What is a teacher to do when confronted with a student who says “I understand that theory (e.g., evolution), but I don't believe it”? The purpose of this article is to provide a rationale for answering this question. First we describe the various ways in which the terms know/knowledge and believe/belief are used and summarize the distinctions commonly used to differentiate between these terms. Second, we propose that the primary goal of science education should be student knowledge and understanding, which we will argue typically (but not always) involves belief and typically (but not always) guides action. In those instances where a student evidences a meaningful understanding but still disbelieves, we further propose that the appropriate goal is for students to believe that the theory in question affords the best current scientific account of the relevant phenomena based on the available empirical evidence. Third, we evaluate instructional procedures for addressing the issues of knowledge, belief, and understanding recommended by recent authors before providing our own suggestions to teachers that we hope will be both more philosophically sound and more effective in the classroom.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in to check access.
Buy single article
Instant access to the full article PDF.
Price includes VAT for USA
Subscribe to journal
Immediate online access to all issues from 2019. Subscription will auto renew annually.
This is the net price. Taxes to be calculated in checkout.
Adler, J.E.: 2002, Belief's Own Ethics, The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
Alexander, P.A. & Dochy, F.J.R.C.: 1995, ‘Conceptions of Knowledge and Beliefs: A Comparison across Varying Cultural and Educational Communities’, American Educational Research Journal 32, 413–442.
Alexander, P.A., Schallert, D.L., & Hare, V.C.: 1991, ‘Coming to Terms: How Researchers in Learning and Literacy Talk about Knowledge’, Review of Educational Research 61, 315–343.
Alters, B.J.: 1997, ‘Should Student Belief of Evolution be a Goal’, Reports of the National Center for Science Education 17, 15–16.
Arons, A.: 1990, A Guide to Introductory Physics, Wiley, New York, NY.
Bishop, B.A. & Anderson, C.W.: 1990, ‘Student Conceptions of Natural Selection and its Role in Evolution’, Journal of Research in Science Teaching 27, 415–427.
Clouser, R.A.: 1991, The Myth of Religious Neutrality: An Essay on the Hidden Role of Religious Belief in Theories, University of Notre Dame Press, Notre Dame, IN.
Cobern, W.W.: 1994, ‘Point: Belief, Understanding, and the Teaching of Evolution’, Journal of Research in Science Teaching 31, 583–590.
Cobern, W.W.: 2000, ‘The Nature of Science and the Role of Knowledge and Belief’, Science & Education 9, 219–246.
Cooper, R.A.: 2001, ‘The Goal of Evolution Instruction: Should We Aim for Belief or Scientific Literacy’, Reports of the National Center for Science Education 21, 14–18.
Dewey, J.: 1910, How We Think, D.C. Heath, Lexington, MA.
Evnine, S.J.: 2001, ‘Learning from One's Mistakes: Epistemic Modesty and the Nature of Belief’, Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 82, 157–177.
Gauld, C.: 2001, ‘Knowledge, Belief and Understanding in Science Education’, in Proceedings of the Sixth Conference of the International History, Philosophy and Science Teaching Group.
Gess-Newsome, J.: 1999, ‘Teachers' Knowledge and Beliefs about Subject Matter and its Impact on Instruction’, in J. Gess-Newsome & N.G. Lederman (eds.), Examining Pedagogical Content Knowledge: The Construct and its Implication for Science Education, Kluwer, Dordrecht, pp. 51–94.
Good, R.G.: 2001, ‘Habits of Mind Associated with Science and Religion: Implications for Science Education’, in Proceedings of the Sixth Conference of the International History, Philosophy, and Science Teaching Group,Denver,CO.
Hart, H.: 1980, The Impasse of Rationality Today, The Association for the Advancement of Christian Scholarship, Toronto.
Hofer, B.K. & Pintrich, P.R.: 1997, ‘The Development of Epistemological Theories: Beliefs about Knowledge and Knowing and Their Relation to Learning’, Review of Educational Research 67, 88–140.
Körner, S.: 1966, Experience and Theory: An Essay in the Philosophy of Science, Routledge and Kegan Paul, London.
Lawson, A.E. & Weser, J.: 1990, ‘The Rejection of Nonscientific Beliefs about Life: Effects of Instruction and Reasoning Skills’, Journal of Research in Science Teaching 27, 589–606.
Lehrer, K.: 1990, Theory of Knowledge, Westview Press, Boulder, CO.
Milne, A.A.: 1950, The House at Pooh Corner, Dutton, New York.
Noddings, N.: 1993, Educating for Intelligent Belief or Unbelief, Teachers College Press, New York, NY.
Oliver, J.S. & Koballa, T.R.: 1992, ‘Science Educators Use of the Concept of Belief’, Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the National Association for Research in Science Teaching, Boston, MA.
Scheffler, I.: 1965, in M.L. Borrowman, I. Scheffler, & E.J. Shoben (eds.), Conditions of Knowledge: An Introduction to Epistemology and Education, Keystones of Education, Scott, Foresman and Company, Chicago, IL.
Shea, W.M. & Huff, P.A.: 1995, Knowledge and Belief in America: Enlightenment Traditions and Modern Religious Thought, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.
Siegel, H.: 1985, ‘What is the Question Concerning the Rationality of Science?’ Philosophy of Science 52, 517–537.
Siegel, H.: 1987, Relativism Refuted: A Critique of Contemporary Epistemological Relativism, Kluwer, Dordrecht.
Siegel, H.: 1988, Educating Reason: Rationality, Critical Thinking, and Education, Routledge, London.
Siegel, H.: 1997, Rationality Redeemed?: Further Dialogues on an Educational Ideal, Routledge, New York, NY.
Siegel, H.: 1998, ‘Knowledge, Truth and Education’, in D. Carr (ed.), Education, Knowledge and Truth: Beyond the Postmodern Impasse, Routledge, London, pp. 19–36.
Smith, M.U.: 1994, ‘Belief, Understanding, and the Teaching of Evolution’, Journal of Research in Science Teaching 31, 591–597.
Smith, M.U. & Scharmann, L.C.: 1999, ‘Defining versus Describing the Nature of Science: A Pragmatic Analysis for Classroom Teachers and Science Educators’, Science Education 83, 493–509.
Smith, M.U., Siegel, H., and McInerney, J.D.: 1995, ‘Foundational Issues in Evolution Education’, Science and Education 4, 23–46.
Southerland, S.A., Sinatra, G.M., and Matthews, M.R.: 2001a, ‘Belief, Knowledge, and Science Education’, Educational Psychology Review 13, 325–351.
Southerland, S.A., Sinatra, G.M., and Matthews, M.R.: 2001b, Belief, Knowledge, and Science Education, Unpublished draft of paper later published in Educational Psychology Review.
Strike, K.A. & Posner, G.J.: 1985, ‘A Conceptual Change View of Learning and Understanding’, in L.H.T. West and A.L. Pines (eds.), Cognitive Structure and Conceptual Change, Academic Press, Orlando, FL, pp. 211–231.
About this article
Cite this article
Smith, M.U., Siegel, H. Knowing, Believing, and Understanding: What Goals for Science Education?. Science & Education 13, 553–582 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1023/B:SCED.0000042848.14208.bf