Environment, Development and Sustainability

, Volume 5, Issue 3–4, pp 383–400 | Cite as

Market Integration and Ecosystem Degradation: Is Sustainable Tourism Development in Rural Communities a Contradiction in Terms?

  • Stefan Gössling
Article

Abstract

Neoclassic economic theory suggests global market integration as a strategy to reduce poverty. In line with this paradigm, an increasing number of developing countries have focused on tourism to generate foreign exchange earnings and to meet rising workforce pressure. Coastlines in particular, have been at the forefront of tourist infrastructure development. The article describes tourism development in the village of Kiwengwa on the east coast of Unguja Island (Zanzibar), Tanzania. It is shown that changes caused by tourism are far more complex than economic theory suggests. Economically, tourism has substantially increased local income, but it has also led to a focus on individual benefit and dissolving kinship relationships, encouraged the abandonment of traditional resource-use strategies, contributed to the commoditization of local natural resources, and spread the idea that these resources can be replaced with imports. Overall, tourism has fundamentally disrupted the local socio-economic system and led to a self-reinforcing cycle of ecosystem degradation. Tourism development is nevertheless perceived as positive and sustainable, because (i) changes are complex and damage becomes perceptible only in the medium- or long-term future, (ii) the tourist industry tends to shift its impacts to remote areas, i.e. a supplying periphery, (iii) the village has become a center of resource allocation itself, with imports compensating for the losses in local ecosystem capacity. As a development option imposed by the transnational tourist industry, tourism leads to the creation of new centers (i.e. the former periphery) while simultaneously creating new peripheries. In a finite world with a limited hinterland for such a continuous expansion, this cannot be sustainable.

ecological capacity ecosystem sustainable development Tanzania tourism Zanzibar. 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Andersson, J. and Ngazi, Z.: 1998, ‘Coastal communities’ production choices, risk diversification, and subsistence behavior: responses in periods of transition’, Ambio 27(8), 686-693.Google Scholar
  2. Bakari, R.: 1998, ‘Factors determining the exploitation of crustacean resources in Tanzania: an application of fisheries model’, Paper Presented at the Workshop on Valuation of the Marine and Coastal Resources and the Environment, 6-9 December, Zanzibar, Tanzania.Google Scholar
  3. Barnett, R.: 1997, ‘The shark trade in Mainland Tanzania and Zanzibar’, in N.T. Marshall and R. Barnett (eds.), The trade in sharks and shark products in the Western Indian and Southeast Atlantic Oceans, TRAFFIC East/Southern Africa, pp. 39-67.Google Scholar
  4. Burton, R.: 1872, Zanzibar: City, Island and Coast (2 vols), London, Tinsley.Google Scholar
  5. Butler, R.W.: 1980, ‘The concept of a tourist-area cycle of evolution and implications for management’, The Canadian Geographer 24, 5-12.Google Scholar
  6. Cesar, H., Lundin, C.G., Bettencourt, S. and Dixon, J.: 1997, ‘Indonesian coral reefs-an economic analysis of a precious but threatened resource’, Ambio 26(6), 345-350.Google Scholar
  7. Commission for Tourism: 1996, Tourist Expenditure 1984-1997, Zanzibar, Tanzania.Google Scholar
  8. Commission for Tourism: 2000, International Tourist Arrivals by Nationality 1985-1999, Zanzibar, Tanzania.Google Scholar
  9. Dixon, J., Scura, L.F. and van't Hof, T.: 1993, ‘Meeting ecological and economic goals: marine parks in the Caribbean’, Ambio 22(2-3), 117-125.Google Scholar
  10. Domroes, M.: 1990, ‘Tourism resources and their development in Maldive Islands’, GeoJournal 10, 119-126.Google Scholar
  11. Gadgil, M., Berkes, F. and Folke, C.: 1993, ‘Indigenous knowledge for biodiversity conservation’, Ambio 22(2-3), 151-156.Google Scholar
  12. Gössling, S.: 1999, ‘Ecotourism-a means to safeguard biodiversity and ecosystem functions?’ Ecological Economics 29, 303-320.Google Scholar
  13. Gössling, S.: 2000a, ‘The consequences of tourism for sustainable water use on a tropical island: Zanzibar, Tanzania’, Journal of Environmental Management 61(2), 179-191.Google Scholar
  14. Gössling, S.: 2000b, ‘Sustainable tourism development in developing countries: some aspects of energy use’, Journal of Sustainable Tourism 8(5), 410-425.Google Scholar
  15. Gössling, S.: 2000c, ‘Tourism development in Sri Lanka: the case of Ethukala and Unawatuna’, Tourism Recreation Research 25(3), 103-114.Google Scholar
  16. Gössling, S.: 2001,‘Tourism, environmental degradation and economic transition: interacting processes in a Tanzanian coastal community’, Tourism Geographies, 3(4), 230-254.Google Scholar
  17. Gössling, S., Borgström-Hansson, C., Hörstmeier, O. and Saggel, S.: 2002, ‘Ecological footprint analysis as a tool to analyse tourism sustainability’, Ecological Economics, 43, 199-211.Google Scholar
  18. Honey, M.: 1999, Ecotourism and Sustainable Development, Washington DC, Island Press.Google Scholar
  19. Iwand, W.M.: 1999, ‘Tourismus als globale Strategie f¨ur nachhaltige Entwicklung [Tourism as a global strategy for sustainable development]’, Presentation during the International Tourism Exchange (ITB) in Berlin, 7 March 1999, Berlin.Google Scholar
  20. Jiddawi, N.: 1998, ‘The reef dependent fisheries of Zanzibar’, in R.W. Johnstone, J. Francis and C.A. Muhando (eds.), Coral Reefs: Values, Threats, and Solutions, Proceedings of the National Conference on Coral Reefs, Zanzibar, Tanzania. Institute of Marine Sciences, Zanzibar, pp. 22-36.Google Scholar
  21. Johnstone, R.W., Muhando, C.A. and Francis, J.: 1998, ‘The status of the coral reefs of Zanzibar: one example of a regional predicament’, Ambio 27(8), 700-707.Google Scholar
  22. Khatib, A.H.: 1998, ‘The importance of tourism to coral reefs on Zanzibar’, in R.W. Johnstone, J. Francis and C.A. Muhando (eds.), Coral Reefs: Values, Threats, and Solutions, Proceedings of the National Conference on Coral Reefs, Zanzibar, Tanzania. Institute of Marine Sciences, Zanzibar, pp. 36-38.Google Scholar
  23. Lindén, O. and Lundin, C.G. (eds.): 1997, ‘The journey from Arusha to Seychelles. Successes and failures of integrated coastal zone management in Eastern Africa and island states’, Proceedings of Coastal Zone Management in Eastern Africa and Island States, 23-25 October 1996, Seychelles.Google Scholar
  24. Marks, R.: 1996, ‘Conservation and community: the contradictions and ambiguities of tourism in the Stone Town of Zanzibar’, Habitat International 20(2), 265-278.Google Scholar
  25. Middleton, J.: 1992, The World of the Swahili. An African Mercantile Civilization, New Haven, Yale University Press.Google Scholar
  26. Moffat, D., Ngoile, M.N., Linden, O. and Francis, J.: 1998, ‘The reality of the stomach: coastal management at the local level in Eastern Africa’, Ambio 27(8), 590-598.Google Scholar
  27. Msuya, F.E.: 1998, ‘Socioeconomic impacts of coral destruction on Unguja Island, Zanzibar, Tanzania’, in R.W. Johnstone, J. Francis and C.A. Muhando (eds.), Coral Reefs: Values, Threats, and Solutions, Proceedings of the National Conference on Coral Reefs, Zanzibar, Tanzania, Institute of Marine Sciences, Zanzibar, pp. 52-62.Google Scholar
  28. MWCELE (Ministry of Water, Energy, Construction, Lands and Environment): 1993, Tourism Zoning Plan: Main Report, Zanzibar, Tanzania.Google Scholar
  29. MWCELE (Ministry of Water, Energy, Construction, Lands and Environment): 1995, National Land Use Plan: Analysis of Potentials and Issues, Zanzibar, Tanzania.Google Scholar
  30. Pet-Soede, C., Cesar, H.S.J. and Pet, J.S.: 1999, ‘An economic analysis of blast fishing on Indonesian coral reefs’, Environmental Conservation 26(2), 83-93.Google Scholar
  31. Pettersson-Löfquist, P.: 1995, ‘The development of open-water algae farming in Zanzibar: reflections on the socioeconomic impact’, Ambio 24(7-8): 487-491.Google Scholar
  32. Sachs,W.: 2000, ‘Wie zukunftsf¨ahig ist Globalisierung?’, Wuppertal Papers 99,Wuppertal Institut für Klima, Umwelt, Energie GmbH. Wuppertal, Germany.Google Scholar
  33. Sala, O.E., Chapin III, F.S., Armesto, J.J., Berlow, E., Bloomfield, J., Dirzo, R., Huber-Sanwald, E., Huenneke, L.F., Jackson, R.B., Kinzig, A., Leemans, R., Lodge, D.M., Mooney, H.A., Oesterheld, M., Poff, N.L., Sykes, M.T., Walker, B.H., Walker, M. and Wall, D.H.: 2000, ‘Global biodiversity scenarios for the Year 2100’, Science 287, 1770-1774.Google Scholar
  34. Sheriff, A.: 1987, Slaves, Spices, and Ivory in Zanzibar. Integration of an East African Commercial Empire into the World Economy, 1770-1873, Eastern African Studies, Nairobi, Heinemann.Google Scholar
  35. Sheriff, A. and Fergusson, E. (eds.): 1991, Zanzibar under Colonial Rule. Eastern African Studies, Nairobi, Heinemann.Google Scholar
  36. Tobisson, E., Andersson, J., Ngazi, Z., Rydberg, L. and Cederlöf, U.: 1998, ‘Tides, monsoons and seabed: local knowledge and practice in Chwaka Bay, Zanzibar’, Ambio 27(8), 677-685.Google Scholar
  37. UNDP/UNEP/World Bank/WRI: 2000, World Resources 2000-2001, World Resources Institute.Google Scholar
  38. Wackernagel, M. and Rees, W. E.: 1996, Our Ecological Footprint: Reducing Human Impact on the Earth, Gabriola Island, BC, New Society.Google Scholar
  39. World Bank: 1998, ‘Think Tank Group and World Tourism Organization Examine Role of Tourism in Development’, News Release No. 98/1853/S, June 25, 1998, Washington DC.Google Scholar
  40. WTO (World Tourism Organisation): 1997, ‘Tourism is One of the Environment's best Friends’, Secretary-General Addresses Special Session of United Nations, New York, Press release 24/6/1997.Google Scholar
  41. WWF (World Wildlife Fund): 1995, ‘Ecotourism: conservation tool or threat’, Conservation Issues 2(3), 1-10.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2003

Authors and Affiliations

  • Stefan Gössling
    • 1
  1. 1.Institute of Cultural GeographyFreiburg UniversityFreiburgGermany

Personalised recommendations