Advertisement

Journal of Business Ethics

, Volume 51, Issue 3, pp 301–312 | Cite as

Ethics in Information Technology and Software Use

  • Vincent J. Calluzzo
  • Charles J. Cante
Article

Abstract

The emerging concern about software piracy and illegal or unauthorized use of information technology and software has been evident in the media and open literature for the last few years. In the course of conducting their academic assignments, the authors began to compare observations from classroom experiences related to ethics in the use of software and information technology and systems. Qualitatively and anecdotally, it appeared that many if not most, students had misconceptions about what represented ethical and unethical behaviors in these realms. Clearly, one can argue that if college students are uncertain about what constitutes appropriate and inappropriate behavior then this uncertainty will be carried forward into their workplaces upon graduation. Furthermore, if their workplaces don't provide ethics training as a component of a new employee orientation program, one can project a potential for unintentional violations and infringements of copyrights and law in the field. This study was conducted among graduate and undergraduate students to gain insight into their attitudes, perceptions and understanding of some of the relevant ethics issues. A questionnaire of 11 statements was employed that described ubiquitous but most likely unethical (or surely dubious) behaviors in the prevailing business and academic environments. Each respondent was asked to evaluate each statement twice (once for “self” and once for “colleague”) on a five-option highly ethical (5) to neutral (3) to highly unethical (1) scale. The statements were worded such that lower instrument score was associated with higher ethical responses. The questionnaire's two-part structure was designed to solicit honest answers. The encouraging learning from this study was that the overall sample and its various sub-samples did not consider any of the eleven behaviors to be “ethical” or “highly ethical.” It was also encouraging to note that the overall sample and all sub-samples considered “highly unethical” those behaviors associated with personal privacy or property or outright theft. This indicated that moral judgment and probity prevail. The discouraging learning was that behaviors associated with the use of enterprise property were viewed as “neutral” i.e., neither “ethical” nor “unethical.” These findings suggested confusion and lack of clarity and definition around workplace deportment as it regards ethics in software and information technology use. The current study suggests that additional research needs to be conducted to define and clarify the issues, which in turn can form the basis for programs to rectify or at least ameliorate the situation.

ethics gender graduate students undergraduate students information technology software privacy survey unethical behavior 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Alexander, S.: 1998, 'Those Flippin' Recruiters!' Computerworld 23 Nov., 67-69.Google Scholar
  2. Belsie, L.: 1998, 'Watching for Technology Abuse at Work', Christian Science Monitor 17 Aug., 136.Google Scholar
  3. 'By the numbers': 1998, Information Security June, 12.Google Scholar
  4. Chan, A., S. Wong and P. Leung: 1998, 'Ethical Beliefs of Chinese Consumers in Hong Kong', J. Business Ethics Aug., 1163-1170.Google Scholar
  5. 'China cracks down on IPR violations': 1998, Asia Computer Weekly 23 Nov., 1.Google Scholar
  6. Cohen, E. and L. Cornwell: 1989, 'College Students Believe Piracy is Acceptable', CIS Educator Forum 1(3), 2-5.Google Scholar
  7. 'Corporate strategies': 1998, Computerworld 4, 37.Google Scholar
  8. 'CSC, other tech companies join ITAA and Department of Justice to unveil cybercitizen partnership; new alliance to promote computer ethics, civic responsibility': 1999, PR Newswire 15 Mar. Google Scholar
  9. D'Aquila, J. M.: 2001, 'Financial Accountants' Perception of Managements' Ethical Standards', J. Business Ethics 31(3), 233 (June).Google Scholar
  10. 'Ever done something illicit at work using technology?': 1999, PC/Computing Jan., 306.Google Scholar
  11. Grimsley, K. D.: 1998, ' “Ethical” Employer is a Software Cheat', The Washington Post 27 Sep., 1104.Google Scholar
  12. 'Is that work-related?': 1999, The Journal News 22 Nov., 1D.Google Scholar
  13. Kohanski, D.: 1998, 'Computers that Spy on Us/Unethical Programmers Insert Code that Serves their Interest, Not Ours', San Francisco Chronicle 1 Dec, A23.Google Scholar
  14. Machlis, A.: 1998, Financial Times (London) 27 May, 7.Google Scholar
  15. Maharaj, D.: 1998, 'A Pitch to Snitch: Software Firms Urge Employees to Turn in Bosses', The Los Angeles Times 14 August, 1.Google Scholar
  16. Manley, J. F., G. F. Conlin and C. L. Williams: 1998, 'Factors that Contribute to the Ethical Judgements of Business Students: An Empirical Study', The Management of Values: Organizational and Educational Issues 5 Dec., 363-370.Google Scholar
  17. Pemberton, J. M.: 1998, 'Through a Glass Darkly: Ethics and Information Technology', Records Management Quarterly Jan., 76.Google Scholar
  18. Sibley, K.: 1998, 'Technology Complicates Workplace Ethics: KPMG Survey', Computer Dealer News (Canada) 15 June, 14.Google Scholar
  19. Silbert, M. D.: 1998, Canadian Chemical News Feb., 50.Google Scholar
  20. Wood, W., R. Behling and A. Y. Ang: 1999, 'Software Piracy: Issues and Perceptions of Australian University Students', International Information Management 7(2), 17-26.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2004

Authors and Affiliations

  • Vincent J. Calluzzo
    • 1
  • Charles J. Cante
    • 1
  1. 1.Hagan School of BusinessIona CollegeNew RochelleU.S.A.

Personalised recommendations