Advertisement

Synthese

, Volume 141, Issue 2, pp 155–173 | Cite as

Introducing Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS) and its Property of Causal Inference in Investigating Brain-Function Relationships

  • Dennis J. L. G. Schutter
  • Jack Van Honk
  • Jaak Panksepp
Editorial Introduction

Abstract

Transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) is a method capable of transiently modulating neural excitability. Depending on the stimulation parameters information processing in the brain can be either enhanced or disrupted. This way the contribution of different brain areas involved in mental processes can be studied, allowing a functional decomposition of cognitive behavior both in the temporal and spatial domain, hence providing a functional resolution of brain/mind processes. The aim of the present paper is to argue that TMS with its ability to draw causal inferences on function and its neural representations is a valuable neurophysiological tool for investigating the causal basis of neuronal functions and can provide substantive insight into the modern interdisciplinary and (anti)reductionist neurophilosophical debates concerning the relationships between brain functions and mental abilities. Thus, TMS can serve as a heuristic method for resolving causal issues in an arena where only correlative tools have traditionally been available.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

REFERENCES

  1. Aleman, A., D. J. L. G. Schutter, N. F. Ramsey, J. Van Honk, R. P. C. Kessels, J. M. Hoogduin, A. Postma, R. S. Kahn, and E. H. F. De Haan: 2002, ‘Functional Anatomy of Top-down Visuospatial Processing in the Human Brain: Evidence from rTMS’, Cognitive Brain Research 14, 300–302.Google Scholar
  2. Amassian, V. E., R. Q. Cracco, P. J. Maccabee, J. B. Cracco, A. Rudell, and L. Eberle: 1989, ‘Suppression of Visual Perception by Magnetic Coil Stimulation of Human Occipital Cortex’, Electroencephalography and Clinical Neurophysiology 74, 458–462.Google Scholar
  3. Anand, S., J. D. Olson, and J. R. Hotson: 1998, ‘Tracing the Timing ofHumanAnalysis of Motion and Chromatic Signals From Occipital to Temporo-parieto-occipital Cortex:ATranscranial Magnetic Stimulation Study’, Vision Research 38, 2619–2627.Google Scholar
  4. Barker, A. T., R. Jalinous, and I. L. Freeston: 1985, ‘Non-invasive Magnetic Stimulation of the Human Motor Cortex’, Lancet 1, 1106–1107.Google Scholar
  5. Barker, A. T., I. L. Freeston, R. Jalinous, and J. A. Jarratt: 1987, ‘Magnetic Stimulation of the Human Brain and Peripheral Nervous System: An Introduction and the Results of an Initial Clinical Evaluation’, Neurosurgery 20, 100–109.Google Scholar
  6. Bechtel, W.: 2002, ‘Decomposing the Mind-Brain: A Long-Term Pursuit’, Brain and Mind 3, 229–242.Google Scholar
  7. Bestmann, S., J. Baudewig, H. R. Siebner, J. C. Rothwell, and J. Frahm: 2004, ‘Functional MRI of the Immediate Impact of Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation on Cortical and Subcortical Motor Circuits’, European Journal of Neuroscience 19, 1950–1962.Google Scholar
  8. Bickle, J.: 2003, Philosophy and Neuroscience: A Ruthlessly Reductive Account, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht.Google Scholar
  9. Bohning, D. E.: 2000, ‘Introduction and Overview of TMS Physics’, in M. S. George and R. H. Belmaker (ed), Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation in Neuropsychiatry, American Psychiatric Press, Washington, pp. 3–44.Google Scholar
  10. Burt, T., S. H. Lisanby and H. A. Sackeim: 2002, ‘Neuropsychiatric Applications of Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation: A Meta Analysis’, International Journal of Neuropsychopharmacology 5, 73–103.Google Scholar
  11. Chalmers, D. J.: 1996, ‘Facing up to the Problem of Consciousness’, in S. R. Hamerhoff, A. W. Kaszniak and A. C. Scott (eds), Towards a Science of Consciousness, MIT Press, Cambridge, pp. 200–219.Google Scholar
  12. Churchland, P.: 1992, ‘Reduction and the neurobiological basis of consciousness’, in A. Marcel and E. Bisiach (eds), Consciousness in contemporary science, Clarendon Press, Oxford.Google Scholar
  13. D'Alfonso, A. A. L., J. Van Honk, E. J. Hermans, A. Postma and E. H. F. De Haan: 2000, ‘Laterality Effects in Selective Attention to Threat After Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation at the Prefrontal Cortex in Female Subjects’, Neuroscience Letters 280, 195–198.Google Scholar
  14. Damasio, A.: 1999, The Feeling of What Happens, Harcourt Brace, New York.Google Scholar
  15. Daskalakis, Z. J., G. O. Paradiso, B. K. Christensen, P. B. Fitzgerald, C. Gunraj and R. Chen: 2004, ‘Exploring the Connectivity Between the Cerebellum and Motor Cortex in Humans’, Journal of Physiology, 557, 689–700.Google Scholar
  16. Dias, R., T. W. Robbins and A. C. Roberts: 1997, ‘Dissociable Forms of Inhibitory Control within Prefrontal Cortex with an Analog of the Wisconsin Card Sort Test: Restriction to Novel Situations and Independence from ‘On-line’ Processing’, Journal of Neuroscience 17, 9285–9297.Google Scholar
  17. Drevets, W. C.: 2001, ‘Neuroimaging and Neuropathological Studies of Depression: Implications for the Cognitive-Emotional Features of Mood Disorders’, Current Opinions in Neurobiology 11, 240–249.Google Scholar
  18. Epstein, C. M.: 1998, ‘Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation: Language Function’, Journal of Clinical Neurophysiology 15, 325–332.Google Scholar
  19. Fadiga, L., G. Buccino, L. Craighero, L. Fogassi, V. Gallese and G. Pavesi: 1999, ‘Corticospinal Excitability is Specifically Modulated by Motor Imagery: A Magnetic Stimulation Study’, Neuropsychologia 37, 147–158.Google Scholar
  20. Fitzgerald, P. B., T. L. Brown, N. A. Marston, Z. J. Daskalakis, A. De Castella and J. Kulkarni: 2003, ‘Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation in the Treatment of Depression: A Double-blind, Placebo-Controlled Trial’, Archives of General Psychiatry 60, 1002–1008.Google Scholar
  21. Fodor, J.: 1975, The Language of Thought, Thomas Crowell, New York.Google Scholar
  22. Fox, P., R. Ingham, M. S. George, H. Mayberg, J. Ingham, J. Roby, C. Martin and P. Jerabek: 1997, ‘Imaging Human Intra-Cerebral Connectivity by PET During TMS’, Neuroreport 18, 2787–2791.Google Scholar
  23. George, M. S. and R. H. Belmaker: 2000, Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation in Neuropsychiatry, American Psychiatric Press, Washington, DC.Google Scholar
  24. George, M. S., E. M. Wassermann, T. A. Kimbrell, J. T. Little, W. E. Williams, A. L. Danielson, B. D. Greenberg, M. Hallett and R. M. Post: 1997, ‘Mood Improvement Following Daily Left Prefrontal Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation in Patients with Depression: A Placebo-Controlled Crossover Trial’, American Journal of Psychiatry 154, 1752–1756.Google Scholar
  25. George, M. S., S. H. Lisanby and H. A. Sackheim: 1999, ‘Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation: Applications in Neuropsychiatry’, Archives of General Psychiatry 56, 300–311.Google Scholar
  26. Grabowski, T. J. and A. R. Damasio: 2000, ‘Investigating language with functional neuroimaging’, in. A. W. Toga and J. C. Mazziotta (eds) Brain Mapping: The Systems, Academic Press, San Diego, pp. 425–462.Google Scholar
  27. Grafman, J. and E. M. Wassermann: 1999, ‘Transcranial magnetic stimulation can measure and modulate learning and memory’, Neuropsychologia 37, 159–167.Google Scholar
  28. Harris, J. A., C. Miniussi, I. M. Harris and M. E. Diamond: 2002, ‘Transient Storage of a Tactile Memory Trace in Primary Somatosensory Cortex’, Journal of Neuroscience 22, 8720–8725.Google Scholar
  29. Hoffman, R. E., K. A. Hawkins, R. Gueorguieva, N. N. Boutros, F. Rachid, K. Carroll and J. H. Krystal: 2003, ‘Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation of Left Temporoparietal Cortex and Medication-Resistant Auditory Hallucinations’, Archives of General Psychiatry 60, 49–56.Google Scholar
  30. Horwitz, B. and D. Poeppel: 2002, ‘How can EEG/MEG and fMRI/PET Data be Combined’, Human Brain Mapping 17, 1–3.Google Scholar
  31. Iyer, M. B., N. Schleper and E. M. Wassermann: 2003, ‘Priming Stimulation Enhances the Depressant Effect of Low-Frequency Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation’, Journal of Neuroscience 23, 10867–10872.Google Scholar
  32. Klein, E., I. Kreinin, A. Chistyakov, D. Koren, L. Mecz, S. Marmur, D. Ben-Schachar, and M. Feinsod: 1999, ‘Therapeutic Efficacy of Right Prefrontal Slow Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation in Major Depression: A Double-Blind Controlled Study’, Archives of General Psychiatry 56, 315–320.Google Scholar
  33. Kozel, F. A. and M. S. George: 2002, ‘Meta-Analysis of Left Prefrontal Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (rTMS) to Treat Depression’, Journal of Psychiatric Practice 8, 270–275.Google Scholar
  34. Logothetis, N. K., J. Pauls, M. Augath, T. Trinath and A. Oeltermann: 2001, ‘Neurophysiological Investigation of the Basis of the fMRI Signal’, Nature 412, 150–157.Google Scholar
  35. Logothetis, N. K.: 2002, ‘The Neural Basis of the Blood-Oxygen-Level-Dependent Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging Signal’, Philosophical Transactions: Biological Sciences 357, 1003–1037.Google Scholar
  36. Maeda, F. and A. Pascual-Leone: 2003, ‘Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation: Studying Motor Neurophysiology of Psychiatric Disorders’, Psychopharmacology 168, 359–376.Google Scholar
  37. Mayberg, H. S. and S. McGinnis: 2000, ‘Brain Mapping: The Applications’, in A. W. Toga and J. C. Mazziotta (eds), Brain Mapping: The Systems, Academic Press, San Diego, pp. 491–522.Google Scholar
  38. McNamara, B., J. L. Ray, O. J. Arthurs and S. Boniface: 2001, ‘Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation for Depression and Other Psychiatric Disorders’, Psychological Medicine 31, 1141–1146.Google Scholar
  39. Nahas, Z., M. Lomarev, D. R. Roberts, A. Shastri, J. P. Lorberbaum, C. Teneback, K. McConnell, D. J. Vincent, X. Li, M. S. George and D. E. Bohning: 2001, ‘Unilateral Left Prefrontal Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS) Produces Intensity-Dependent Bilateral Effects as Measured by Interleaved BOLD fMRI’, Biological Psychiatry 50, 712–720.Google Scholar
  40. Nahas, Z., J. P. Lorberbaum, F. A. Kozel and M. S. George: 2004, ‘Somatic Treatment in Psychiatry’, in J. Panksepp, (ed.), Textbook of Biological Psychiatry, Wiley, New York, pp. 521–548.Google Scholar
  41. Neggers, S. F. W., T. R. Langerak, D. J. L. G. Schutter, R. C. Mandl, N. F. Ramsey, P. J. Lemmens and A. Postma: 2004, ‘A Stereotactic Method for Image-Guided Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation Validated with fMRI and Motor-Evoked Potentials’, Neuroimage 21, 1805–1817.Google Scholar
  42. Panksepp, J.: 1998, Affective Neuroscience: The Foundations of Human and Animal Emotions, Oxford Unviersity Press, New York.Google Scholar
  43. Panksepp, J., J. R. Moskal, J. B. Panksepp and R. A. Kroes: 2002, ‘Comparative Approaches in Evolutionary Psychology: Molecular Neuroscience Meets the Mind’, Neuroendocrinology Letters 23, 105–115.Google Scholar
  44. Panksepp, J. and J. B. Panksepp: 2000, ‘The Seven Sins of Evolutionary Psychology’, Evolution and Cognition 6, 108–131.Google Scholar
  45. Pascual-Leone, A., B. Rubio, F. Pallardo and M. D. Catala: 1996, ‘Rapid-Rate Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation of Left Dorsolateral Prefrontal Cortex in Drug-Resistant Depression’, Lancet 348, 233–237.Google Scholar
  46. Pascual-Leone, A., D. Bartres-Faz and J. P. Keenan: 1999, ‘Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation: Studying the Brain-Behaviour Relationship by Induction of ‘Virtual Lesions’, Philosophical Transactions in the Royal Society of London B 354, 1229–1238.Google Scholar
  47. Pascual-Leone, A., V. Walsh and J. Rothwell: 2000, ‘Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation in Cognitive Neuroscience: Virtual Lesion, Chronometry, and Functional Connectivity’, Current Opinion in Neurobiology 10, 232–237.Google Scholar
  48. Pascual-Leone, A. and V. Walsh: 2001, ‘Fast Backprojections from the Motion to the Primary Visual Necessary for Visual Awareness’, Science 292, 510–512.Google Scholar
  49. Paus, T., R. Jech, C. J. Thompson, R. Comeau, T. Peters and A. C. Evans: 1997, ‘Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation During Positron Emission Tomography: A New Method for Studying Connectivity of the Human Cerebral Cortex’, Journal of Neuroscience 17, 3178–3184.Google Scholar
  50. Phan, K. L., T. Wager, S. F. Taylor and I. Liberson: 2002, ‘Functional Neuroanatomy of Emotions: A Meta-analysis of Emotion Activation Studies in PET and fMRI’, Neuroimage 16, 331–348.Google Scholar
  51. Putnam, H. 1975, ‘The Nature of Mental States’, in W. Captain and D. Merrill (eds), Mind, Language, and Reality, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 429–440.Google Scholar
  52. Rees, G., K. Friston and C. Koch: 2000, ‘A Direct Quantitative Relationship Between the Functional Properties of Human and Macaque V5’, Nature Neuroscience 3, 716–723.Google Scholar
  53. Schutter, D. J. L. G.: 2001, ‘De Organische Resolutie van Cognitie: Een Polymorfe Systeembenadering’, Nederlands Tijdschrift voor de Psychologie 56, 106–118.Google Scholar
  54. Schutter, D. J. L. G., J. Van Honk, A. A. L. D'Alfonso, A. Postma and E. H. F. De Haan: 2001, ‘Effects of Slow rTMS at the Right Dorsolateral Prefrontal Cortex on EEG Asymmetry and Mood’, Neuroreport 12, 445–447.Google Scholar
  55. Schutter, D. J. L. G., A. A. L. D'Alfonso and J. Van Honk: 2003a, ‘Counterintuitive Antidepressant Properties of Slow rTMS over the Left Frontal Cortex: A Possible Mechanism’, Journal of Neuropsychiatry and Clinical Neurosciences 15, 243–244.Google Scholar
  56. Schutter, D. J. L. G., J. Van Honk, A. A. L. D'Alfonso, J. S. Peper and J. Panksepp: 2003b, ‘High Frequency Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation over the Medial Cerebellum Induces a Shift in the Prefrontal EEG Gamma Spectrum: A Pilot Study in Humans’, Neuroscience Letters 336, 73–76.Google Scholar
  57. Sober, E.: 1999, ‘The Multiple Realizability Argument Against Reductionism’, Philosophy of Science 66, 542–564.Google Scholar
  58. Stewart, L. M., A. Ellison, V. Walsh and A. Cowey: 2001, ‘The Role of Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS) in Studies of Vision, Attention and Cognition’, Acta Psychologica 107, 275–291.Google Scholar
  59. Strafella, A. P., T. Paus, J. Barrett and A. Dagher: 2001, ‘Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation of the Human Prefrontal Cortex Induces Dopamine Release in the Caudate Nucleus’, Journal of Neuroscience 21, RC157.Google Scholar
  60. Toga, A. W. and J. C. Mazziotta: 2000, Brain Mapping: The Systems, Academic Press, San Diego.Google Scholar
  61. Uttal, W. R.: 2002, ‘Précis of The New Phrenology: The Limits of Localizing Cognitive Processes in the Brain’, Brain and Mind 3, 221–228.Google Scholar
  62. Van Honk, J., E. J. Hermans, A. A. L. D'Alfonso, D. J. L. G. Schutter, L. Van Doornen and E. H. F. De Haan: 2002a, ‘A Left-Prefrontal Lateralized, Sympathetic Mechanism Directs Attention Towards Social Threat: Evidence from rTMS’, Neuroscience Letters 319, 99–102.Google Scholar
  63. Van Honk, J., D. J. L. G. Schutter, A. A. L. D'Alfonso, R. P. C. Kessels and E. De Haan: 2002b, ‘1 Hz rTMS over the Right Prefrontal Cortex Reduces Vigilant Attention to Unmasked But not to Masked Fearful Faces’, Biological Psychiatry 52, 312–317.Google Scholar
  64. Wassermann, E. M., L. M. McShane, M. Hallett and L. G. Cohen: 1992, ‘Noninvasive Mapping of Muscle Representations in Human Motor Cortex’, Electroencephalography and Clinical Neurophysiology 85, 1–8.Google Scholar
  65. Wassermann, E. M. and S. H. Lisanby: 2001, ‘Therapeutic Application of Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation: A Review’, Clinical Neurophysiology 112, 1367–1377.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2004

Authors and Affiliations

  • Dennis J. L. G. Schutter
    • 1
  • Jack Van Honk
    • 1
  • Jaak Panksepp
    • 2
  1. 1.Affective Neuroscience Section, Helmholtz Research InstituteUtrecht UniversityUtrechtThe Netherlands
  2. 2.J.P. Scott center for Neuroscience, Mind and Behaviour, Department of PsychologyBowling Green State UniversityBowling GreenU.S.A

Personalised recommendations