Abstract
After a brief flirtation with logicism around 1917, David Hilbertproposed his own program in the foundations of mathematics in 1920 and developed it, in concert with collaborators such as Paul Bernays andWilhelm Ackermann, throughout the 1920s. The two technical pillars of the project were the development of axiomatic systems for everstronger and more comprehensive areas of mathematics, and finitisticproofs of consistency of these systems. Early advances in these areaswere made by Hilbert (and Bernays) in a series of lecture courses atthe University of Göttingen between 1917 and 1923, and notably in Ackermann's dissertation of 1924. The main innovation was theinvention of the ∈-calculus, on which Hilbert's axiom systemswere based, and the development of the ∈-substitution methodas a basis for consistency proofs. The paper traces the developmentof the ``simultaneous development of logic and mathematics'' throughthe ∈-notation and provides an analysis of Ackermann'sconsistency proofs for primitive recursive arithmetic and for thefirst comprehensive mathematical system, the latter using thesubstitution method. It is striking that these proofs use transfiniteinduction not dissimilar to that used in Gentzen's later consistencyproof as well as non-primitive recursive definitions, and that thesemethods were accepted as finitistic at the time.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
REFERENCES
Ackermann, H. R.: 1983, ‘Aus dem Briefwechsel Wilhelm Ackermanns’, History and Philosophy of Logic 4, 181–202.
Ackermann, W.: 1924a, ‘Begründung des “tertium non datur” mittels der Hilbertschen Theorie der Widerspruchsfreiheit’, Mathematische Annalen 93, 1–36.
Ackermann, W.: 1924b, ‘Begründung des “tertium non datur” mittels der Hilbertschen Theorie der Widerspruchsfreiheit’, Dissertation, Universität Göttingen..
Ackermann, W.: 1928a, ‘Ñber die Erfüllbarkeit gewisser Zählausdrücke’, Mathematische Annalen 100, 638–649.
Ackermann, W.: 1928b, ‘Zum Hilbertschen Aufbau der reellen Zahlen’, Mathematische Annalen 99, 118–133.
Ackermann, W.: 1940, ‘Zur Widerspruchsfreiheit der Zahlentheorie’, Mathematische Annalen 117, 162–194.
Ackermann, W.: 1954, Solvable Cases of the Decision Problem, North-Holland, Amsterdam.
Behmann, H.: 1918, ‘Die Antinomie der transfiniten Zahl und ihre Auflösung durch die Theorie von Russell und Whitehead’, Dissertation, Universität Göttingen, 352 pp.
Bernays, P.: 1918, ‘Beiträge zur axiomatischen Behandlung des Logik-Kalküls’, Habilitationsschrift, Universität Göttingen. Bernays Nachlaß, WHS, Bibliothek, ETH Zürich, Hs 973.192.
Dawson, J. W.: 1988, ‘The Reception of Gödel's Incompleteness Theorems’, In: S. G. Shanker (ed.), Gödel's Theorem in Focus. Routledge, London and New York, pp. 74–95.
Dedekind, R.: 1888, Was sind und was sollen die Zahlen? Vieweg, Braunschweig. English translation in Dedekind (1901).
Dedekind, R.: 1901, Essays on the Theory of Number, Open Court, New York.
Ewald, W. B. (ed.): 1996, From Kant to Hilbert. A Source Book in the Foundations of Mathematics, Vol. 2, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Gentzen, G.: 1936, ‘Die Widerspruchsfreiheit der reinen Zahlentheorie’, Mathematische Annalen 112, 493–565.
Grattan-Guinness, I.: 2000, The Search For Mathematical Roots 1870-1940. Logics, Set Theories and the Foundations of Mathematics from Cantor through Russell to Gödel, Princeton University Press, Princeton, N.J.
Hermes, H.: 1967, ‘In memoriam Wilhelm Ackermann, 1896-1962’, Notre Dame Journal of Formal Logic 8, 1–8.
Hilbert, D.: 1900, ‘Mathematische Probleme’, Nachrichten von der Königlichen Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften zu Göttingen, Math.-Phys. Klasse, pp. 253–297. Lecture given at the International Congress of Mathematicians, Paris, 1900. Partial English translation in Ewald (1996, 1096-1105).
Hilbert, D.: 1905, ‘Ñber die Grundlagen der Logik und der Arithmetik’, In: A. Krazer (ed.), Verhandlungen des dritten Internationalen Mathematiker-Kongresses in Heidelberg vom 8. bis 13. August 1904. Leipzig, pp. 174–185, Teubner. English translation in van Heijenoort (1967, 129-38).
Hilbert, D.: 1918a, ‘Axiomatisches Denken’, Mathematische Annalen 78, 405–415. Lecture given at the Swiss Society of Mathematicians, 11 September 1917. Reprinted in Hilbert (1935, 146-56). English translation in Ewald (1996, 1105-1115).
Hilbert, D.: 1918b, ‘Prinzipien der Mathematik’, Lecture notes by Paul Bernays. Winter-Semester 1917-18. Unpublished typescript. Bibliothek, Mathematisches Institut, Universität Göttingen.
Hilbert, D.: 1920a, ‘Logik-Kalkül’, Vorlesung, Winter-Semester 1920. Lecture notes by Paul Bernays. Unpublished typescript. Bibliothek, Mathematisches Institut, Universität Göttingen.
Hilbert, D.: 1920b, ‘Probleme der mathematischen Logik’, Vorlesung, Sommer-Semester 1920. Lecture notes by Paul Bernays and Moses Schönfinkel. Unpublished typescript. Bibliothek, Mathematisches Institut, Universität Göttingen.
Hilbert, D.: 1922a, ‘Grundlagen der Mathematik’, Vorlesung, Winter-Semester 1921-1922. Lecture notes by Helmut Kneser. Unpublished manuscript, three notebooks.
Hilbert, D.: 1922b, ‘Grundlagen der Mathematik’, Vorlesung, Winter-Semester 1921-1922. Lecture notes by Paul Bernays. Unpublished typescript. Bibliothek, Mathematisches Institut, Universität Göttingen.
Hilbert, D.: 1922c, ‘Neubegründung der Mathematik: Erste Mitteilung’, Abhandlungen aus dem Seminar der Hamburgischen Universität 1, 157–77. Series of talks given at the University of Hamburg, July 25-27, 1921. Reprinted with notes by Bernays in Hilbert (1935, 157-177). English translation inMancosu (1998, 198-214) and Ewald (1996, 1115-1134).
Hilbert, D.: 1923, ‘Die logischen Grundlagen der Mathematik’, Mathematische Annalen 88, 151–165. Lecture given at the Deutsche Naturforscher-Gesellschaft, September 1922. Reprinted in Hilbert (1935, 178-191). English translation in Ewald (1996, 1134-1148).
Hilbert, D.: 1926, ‘Ñber das Unendliche’, Mathematische Annalen 95, 161–190. Lecture given Münster, 4 June 1925. English translation in van Heijenoort (1967, 367-392).
Hilbert, D.: 1928a, ‘Die Grundlagen der Mathematik’, Abhandlungen aus dem Seminar der Hamburgischen Universität 6, 65–85. English translation in van Heijenoort (1967, 464-479).
Hilbert, D.: 1928b, ‘Probleme der Grundlegung der Mathematik’, in N. Zanichelli (ed.), Atti del Congresso Internazionale dei Matematici, 3-10 September 1928, Bologna, pp. 135–141.
Hilbert, D.: 1929, ‘Probleme der Grundlegung der Mathematik’, Mathematische Annalen 102, 1–9. Lecture given at the International Congress of Mathematicians, 3 September 1928. English translation in Mancosu (1998, 266-273).
Hilbert, D.: 1935, Gesammelte Abhandlungen, Vol. 3. Springer, Berlin.
Hilbert, D. and W. Ackermann: 1928, Grundzüge der theoretischen Logik, Springer, Berlin.
Hilbert, D. and P Bernays: 1923a, ‘Logische Grundlagen der Mathematik’, Winter-Semester 1922-1923. Lecture notes by Helmut Kneser, unpublished manuscript.
Hilbert, D. and P. Bernays: 1923b, ‘Logische Grundlagen der Mathematik’, Vorlesung, Winter-Semester 1922-1923. Lecture notes by Paul Bernays, with handwritten notes by Hilbert. Hilbert-Nachlaß, Niedersächsische Staats-und Universitätsbibliothek, Cod. Ms. Hilbert 567.
Hilbert, D. and P. Bernays: 1934, Grundlagen der Mathematik, Vol. 1, Springer, Berlin.
Hilbert, D. and P. Bernays: 1939, Grundlagen der Mathematik, Vol. 2, Springer, Berlin.
Leisenring, A. C.: 1969, Mathematical Logic and Hilbert's ε-Symbol, MacDonald, London.
Mancosu, P. (ed.): 1998, From Brouwer to Hilbert. The Debate on the Foundations of Mathematics in the 1920s, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Mancosu, P.: 1999a, ‘Between Russell and Hilbert: Behmann on the Foundations of Mathematics’, Bulletin of Symbolic Logic 5(3), 303–330.
Mancosu, P.: 1999b, ‘Between Vienna and Berlin: The Immediate Reception of Gödel's Incompleteness Theorems’, History and Philosophy of Logic 20, 33–45.
Mints, G.: 1994, ‘Gentzen-type Systems and Hilbert's Epsilon Substitution Method I’, in D. Prawitz, B. Skyrms, and D. Westerståhl (eds.), Logic, Methodology and Philosophy of Science IX, Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 91–122.
Mints, G.: 1996, ‘Thoralf Skolem and the Epsilon Substitution Method for Predicate Logic’, Nordic Journal of Philosophical Logic 1(2), 133–146.
Mints, G. and S. Tupailo: 1999, ‘Epsilon-Substitution for the Ramified Language and-comprehension Rule’, in A. Cantini, E. Casari, and P. Minari (eds.), Logic and Foundations of Mathematics, Kluwer, Dordrecht, pp. 107–130.
Mints, G., S. Tupailo, and W. Buchholz: 1996, ‘Epsilon Substitution Method for Elementary Analysis’, Archive for Mathematical Logic 35, 103–130.
Moser, G.: 2000, ‘The Epsilon Substitution Method’, Master's thesis, University of Leeds.
Parsons, C.: 1998, ‘Finitism and Intuitive Knowledge’, in M. Schirn (ed.), The Philosophy of Mathematics Today, Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 249–270.
Peckhaus, V.: 1990, Hilbertprogramm und Kritische Philosophie, Vandenhoeck und Ruprecht, Göttingen.
Sieg, W.: 1999, ‘Hilbert's Programs: 1917-1922’, Bulletin of Symbolic Logic 5(1), 1–44.
Skolem, T.: 1923, ‘Begründung der elementaren Arithmetik durch die rekurrierende Denkweise ohne Anwendung scheinbarer Veränderlichen mit unendlichem Ausdehnungsbereich’, Videnskapsselskapets skrifter I. Matematisk-naturvidenskabelig klasse 6. English translation in van Heijenoort (1967, 302-333).
Tait, W. W.: 1965, ‘The Substitution Method’, Journal of Symbolic Logic 30, 175–192.
Tait, W. W.: 1981, ‘Finitism’, Journal of Philosophy 78, 524–546.
Tait, W. W.: 2002, ‘Remarks on Finitism’, in W. Sieg, R. Sommer, and C. Talcott (eds.), Reflections on the Foundations of Mathematics. Essays in Honor of Solomon Feferman, LNL 15. Association for Symbolic Logic.
van Heijenoort, J. (ed.): 1967, From Frege to Gödel. A Source Book in Mathematical Logic, 1897-1931, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
von Neumann, J.: 1927, ‘Zur Hilbertschen Beweistheorie’, Mathematische Zeitschrift 26, 1–46.
Whitehead, A. N. and B. Russell: 1910, Principia Mathematica, Vol. 1, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Whitehead, A. N. and B. Russell: 1913, Principia Mathematica, Vol. 2, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Zach, R.: 1998, ‘Numbers and Functions in Hilbert's Finitism’, Taiwanese Journal for Philosophy and History of Science 10, 33–60.
Zach, R.: 1999, ‘Completeness before Post: Bernays, Hilbert, and the Development of Propositional Logic’, Bulletin of Symbolic Logic 5(3), 331–366.
Zach, R.: 2001a, ‘Hilbert's Program: Historical, Philosophical, and Metamathematical Perspectives’, Ph.D. thesis, University of California, Berkeley.
Zach, R.: 2001b, ‘Hilbert's “Verunglückter Beweis” and the Epsilon-Theorems’, in preparation.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Zach, R. The Practice of Finitism: Epsilon Calculus and Consistency Proofs in Hilbert's Program. Synthese 137, 211–259 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1026247421383
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1026247421383