Abstract
This paper provides new evidence on the impact of electronic trading on brokerage commissions by investigating a sample period that covers the period of transition from floor to electronic trading on the Sydney Futures Exchange. After controlling for liquidity, volatility and broker identity, the introduction of electronic trading remains to be associated with lower brokerage commissions relative to floor markets. The study also provides new evidence on brokerage commissions in futures markets finding that commission fees charged on futures trades average 0.002% of transaction value. This is up to 120 times smaller than the magnitude of brokerage fees charged in stock markets, and considerably lower than the magnitude of brokerage fees assumed for futures markets in previous research. Consistent with existing studies based on stock markets, commissions charged per contract decrease with order size reflecting economies of scale in the provision of brokerage services in futures markets. Commission rates are positively related to bid-ask spreads and price volatility, which proxy for the probability of execution error costs and execution difficulty, respectively. Finally, the identity of the broker is found to be a significant determinant of commissions reflecting different pricing schedules across brokers.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aitken, Micheal J. “The Australian Securities Industry Under Negotiated Brokerage Commissions: Evidence of the Effects of Change on the Structure of the Industry.” Journal of Business Finance and Accounting 17 (1990), 213-245.
Aitken, Michael J. “The Determinants of Brokerage Fees in a Competitive Environment.” Accounting and Finance 31 (1991), 51-68.
Aitken, Michael J., Alex Frino, and Amelia M. Hill. “The Impact of Electronic Trading on Bid-Ask Spreads: Evidence from Futures Markets in Hong Kong, London and Sydney.” Working Paper, University of Sydney, 2002.
Battalio, Robert, Robert Jennings, and Jamie Selway. “The Relationship Among Market-Making Revenue, Payment for Order Flow, and Trading Costs for Market Orders.” Journal of Financial Services Research 19 (2001), 39-56.
Blennerhasset, Michael, and Robert G. Bowman. “A Change in Market Microstructure: The Switch to Electronic Screen Trading on the New Zealand Stock Exchange.” Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money 8 (1998), 261-276.
Blume, Gerald A. “Soft Dollars and the Brokerage Industry.” Financial Analysts Journal 49 (1993), 36-44.
Blume, Gerald A., and Wilbur G. Lewellwen. “Negotiated Brokerage Commissions and the Individual Investor.” Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 18 (1983), 331-343.
Brennan, Michael J., and Tarun Chordia. “Brokerage Commission Schedules.” Journal of Finance 48 (1993), 1379-1402.
Brenner, Minachem, Marti G. Subrahmanyam, and Jun Uno. “Arbitrage Opportunities in the Japanese Stock and Futures Markets.” Financial Analysts Journal 46 (1990), 14-24.
Conrad, Jennifer S., Kevin M. Johnson, and Sunil Wahal. “Institutional Trading and Soft Dollars.” Journal of Finance 56 (2001), 397-416.
Domowitz, Ian. “Liquidity, Transactions Costs, and Reintermediation in Electronic Markets.” Journal of Financial Services Research 22 (2002), 141-157.
Edmister, Robert O. “Commission Cost Structure: Shifts and Scale Economies.” Journal of Finance 33 (1978), 477-486.
Edmister, Robert O., and N. Subramanian. “Determinants of Brokerage Commission Rates for Institutional Investors: A Note.” Journal of Finance 37 (1982), 1087-1093.
Flemming, Jeff, Barbara Ostdiek, and Robert E. Whaley. “Trading Costs and the Relative Rates of Price Discovery in the in Stock, Futures and Options Markets.” Journal of Futures Markets 16 (1996), 353-387.
Frino, Alex, Amelia Hill, and Elvis Jarnecic. “The Impact of Electronic Trading on Bid-ask spreads: Evidence from Futures Markets in Hong Kong, London and Sydney.” Journal of futures Markets (2004), (forthcoming).
Frino, Alex, Thomas H. McInish, and Martin Toner. “The Liquidity of Automated Exchanges: New Evidence from German Bund Futures.” Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money 8 (1998), 225-242.
Gay, Gerald D., and Dae Y. Jung. “A Further Look at Transaction Costs, Short Sale Restrictions, and Futures Market Efficiency: The Case of Korean Stock Index Futures.” Journal of Futures Markets 19 (1999), 153-174.
Grunbichler, Andreas, Francis A. Longstaff, and Eduardo S. Schwartz. “Electronic Screen Trading and the Transmission of Information: An Empirical Examination.” Journal of Financial Intermediation 3 (1993), 166-187.
Gujarati, Damodar N. Basic Econometrics. New York: McGraw-Hill Book Co., 1995, p. 468.
Kuserk, Gregory J., and Peter R. Locke. “Scalper Behaviour in Futures Markets: An Empirical Analysis.” Journal of Futures Markets 13 (1993), 234-276.
Lim, Kian-Guan “Arbitrage and Price Behavior of the Nikkei stock index futures.” Journal of Futures Markets 12 (1992), 152-161.
Locke, Peter R., and P. C. Venkatesh. “Futures Market Transaction Costs.” Journal of Futures Markets 17 (1997), 229-245.
McInish, Thomas R., and Robert A. Wood. “An Analysis of Intraday Patterns in Bid/Ask Spreads for NYSE Stocks.” Journal of Finance 47 (1992), 753-764.
Melnick, Arie, and Aharon R. Ofer. “Competitive Commission Rates, Execution Quality, and Customer's Market Power: Note.” Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 12 (1980), 221-227.
Modest, David M., and M. Sundaresan. “The Relationship Between Spot and Futures Prices in Stock Index Futures Markets: Some Preliminary Evidence.” Journal of Futures Markets 3 (1983), 15-41.
Modest, David M. “On the Price of Stock Index Futures.” Journal of Portfolio Management 10 (1984), 51-57.
Newy, Whitney, and Kenneth West. “A Simple Positive Semi-definite, Heteroskedasiticity and Autocorrelation Consistent Covariance Matrix.” Econometrica 55 (1987), 703-708.
Ofer, Aharon R., and Arie Melnick. “Price Deregulation in the Brokerage Industry: An Empirical Analysis.” The Bell Journal of Economics 9 (1978), 633-641.
Perold, Andre, and Eric Sirri. “The Costs of International Equity Trading.” Working Paper, Harvard Business School, 1994.
Pirrong, Craig. “Market Liquidity and Depth on Computerised and Open Outcry Trading Systems: A Comparison of DTB and LIFFE Bund Contracts.” Journal of Futures Markets 16 (1996), 519-544.
Tinic, Seha M., and Richard R. West. “Competition in the Pricing of Dealer Service in the Over the Counter Stock Market.” Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 7 (1972), 1707-1727.
Tinic, Seha M., and Richard R. West. “The Securities Industry Under Negotiated Brokerage Commissions: Changes in the Structure and Performance of New York Stock Exchange Member Firms.” The Bell Journal of Economics 11 (1980), 29-41.
Tse, Yuiman, and Tatyanan V. Zabotina. “Transaction Costs and Market Quality: Open Outcry versus Electronic Trading.” The Journal of Futures Markets 21 (2001), 713-735.
Wang, George H. K., Jot Yau, and Tony Baptiste. “Trading Volume and Transaction Costs in Futures Markets.” The Journal of Futures Markets 17 (1997), 757-780.
West, Richard R., and Seha M. Tinic. “Minimum Commission Rates on New York Stock Exchange Transactions.” The Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science 2 (1971), 577-605.
Yadev, P. and P. Pope. “Stock Index Futures Arbitrage: International Evidence.” Journal of Futures Markets 10 (1990), 573-603.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bortoli, L.G., Frino, A. & Jarnecic, E. Differences in the Cost of Trade Execution Services on Floor-Based and Electronic Futures Markets. Journal of Financial Services Research 26, 73–87 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1023/B:FINA.0000029658.53325.c8
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/B:FINA.0000029658.53325.c8