Advertisement

Foundations of Chemistry

, 5:189 | Cite as

Mendeleev's Discovery of the Periodic Law: The Origin and the Reception

  • Masanori Kaji
Article

Abstract

This paper addresses the conceptual as well as social origins of Mendeleev’s discovery of the periodic law and its reception by the chemical community by taking account of three factors: Mendeleev’s early research and its relevance to the discovery; his concepts of chemistry, especially that of the chemical elements; and the social context of the discovery and the reception in the chemical community. Mendeleev's clear distinction between abstract elements and simple bodies was a departure from Lavoisier’s famous definition of elements as an endpoint of analysis and originated from his research in indefinite compounds. As a comparison, the paper also analyzes Lothar Meyer’s approach to the classification of the elements. Mendeleev’s new concept of chemical elements and the existence of an audience in the form of the newly established Russian Chemical Society, and his ``German connection'', helped Mendeleev in his discovery and its reception.

Keywords

Atomic Weight German Journal Simple Body Gregorian Calendar Julian Calendar 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

REFERENCES

  1. M. Akeroyd, Predictions, Retrodictions and the Periodic Table. Foundations of Chemistry 5: 85–88, 2003.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. M. Akeroyd, Predictions and the Periodic Table: A Response to Scerri and Worrall. Journal for General Philosophy of Science 35, 2004 (accepted for publication).Google Scholar
  3. P.P. Bedson. Lothar Meyer Memorial Lecture. Journal of the Chemical Society 69: 1402–1439, 1896.Google Scholar
  4. O.T. Benfey. Meyer, Julius Lothar, in C.C. Gillispie (Ed.), The Dictionary of Scientific Biography, vol. 9. Scribner, New York, pp. 347–353, 1981.Google Scholar
  5. B. Bensaude-Vincent, Mendeleev's Periodic System of Chemical Elements. British Journal for the History of Science 19: 3–17, 1986.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. N.M. Brooks, The Formation of a Community of Chemists in Russia, 1700–1870. Unpub. Ph.D. dissertation, Columbia University, 1989.Google Scholar
  7. S.G. Brush, The Reception of Mendeleev's Periodic Law in America and Britain. Isis 87: 595–628, 1996.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. S. Cannizzaro. Sunto di un corso di filosofia chimica. Il nuovo cimento 7: 321–366, 1858.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. S. Cannizzaro, Sketch of a Course in Chemical Philosophy, Alembic Club Reprints, no. 18. Alembic Club, Edinburgh, re-issue edn., 1969.Google Scholar
  10. R.B. Dobrotin. Rannii period nauchnoi deiatel'nosti D.I. Mendeleeva kak etap na puti k otkruitiyu periodicheskogo zakona. Candidate dissertation, Leningrad State University, 1953.Google Scholar
  11. I.S. Dmitriev, Nauchnoe otkrytie in Statu Nascendi: periodicheskii zakon D.I. Mendeleeva. VIET (1): 31–82, 2001.Google Scholar
  12. M.G. Faershtein, Istoriya ucheniya o molekule v khimii (do 1860g.). Izd. Akademii Nauk SSSR, Moscow, 1961.Google Scholar
  13. N.A. Figurovskii and K.Ts. Elagina, Aleksandr Abramovich Voskresenskii (1809–1880). Trudy instituta istorii estestvoznaniya i tekhniki 18: 213–235, 1958.Google Scholar
  14. M.D. Gordin, The Ordered Society and Its Enemies: D.I. Mendeleev and the Russian Empire, 1861–1905. Ph.D. dissertation. Harvard University, 2001.Google Scholar
  15. M.D. Gordin, The Organic Roots of Mendeleev's Periodic Law. Historical Studies in the Physical and Biological Sciences 32(1): 263–290, 2002.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. A.J. Ihde, The Development of Modern Chemistry. Harper & Row, New York/Evanston/London, 1964.Google Scholar
  17. M. Kaji, On Mendeleev's Path to the Discovery of the Periodic Law: Analysis of HisWork Between 1854 and 1869 (in Japanese). Kagakusi Kenkyu (Journal for the History of Science Society of Japan) 26: 129–139, 1987.Google Scholar
  18. M. Kaji, The Historical Context of the First Edition of the Mendeleev's Chemistry Textbook “The Principles of Chemistry” (in Japanese). Kagakusi Kenkyu (Journal for the History of Science Society of Japan) 27: 24–36, 1988.Google Scholar
  19. M. Kaji, Mendeleev's Discovery of the Periodic Law of the Chemical Elements (The Scientific and Social Context of His Discovery) (in Japanese with English summary). Hokkaido UP, Sapporo, 1997.Google Scholar
  20. M. Kaji, D.I. Mendeleev's Concept of Chemical Elements and the Principles of Chemistry. Bulletin for the History of Chemistry 27(1): 4–16, 2002.Google Scholar
  21. M. Kaji, Social Background of the Discovery and the Reception of the Periodic Law of the Elements. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 988: 1–5, 2003.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. G.B. Kauffman, The Reception of Mendeleev's Ideas in the United States and Mendeleev's Correspondence with American Scientists. Archives Interantionale d'Histoire des Sciences 23: 84–106, 1970.Google Scholar
  23. B.M. Kedrov, Den' odnogo velikogo otkrytia. Izd. Sotsial'no-ekonomicheskoi Literatury, Moscow, 1958 (reprinted in 2001, Editorial URSS, Moscow).Google Scholar
  24. B.M. Kedrov, Filosofiskii analiz pervykh trudov D.I. Mendeleeva o periodicheskom zakone (1869–1871). Izd-vo Nauka, Moscow, 1959.Google Scholar
  25. V.V. Kozlov, Ocherki istorii khimicheskikh obshchestv SSSR. Izd-vo AN SSSR, Moscow, 1961.Google Scholar
  26. V.A. Krotikov, Dve oshibki v pervykh publikatsiyakh o periodicheskom zakone D.I. Mendeleeva. VIET (29): 129–131, 1969.Google Scholar
  27. H.M. Leicester, The Historical Background of Chemistry. Dover, New York, 1971 (first published in 1956).Google Scholar
  28. H.M. Leicester and H.S. Klickstein (Eds), Source Book in Chemistry 1400–1900. New York, 1952.Google Scholar
  29. A.A. Makarenya, D.I. Mendeleev i fiziko-khimicheskie nauki – Opuit nauchnoi biografii D.I. Mendeleeva, 2-e izd. Energoizdat, Moscow, 1982 (1-e izd. 1972).Google Scholar
  30. D.I. Mendeleev, Chemische Analyse des Orthits aus Finnland. Verhandlungen der russisch-kaiserlichen mineralogischen Gesellschaft zu St.-Petersburg, Jg 1854, St.-Petersburg, pp. 234–239, 1854a.Google Scholar
  31. D.I. Mendeev, Rezul'tatui khimicheskogo analiza selenginskoi umbrui, proizvedennogo v laboratorii Glavnogo pedagogicheskogo instituta. Vestnik imp. russkogo geograficheskogo obshchestva. St.-Petersburg, pt. 12, section 5, Geogr. izv. i sves, pp. 36–37, 1854b.Google Scholar
  32. D.I. Mendeleev, Izomorfizm v svyazi s otnosheniyami kristallicheskoi formy k sostavu. Gornyi zhurnal ch. 3, kn. 8, pp. 229–400; kn. 9, pp. 405–467, 1855.Google Scholar
  33. D.I. Mendeleev, Pyroxen aus Ruskiala in Finnland. Verhandlungen der Russisch-kaiserlichen mineralogischen Gesellschaft zu St.-Petersburg. Jg 1855–1856, pp. 207–210, 1856a.Google Scholar
  34. D.I. Mendeleev, Udel'nye obemy. Master's thesis, 1856b.Google Scholar
  35. D.I. Mendeleev, O stroenii kremnezemistykh soedinenii. A dissertation pro venia legendi, 1856c.Google Scholar
  36. D.I. Mendeleev, Chastichnoe stseplenie nekotoruikh zhidkikh organicheskikh soedinienii. Khimicheskii zhurnal N. Sokolova i A. Engel'garta 3(2): 81–97; (3): 145–170, 1860a.Google Scholar
  37. D.I. Mendeleev, Notiz über die Ausdehnung homologer Flüssigkeiten. Ann. Chem. Pharm. 114(2): 165–169, 1860b.Google Scholar
  38. D.I. Mendeleev, Sur la cohésion de quelques liquides et sur le rôle de la cohésion moléculaire dans les réactions chimiques des corps. Compt. rend. 51(3): 97–99, 1860c.Google Scholar
  39. D.I. Mendeleev, O rasshirenii zhidkostei ot nagrevaniya vyshe temgeratur kipeniya. Gornyi zhurnal, ch. 2, No. 4 otd. 3 Khimiya, pp. 141–152, 1860d.Google Scholar
  40. D.I. Mendeleev, Khimicheskii kongress v Karlsrue (Pis'mo k A.A. Voskresenskomu iz Geidel'berga ot 7 sent. 1860g.). gaz. S.-Peterb. ved., 1860, 2 noyabrya, No. 238, p. 4, stlb. 2–5, 1860e.Google Scholar
  41. D. Mendeleev, Organicheskaya khimiya, 1st edn. Izd.tov-va “Obshchestv. pol'za”, St. Petersburg, 1861.Google Scholar
  42. D. Mendeleev, Essai d'une théorie sur les limites des combinaisons organiques. Bulletin de l'Académie impériale des sciences de St.-Pétersbourg 4: 245–250, 1862.Google Scholar
  43. D.I. Mendeleev, O soedinenii spirta s vodoi. Rassuzhlenie, predstavlennoe v fiziko-matematicheskii fakul'tet I.S. Peterburgskogo universiteta dlya poluchenii doktora khimii. Tip. tov-va “Obshchestv. pol'za,” St. Petersburg, 1865.Google Scholar
  44. D.I. Mendeleev, Osnovy khimii, ch. 1, v. 1, gl. 1–11. Tip. tov-va “Obshchestv. pol'za,” St. Petersburg, 1868a.Google Scholar
  45. D.I. Mendeleev, Lektsii organicheskoi khimii, chitannye D.I. Mendeleevym v Tekhnologicheskom institute. Uglerodistye vodorody. Izd. M. Matyukevich, St. Petersburg, 1868b.Google Scholar
  46. D.I. Mendeleev, Opyt sistemy elementov, osnovannoi na ikh atomnom vese i khimicheskom skhodstve, 1869a.Google Scholar
  47. D. Mendeleev, Sootnoshenie svoistv s atomnym vesom elementov. Zh. Russ. Khim. Obshch 1(2/3): 60–77, 1869b.Google Scholar
  48. D.I. Mendeleev, Osnovy khimii, ch. 1, v. 2, gl. 12–22. Tip. tov-va “Obshchestv. pol'za,” St. Petersburg, 1869c.Google Scholar
  49. D. Mendelejeff, Über die Beziehungen der Eigenshaften zu den Atomgewichten der Elemente. Zeitschrift für Chemie 12: 405–406, 1869d.Google Scholar
  50. D.I. Mendeleev, Osnovy khimii, ch. 2, v. 3, gl. 1–8. Tip. tov-va “Obshchestv. pol'za,” St. Petersburg, 1870a.Google Scholar
  51. D.I. Mendeleev, Über die Stellung des Ceriums in System der Elemente. Bulletin de l'Académie impériale des sciences de St.-Petersburg 16(1): 45–51, 1870b.Google Scholar
  52. D.I. Mendeleev, Estestvennaya sistema elementov i primeninie ee k ukazaniyu svoistv neotkrytykh elementov. ZhRKhO 3(2): 25–56, 1870c.Google Scholar
  53. D.I. Mendeleev, Osnovy khimii, ch. 2, v. 1, gl. 9–22. Tip. tov-va “Obshchestv. pol'za,” St. Petersburg, 1871a.Google Scholar
  54. D. Mendelejeff, Die periodische Gesetzmässigkeit der chemischen Elements. Annalen der Chemie und Pharmacie Supplementband 8: 133–229, 1871b.Google Scholar
  55. D. Mendelejeff, Zur Gechichte des periodischen Gesetzes. Berichte der Deutschen Chemischen Gesellschaft 13: 1796–1804, 1880.Google Scholar
  56. Mendeléeff, The Periodic Law of the Chemical Elements, in The Principles of Chemistry, 3rd English edn., vol. II. Longmans, Green & Co., London/New York/Bombay, p. 493, 1905.Google Scholar
  57. D.I. Mendeleev, Arkhiv D.I. Mendeleeva tom 1, avtobiograficheskie materialy, sbornik dokumentov. Muzei-arkhiv D.I. Mendeleeva, Leningrad, 1951.Google Scholar
  58. D.I. Mendeleev, D.I. Mendeleev. Nauchyi arkhiv, T. 1, Periodicheskii zakon. Estestvennaya sistema elementov. Rukopisi i tablitsy, 1869–1871. Izd-vo AN SSSR, Moscow, 1953.Google Scholar
  59. D.I. Mendeleev, B.M. Kedrov (Ed.), Periodicheskii Zakon [Periodic Law]. Izd-vo AN SSSR, Moscow, 1958.Google Scholar
  60. D.I. Mendeleev, B.M. Kedrov (Ed.), Periodicheskii Zakon. Dopolnitel'nye materialy [Periodic Law. Additional Materials]. Izd-vo AN SSSR, Moscow, 1960.Google Scholar
  61. D.I. Mendeleev, Izbrannye lektsii po khimii. Izd-vo Vyshaya shkola, Leningrad/ Moscow, 1968.Google Scholar
  62. L. Meyer, Die modernen Theorien der Chemie und ihre Bedeutung für die chemische Statik. Verlag von Maruschke & Berendt, Breslau, 1864.Google Scholar
  63. L. Meyer, Die Natur der chemischen Elemente als Function ihrer Atomgewichte. Annalen der Chemie und Pharmarcie Supplementband 7: 354–364, 1870.Google Scholar
  64. L. Meyer, Zur Systematik der anorganischen Chemie. Berichte der Deutschen Chemischen Gesellschaft 6: 101–106, 1873.Google Scholar
  65. L. Meyer, Zur Geschichte des periodischen Atomistik. Berichte der Deutschen Chemischen Gesellschaft 13: 259–265, 1880a.Google Scholar
  66. L. Meyer, Zur Geschichte des periodischen Atomistik. Berichte der Deutschen Chemischen Gesellschaft 13: 2043–2044, 1880b.Google Scholar
  67. M.J. Nye, The Question of the Atom: From the Karlsruhe Congress to the First Solvay Conference, 1860–1911. Tomash Publishers, Los Angeles, 1984.Google Scholar
  68. F.A. Paneth, Chemical Elements and Primordial Matter: Mendeleeff's View and the Present Position, in Chemistry and Beyond. Interscience Publishers, New York/London/Sydney, pp. 53–72, 1965.Google Scholar
  69. V. von Richter, Uchebnik neorganicheskoi khimii po noveishim vozzreniyam. Tip. Ivanaya Yavorskogo, Warsaw, 1874.Google Scholar
  70. A.J. Rocke, Chemical Atomism in the Nineteenth Century: From Dalton to Cannizzaro, Ohio State University Press, Columbus, 1984.Google Scholar
  71. A.J. Rocke, The Quiet Revolution: Herman Kolbe and the Science of Organic Chemistry. University of California Press, Berkeley/Los Angeles/London, 1993.Google Scholar
  72. S.F. Savchenkov, Otnosheniya mezhdu atomnuimi vesami elementov. Gornui zhurnal, ch. 2, No. 5, pp. 234–251, 1871.Google Scholar
  73. E.R. Scerri. Realism, Reduction, and the “Intermediate Position”, in N. Bhushan and S. Rosenfeld (Eds), Of Minds and Molecules. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2000, pp. 51–72.Google Scholar
  74. E.R. Scerri and J. Worrall, Prediction and the Periodic Table. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 32A: 407–452, 2001.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  75. K. Seubert (Ed.), Das natürliche System der chemischen Elemente. Abhandlungen von Lothar Meyer und D. Mendelejeff. Ostwald's Klassiker der exakten Wissenschaften Nr. 68. Verlag vonWelhelm Engelmann, Leipzig, 1895.Google Scholar
  76. K. Seubert, Lothar Meyer. Berichte der Deutschen Chemischen Gesellschaft 28(4): 1109–1146, 1896.Google Scholar
  77. S.A. Shchukarev and R.B. Dobrotin, Pervye nauchye D.I. Mendeleeva kak etap na puti k otkrytiyu periodicheskogo zakona. Vestnik leningradskogo universiteta (2): 165–177, 1954.Google Scholar
  78. Y.I. Solov'ev, D.I. Mendeleev and the English Chemists. Journal of Chemical Education 61: 1069–1071, 1984.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  79. D.N. Trifonov, Versiya-2: k istorii otkrytiya periodicheskogo zakona D.I. Mendeleevym. VIET (2): 25–36; (3): 20–32, 1990.Google Scholar
  80. Tridtsatipyatiletie vysochaishche utverzhdennogo Tovarishchestva “Obshchestvennaya pol'za”. Tip. izd-va Obshchestv. pol'za, St. Petersburg, 1895.Google Scholar
  81. G. Urbain, Comment les idées de Mendeleiev ont été acctueillies en France. Revue Scientifique 72: 657–661, 1934.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2003

Authors and Affiliations

  • Masanori Kaji
    • 1
  1. 1.Graduate School of Decision Science and TechnologyTokyo Institute of TechnologyMeguro-ku, TokyoJapan

Personalised recommendations