Agronomy for Sustainable Development

, Volume 28, Issue 1, pp 139–149 | Cite as

Agri-environmental indicators to assess cropping and farming systems. A review

  • Christian Bockstaller
  • Laurence Guichard
  • David Makowski
  • Anne Aveline
  • Philippe Girardin
  • Sylvain Plantureux
Review Article

Abstract

Environmental impacts of agriculture cannot be always assessed by using direct measurements. Since the 1990s, numerous agri-environmental indicators were developed to assess the adverse effects of cropping and farming systems in the environment, such as water pollution, soil erosion, and emission of greenhouse gases. Here we present the different types of indicators developed during the last decade and review the progress of the methods used for their development. The application of different groups of indicators is discussed and illustrated by examples in the fields of nitrogen losses and pesticide risk: (1) indicators based on a single or a combination of variables related to farmer practices, (2) indicators derived from operational or more complex simulation models assessing emissions of pollutants, and (3) measured indicators linked directly to environmental impacts. The nitrogen indicator (IN) of the INDIGO method and the MERLIN indicator will be presented and used to illustrate the methodological discussion. We show that a good identification of the end-users, of the practical objectives of the indicator, and of the spatial and temporal scales is essential and should be done at a preliminary step before designing the indicator itself. The possibilities of deriving an indicator from a model and of setting a reference value are discussed. Several methods are also presented to study the sensitivity and the validity of agri-environmental indicators. Finally, several practical recommendations are made. As only few data are usually available at the regional level, several simple indicators should be used for assessing a given impact at this level. When more detailed information is available, indicators based on operational models can be useful to analyse the effects of several factors related to soil, climate, and cropping system on an environmental impact. In experimental studies, we suggest using both measured indicators and model-based indicators.

environmental assessment indicators simulation model validation nitrogen pesticide 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Aimon-Marié F., Angevin F., Guichard L. (2001) Une méthode agronomique pour apprécier les risques de pollution diffuse par les nitrates d’origine agricole, Chambre d’Agriculture de Charente Maritime, La Rochelle, p. 29.Google Scholar
  2. Andreoli M., Rossi R., Tellarini V. (1999) Farm sustainability assessment: some procedural issues, Landscape Urban Plan. 46, 41–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Ardente F., Beccali M., Cellura M. (2004) FALCADE: a fuzzy software for the energy and environmental balances of products, Ecol. Model. 176, 359–379.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Arondel C., Girardin P. (2000) Sorting cropping systems on the basis of their impact on groundwater quality, Eur. J. Oper. Res. 127, 476–482.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Aurousseau P. (2004) Agrégation des paramètres et bases mathématiques de combinatoire de facteurs de risque, in: Barriuso E. (Ed.), Estimation des risques environnementaux des pesticides, INRA Editions, Paris, pp. 58–74.Google Scholar
  6. Basset-Mens C., van der Werf H.M.G., Durand P., Leterme P. (2006) Implications of uncertainty and variability in the life cycle assessment of pig production systems, Int. J. LCA 11, 298–304.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Bockstaller C., Girardin P. (2001) “IN”, an indicator to assess nitrogen losses in cropping systems, 11th Nitrogen Workshop, INRA, Reims, pp. 419–420.Google Scholar
  8. Bockstaller C., Girardin P. (2003) How to validate environmental indicators, Agr. Syst. 76, 639–653.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Bockstaller C., Girardin P., Van der Werf H.G.M. (1997) Use of agro-ecological indicators for the evaluation of farming systems, Eur. J. Agron. 7, 261–270.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Bossel H. (1999) Indicators for sustainable development: Theory, method, applications. USD International Institute of Sustainable Development, Winnipeg, Manitoba USA, p. 125.Google Scholar
  11. Braband D., Geier U., Kopke U. (2003) Bio-resource evaluation within agri-environmental assessment tools in different European countries, Agr. Ecosyst. Environ. 98, 423–434.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Brentrup F., Kusters J., Kuhlmann H., Lammel J. (2004) Environmental impact assessment of agricultural production systems using the life cycle assessment methodology — I. Theoretical concept of a LCA method tailored to crop production, Eur. J. Agron. 20, 247–264.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Brown C.D., Hart A., Lewis K.A., Dubus I.G. (2003) P-EMA (1): simulating the environmental fate of pesticides for a farm-level risk assessment system, Agronomie 23, 67–74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Carignan V., Villard M.A. (2002) Selecting indicator species to monitor ecological integrity: A review, Environ. Monit. Assess. 78, 45–61.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Clergué B., Amiaud B., Pervanchon F., Lasserre-Joulin F., Plantureux S. (2005) Biodiversity: function and assessment in agricultural areas. A review, Agron. Sustain. Dev. 25, 1–15.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Cloquell-Ballester V.A., Cloquell-Ballester V.A., Monterde-Diaz R., Santamarina-Siurana M.C. (2006) Indicators validation for the improvement of environmental and social impact quantitative assessment, Environ. Impact Assess. Rev. 26, 79–105.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Crabtree J.R., Brouwer F.M. (1999) Discussion and conclusions, in: Brouwer F.M., Crabtree J.R. (Eds.), Environmental indicators and agricultural policy, CAB International, Wallingford, pp. 279–285.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Delbaere B., Serradilla A.N.E. (2004) Environmental risks from agriculture in Europe: Locating environmental risk zones in Europe using agri-environmental indicators, EC NC-European Centre for Nature Conservation, Tilburg, The Netherlands, p. 184.Google Scholar
  19. Devillers J., Farret R., Girardin P., Rivière J.-L., Soulas G. (2005) Indicateurs pour évaluer les risques liés à l’utilisation des pesticides, Lavoisier, Londres, Paris, New-York.Google Scholar
  20. Douguet J.M., O’Connor M., Girardin P. (1999) Validation socio-économique des Indicateurs Agro-écologiques. C3ED, Université de Versailles Saint-Quentin-en-Yvelines, Guyancourt, France, p. 73.Google Scholar
  21. Durand P., Gascuel-Odoux C., Cordier M.O. (2002) Parametrisation of hydrological models: a review and lesson learned from studies on an agricultural catchment (Naizin, France), Agronomie 22, 217–228.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Eckert H., Breitschuh G., Sauerbeck D. (2000) Criteria and Standards for Sustainable Agriculture, J. Plant Nutr. Soil Sci. 163, 337–351.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. EEA (2005) Agriculture and environment in EU-15; the IRENA indicator report. European Environmental Agency (EEA), Copenhagen (Denmark), p. 128.Google Scholar
  24. Enea M., Salemi G. (2001) Fuzzy approach to the environmental impact evaluation, Ecol. Model. 136, 131–147.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Flemström K., Carlson R., Erixon M. (2004) Relationships between Life Cycle Assessment and Risk Assessment — Potentials and Obstacles, Chalmers University of Technology, Göteborg (Sweden), p. 82.Google Scholar
  26. Freyer B., Reisner Y., Zuberbuhler D. (2000) Potential impact model to assess agricultural pressure to landscape ecological functions, Ecol. Model. 130, 121–129.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Garcet J.D.M., Ordonez A., Roosen J., Vanclooster M. (2006) Metamodelling: Theory, concepts and application to nitrate leaching modelling, Ecol. Model. 193, 629–644.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Girardin P., Bockstaller C., van der Werf H.M.G. (1999) Indicators: tools to evaluate the environmental impacts of farming systems, J. Sustain. Agr. 13, 5–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Goodlass G., Halberg N., Verschuur G. (2003) Input output accounting systems in the European community — an appraisal of their usefulness in raising awareness of environmental problems, Eur. J. Agron. 20, 17–24.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Gras R., Benoit M., Deffontaines J.P., Duru M., Lafarge M., Langlet A., Osty P.L. (1989) Le fait technique en agronomie, Activité agricole, concepts et méthodes d’étude, Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique, L’Hamarttan, Paris, France.Google Scholar
  31. Gudmundsson H. (2003) The policy use of environmental indicators — learning from evaluaiton research, J. Transdisciplinary Environ. Studies 2, 1–11.Google Scholar
  32. Hansen J.W. (1996) Is agricultural sustainability a useful concept? Agr. Syst. 50, 117–143.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Hayashi K. (1998) Multicriteria aid for agricultural decisions using preference relations: Methodology and application, Agr. Syst. 58, 483–503.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Hertwich E.G., Pease W.S., Koshland C.P. (1997) Evaluating the environmental impact of products and production processes: A comparison of six methods, Sci. Total Environ. 196, 13–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Hess B., Schmid H., Lehmann B. (1999) Umweltindikatoren — Scharnier zwischen Ökonomie und Ökologie, Agrarforsch. 6, 29–32.Google Scholar
  36. Hülsbergen K.J. (2003) Entwickluung und Anwendung eines Bilanzierungsmodells zur Bewertung der Nachhaltigkeit landwirtschaftlicher Systeme, Shaker Verlag (Halle, Univ., Habil.-Schr., 2002), Aachen.Google Scholar
  37. Jollands N. (2006) How to aggregate sustainable development indicators: a proposed framework and its application, Int. J. Agric. Resources Governance Ecol. 5, 18–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Levitan L. (2000) “How to” and “why”: assessing the enviro-social impacts of pesticides, Crop Prot. 19, 629–636.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. López-Ridaura S., van Keulen H., van Ittersum M.K., Leffelaar P.A. (2005) Multi-scale methodological framework to derive criteria and indicators for sustainability evaluation of peasant natural resource management systems, Environ. Dev. Sustain. 7, 51–69.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Makowski D., Taverne M., Bolomier J., Ducarne M. (2005) Comparison of risk indicators for sclerotinia control in oilseed rape, Crop Prot. 24, 527–531.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Maud J., Edwardsjones G., Quin F. (2001) Comparative evaluation of pesticide risk indices for policy development and assessment in the United Kingdom, Agr. Ecosyst. Environ. 86, 59–73.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Maurizi B., Verrel J.-L. (2002) Des indicateurs pour des actions de maîtrise des pollutions d’origine agricole, Ingénieries 30, 3–14.Google Scholar
  43. Merkle A., Kaupenjohann M. (2000) Derivation of ecosystemic effect indicators — method, Ecol. Model. 130, 39–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Mertens M., Huwe B.U. (2002) FuN-Balance: a fuzzy balance approach for the calculation of nitrate leaching with incorporation of data imprecision, Geoderma 109, 269–287.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Meyer-Aurich A. (2005) Economic and environmental analysis of sustainable farming practices — a Bavarian case study, Agr. Syst. 86, 190–206.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Mitchell G., May A., Mc Donald A. (1995) PICABUE: a methodological framework for the development of indicators of sustainable development, Int. J. Sustain. Dev. World Ecol. 2, 104–123.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Nardo M., Saisana M., Saltelli A., Tarantola S. (2005) Tools for composite indicators building. Joint Research Center, European Commission, Ispra (Italy), p. 134.Google Scholar
  48. Oenema O., Kros H., de Vries W. (2003) Approaches and uncertainties in nutrient budgets: implications for nutrient management and environmental policies, Eur. J. Agron. 20, 3–16.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Oenema O., van Liere L., Schoumans O. (2005) Effects of lowering nitrogen and phosphorus surpluses in agriculture on the quality of groundwater and surface water in the Netherlands, J. Hydrol. 304, 289–301.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Payraudeau S., van der Werf H.M.G. (2005) Environmental impact assessment for a farming region: a review of methods, Agr. Ecosyst. Environ. 107, 1–19.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Pervanchon F., Bockstaller C., Bernard P.Y., Peigné J., Amiaud B., Vertès F., Fiorelli J.L., Plantureux S. (2005) A novel indicator of environmental risks due to nitrogen management on grasslands, Agr. Ecosyst. Environ. 105, 1–16.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Phillis Y.A., Andriantiatsaholiniaina L.A. (2001) Sustainability: an ill-defined concept and its assessment using fuzzy logic, Ecol. Econ. 37, 435–456.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Prato T. (2005) A fuzzy logic approach for evaluating ecosystem sustainability, Ecol. Model. 187, 361–368.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Primot S., Valantin-Morison M., Makowski D. (2006) Predicting the risk of weed infestation in winter oilseed rape crops, Weed Res. 46, 22–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Purtauf T., Thies C., Ekschmitt K., Wolters V., Dauber J. (2005) Scaling properties of multivariate landscape structure, Ecol. Indic. 5, 295–304.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Reus J., Leenderste P., Bockstaller C., Fomsgaard I., Gutsche V., Lewis K., Nilsson C., Pussemier L., Trevisan M., van der Werf H., Alfarroba F., Blümel S., Isart J., McGrath D., Seppälä T. (2002) Comparing and evaluating eight pesticide environmental risk indicators developed in Europe and recommandations for future use, Agr. Ecosyst. Environ. 90, 177–187.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Rigby D., Woodhouse P., Young T., Burton M. (2001) Constructing a farm level indicator of sustainable agriculture agriculture practice, Ecol. Econ. 39, 463–478.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Riley J. (2001a) The indicator explosion: local needs and international challenges, Agr. Ecosyst. Environ. 87, 119–120.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Riley J. (2001b) Indicator quality for assessment of impact of multidisci-plinary systems, Agr. Ecosyst. Environ. 87, 121–128.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Riley J. (2001c) Multidisciplinary indicators of impact and change — Key issues for identification and summary, Agr. Ecosyst. Environ. 87, 245–259.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Romstad E. (1999) Theorical considerations in the development of environmental indicators, in: Brouwer F.M., Crabtree J.R. (Eds.), Environmental indicators and agricultural policy, Wallingford, CAB International, pp. 13–23.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Rosnoblet J., Girardin P., Weinzaepflen E., Bockstaller C. (2006) Analysis of 15 years of agriculture sustainability evaluation methods, in: Fotyma M., Kaminska B. (Eds.), 9th ESA Congress. Warsaw, Poland, September 4–6, 2006, pp. 707–708.Google Scholar
  63. Rousseau M.L. (2003) L’évaluation de MERLIN, une méthode utilisée en Poitou-Charentes constituée d’indicateurs agro-environnementaux (EQUIF, IC, SENSIB), ESA Angers, p. 75.Google Scholar
  64. Sadok W., Angevin F., Bergez J.-E., Bockstaller C., Colomb B., Guichard L., Reau R., Doré T. (2007) Ex ante assessment of the sustainability of alternative cropping systems: guidelines for identifying relevant multi-criteria decision aid methods, Agron. Sustain. Dev. DOI: 10.1051/agro: 2007043.Google Scholar
  65. Shan Y., Pauli D., McKay R.I. (2006) Machine learning of poorly predictable ecological data, Ecol. Model. 195, 129–138.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. Silvert W. (2000) Fuzzy indices of environmental conditions, Ecol. Model. 130, 111–119.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Skeffington R. (2006) Quantifying uncertainty in critical loads: (A) literature review, Water Air Soil Pollut. 169, 3–24.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Stein A., Riley J., Halberg N. (2001) Issues of scale for environmental indicators, Agr. Ecosyst. Environ. 87, 215–232.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Swets J. (1988) Measuring the accuracy of diagnostic systems, Science 240, 1285–1293.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  70. ten Berge H.F.M., Burgers S.L.G.E., Schröder E.J., Hofstad E.J. (2002) ‘Partial balance’-regression models for Nmin,H, in: ten Berge H.F.M. (Ed.), A review of potential indicators for nitrate loss from cropping and farming systems in the Netherlands, Plant Research International B.V., Wageningen (The Netherlands), pp. 25–60.Google Scholar
  71. Van Cauwenbergh N., Biala K., Bielders C., Brouckaert V., Franchois L., Garcia Cidad V., Hermy M., Mathijs E., Muys B., Reijnders J., Sauvenier X., Valckx J., Vanclooster M., Van der Veken B., Wauters E., Peeters A. (2007) SAFE-A hierarchical framework for assessing the sustainability of agricultural systems, Agr. Ecosyst. Environ. 120, 229–242.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  72. van der Werf H.G.M., Petit J. (2002) Evaluation of environmental impact of agroculture at the farm level: a comparison and analysis of 12 indicator-based methods, Agr. Ecosyst. Environ. 93, 131–145.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  73. van der Werf H.M.G., Zimmer C. (1998) An indicator of pesticide environmental impact based on a fuzzy expert system, Chemosphere 36, 2225–2249.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. von Wirén-Lehr S. (2001) Sustainability in agriculture — an evaluation of principal goal-oriented concepts to close the gap between theory and practice, Agr. Ecosyst. Environ. 84, 115–129.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  75. Yli-Viikari A., Hietala-Koivu R., Huusela-Veistola E., Hyvonen T., Perala P., Turtola E. (2007) Evaluating agri-environmental indicators (AEIs) — Use and limitations of international indicators at national level, Ecol. Indic. 7, 150–163.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© INRA, EDP Sciences 2008

Authors and Affiliations

  • Christian Bockstaller
    • 1
  • Laurence Guichard
    • 2
  • David Makowski
    • 2
  • Anne Aveline
    • 3
  • Philippe Girardin
    • 1
  • Sylvain Plantureux
    • 4
  1. 1.UMR1121 INPL/ENSAIA/INRAINRAColmarFrance
  2. 2.UMR211 INRA/AgroParisTechINRAThiverval-GrignonFrance
  3. 3.Laboratoire d’Écophysiologie Végétale et AgronomieESAAngersFrance
  4. 4.UMR1121 INPL/ENSAIA/INRAINPL/ENSAIAVandœuvreFrance

Personalised recommendations