scholar
  52. Lloyds Banking Group Plc (2011) Annual Report and Accounts 2011: Becoming the Best Bank for Customers. London, UK.Google Scholar
  53. Moore, P. (2009a) Memorandum of further additional evidence to the House of Commons Treasury Select Committee relating to the banking crisis. In: Committee HoCT (ed.) UK: s.n.Google Scholar
  54. Wisskirchen, C., Vater, D., Wright, T., De Becker, P. and Detrick, C. (2006) The customer-led bank: Converting customers from defectors into fans. Strategy & Leadership 34 (2): 10–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Stephan, A. (2011) Did Lloyds/HBOS mark the failure of an enduring economics based system of merger regulation? Northern Ireland Legal Quarterly 62 (4): 539–552.Google Scholar
  56. Jenkins, P. and Jones, A. (2011) Lloyds shares sink to half bail-out price. The Financial Times, http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/344e168a-beb9-11e0-a36b-00144feabdc0.html#axzz27yfPMUYi, accessed 4 August 2011.
  57. Financial Services Authority (2012) FSA publishes censure against Bank of Scotland plc in respect of failings within its Corporate Division between January 2006 and December 2008. LondonNotice FSA/PN/024/2012, http://www.fsa.gov.uk/library/communication/pr/2012/024.shtml, accessed 6 December 2012.
  58. Osborne, A. (2013) Former HBOS chief James Crosby quits bridgepoint role after damning report. The Telegraph 5 April.Google Scholar
  59. Sunderland, R. (2012) No Jubilee for dismal Barclays: Banks’ shares are lower now than sixty years ago, but bosses pay has soared, http://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/markets/article-2156086/A-dismal-jubilee-Barclays-shares-lower-60-years-ago.html, accessed 7 June 2012.
  60. Jenkins, P. (2012) Barclays set for a change of course, http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/8e30d07a-c534-11e1-b6fd-00144feabdc0.html#axzz2B5USEHny, accessed 3 July 2012.
  61. Barclays Plc (2004) Barclays Plc Annual Report. London: Barclays Plc.Google Scholar
  62. Barclays Plc (2005) Barclays Plc Annual Report. London: Barclays Plc.Google Scholar
  63. Barclays Plc (2006) Barclays Plc Annual Report. London: Barclays Plc.Google Scholar
  64. Barclays Plc (2007) Barclays Plc Annual Report. London: Barclays Plc.Google Scholar
  65. Barclays Plc (2008) Barclays Plc Annual Report. London: Barclays Plc.Google Scholar
  66. Barclays Plc (2009) Barclays Plc Annual Report. London: Barclays Plc.Google Scholar
  67. Daly, J. (2012) The law cannot curb greedy bankers, but morals might. The Telegraph 7 July.Google Scholar
  68. Sikka, P. (2012) Bankers must be made to bear the cost of their reckless risk-taking. The Guardian, http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2012/nov/04/bankers-bear-cost-risk-taking, accessed 4 November 2012.
  69. Press Association (2011) Barclays fuels anger over Bob Diamond’s pay. The Independent 7 March.Google Scholar
  70. Treanor, J. (2012) Barclays chief Bob Diamond takes home £17m in pay, shares and perks. The Guardian, http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2012/mar/09/barclays-chief-bob-diamond-pay, accessed 9 March 2012.
  71. Barclays Plc (2010) Annual Report and Accounts. London: Barclays Plc.Google Scholar
  72. Slater, S. (2012) British bankers see average bonus shrink to 12,000 pounds. Reuters 19 September.Google Scholar
  73. Gregg, P., Jewell, S. and Tonks, I. (2012) Executive pay and performance: Did bankers’ bonuses cause the crisis? International Review of Finance 12 (1): 89–122.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Bebchuk, L., Cohen, A. and Spamann, H. (2010) Wages of failure: Executive compensation at Bear Stearns and Lehman 2000–2008. Yale Journal of Regulation 27: 257–282.Google Scholar
  75. House of Commons Treasury Select Committee (2012) Uncorrected Transcript of Oral Evidence: Corporate Governance and Remuneration in the Financial Services Sector. London: HMSO.Google Scholar
  76. Financial Services Authority (2012) Barclays fined £59.5 million for significant failings in relation to LIBOR and EURIBOR, http://www.fsa.gov.uk/library/communication/pr/2012/070.shtml, accessed 7 March 2012.
  77. BBC (2012) Timeline: Libor-fixing scandal. London, cited 20 September, http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-18671255, accessed 6 February 2013.
  78. House of Commons Treasury Select Committee (2012a) Fixing LIBOR: Some preliminary findings. In: Committee HoCT (ed.) London: HMSO.Google Scholar
  79. Luyendijk, J. (2011) Voices from the world of finance. The Guardian, http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/joris-luyendijk-banking-blog/interactive/2011/sep/15/voices-world-finance-interactive, accessed 19 October 2011.
  80. Luyendijk, J. (2011) Voices of finance: Risk and compliance consultant at a major bank. The Guardian, http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2011/nov/03/voices-of-finance-risk-and-compliance, accessed 3 November 2011.
  81. Goodway, N. (2012) California scheming? Barclays facing record $470m fine. The Independent, http://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/analysis-and-features/california-scheming-barclays-facing-record-470m-fine-8274667.html, accessed 23 November 2012.
  82. House of Commons Treasury Select Committee (2012b) Corporate governance and remuneration in the financial services sector – Written evidence. In: Committee HoCTS (ed.) London: HMSO.Google Scholar
  83. Walker, D.A. (2009) Review of corporate governance in UK banks and other financial industry entities. In: H. Treasury (ed.) London: HMSO.Google Scholar
  84. HSBC Plc (2012) Travel our UK timeline. London, http://www.hsbc.co.uk/1/2/about-us/history/uk-history?HBEU_dyn_lnk=OurHistory_UKTimeline_FindABranch_Link, accessed 29 November 2012.
  85. HSBC Plc (2007) Annual Report and Accounts. London: HSBC Plc.Google Scholar
  86. The Economist (2011) Gulliver’s travels: HSBC’s New Boss must Save a Great Firm from Mediocrity. London: The Economist.Google Scholar
  87. The Financial Times (2011) HSBC’s difficult year, http://media.ft.com/cms/b963cc60-a406-11dc-a28d-0000779fd2ac.swf, accessed 5 December 2012.
  88. Burgess, K. (2007) Critic fails to find allies. The Financial Times, http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/0e56bcba-9c8b-11dc-bcd8-0000779fd2ac.html#axzz2F2reSV53, accessed 27 November 2007.
  89. HSBC (2004) Annual Reports and Accounts. London: HSBC.Google Scholar
  90. HSBC (2006) Annual Report and Accounts. London: HSBC.Google Scholar
  91. HSBC (2009) Annual Report and Accounts. London: HSBC.Google Scholar
  92. US Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations (2012) US vulnerabilities to money laundering, drugs, and terrorist financing: HSBC case history. In: Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs (ed.) Washington DC: Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs.Google Scholar
  93. Dorner, I. (2012) Written Testimony for Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations, http://www.hsgac.senate.gov/subcommittees/investigations/hearings/us-vulnerabilities-to-money-laundering-drugs-and-terrorist-financing-hsbc-case-history, accessed 30 March 2012.
  94. Treanor, J. and Rushe, D. (2012) HSBC to pay £1.2bn over Mexico scandal. The Guardian, http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2012/dec/10/standard-chartered-settle-iran-sanctions, accessed 11 December 2012.
  95. BBC (2012) HSBC to pay $1.9bn in US money laundering penalties, http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-20673466, accessed 11 December 2012.
  96. US Department of Justice (2012) HSBC Holdings Plc. and HSBC Bank USA N.A. Admit to Anti-Money Laundering and Sanctions Violations, Forfeit $1.256 Billion in Deferred Prosecution Agreement, http://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/2012/December/12-crm-1478.html, accessed 16 December 2012.
  97. Financial Services Authority (2013) FSA publishes its Internal Audit Report on: Review of the extent of awareness within the FSA of inappropriate LIBOR submissions, http://www.fsa.gov.uk/library/communication/pr/2013/020.shtml, accessed 13 March 2013.

Copyright information

© Palgrave Macmillan, a division of Macmillan Publishers Ltd 2014

Authors and Affiliations

  • Alison Lui
    • 1
  1. 1.School of Law, Liverpool John Moores UniversityLiverpoolUK

Personalised recommendations