Population Research and Policy Review

, Volume 23, Issue 2, pp 135–159

The relative stability of cohabiting and marital unions for children

  • Wendy D. Manning
  • Pamela J. Smock
  • Debarun Majumdar

Abstract

Children are increasingly born into cohabiting parent families, but we know little to date about the implications of this family pattern for children's lives. We examine whether children born into premarital cohabitation and first marriages experience similar rates of parental disruption, and whether marriage among cohabiting parents enhances union stability. These issues are important because past research has linked instability in family structure with lower levels of child well-being. Drawing on the 1995 National Survey of Family Growth, we find that white, black and Hispanic children born to cohabiting parents experience greater levels of instability than children born to married parents. Moreover, black and Hispanic children whose cohabiting parents marry do not experience the same levels of family stability as those born to married parents; among white children, however, the marriage of cohabiting parents raises levels of family stability to that experienced by children born in marriage. The findings from this paper contribute to the debate about the benefits of marriage for children.

Children Cohabitation Divorce Family structure Marriage Race and ethnicity 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Acs, G. & Nelson, S. (2001), Honey, I'm home. Changes in living arrangements in the late 1990's, New Federalism National Survey of America's Families B-38, Washington DC: Urban Institute.Google Scholar
  2. Allison, P. (1984), Event history analysis: Regression for longitudinal event data, Beverly Hills: Sage Publications.Google Scholar
  3. Allison, P. (1995), Survival analysis using the SAS system: A practical guide, Cary, NC: SAS Institute.Google Scholar
  4. Astone, N., Schoen, R., Ensminger, M. & Rothert, K. (1999), The family life course of African American men. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Population Association of America, NY.Google Scholar
  5. Axinn, W. & Thornton, A. (1992), The relationship between cohabitation and divorce: Selectivity or causal influence? Demography 29: 357–374.Google Scholar
  6. Bean, F. & Tienda, M. (1987), The Hispanic population of the United States, New York: Russell Sage.Google Scholar
  7. Bennett, N., Blanc, A. & Bloom, D. (1988), Commitment and the modern union: Assessing the link between premarital cohabitation and subsequent marital instability, American Sociological Review 53: 127–138.Google Scholar
  8. Booth, A. & Johnson, D. (1988), Premarital cohabitation and marital success, Journal of Family Issues 9: 255–272.Google Scholar
  9. Bramlett, M. & Mosher, W. (2002), Cohabitation, marriage and divorce and remarriage in the United States, National Center for Health Statistics. Vital Health Statistics 23(22)Google Scholar
  10. Brown, S. (2000a), The effect of union type of psychological well-being: Depression among cohabitors versus marrieds, Journal of Health and Social Behavior 41: 241–255.Google Scholar
  11. Brown, S. (2000b), Union transitions among cohabitors: The significance of relationship assessments and expectations, Journal of Marriage and the Family 62: 833–846.Google Scholar
  12. Brown, S. & Booth, A. (1996), Cohabitation versus marriage: A comparison of relationship quality, Journal of Marriage and the Family 58: 668–678.Google Scholar
  13. Bumpass, L. (1998), The changing significance of marriage in the United States, pp. 63–70, in K.O. Mason, N. Nilsuya & M. Choe (eds.), The changing family in comparative perspective: Asia and the United States, Honolulu: EastWest Center.Google Scholar
  14. Bumpass, L. & Lu, H. (2000), Trends in cohabitation and implications for children's family contexts, Population Studies 54: 29–41.Google Scholar
  15. Bumpass, L. & Sweet, J. (1989), National estimates of cohabitation, Demography 26: 615–625.Google Scholar
  16. Bumpass, L., Raley, R. & Sweet, J. (1995), The changing character of stepfamilies: Implications of cohabitation and nonmarital childbearing, Demography 32: 425–436.Google Scholar
  17. Casper, L. & Bianchi, S. (2002), Continuity and change in the American family, Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.Google Scholar
  18. Clarkberg, M. (1999), The price of partnering: The role of economic well-being in young adults' first union experiences, Social Forces 77: 945–968.Google Scholar
  19. Cohen, P. (1999), Racial-ethnic and gender differences in returns to cohabitation and marriage: Evidence from the current population survey. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Population Association of American. Washington, DC.Google Scholar
  20. Del Pinel, J. &. Singer, A. (1997), Generations of diversity: Latinos in the United States, Population Bulletin 52,No. 3.Google Scholar
  21. DeMaris, A. (2002), Regression models, pp. 255–288, in M. Wiederman & B. Whitley (eds.), Handbook for conducting research on human sexuality, Mahway, NJ: Lawrence Erlbum.Google Scholar
  22. DeMaris, A. & MacDonald, W. (1993), Premarital cohabitation and marital instability: A test of the unconventionality hypothesis, Journal of Marriage and the Family 55: 399–407.Google Scholar
  23. DeMaris, A. & Rao, K. (1992), Premarital cohabitation and subsequent marital stability in the United States: A reassessment, Journal of Marriage and the Family 54: 178–190.Google Scholar
  24. Durst, R. (1997), Ties that bind: Drafting enforceable cohabitation agreements, New Jersey Law Journal 147, S13–S14.Google Scholar
  25. Fields, J. (2001), Living arrangements of children, Current Population Reports P70-74. Washington, DC: US Census Bureau.Google Scholar
  26. Fields, J. & Casper, L. (2002), America's families and living arrangements: March 2000, Current Population Reports P20-537. Washington, DC: US Census Bureau.Google Scholar
  27. Graefe, D. & Lichter, D. (1999), Life course transitions of American children: Parental cohabitation, marriage and single motherhood, Demography 36: 205–217.Google Scholar
  28. Hao, L. (1996), Family structure, private transfers, and the economic well-being of families with children, Social Forces 75: 269–292.Google Scholar
  29. Landale, N. & Fennelly, K. (1992), Informal unions among mainland Puerto Ricans: Cohabitation or an alternative to legal marriage? Journal of Marriage and the Family 54: 269–280.Google Scholar
  30. Landale, N. & Hauan, S. (1992), The family life course of Puerto Rican children, Journal of Marriage and the Family 54: 912–924.Google Scholar
  31. Lichter, D. & Landale, N. (1995), Parental employment, family structure, and poverty among Latino children, Journal of Marriage and the Family 57: 346–361.Google Scholar
  32. Lichter, D., McLaughlin, C., Kephart, G. & Landry, D. (1992), Race and the retreat from marriage: A shortage of marriageable men? American Sociological Review 57: 781–799.Google Scholar
  33. Lillard, L., Brien, M. & Waite, L. (1995), Premarital cohabitation and subsequent marital dissolution: A matter of self-selection? Demography 32: 437–457.Google Scholar
  34. Loomis, L. & Landale, N. (1994), Nonmarital cohabitation and childbearing among black and white American women, Journal of Marriage and the Family 56: 949–962.Google Scholar
  35. McLanahan, S. & Carlson, M. (2002), Welfare reform, fertility, and father involvement, Future of Children 12: 147–165.Google Scholar
  36. McLanahan, S. & Casper, L. (1995), Growing diversity and inequality in the American family, pp. 1–45, in R. Farley (ed.), State of the Union: America in the 1990s, New York: Russell Sage Foundation.Google Scholar
  37. McLanahan, S. & Sandefur, G. (1994), Growing up with a single parent: What hurts, what helps? Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
  38. Manning, W. (2001), Childbearing in cohabiting unions: Racial and ethnic differences, Family Planning Perspectives 33: 217–223.Google Scholar
  39. Manning, W. (2002), The implications of cohabitation for children's well-being, pp. 121–152, in A. Booth & A. C. Crouter (eds.), Just living together: Implications for children, families, and public policy, Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.Google Scholar
  40. Manning, W. & Brown, S. (2003), Children's economic well-being in cohabiting parent families: An update and extension. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Population Association of America, Minneapolis, MN.Google Scholar
  41. Manning, W. & Lichter, D. (1996), Parental cohabitation and children's economic well-being, Journal of Marriage and the Family 58: 998–1010.Google Scholar
  42. Manning, W. & Smock, P. (1995), Why marry? Race and the transition to marriage among cohabitors, Demography 32: 509–520.Google Scholar
  43. Manning, W. & Smock, P. (2002), First comes cohabitation and then comes marriage, Journal of Family Issues 23: 1065–1087.Google Scholar
  44. Marcil-Gratton, N., Le Bourdais, C. & Lapierre-Adamcyk, E. (2000), The implications of parents' conjugal histories for children, Canadian Journal of Policy Research 1: 32–40.Google Scholar
  45. Mare, R. & Winship, C. (1991), Socioeconomic change and the decline of marriage for blacks and whites, pp. 175–202, in C. Jencks & P. E Peterson (eds.), The urban underclass, Washington, DC: Urban Institute.Google Scholar
  46. Morrison, D. R. & Ritualo, A. (2000), Routes to children's economic recovery after divorce: Are maternal cohabitation and remarriage equivalent? American Sociological Review 65: 560–580.Google Scholar
  47. Musick, K. (2002), Planned and unplanned childbearing among unmarried women, Journal of Marriage and Family 64: 915–930.Google Scholar
  48. Nock, S. (1995), A comparison of marriages and cohabiting relationships, Journal of Family Issues 16: 53–76.Google Scholar
  49. Oppenheimer, V. (1994), Women's rising employment and the future of the family in industrial societies, Population and Development Review 20: 293–342.Google Scholar
  50. Oropesa, R. (1996), Normative beliefs about marriage and cohabitation: A comparison of non-Latino whites, Mexican Americans and Puerto Ricans, Journal of Marriage and the Family 58: 49–62.Google Scholar
  51. Oropesa, R., Lichter, D. & Anderson, R. (1994), Marriage markets and the paradox of Mexican American nuptiality, Journal of Marriage and the Family 56: 889–907.Google Scholar
  52. Raley, R. (1996), A shortage of marriageable men? A note on the role of cohabitation in black-white differences in marriage rates, American Sociological Review 61: 973–983.Google Scholar
  53. Raley, R. (2001), Increasing fertility in cohabiting unions: Evidence for the second demographic transition in the United States? Demography 38: 59–66.Google Scholar
  54. Raley, R. & Wildsmith, E.M. (2001), Cohabitation and children's family instability. Population research center working paper 01-02-06. University of Texas.Google Scholar
  55. Schoen, R. (1992), First unions and the stability of first marriages, Journal of Marriage and the Family 54: 281–284.Google Scholar
  56. Seff, M. (1995), Cohabitation and the law, Marriage and Family Review 21: 141–168.Google Scholar
  57. Seltzer, J. (1994), Consequences of marital dissolution for children, Annual Review of Sociology 20: 235–266.Google Scholar
  58. Smock, P. (2000), Cohabitation in the United States, Annual Review of Sociology 26: 1–20.Google Scholar
  59. Smock, P. & Gupta, S. (2002), What is the role of cohabitation in contemporary North American family structure?, pp. 53–84, in A. Booth & A. Crouter (eds.), Just living together: Implications of cohabitation on families, children, and social policy, Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.Google Scholar
  60. Smock, P. & Manning, W. (1997), Cohabiting partners' economic circumstances and marriage, Demography 34: 331–341.Google Scholar
  61. Smock, P., Manning, W. & Gupta, S. (1999), The effect of marriage and divorce on women's economic well-being, American Sociological Review 64: 794–812.Google Scholar
  62. Stewart, S. (2002), The effects of stepchildren on childbearing intentions and births, Demography 39: 181–197Google Scholar
  63. Teachman, J. & Polonko, K. (1990), Cohabitation and marital stability in the United States, Social Forces 69: 207–220.Google Scholar
  64. Teachman, J., Thomas, J. & Paasch, K. (1991), Legal status and stability of coresidential unions, Demography 28: 571–586.Google Scholar
  65. Testa, M., Astone, N., Krogh, M. & Neckerman, K. (1989), Employment and marriage among inner-city fathers, Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 501: 79–91.Google Scholar
  66. Thomson, E. & Collela, U. (1992), Cohabitation and marital stability: Quality or commitment? Journal of Marriage and the Family 54: 259–267.Google Scholar
  67. Thomson, E. & Li, J. (2002), Her, his and their children: Childbearing intentions and births in stepfamilies, National Survey of Families and Households Working Paper 89, University of Wisconsin-Madison.Google Scholar
  68. Thornton, A., Axinn, W. & Teachman, J. (1995), The influence of school enrollment and accumulation on cohabitation and marriage in early adulthood, American Sociological Review 60: 762–774.Google Scholar
  69. Waite, L. (1995), Does marriage matter? Demography 32: 483–508.Google Scholar
  70. Waite, L. & Gallagher, M. (2000), The case for marriage, New York: Doubleday.Google Scholar
  71. Waite, L. & Joyner, K. (2001), Emotional and physical satisfaction in married, cohabiting, and dating sexual unions: Do men and women differ?, pp. 239–274, in E. Laumann & R. Michael (eds.), Sex, love, and health in America: Private choices and public policies, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  72. Waller, M. (1999), Meanings and motives in new family stories: The separation of reproduction and marriage among low-income black and white parents, pp. 182–218, in M. Lamont (ed.), The cultural territories of race: Black and white boundaries, New York: Russell Sage.Google Scholar
  73. Wiesensale, S. & Heckart, K. (1993), Domestic partnerships: A concept paper and policy discussion, Family Relations 42: 199–204.Google Scholar
  74. Wu, L. (1996), Effects of family instability, income, and income instability on the risk of premarital birth, American Sociological Review 61: 386–406.Google Scholar
  75. Wu, L. & Martinson, B. (1993), Family structure and the risk of a premarital birth, American Sociological Review 58: 210–232.Google Scholar
  76. Wu, L. & Musick, K. (2002), Stability of marital and cohabiting unions following a first birth. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Population Association of America, Atlanta.Google Scholar
  77. Wu, L., Bumpass, L. & Musick, K. (2001), Historical and life course trajectories of nonmarital childbearing, pp. 3–48, in L. Wu & B. Wolfe (eds.), Out of wedlock: Causes and consequences of nonmarital fertility, New York: Russell Sage.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2004

Authors and Affiliations

  • Wendy D. Manning
    • 1
  • Pamela J. Smock
    • 2
  • Debarun Majumdar
    • 3
  1. 1.Department of Sociology & Center for Family and Demographic ResearchBowling Green State UniversityOhioUSA
  2. 2.Department of Sociology & Population Studies CenterThe University of MichiganAnn ArborUSA
  3. 3.Department of SociologySouthwest Texas State UniversitySan MarcosUSA

Personalised recommendations