The Ultimate Glass Ceiling Revisited: The Presence of Women on Corporate Boards

Abstract

Has the diversity of corporate boards of directors improved? Should it? What role does diversity play in reducing corporate wrongdoing? Will diversity result in a more focused board of directors or more board autonomy? Examining the state of Tennessee as a case study, the authors collected data on the board composition of publicly traded corporations and compared those data to an original study conducted in 1995. Data indicate only a modest improvement in board diversity. This article discusses reasons for the scarcity of women on boards and concludes that, to enhance strategic decisions, board membership should reflect the corporation's consumer population. Thus, women are a critical but overlooked resource. Areas for future research are also considered.

This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution.

References

  1. Melissa, A.: 2002, ‘Study Says Women Made Less Progress in Joining Top Ranks of Illinois Firms’, Knight Ridder Tribune Business News (Washington, May 7), p. 1.

  2. Arfken, D. E., S. L. Bellar and M. M. Helms: 1998, ‘The Ultimate Glass Ceiling: Women on Corporate Boards’, A Leadership Journal: Women in Leadership-Sharing the Vision 3(1), 95–105. ‘Behind many errant CEOs hide weak corporate boards’, 2003, U.S.A. Today (Monday, April 28, 2003), p. 10A.

    Google Scholar 

  3. Blackwell, R.: 2002, ‘More Women Needed on Boards: CEOs’, Globe and Mail (October 30), Section B, 2–3.

  4. Board of Directors Network. www. boarddirectorsnetwork.org.

  5. Business Women's Network. www.bwni.com.

  6. Bratten, C.: 1998, ‘Boys Club No More’, Corporate Board Member (Autumn).

  7. ‘Consumer insight: Fifth annual ACNielsen consumer and market trends report 2001’, September, ACNielsen Company.

  8. ‘Corporate governance: Introducing the boardroom scoreboard’, 2002. CFO December, 18.

  9. Coyle, J. S.: 1999, ‘The Next Generation: Ten New Faces for Your Board’, Corporate Board Member (Summer).

  10. Daily, C. M.: 1995, ‘An Empirical Examination of the Relationship Between CEOs and Directors’, The Journal of Business Strategies 12(1), 60–68.

    Google Scholar 

  11. Donkin, R.: 1999, ‘Pay is Catching Up, But Numbers Are Not’, Financial Times-London (March 19), 12.

  12. Donovan, A.: 2001, ‘No Gains for Women on Corporate Boards’, The New York Times ( June 24, pBU4(N)-pBU4(L).

  13. D&B®Million Dollar Directory: 2002, ‘Series Cross-Reference by Geography’, 7052–7076.

  14. EDGAR online: www.edgaronline.com.

  15. Ezzard, M.: 2002a, ‘Female CEOs Missing in Action’, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution (October 15), A15.

  16. Ezzard, M.: 2002b, ‘Georgia's Corporate Boards in Need of Minority Women’, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution (March 17).

  17. Finer, J.: 2002, ‘Study Finds Few Women at Top’, The Washington Post (August 28), E03.

  18. Flessner, D.: 2002, ‘Breaking the Glass Ceiling: More Women Rising to Take Top Corporate Jobs’, Chattanooga Times Free Press (Sunday, September 29), 133(289), A1, A9.

    Google Scholar 

  19. Gomez, R.: 2002, ‘Women Slowly Make Gains in Boardrooms’, Chattanooga Times Free Press (Tuesday, November 19), C5.

  20. Gray, J.: 1993, Men are From Mars, Women are From Venus (HarperCollins, New York).

    Google Scholar 

  21. Gutner, T.: 2001, ‘Wanted: More Diverse Directors’, Business Week (April 30), 134.

  22. Hefferman, M.: 2002, ‘Exhibit A: The Female CEO’, Fast Company (August), 61, 58–66.

  23. library/ustudy/hoovers.html Howell, J. and S. Hibbard: 2002, ‘Navigating the Changed Landscape of Corporate Governance’, Harvard Management Update (December), 7–8.

  24. ‘Key facts show the dynamic growth of womenowned businesses’: 2003, News: Center for Women's Business Research, No. 1, p. 1.

  25. Kahn, A. E.: 2002, ‘Defining a Diversity Initiative’, Inside Supply Management (December), 8–9.

  26. Korn/Ferry International. www.kornferry.com.

  27. Knude, D.: 2000, ‘Corporate Boards and More Women’, The Dallas Morning News ( January 15), 2.

  28. Krotz, J.: 1999, ‘All Aboard’, Working Woman (April), 65–71.

  29. Lewis, D. E.: 1999, ‘Board Gains Seen for Women but Growth at top 500 U.S. Firms Slow, Poll Says’, Boston Globe (December 16), D, 1:5.

  30. Marshall, J.: 2001, ‘As Boards Shrink, Responsibilities Grow’, Financial Executive 17(4), 36–39.

    Google Scholar 

  31. Myers, R.: 2002, ‘Are You Paid Enough’, Corporate Board Member (November/December).

  32. ‘News’, Center for Women's Business Research. 2003. No. 1, p. 1.

  33. purpose.html.

  34. Poole, S. M.: 2001, ‘Women Now on 36% of Georgia Corporate Boards’, The Atlanta Journal Constitution (September 29), E6.

  35. Ridge, P. S.: 2000, ‘New Economy Boards Often Lack Women, Outsiders and Separate Governance’, The Wall Street Journal (April 27), PA1(W)-PA1(E).

  36. Roberts, R.: 2002, ‘M&A Market Marks Next Spring for Possible Turnaround’, Investor Relations Business (October 7), 1.

  37. Standard and Poor's Register Of Corporations, Directors, and Executives. Geographic index. United States and Canada (Standard and Poor Corporation, New York, 1996).

    Google Scholar 

  38. Strauss, G.: 2002, ‘Good Old Boy's Network Still Rules Corporate Boards’, U.S.A. Today (Friday, November 1), B1–2.

  39. Swedberg, J.: 2002, ‘The Board Balancing Act’, Credit Union Management (September) 25(9), 42–45.

    Google Scholar 

  40. ‘2002 Catalyst census of women corporate officers and top earners in the Fortune 500’, www.catalvstwomen.org.

  41. The 2002 female FTSE index: Women directors in the Top 100 Companies. 2002. The Cranfield Centre for Developing Women Business Leaders, Cranfield: U.K.

  42. Ulrich, D. and N. Smallwood: 2002, ‘Mergers and Acquisitions’, Executive Excellence (October), 19(10), 15–16.

    Google Scholar 

  43. U.S. Census Bureau: The Official Statistics (U.S. Government Printing, Washington, DC), 20.

  44. Walsh, M. W.: 2002, ‘Preparing a Corps of Women for Corporate Responsibility’, The New York Times (August 13), C 1(N)-C 1(L).

  45. ‘What directors think’: 2002, A Kom/Ferry International and Corporate Board Magazine Study at www.kornferry.com.br.

  46. ‘Women moving up at Fortune 500 firms: Female execs now make up 12.5% of officers, survey finds’: The Presence of Women on Corporate Boards 185 2000, The Plain Dealer, Cleveland, Ohio, November 14, 4C.

Download references

Author information

Affiliations

Authors

Rights and permissions

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Arfken, D.E., Bellar, S.L. & Helms, M.M. The Ultimate Glass Ceiling Revisited: The Presence of Women on Corporate Boards. Journal of Business Ethics 50, 177–186 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1023/B:BUSI.0000022125.95758.98

Download citation

  • corporate boards
  • directors
  • diversity
  • gender
  • minorities
  • women