OBJECTIVE: To examine the influence of utilization review and denial of specialty referrals on patient satisfaction with overall medical care, willingness to recommend one’s physician group to a friend, and desire to disenroll from the health plan.
DESIGN: Two cross-sectional questionnaires: one of physician groups and one of patient satisfaction.
SETTING: Eighty-eight capitated physician groups in California.
PARTICIPANTS: Participants were 11,710 patients enrolled in a large California network-model HMO in 1993 who received care in one of the 88 physician groups.
MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Our main measures were how groups conducted utilization review for specialty referrals and tests, patient-reported denial of specialty referrals, and patient satisfaction with overall medical care. Patients in groups that required preauthorization for access to many types of specialists were significantly (p≤.001) less satisfied than patients in groups that had few preauthorization requirements, even after adjusting for patient and other group characteristics. Patients who had wanted to see a specialist in the previous year but did not see one were significantly less satisfied than those who had wanted to see a specialist and actually saw one (p<.001). In addition, patients who did not see a specialist when desired were more likely to want to disenroll from the health plan than patients who saw the specialist (40% vs 18%, p≤.001) and more likely not to recommend their group to a friend (38% vs 13%, p≤.001).
CONCLUSIONS: Policies that limited direct access to specialists, and especially denial of patient-desired referrals, were associated with significantly lower patient satisfaction, increased desire to disenroll, and lower likelihood of recommending the group to a friend. Health plans and physician groups need to take these factors into account when designing strategies to reduce specialty care use.
patient satisfaction access to specialists gate-keeping utilization management managed care
This is a preview of subscription content, log in to check access.
Greenfield S. Dividing up the turf: generalists versus specialists. J Gen Intern Med. 1996;11(4):245–6.PubMedGoogle Scholar
Mechanic D, Schlesinger M. The impact of managed care on patients’ trust in medical care and their physicians. JAMA. 1996;275(21):1693–7.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
St. Peter RF. Gatekeeping Arrangements are in Wide-Spread Use. Results from the Community Tracking Study. Washington, DC: Center for Studying Health System Change; 1997(7).Google Scholar
Kerr EA, Mittman BS, Hays RD, Siu AL, Leake B, Brook RH. Managed care and capitation in California: how do physicians at financial risk control their own utilization? Ann Intern Med. 1995;123(7):500–4.PubMedGoogle Scholar
Gold M, Hurley R. Role of managed care products in managed care plans. Inquiry. 1997;34:29–37.PubMedGoogle Scholar
Franks P, Clancy CM, Nutting PA. Gatekeeping revisited: protecting patients from overtreatment. N Engl J Med. 1992;327(6):424–9.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Greenfield S, Nelson EC, Zubkoff M, et al. Variations in resource utilization among medical specialities and systems of care: results from the medical outcomes study. JAMA. 1992;267(12):1624–30.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Forrest CB, Starfield B. The effect of first-contact care with primary care clinicians on ambulatory health care expenditures. J Fam Pract. 1996;43(1):40–8.PubMedGoogle Scholar
Jollis JG, DeLong ER, Peterson ED, et al. Outcome of acute myocardial infarction according to the specialty of the admitting physician. N Engl J Med. 1996;335:1880–7.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sturm R, Meredith LS, Wells KB. Provider choice and continuity for the treatment of depression. Med Care. 1996;34:723–34.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ayanian JZ, Hauptman PJ, Guadagnoli E, Antman EM, Pashos CL, McNeil BJ. Knowledge and practices of generalist and specialist physicians regarding drug therapy for acute myocardial infarction. N Engl J Med. 1994;331(17):1136–42.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Engel W, Freund DA, Stein JS, Fletcher RH. The treatment of patients with asthma by specialists and generalists. Med Care. 1989;27(3):306–14.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dillon EC, Sergott RC, Savino PJ, Bosley TM. Diagnostic management by gatekeepers is not cost effective for neuro-ophthalmology. Ophthalmology. 1994;101:1627–30.PubMedGoogle Scholar
Gerbert B, Maurer T, Berger T, et al. Primary care physicians as gatekeepers in managed care. Arch Dermatol. 1996;132:1030–8.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mitchell JB, Ballard DJ, Whisnant JP, Ammering CJ, Samsa GP, Matchar DB. What role do neurologists play in determining the costs and outcomes of stroke patients? Stroke. 1996;27(11):1937–43.PubMedGoogle Scholar
Gold M, Wooldridge J. Surveying consumer satisfaction to assess managed-care quality: current practices. Health Care Financing Rev. 1995;16(4):155–73.Google Scholar
Donabedian A. The criteria and standards of quality. In: Explorations in Quality Assessment and Monitoring, Vol. II. Ann Arbor, Mich: Health Administration Press; 1982.Google Scholar
Cleary PD, McNeil BJ. Patient satisfaction as an indicator of quality care. Inquiry. 1988;25:25–36.PubMedGoogle Scholar
Sherbourne CD, Hays RD, Ordway L, DiMatteo MR, Kravitz R. Antecedents of adherence to medical recommendations: results from the Medical Outcomes Study. J Behav Med. 1992;15:447–68.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
DiMatteo MR, Hays R. The significance of patients’ perceptions of physician conduct: a study of patient satisfaction in a family practice center. J Commun Health. 1980;6:18–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
DiMatteo MR, Hays RD, Prince LM. Relationship of physicians’ nonverbal communication skill to patient satisfaction, appointment noncompliance, and physician workload. Health Psychol. 1986;5:581–94.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Marquis MS, Davies AR, Ware JE Jr. Patient satisfaction and change in medical care provider: a longitudinal study. Med Care. 1983;21(8):821–9.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rubin HR, Gandek B, Rogers WH, Kosinski M. Patients’ ratings of outpatient visits in different practice settings: results from the Medical Outcomes Study. JAMA. 1993;270(7):835–40.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kerr EA, Hays RD, Lee M, Siu AL. Does dissatisfaction with access to specialists affect the desire to leave a managed care plan? Med Care Res Rev. 1998;55(1):59–77.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Davis K, Collins KS, Schoen C, Morris C. Choice matters: enrollees’ views of their health plans. Health Aff (Millwood). 1995:99–112.Google Scholar
Blendon RJ, Knox RA, Brodie M, Benson JM, Chervinsky G. Americans compare managed care, Medicare, and fee-for-service. J Am Health Policy. May/June 1994:42–7.Google Scholar
Murray JP. A follow-up comparison of patient satisfaction among prepaid and free-for-service patients. J Fam Pract. 1988;26(5):576–81.PubMedGoogle Scholar
Kerr EA, Mittman BS, Hays RD, Leake B, Brook RH. Quality assurance in capitated physician groups: where is the emphasis? JAMA. 1996;276(15):1236–9.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Davies AR, Ware JE Jr. GHAA’s Consumer Satisfaction Survey and User’s Manual. 2nd ed. Washington, DC: Group Health Association of America; May 1991.Google Scholar
Huber PJ. The behavior of maximum likelihood estimates under non-standard conditions. In: Proceedings of the Fifth Berkeley Symposium on Mathematical Statistics and Probability; 1967. Berkely, Calif: University of California Press; 1967:1:221–23.Google Scholar
White H. A heteroskedasticity—consistent covariance matrix estimator and a direct test for heteroskedasticity. Econometrica. 1980;48:817–30.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fincham JE, Wertheimer AI. Predictors of patient satisfaction in a health maintenance organization. J Health Care Marketing. 1986;6(3):5–11.Google Scholar
Mechanic D, Greenley JR, Cleary PD, Hoeper EW, Wenzel FJ. A model of rural health care: consumer response among users of the Marshfield Clinic. Med Care. 1980;18(6):597–608.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Weiss GL, Ramsey CA. Regular source of primary medical care and patient satisfaction. Qual Rev Bull. June 1989:180–4.Google Scholar
Hornbrook MC, Goodman MJ. Assessing relative health plan risk with the RAND-36 Health Survey. Inquiry. 1995;32(1):56–74.PubMedGoogle Scholar
Andersen R, Newman J. Societal and individual determinants of medical care utilization in the United States. Milbank Mem Fund Q. 1973;51:95–124.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ware JE, Davies AR. Behavioral consequences of consumer dissatisfaction with medical care. Eval Prog Plan. 1983;6:291–7.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Emanuel EJ, Neveloff-Dubler N. Preserving the physician-patient relationship in the era of managed care. JAMA. 1995;273(4):323–40.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar