Abstract
This paper reviews the debate between Carnap and Schrödinger about Hypothesis P (It is not only I who have perceptions and thoughts; other human beings have them too)–a hypothesis that underlies the possibility of doing science. For Schrödinger this hypothesis is not scientifically testable; for Carnap it is. But Schrödinger and Carnap concede too much to each other and miss an alternative understanding: science does not depend on an explicit hypothesis concerning what other human beings see and think; it is simply a practice of communication which anticipates or presupposes the perfect interchangeability of positions amongst the members of the linguistic community. The mentalistic vocabulary of folk-psychology, used by Carnap and Schrödinger, does not take first but last place in this perspective; because it does nothing but express after the event the confidence to which the disputants bear witness regarding a generally successful practice of communication.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bouveresse, J. 1987. Le mythe de l'intériorité. Minuit.
Carnap, R. 1936. Existe-t-il des prémisses de la science qui soient incontrôlables? Scienta 60: 129-135.
Carnap, R. 1958. Meaning and Necessity. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Carnap, R. 1967. The Logical Structure of the World. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
Nef, F. 1992. A propos d'une controverse entre Carnap et Schrödinger. In: M. Bitbol and O. Darrigol (eds), Erwin Schrödinger: Philosophy and the Birth of Quantum Mechanics. Paris: Editions Frontières.
Schrödinger, E. 1935. Quelques remarques au sujet des bases de la connaissance scientifique. Scientia 57: 181-191.
Schrödinger, E. 1948. Nature and the Greeks. Cambridge University Press (French translation, La nature et les Grecs, prefaced by La clôture de la représentation. Trans. M. Bitbol, Seuil, 1992).
Schr¨odinger, E. 1967a. Mind and Matter (with What is life?). Cambridge University Press (French translation, L'esprit et la matière, prefaced by L'élision. Trans. M. Bitbol, Seuil, 1990).
Schrödinger, E. 1967b. Letter to W. Wien 25 August 1926. In: K. Przibram (ed), Letters in Wave Mechanics. New York: Philosophical Library, 1967.
Searle, J. 1983. Intentionality. Cambridge University Press.
Wittgenstein, L. 1969. On Certainty. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bitbol, M. The problem of other minds: A debate between Schrödinger and Carnap. Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences 3, 115–123 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1023/B:PHEN.0000041896.22717.d6
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/B:PHEN.0000041896.22717.d6