Abstract
Optimal management of pineal region tumors depends on securing an accurate histologic diagnosis to facilitate management customized to the nuances of specific pathologies. As an initial step, surgical intervention by either stereotactic biopsy or open surgery is necessary to obtain tissue for pathologic examination. Stereotactic biopsy has the benefit of relative ease and minimal morbidity but is associated with greater likelihood of diagnostic inaccuracy compared to open surgery where more extensive tissue sampling is possible.
The role of surgical debulking in the management of pineal tumors is clearly defined for some tumors but is less evident for others. Among the one third of pineal tumors that are benign or low grade, complete surgical resection is achievable and constitutes optimal management with excellent long-term recurrence-free survival. The benefits of aggressive surgical resection among malignant tumors are less clear but several studies have correlated degree of tumor removal with improved outcome.
Advances in technology, surgical technique, and post-operative care have minimized surgical complications, however all surgical procedures in the pineal region, including both stereotactic biopsy and open surgery, are potentially hazardous. Advanced judgment, experience, and expertise are necessary to achieve rates of success sufficient to justify aggressive management. Management strategies using stereotactic biopsy, endoscopy, and radiosurgery can also provide favorable outcomes in some cases. Selective incorporation of these innovations can be expected to improve the already highly favorable outcome for all pineal region tumors.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Dandy W: Operative experience in cases of pineal tumor. Arch Surg 33: 19–46, 1936
Cushing H: Intracranial tumors: notes upon a series of two thousand veri ed cases with surgical mortality pertaining thereto. Charles C. Thomas, Springfield, IL. 1932
Dandy W: An operation for the removal of pineal tumors. Surg, Gynecol, Obstet 33: 113–119, 1921
Rorschach H: Zur pathologie und operabilitat der zirbeldruse. Beitr z klin Chir 83: 451, 1913
Pruusep: Das operative Entfernung einer Zyste der Glandula pinealis. Neurol Centralbl 53: 560, 1914
Kahn E: Surgical treatment of pineal tumor. Arch Neuro Psychiat 38: 833, 1937
Foerster O: Das operative Vorgehen bei Tumoren der Vierhugelgegend. Wien klin Echnschr 41: 986, 1928
Sachs E: The diagnosis and treatment of brain tumors. V. Mosby Company, St. Louis, 1931, p 276
Harris WC, H: Diagnosis and treatment of pineal tumors. Lancet 1: 3–9, 1932
McLean A: Pineal teratomas, with report of case of operative removal. Surg, Gynecol, Obste 61: 523, 1935
Wagenen V: A surgical approach for the removal of certain pineal tumors. Surg, Gynecol, Obstet 37: 216–220, 1931
Horrax G: Extirpation of a huge pinealoma from a patient with pubertas praecox: a new operative approach. Arch Neuro Psychiat 37: 385, 1937
Horrax G: Treatment of tumors of the pineal body. Experience in a series of twenty-two cases. Arch Neurol Psychiat 64: 227–242, 1950
Kunicki A: Operative experiences in 8 cases of pineal tumor. J Neurosurg 17: 815–823, 1960
Suzuki J, Iwabuchi T: Surgical removal of pineal tumors pinealomas and teratomas. Experience in a series of 19 cases. J Neurosurg 23 (6): 565–571, 1965
Poppen JL: The right occipital approach to a pinealoma. J Neurosurg 25 (6): 706–710, 1966
Jenkin RD, Simpson WJ, Keen CW: Pineal and suprasellar germinomas. Results of radiation treatment. J Neurosurg 48 (1): 99–107, 1978
Abay EO II, Laws ER Jr, Grado GL, Bruckman JE, Forbes GS, Gomez MR, Scott M: Pineal tumors in children and adolescents. Treatment by CSF shunting and radiotherapy. J Neurosurg 55 (6): 889–895, 1981
Marsh WR, Laws ER Jr: Shunting and irradiation of pineal tumors. Clin Neurosurg 32: 384–396, 1985
Stein BM: The infratentorial supracerebellar approach to pineal lesions. J Neurosurg 35 (2): 197–202, 1971
Jamieson KG: Excision of pineal tumors. J Neurosurg 35 (5): 550–553, 1971
Kreth FW, Schatz CR, Pagenstecher A, Faist M, Volk, B, Ostertag CB: Stereotactic management of lesions of the pineal region. Neurosurgery 39 (2): 280–289, discussion 9–91, 1996
Regis J, Bouillot P, Rouby-Volot F, Figarella-Branger D, Dufour H, Peragut JC: Pineal region tumors and the role of stereotactic biopsy: review of the mortality, morbidity, and diagnostic rates in 370 cases. Neurosurgery 39 (5): 907–912, discussion 12–14, 1996
Favre J, Taha JM, Burchiel KJ: An analysis of the respective risks of hematoma formation in 361 consecutive morphological and functional stereotactic procedures. Neurosurgery 50 (1): 48–56, discussion-7, 2002
Field M, Witham TF, Flickinger JC, Kondziolka D, Lunsford LD: Comprehensive assessment of hemorrhage risks and outcomes after stereotactic brain biopsy. J Neurosurg 94 (4): 545–551, 2001
Sawin PD, Hitchon PW, Follett KA, Torner JC: Computed imaging-assisted stereotactic brain biopsy: a risk analysis of 225 consecutive cases. Surg Neurol 49 (6): 640–649, 1998
Bruce JN: Management of pineal region tumors. Neurosurg Quart 3: 103–119, 1993
Stein BM, Bruce JN: Surgical management of pineal region tumors honored guest lecture. Clin Neurosurg 39: 509–532, 1992
Bruce JN: Pineal tumors. In: Winn H (ed), Youman ‘s Neurological Surgery. WB Saunders Company, Philadelphia, 2004, pp 1011–1029
Weiner HL, Finlay JL: Surgery in the management of primary intracranial germ cell tumors. Childs Nerv Syst 15: 11–12, 770–773, 1999
Choi JU, Kim DS, Chung SS, Kim TS: Treatment of germ cell tumors in the pineal region. Childs Nerv Syst 14: 1–2: 41–48, 1998
Goodman R: Magnetic resonance imaging-directed stereotactic endoscopic third ventriculostomy. Neurosurgery 32: 1043–1047, 1993
Bruce JN, Stein BM: Surgical management of pineal region tumors. Acta Neurochir (Wien)134 (3–4): 130–135, 1995
Dempsey PK, Kondziolka D, Lunsford LD: Stereotactic diagnosis and treatment of pineal region tumours and vascular malformations. Acta Neurochir (Wien)116 (1): 14–22, 1992
Edwards MS, Hudgins RJ, Wilson CB, Levin VA, Wara WM: Pineal region tumors in children. J Neurosurg 68 (5): 689–697, 1988
Fauchon F, Jouvet A, Paquis P, Saint-Pierre G, Mottolese C, Ben Hassel M, Chauveinc L, Sichez JP, Philippon J, Schlienger M, Bouffet E: Parenchymal pineal tumors: a clinicopathological study of 76 cases. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 46 (4): 959–968, 2000
Neuwelt EA: An update on the surgical treatment of malignant pineal region tumors. Clin Neurosurg 32: 397–428, 1985
Pluchino F, Broggi G, Fornari M, Franzini A, Solero CL, Allegranza A: Surgical approach to pineal tumours. Acta Neurochir (Wien)96 (1–2): 26–31, 1989
Stein BM: Supracerebellar-infratentorial approach to pineal tumors. Surg Neurol 11 (5): 331–337, 1979
Lapras C, Patet JD, Mottolese C, Lapras C Jr: Direct surgery for pineal tumors: occipital-transtentorial approach. Prog Exp Tumor Res 30: 268–280, 1987
Konovalov AN, Pitskhelauri DI: Principles of treatment of the pineal region tumors. Surg Neurol 59 (4): 250–268, 2003
Schild SE, Scheithauer BW, Haddock MG, Wong WW, Lyons MK, Marks LB, Norman MG, Burger PC: Histologically confirmed pineal tumors and other germ cell tumors of the brain. Cancer 78 (12): 2564–2571, 1996
MacKay CI, Baeesa SS, Ventureyra EC: Epidermoid cysts of the pineal region. Childs Nerv Syst 15 (4): 170–178, 1999
Chandy MJ, Damaraju SC: Benign tumours of the pineal region: a prospective study from 1983 to 1997. Br J Neurosurg 12 (3): 228–233, 1998
Matsutani M, Sano K, Takakura K, Fujimaki T, Nakamura O, Funata N, Seto T: Primary intracranial germ cell tumors: a clinical analysis of 153 histologically verified cases. J Neurosurg 86 (3): 446–455, 1997
Vaquero J, Ramiro J, Martinez R, Coca S, Bravo G: Clinicopathological experience with pineocytomas: report of five surgically treated cases. Neurosurgery 27 (4): 612–618, discussion 8–9, 1990
Schild SE, Scheithauer BW, Schomberg PJ, Hook CC, Kelly PJ, Frick L, Robinow JS, Buskirk SJ: Pineal parenchymal tumors. Clinical, pathologic, and therapeutic aspects. Cancer 72 (3): 870–880, 1993
Barnett DW, Olson JJ, Thomas WG, Hunter SB: Low-grade astrocytomas arising from the pineal gland. Surg Neurol 43 (1): 70–75, discussion 5–6, 1995
Kraichoke S, Cosgrove M, Chandrasoma PT: Granulomatous inflammation in pineal germinoma. A cause of diagnostic failure at stereotaxic brain biopsy. Am J Surg Pathol 12 (9): 655–660, 1988
Lutterbach J, Fauchon F, Schild SE, Chang SM, Pagenstecher A, Volk B, Ostertag C, Momm F, Jouvet A: Malignant pineal parenchymal tumors in adult patients: patterns of care and prognostic factors. Neurosurgery 51 (1): 44–55, discussion-6, 2002
Mena H, Rushing EJ, Ribas JL, Delahunt B, McCarthy WF: Tumors of pineal parenchymal cells: a correlation of histological features, including nucleolar organizer regions, with survival in 35 cases. Hum Pathol 26 (1): 20–30, 1995
Reddy AT, Janss AJ, Phillips PC, Weiss HL, Packer RJ: Outcome for children with supratentorial primitive neuroectodermal tumors treated with surgery, radiation, and chemotherapy. Cancer 88 (9): 2189–2193, 2000
Hasegawa T, Kondziolka D, Hadjipanayis CG, Flickinger JC, Lunsford LD: The role of radiosurgery for the treatment of pineal parenchymal tumors. Neurosurgery 51 (4): 880–889, 2002
Peragut JC, Dupard T, Graziani N, Sedan R: De la pre’vention des risques de la biopsie ste’re’otaxique de certaines tumeurs de la re’gion pine’ale: a propos de 3 observations. Neurochirurgie 33: 23–27, 1987
Pecker J, Scarabin JM, Vallee B, Brucher JM: Treatment in tumours of the pineal region: value of sterotaxic biopsy. Surg Neurol 12 (4): 341–348, 1979
Raco A, Raimondi AJ, Ds’Alonzo A, Esposito V, Valentino V: Radiosurgery in the management of pediatric brain tumors. Childs Nerv Syst 16 (5): 287–295, 2000
Kobayashi T, Kida Y, Mori Y: Stereotactic gamma radiosurgery for pineal and related tumors. J Neurooncol 54 (3): 301–309, 2001
Hasegawa T, Kondziolka D, Hadjipanayis CG, Flickinger JC, Lunsford LD: Stereotactic radiosurgery for CNS nongerminomatous germ cell tumors. Report of four cases. Pediatr Neurosurg 38 (6): 329–333, 2003
Manera L, Regis J, Chinot O, Porcheron D, Levrier O, Farnarier P, Peragut JC: Pineal region tumors: the role of stereotactic radiosurgery. Stereotact Funct Neurosurg 66 (Suppl 1): 164–173, 1996
Maciunas R: Stereotactic biopsy of pineal region lesions. In: Kaye A, Black P (eds), Operative Neurosurgery. Churchill Livingstone, London, 2000, pp 841–845
Pople IK, Athanasiou TC, Sandeman DR, Coakham HB: The role of endoscopic biopsy and third ventriculostomy in the management of pineal region tumours. Br J Neurosurg 15 (4): 305–311, 2001
Gangemi M, Maiuri F, Colella G, Buonamassa S: Endoscopic surgery for pineal region tumors. Minim Invasive Neurosurg 44 (2): 70–73, 2001
Ferrer E, Santamarta D, Garcia-Fructuoso G, Caral L, Rumia J: Neuroendoscopic management of pineal region tumours. Acta Neurochir (Wien)139 (1): 12–20, discussion-1, 1997
Oi S, Kamio M, Joki T, Abe T: Neuroendoscopic anatomy and surgery in pineal region tumors: role of neuroendoscopic procedure in the ‘minimally-invasive preferential’ management. J Neurooncol 54 (3): 277–286, 2001
Oi S, Shibata M, Tominaga J, Honda Y, Shinoda M, Takei F, Tsugane R, Matsuzawa K, Sato O: Efficacy of neuroendoscopic procedures in minimally invasive preferential management of pineal region tumors: a prospective study. J Neurosurg 93 (2): 245–253, 2000
Kobayashi S, Sugita K, Tanaka Y, Kyoshima K: Infratentorial approach to the pineal region in the prone position: Concorde position. J Neurosurg 58: 141–143, 1983
Apuzzo ML, Chandrasoma PT, Cohen D, Zee CS, Zelman V: Computed imaging stereotaxy: experience and perspective related to 500 procedures applied to brain masses. Neurosurgery 20 (6): 930–937, 1987
Hoffman HJ, Yoshida M, Becker LE, Hendrick EB, Humphreys RP: Pineal region tumors in childhood. Experience at the Hospital for Sick Children. 1983. Pediatr Neurosurg 21 (1): 91–103, discussion-4, 1994
Luo SQ, Li DZ, Zhang MZ, Wang ZC, Zhong CW: Occipital transtentorial approach for removal of pineal region tumors: report of 64 consecutive cases. Surg Neurol 32 (1): 36–39, 1989
Vaquero J, Ramiro J, Martinez R, Bravo G: Neurosurgical experience with tumours of the pineal region at Clinica Puerta de Hierro. Acta Neurochir (Wien)116 (1): 23–32, 1992
Herrmann HD, Winkler D, Westphal M: Treatment of tumours of the pineal region and posterior part of the third ventricle. Acta Neurochir (Wien)116 (2–4): 137–146, 1992
Kang JK, Jeun SS, Hong YK, Park CK, Son BC, Lee IW, Kim MC: Experience with pineal region tumors. Childs Nerv Syst. 14 (1–2): 63–68, 1998
Shin HJ, Cho BK, Jung HW, Wang KC: Pediatric pineal tumors: need for a direct surgical approach and complications of the occipital transtentorial approach. Childs Nerv Syst 14 (4–5): 174–178, 1998
Bruce J, Stein B: Supracerebellar approaches in the pineal region, In Apuzzo M. (ed): Brain surgery: Complication Avoidance and Management. Churchill-Livingstone, New York, 1993, pp 511–536
Fetell MR, Bruce JN, Burke AM, Cross DT, Torres RA, Powers JM, Stein BM: Non-neoplastic pineal cysts Neurology 41 (7): 1034–1340, 1991
Wolden SL, Wara WM, Larson DA, Prados MD, Edwards MS, Sneed PK: Radiation therapy for primary intracranial germ-cell tumors. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 32 (4): 943–949, 1995
Sawamura Y, de Tribolet N, Ishii N, Abe H: Management of primary intracranial germinomas: diagnostic surgery or radical resection? J Neurosurg 87 (2): 262–266, 1997
Franzini A, Leocata F, Servello D, Cajola L, Allegranza A, Broggi G: Long-term follow-up of germinoma after stereotactic biopsy and brain radiotherapy: a cell kinetics study. J Neurol 245 (9): 593–597, 1998
Rich TA, Cassady JR, Strand RD, Winston KR: Radiation therapy for pineal and suprasellar germ cell tumors. Cancer 55 (5): 932–940, 1985
Balmaceda C, Heller G, Rosenblum M, Diez B, Villablanca JG, Kellie S, Maher P, Vlamis V, Walker RW, Leibel S, Finlay JL: Chemotherapy without irradiation-a novel approach for newly diagnosed CNS germ cell tumors: results of an international cooperative trial. The First International Central Nervous System Germ Cell Tumor Study. J Clin Oncol 14 (11): 2908–2915, 1996
Buckner JC, Peethambaram PP, Smithson WA, Groover RV, Schomberg PJ, Kimmel DW, Raffel C, O’Fallon JR, Neglia J, Shaw EG: Phase II trial of primary chemotherapy followed by reduced-dose radiation for CNS germ cell tumors. J Clin Oncol 17 (3): 933–940, 1999
Oi S: Recent advances and racial differences in therapeutic strategy to the pineal region tumor. Childs Nerv Syst 14 (1–2): 33–35, 1998
Oi S, Matsuzawa K, Choi JU, Kim DS, Kang JK, Cho BK: Identical characteristics of the patient populations with pineal region tumors in Japan and in Korea and therapeutic modalities. Childs Nerv Syst 14 (1–2): 36–40, 1998
Kersh CR, Constable WC, Eisert DR, Spaulding CA, Hahn SS, Jenrette JM, Marks RD: Primary central nervous system germ cell tumors: effect of histologic confirmation on radiotherapy. Cancer 61: 2148–2152, 1988
Matsutani M, Sano K, Takakura K, Fujimaki T, Nakamura O: Combined treatment with chemotherapy and radiation therapy for intracranial germ cell tumors. Childs Nerv Syst 14 (1–2): 59–62, 1998
Camins MB, Schlesinger EB: Treatment of tumours of the posterior part of the third ventricle and the pineal region: a long term follow-up. Acta Neurochir (Wien) 40 (1–2): 131–143, 1978
Robertson PL, DaRosso RC, Allen JC: Improved prognosis of intracranial non-germinoma germ cell tumors with multimodality therapy. J Neurooncol 32 (1): 71–80, 1997
Kochi M, Itoyama Y, Shiraishi S, Kitamura I, Marubayashi T, Ushio Y: Successful treatment of intracranial nongerminomatous malignant germ cell tumors by administering neoadjuvant chemotherapy and radiotherapy before excision of residual tumors. J Neurosurg 99 (1): 106–114, 2003
Weiner HL, Lichtenbaum RA, Wisoff JH, Snow RB, Souweidane MM, Bruce JN, Finlay JL: Delayed surgical resection of central nervous system germ cell tumors. Neurosurgery 50 (4): 727–733, discussion 33–34, 2002
Friedman JA, Lynch JJ, Buckner JC, Scheithauer BW, Raffel C: Management of malignant pineal germ cell tumors with residual mature teratoma. Neurosurgery 48 (3): 518–522, discussion 22–23, 2001
Jouvet A, Saint-Pierre G, Fauchon F, Privat K, Bouffet E, Ruchoux MM, Chauveinc L, Fevre-Montange M: Pineal parenchymal tumors: a correlation of histological features with prognosis in 66 cases. Brain Pathol 10 (1): 49–60, 2000
Borit A, Blackwood W, Mair WG: The separation of pineocytoma from pineoblastoma. Cancer 45 (6): 1408–1418, 1980
Packer RJ, Sutton LN, Rorke LB, Littman PA, Sposto R, Rosenstock JG, Bruce DA Schut L: Prognostic importance of cellular differentiation in medulloblastoma of childhood. J Neurosurg 61 (2): 296–301, 1984
Kurisaka M, Arisawa M, Mori T, Sakamoto T, Seike M, Mori K, Okada T, Wakiguchi H, Kurashige T: Combination chemotherapy cisplatin, vinblastin and low-dose irradiation in the treatment of pineal parenchymal cell tumors. Childs Nerv Syst 14 (10): 564–569, 1998
Jakacki RI, Zeltzer PM, Boyett JM, Albright AL, Allen JC, Geyer JR, Rorke LB, Stanley P, Stevens KR, Wisoff J, et al.: Survival and prognostic factors following radiation and/or chemotherapy for primitive neuroectodermal tumors of the pineal region in infants and children: a report of the Childrens Cancer Group. J Clin Oncol 13 (6): 1377–1383, 1995
Graham ML, Herndon JE: 2nd Casey JR, Chaffee S, Ciocci GH, Krischer JP, Kurtzberg J, Laughlin MJ, Longee DC, Olson JF, Paleologus N, Pennington CN, Friedman HS: High-dose chemotherapy with autologous stem-cell rescue in patients with recurrent and high-risk pediatric brain tumors. J Clin Oncol 15 (5): 1814–1823, 1997
Gururangan S, McLaughlin C, Quinn J, Rich J, Reardon D, Halperin EC, Herndon J, 2nd Fuchs H, George T, Provenzale J, Watral M, McLendon RE, Friedman A, Friedman HS, Kurtzberg J, Vredenbergh J, Martin PL: High-dose chemotherapy with autologous stem-cell rescue in children and adults with newly diagnosed pineoblastomas. J Clin Oncol 21 (11): 2187–2191, 2003
Duffner PK, Cohen ME, Sanford RA, Horowitz ME, Krischer JP, Burger PC, Friedman HS, Kun LE: Lack of efficacy of postoperative chemotherapy and delayed radiation in very young children with pineoblastoma. Pediatric Oncology Group. Med Pediatr Oncol 25 (1): 38–44, 1995
Yeh DD, Warnick RE, Ernst RJ: Management strategy for adult patients with dorsal midbrain gliomas. Neurosurgery 50 (4): 735–738, discussion 8–40, 2002
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bruce, J.N., Ogden, A.T. Surgical Strategies for Treating Patients with Pineal Region Tumors. J Neurooncol 69, 221–236 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1023/B:NEON.0000041885.09226.2d
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/B:NEON.0000041885.09226.2d