Abstract
In South Africa attempts are being made to address the socio-spatial distortions of the apartheid era through a more equitable distribution of resources, and the re-drawing of municipal geographical boundaries. However, boundaries are not neutral geographic lines. Boundary changes are often associated with a redistribution of political power and resources. The aim of this paper is to analyse the effects of the contemporary territorial and administrative restructuring on urban dynamics in South Africa. More specifically, the focus is on how the process of territorial restructuring impacted on metropolitan areas as well as on secondary cities and their hinterlands. Examining and elucidating the manner in which various social, economic and political forces have manifested themselves in the process of boundary delimitation in a major metropolitan centre as well as adjacent rural areas is a central theme of this paper. There were considerable contestations over the delimitation of new local government boundaries. Affluent metro authorities like that in Durban were opposed to the spatial extension of their boundaries because of the costs of the providing services and infrastructure in the deprived margins. Similarly, there was concern that incorporation of rural areas will result in increased municipal service charges being imposed on these communities. Tensions were heightened between urban and rural regions because traditional leaders believed that their territorial jurisdiction and authority were being undermined. In other parts of the country, the merger of traditionally white and black fragments of secondary cities often resulted in many black locations continuing to be marginalized. There appears to be neither the political will nor the economic capacity to upgrade these zones of marginalized urban communities. While the Municipal Demarcation Board was largely successful in eliminating the political geography of apartheid at a macro- scale, this paper suggests that the greater challenge for government and policy makers is to reduce the socio-spatial and economic inequalities which appears to be still very high and perhaps increasing.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Alexander A., 1982: Local Government in Britain since reorganisation.Allen and Unwin, London.
Allanic B., 2001: Borderlands: From dumping grounds to attractive residential settlements, Paper presented in Johannesburg (IFAS) on the 11th of June, seminar Power and territories.
Anderson J., 1996: The shifting stage of politics: New medieval and postmodern territorialities ? In: Anderson J., Brook C. and Cochrane A.(eds), A Global World? Re-ordering Political Space, pp. 65–112. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Badie B., 1995: La fin du territoire. Essai sur le désordre international et sur l'utilité sociale du respect. Fayard, Paris.
Barbier J.-C., Burgel G., Delpech B. and Giraut F. (eds), 1995: Villes secondaires d'Afrique.Villes en Parallè e n 22, Nanterre.
Barlow M., 1981: Spatial Dimensions of Urban Government. Research Studies Press, Chichester.
Barlow M., 1991: Metropolitan Government. Routledge, London.
Barlow, M. 1995: Greater Manchester: conurbation complexity and local government structure. Political Geography 14: 379–400.
Barlow, M. 1997: Administrative systems and metropolitan regions. Environment and Planning C: Government and policy 15: 399–411.
Bekker S. et al., 1997: Local government transition in five eastern seaboard South African towns. Politikon 24(1): 38–56.
Bond P., 1998: Local economic development and the municipal services crisis in post Apartheid South Africa. The case of Stutterheim. Urban Forum 9(2): 159–196.
Cameron R.G. (ed.), 1999: The democratisation of South African local government. A tale of three cities. L. Van Schaik, Pretoria.
Cashden B., 2002: Local government and poverty in South Africa. In: Parnell S., Pieterse E., Swilling M. and Wooldridge D. (eds), Democratising local government: the South African Experiment, pp. 159–180.University of Cape Town Press, Cape Town.
Christopher A.-J., 1994: The Atlas of Apartheid, Routledge, London.
Claval P. and Sanguin A.-L. (eds), 1997: Métropolisation et politique.L'Harmattan, Paris.
Coates B.E. et al., 1986: Urban Inequalities, Market Processes and Local Government. In: A. Blowers, C. Brook, P. Dunleavy and L. McDowell (eds), Urban Change and Conflict: An Interdisciplinary Reader, pp. 122–130. Harper and Row, London.
Coulbois P. and Jung J., 1994: Aménagement du territoire: une méthode. Les exemples de l'Allemagne, de l'Autriche et de la Suisse, La Documentation Française, Paris.
Crouzel Y., 1999: La chéfferie traditionnelle face à la démocratisation des pouvoirs locaux. Afrique Contemporaine 192: 30–39.
Donaldson S.E., 2001: Amalgamation of the former homeland bordertownship of Seshego and the conservative apartheid city Pietersburg during transition. The South African Geographical Journal 83(3): 208–213.
Giraut F., 2000: Innovation territoriale et référent identitaire. Du renouveau des provinces nigériennes à celui des ‘pays’ français. In: Chaléard J.-L.et Pourtier R. (eds), Politiques et dynamiques territoriales dans les pays du Sud, pp. 77–108. Pub. de la Sorbonne, Paris.
Godlewska A. and Smith N. (eds), 1994: Geography and Empire. Blackwell, Oxford.
Gottmann J., 1980: Center and Periphery, Spatial Variations in Politics. Sage Publications, Beverly Hills.
Graaf de V., 1986: The present state of urbanisation in the South African Homelands and some future scenario's. University of Stellenbosch-Dpt of Sociology, Occasional paper 11.
Guichard O., 1976: Vivre ensemble. La Documentation Française, Paris.
Guyot S., 2001: Evolution of political territories and post-apartheid challenges of management of the Port Shepstone area. Paper presented on the International symposium on government, governance and urban territories in Southern Africa, 15 p, Lusaka (University of Zambia), 21-22 November.
Harrison P. and Naidoo J., 2000: Chimera or guiding vision?: Local economic development and the town of Port Shepstone in Kwazulu-Natal. Urban Forum 11(1): 119–131.
Hasson S. and Razin E., 1990: What is hidden behind a municipal boundary conflict? Political Geography Quarterly 9(3): 267–283.
Higgins D., 1986: The process of reorganising local government. Canadian Journal of Political Science 19: 217–242.
Jaglin S. and Dubresson A. (eds), 1993: Pouvoirs et cités d'Afrique noire. Décentralisations en questions. Karthala, Paris.
Kammeier H.D., 2002: Rural-urban linkages and the role of small and medium sized towns in Development: Issues, Concepts and Policies. Paper presented at Workshop on Poverty Alleviation through Rural-Urban Linkages, Siem Reap, Cambodia.
Khan F. and Maharaj B., 1994: A preliminary assessment of the Greater Durban Forum Area. Submission made to the Boundary Forum, Durban.
Khan F. and Maharaj B., 1997: Metropolitan government and local restructuring in South Africa. In: Naidu R. A. and Reddy P.S. (eds), Metropolitan Government and Development: Present and Future Challenges, pp. 153–174. Konrad Adenauer Stiftung, Durban.
Keating M., 1995: Size, efficiency and democracy: Consolidation, fragmentation and public choice. In: Judge D., Stoker G. and Wolman H. (eds), Theories of urban politics, pp. 117–134. Sage Publications, London.
Leresche J. and Joye D., 1995: The emergence of the 'Lemanique metropole': A process of apprenticeship. Political Geography 14: 401–417.
Mamdani M., 1996: Citizen and Subject. Contemporary Africa and the Legacy of Late Colonialism. Princeton University Press, Princeton.
Maharaj B., 1997: The politics of local government restructuring and Apartheid transformation in South Africa. Journal of Contemporary African Studies 15(2): 261–285.
Mawhood P. (ed.), 1993: Local government in the Third World. Experience of decentralization in tropical Africa. African Institute of South Africa, Pretoria.
May J., 1993: Democracy and social concerns in Region E. RDAC Report.
McCarthy J. and Bernstein A., 1996: South Africa's Small Towns: New Strategies for Growth and Development. Centre for Development and Enterprise, Johannesburg.
Mchunu V., 2002a: Rural areas strain city budget. Mercury, 13 June, p. 2.
Mchunu V., 2002b: Police 'unable to service new ares'. Mercury, 21May, p. 3.
Moriconi-Ebrard F., 1994: Villes secondaires et métropoles du tiers monde. In: Barbier J.-C., Burgel G., Delpech B. and Giraut F. (eds), Villes secondaires d'Afrique, Villes en Parallèle 22: 39–56, Nanterre.
Moriconi-Ebrard F., 2000:De Babylone à Tokyo. Les grandes agglomérations du Monde. Ophrys, Paris & Gap.
Municipal Demarcation Board, 1999: An integrated framework of nodal points for metropolitan and district council areas in South Africa: A preliminary framework, Municipal Demarcation Board, Pretoria.
Murray C., 1992: Displaced urbanisation: South Africa's Rural Slums. African Affairs 91: 311–329.
Narsiah S. and Maharaj B., 1997: The Creation of 'Real' Spaces: Regions and Regionalism in the New South Africa. Space and Polity 2(1): 225–248.
Narsiah S. and Maharaj B., 1999: Borders of Dissent in South Africa: The Bushbuckridge Saga. Transformation 40: 36–54.
Nel E.L., 1994: Local development initiatives and Stutterheim. Development Southern Africa 11(3): 363–377.
Olowu, 2001: Decentralization Policies and Practices under Structural Adjustment and Democratization in Africa. In Democracy, Governance and Human Rights (Programme Paper 4), United Nations Research Institute for Social Development.
Ozouf-Marinier M.-V., 1989: La formation des departements. Ed. de l'EHESS, Paris.
PLANACT, 1992: The reorganisation of local government in South Africa. Johannesburg.
Pillay U., 1994: Local government restructuring, growth coalitions, and the development process in the Durban Functional Region, c.1984-1994. Urban Forum 5: 69–86.
Pillay U., 1999: Demarcating South Africa's metro areas: a cautionary lesson from the Durban Metropolitan Area. In: R. Cameron (ed.), Democratisation of South African Local Government, pp. 201–223. J.L. van Schaik, Pretoria.
Razin E., 2000: The impact of local government organization on development and disparities-a comparative perspective. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 18: 17–31.
Raffestin C., 1980: Pour une géographie du pouvoir. LITEC, Paris.
Ramutsindela M.R., 2001: Unfrozen Ground: South Africa's Contested Spaces. Ashgate, Aldershot.
Ramutsindela M.R. and Simon D., 1999: The politics of territory and place in post-apartheid South Africa: the disputed area of Bushbuckridge. Journal of Southern African Studies 25: 479–498.
Reynaud A., 1981: Société, espace et justice. Presses Universitaires de France, Paris.
Sancton A., 1996: Reducing costs by consolidating municipalities: New Brunswick, Nova Scotia and Ontario. Canadian Public Administration 39: 267–289.
Seethal C., 1991: Restructuring the local state in South Africa: Regional Services Councils and crisis revolution. Political Geography Quarterly 10(1): 8–25.
Sole S., 1999: Durban unicity to eclipse provincial power. Sunday Tribune, 12 September, p. 2.
Spate O.H.K., 1942: Factors in the development of capital cities. Geographical Review 32(4): 622–631.
Sutcliffe M., 2002: Municipal Demarcation Board. </del>Paper presented at the French-South African Conference on Terrritorial Innovation, January, Grenoble, France.
Swilling M., Cobbett W. and Hunter., 1991: Finance, electricity costs and the rent boycott. In: M. Swilling, R. Humphries and K. Shubane (eds), Apartheid City in Transition, pp. 174–196. Oxford University Press.
Swilling M., Monteiro O. and Johnson K., 1995: Building democratic local governance in Southern Africa: A review of key trends. Paper presented at the World Congress of the Global Urban Research Initiative, Mexico City.
Wollmann H., 2000: Local government systems: from historic divergence towards convergence? Great Britain, France and Germany as comparative cases in point. Environment and Planning C: Government and policy 18: 33–55.
Wooldridge D., 2002: Introducing Metropolitan Local Government in South Africa. In: S. Parnell, E. Pieterse, M. Swilling and D. Wooldridge (eds), Democratising local government: the South African Experiment, pp. 127–140. University of Cape Town Press, Cape Town.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Giraut, F., Maharaj, B. Contested terrains: Cities and hinterlands in post-apartheid boundary delimitations. GeoJournal 57, 39–51 (2002). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1026018819206
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1026018819206