The Review of Austrian Economics

, Volume 16, Issue 4, pp 309–326 | Cite as

Networks, Law, and the Paradox of Cooperation

  • Bryan Caplan
  • Edward Stringham


There is a tension between libertarians' optimism about private supply of public goods and skepticism of the viability of voluntary collusion (Cowen 1992, Cowen and Sutter 1999). Playing off this asymmetry, Cowen (1992) advances the novel argument that the “free market in defense services” favored by anarcho-capitalists is a network industry where collusion is especially feasible. The current article dissolves Cowen's asymmetry, showing that he fails to distinguish between self-enforcing and non-self-enforcing interaction. Case study evidence on network behavior before and after antitrust supports our analysis. Furthermore, libertarians' joint beliefs on public goods and collusion are, contrary to Cowen and Sutter (1999), theoretically defensible.

networks anarcho-capitalism collusion 


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Allen, P. (2000) “Prepared Testimony of Mr. Paul Allen.” Senate Banking Committee, Subcommittee on Financial Institutions, Hearing on Competition and Innovation in the Credit Card Industry at the Consumer and Network Level, May 25, 2000.Google Scholar
  2. Banner, S. (1998) “The Origin of the New York Stock Exchange, 1791-1860.” Journal of Legal Studies, 27: 113–140.Google Scholar
  3. Benson, B. (1990) The Enterprise of Law. San Francisco: Pacific Research Institute for Public Policy.Google Scholar
  4. Benson, B. (1993) “The Impetus for Recognizing Private Property and Adopting Ethical Behavior in a Market Economy: Natural Law, Government Law, or Evolving Self-Interest.” Review of Austrian Economics, 6: 43–80.Google Scholar
  5. Benson, B. (1998) To Serve and Protect: Privatization and Community in Criminal Justice. New York: New York University Press.Google Scholar
  6. Bernheim, D. and Whinston, M. (1985) “Common Marketing Agencies as a Device for Facilitating Collusion.” Rand Journal of Economics, 16: 269–281.Google Scholar
  7. Boal,W. and Ransom, M. (1997) “Monopsony in the Labor Market.” Journal of Economic Literature, 35: 86–112.Google Scholar
  8. Calomiris, C. and Kahn, C. (1991) “The Role of Demandable Debt in Structuring Optimal Banking Arrangements.” American Economic Review, 81: 497–513.Google Scholar
  9. Calomiris, C. (1990) “Is Deposit Insurance Necessary? A Historical Perspective.” Journal of Economic History, 50: 283–295.Google Scholar
  10. Cannon, J. G. (1910) Clearing Houses. Washington, Govt. Print. Off.Google Scholar
  11. Carlton, D. and Frankel, A. (1995a) “The Antitrust Economics of Payment Card Networks.” Antitrust Law Journal, 63: 643–668.Google Scholar
  12. Carlton, D. and Frankel, A. (1995b) “The Antitrust Economics of Payment Card Networks: Reply to Evans and Schmalensee Comment.” Antitrust Law Journal, 63: 903–915.Google Scholar
  13. Coate, S. and Loury, G. (1993) “Will Affirmative-Action Policies Eliminate Negative Stereotypes?” American Economic Review, 83: 1220–1240.Google Scholar
  14. Cowen, T. (1992) “Law as a Public Good: The Economics of Anarchy.” Economics and Philosophy, 8: 249–267.Google Scholar
  15. Cowen, T. (1994) “Rejoinder to David Friedman on the Economics of Anarchy.” Economics and Philosophy, 10: 329–332.Google Scholar
  16. Cowen, T. and Sutter, D. (1999) “The Costs of Cooperation.” The Review of Austrian Economics, 12: 161–173.Google Scholar
  17. Dewing, A. (1914) Corporate Promotions and Reorganizations. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
  18. Dowd, K. (1994) “Competitive Banking, Bankers' Clubs, and Bank Regulation.” Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 26: 289–308.Google Scholar
  19. Economides, N. (1995) “Commentary on 'Antitrust Economics of Credit Card Networks'.” Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Review, Nov.-Dec. 1995: 60–63.Google Scholar
  20. Evans, D. and Schmalensee, R. (1995) “Economic Aspects of Payment Card Systems and Antitrust Policy Toward Joint Ventures.” Antitrust Law Journal, 63: 861–901.Google Scholar
  21. Evans, D. and Schmalensee, R. (1999) Paying with Plastic: The Digital Revolution in Buying and Borrowing. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar
  22. Fort, R. and Quirk, J. (1995) “Cross-Subsidization, Incentives, and Outcomes in Professional Sports Leagues.” Journal of Economic Literature, 33: 1265–1299.Google Scholar
  23. Friedman, D. (1989) The Machinery of Freedom, Guide to Radical Capitalism, 2nd ed. La Salle, IL: Open Court.Google Scholar
  24. Friedman, D. (1994) “Law as a Private Good: A Response to Tyler Cowen on the Economics of Anarchy.” Economics and Philosophy, 10: 319–327.Google Scholar
  25. Gabel, D. (1994) “Competition in a Network Industry: The Telephone Industry, 1894-1910.” Journal of Economic History, 54: 543–572.Google Scholar
  26. Geddes, R. (2000) “Public Utilities.” In: Encyclopedia of Law and Economics,Vol. III. The Regulation of Contracts.Google Scholar
  27. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar, pp. 1162-1205.Google Scholar
  28. Goodhart, C. (1988) The Evolution of Central Banks. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar
  29. Gorton, G. (1985) “Clearinghouses and the Origin of Central Banking in the United States.” Journal of Economic History, 45: 277–283.Google Scholar
  30. Gorton, G. and Mullineaux, D. (1987) “The Joint Production of Confidence: Endogenous Regulation and Nineteenth Century Commercial-Bank Clearinghouses.” Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 19: 457–468.Google Scholar
  31. Greif, A. (1993) “Contract Enforceability and Economic Institutions in Early Trade: The Maghribi Traders' Coalition.” American Economic Review, 83: 525–548.Google Scholar
  32. Greif, A., Milgrom, P., and Weingast, B. R. (1994) “Coordination, Commitment, and Enforcement: The Case of the Merchant Guild.” Journal of Political Economy, 102: 745–776.Google Scholar
  33. Hanft, N. (2000) “PreparedTestimony ofMr. Noah Hanft.” Senate Banking Committee, Subcommittee on Financial Institutions, Hearing on Competition and Innovation in the Credit Card Industry at the Consumer and Network Level, May 25, 2000.Google Scholar
  34. Hausman, J., Leonard, G., and Tirole, J. (1999) “The Impact of Duality on Productive Efficiency and Innovation.” Working paper, MIT.Google Scholar
  35. Hock, D. (1999) Birth of the Chaordic Age. San Francisco: Berrett-Koehler Pub.Google Scholar
  36. Katz, M. and Shapiro, C. (1985) “Network Externalities, Competition, and Compatibility.” American Economic Review, 75: 424–440.Google Scholar
  37. Katz, M. and Shapiro, C. (1994) “Systems Competition and Network Effects.” Journal of Economic Perspectives, 8: 93–115.Google Scholar
  38. Klein, D. (1990) “The Voluntary Provision of Public Goods? The Turnpike Companies of Early America.” Economic Inquiry, 28: 788–812.Google Scholar
  39. Lal, D. (1997) “From Planning to Regulation: Toward a New Dirigisme?” The Cato Journal, 17: 211–227.Google Scholar
  40. Libecap, G. and Wiggins, S. (1984) “Contractual Responses to the Common Pool: Prorationing of Crude Oil Production.” American Economic Review, 74: 87–98.Google Scholar
  41. Liebowitz, S. J. and Margolis, S. (1994) “Network Externality: An Uncommon Tragedy.” Journal of Economic Perspectives, 8: 133–150.Google Scholar
  42. Liebowitz, S. J. and Margolis, S. (1995) “Are Network Externalities a New Source of Market Failure?” Research in Law and Economics, 17: 1–22.Google Scholar
  43. Liebowitz, S. J. and Margolis, S. (1998) “Network Effects and Externalities.” In: The New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics and the Law, pp. 671–675. London: MacMillan.Google Scholar
  44. Mahoney, P. (1997) “The Exchange as Regulator.” Virginia Law Review, 83: 1453–1500.Google Scholar
  45. McChesney, F. and Shughart, W. (1995) The Causes and Consequences of Antitrust: The Public-Choice Perspective. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  46. National Collegiate Athletic Association (2000) NCAA Division I Manual 2000-2001. Overland Park, KS: NCAA.Google Scholar
  47. National Collegiate Athletic Association v. Board of Regents of the University of Oklahoma et al. (1984) 468 U.S. 85.Google Scholar
  48. Neale, W. (1964) “The Peculiar Economics of Professional Sports.” Quarterly Journal of Economics, 78: 1–14.Google Scholar
  49. Noll, R. (Ed.) (1974) Government and the Sports Business. Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution.Google Scholar
  50. Rochet, J. C. and Tirole, J. (2000) “Cooperation among Competitors: The Economics of Payment Card Associations.” Working paper, IDEI, Toulouse.Google Scholar
  51. Rosen, S. (1981) “The Economics of Superstars.” American Economic Review, 71: 845–858.Google Scholar
  52. Rothbard, M. N. (1978) For a New Liberty: The Libertarian Manifesto. NY: Libertarian Review Foundation.Google Scholar
  53. Salop, S. and White, L. J. (1991) “Policy Watch: Antitrust Goes to College.” Journal of Economic Perspectives, 5: 193–202.Google Scholar
  54. Schmidtz, D. (1991) The Limits of Government: An Essay on the Public Goods Argument. Boulder: Westview Press.Google Scholar
  55. Smith, V. L. (1980) “Experiments with a Decentralized Mechanism for Public Good Decisions.” American Economic Review, 70: 584–599.Google Scholar
  56. Sowell, T. (1994) Race and Culture. NY: Basic Books.Google Scholar
  57. Sprague, O. M. W. (1910/1977) History of Crisis Under the National Banking System. Fairfield, NJ: Augustus M Kelly Publishers.Google Scholar
  58. Stringham, E. (1999) “Market Chosen Law.” Journal of Libertarian Studies, 14: 53–77.Google Scholar
  59. Stringham, E. (2002) “The Emergence of the London Stock Exchange as a Self-Policing Club.” Journal of Private Enterprise, 17: 1–19.Google Scholar
  60. Stringham, E. (2003) “The Extralegal Development of Securities Trading in Seventeenth Century Amsterdam.” Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance, 43: 321–344.Google Scholar
  61. Sutter, D. (1995) “Asymmetric Power Relations and Cooperation in Anarchy.” Southern Economic Journal, 61: 602–613.Google Scholar
  62. Telser, L. (1980) “A Theory of Self-Enforcing Agreements.” Journal of Business, 53: 27–44.Google Scholar
  63. Timberlake, R. (1984) “The Central Banking Role of Clearinghouse Associations.” Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 16: 1–15.Google Scholar
  64. Tullock, G. (1974) The Social Dilemma: The Economics of War and Revolution. Blacksburg, VA: University Publications.Google Scholar
  65. Tullock, G. (1981) “The Rhetoric and Reality of Redistribution.” Southern Economic Journal, 47: 895–907.Google Scholar
  66. Veitch, J. (1986) “Repudiations and Confiscations by the Medieval State.” Journal of Economic History, 46: 31–36.Google Scholar
  67. Zywicki, T. (2000) “The Economics of Credit Cards.” Chapman Law Review, 3: 79–172.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2003

Authors and Affiliations

  • Bryan Caplan
    • 1
  • Edward Stringham
    • 1
  1. 1.Department of EconomicsSan Jose State UniversitySan Jose

Personalised recommendations