Abstract
To evaluate the effects of ethnicity, culture, and counseling style on the interpretation of nondirectiveness in genetic counseling, a questionnaire containing premarital and prenatal case vignettes in two versions (pessimistic/optimistic) was administered to 281 Jewish and 133 Bedouin respondents. The first study population was comprised of Jewish students enrolled in a university and a community college in the Negev (southern part of Israel). The second study population was comprised of Muslim-Bedouin college students from the same area. The majority of Jewish respondents interpreted the nondirective message as intended by counselors, while the majority of Bedouin respondents did not. Counseling style was found to have a statistically significant effect on the interpretation of the general role of counseling. Gender and susceptibility were not found to have a significant effect on interpretation. Group differences are analyzed through a cultural lens in which different interpretive norms can generate expectations for either nondirectiveness or directiveness.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abeliovich, D., Quint, A., Weinberg, N., Verchezon, G., Lerer, I., Eckstein, J., et al. (1996). Cystic fibrosis heterozygote screening in the orthodox community of Ashkenazi Jews: The Dor Yesharim approach and heterozygote frequency. Eur J Hum Genet, 4, 77-82.
Andrews, L. (1994). Public choices and private choices: Legal regulation of genetic testing. In T. Murphy, & M. Lappé (Eds.), Justice and the human genome project (pp. 46-75.) Berkeley: University of California Press.
Angastiniotis, M. A., & Hadjiminas, M. G. (1981). Prevention of thalassemia in Cyprus. Lancet, 1, 369-370.
Angastiniotis, M. A., Kyriakidou, S., & Hadjiminas, M. (1986). How thalassemia was controlled in Cyprus. World Health Forum, 7, 291-297.
Brisson, D. (2000). Analysis and integration of definitions of community genetics. Community Genet, 3, 99-101.
Britton, B., & Pellegrini, A. (1991). Narrative thought and narrative language. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Broide, E., Zeigler, M., Eckstein, J., Bach, G. (1993). Screening for carriers of Tay-Sachs disease in the ultraorthodox Ashkenazi Jewish community in Israel. Am J Med Genet, 47, 21-35.
Burke, B., & Kolker, A. (1994). Directiveness in prenatal genetic counseling. Women Health, 22, 31-53.
Carmi, R., Elbedour, K., Weitzman, D., Sheffield V., & Shoham-Vardi, I. (1998). Lowering the burden of hereditary diseases in a traditional inbred community: Ethical aspects of genetic research and its application. Science Context, 11, (3/4), 391-395.
Chadwick, R. (1998). Can genetic counseling avoid the charge of eugenics? Sci Context, 11, (3/4), 471-481.
Chadwick, R., Darren, S., ten Have, H., & U. Wiesing (Eds.). (1999). The ethics of genetic screening. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Chapple, A., Campion, P., & May, C. (1997). Clinical terminology: Anxiety and confusion amongst families undergoing genetic counseling. Patient Educ Counsel, 32, 81-91.
Chapple, A., & May, C. (1996). Genetic knowledge and family relationships: Two case studies. Health Soc Care Community, 4(3), 166-171.
Christakis, N. (1992). Ethics are local: Engaging cross-cultural variation in the ethics for clinical research. Soc Sci Med, 35, 1079-1091.
Clarke, A. (1991). Is non-directive genetic counselling possible? (Editorial) The Lancet, 338(8773), 998(4).
Clarke, A., & Parsons, E. (Eds.). (1996). Culture, kinship and genes: Towards cross-cultural genetics. London: Macmillan.
Cohen, J. (1969). Statistical power analysis for the social sciences. New York: Academic Press.
Darr, A. (1996). Consanguineous marriage and genetics: A positive relationship. In A. Clarke & E. Parsons (Eds.), Culture, kinship and genes pp. 83-97 London: Macmillan.
Davidov, B., et al. (1994). Prenatal testing for Down syndrome in the Jewish and non-Jewish populations in Israel. Israel J Med Sci, 30, 629-633.
Dunne, C., & Warren, C. (1998). Lethal autonomy: The malfunction of the informed consent mechanism within the context of prenatal diagnosis of genetic variants. Issues Law Med, 14(2), 165-181.
Fish, S. (1980). Is there a text in this class?—The authority of interpretive communities. Harvard: Harvard University Press.
Fraser, F. (1974). Genetic counseling. Am J Hum Genet, 26, 636-659.
Hazan, H. (2000). Simulated dreams: Jewish youth and Zionism. London: Berghan Press.
Hoedemaeker, R., & ten Have, H. (1998). Geneticization: The Cyprus case. J Med Philos, 23(3), 274-287.
Hoshino, K. (Ed.). (1997). Japanese and western bioethics: Studies in moral diversity. Dodrecht: Kluwer.
Ioannou, P. (1999). Thalassemia prevention in Cyprus. In R. Chadwick et al. (Eds.), The ethics of genetic screening (pp. 55-67) Dodrecht: Kluwer.
Katriel, T. (1986). Talking straight: Dugri speech in Jewish Sabra culture. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
King, P. (1992). The past as prologue: Race, class, and gene discrimination. In G. Annas & S. Elias (Eds.). Gene mapping: Using law and ethics as guides (pp. 94-111). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Kressel, G. (1992). Shame and Gender. Anthropol Q, 65(1), 34-46.
Kressel, G. (1986). Prespective patrilateral parallel cousin marriage: The perspective of thebride's father and brothers. Ethnology, 25, 163-180.
Lewando-Hundt, G., Shoham-Vardi, I., Beckerelg, I., Belmaker, I., Kassem F., & Abu Jaafar, A. (2001). Knowledge, action and resistance: The selective use of prenatal screening among Bedouin women of the Negev, Israel. Soc Sci Med, 52, 561-569.
Meir, A. (1997). As Nomadism ends: The Bedouin of the Negev. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
Mernissi, F. (1987). Beyond the veil: Male–female dynamics in modem Muslim society. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
Mittman, I., Crombleholme, W., Green, J., & Golbus, M. (1998). Reproductive genetic counseling to Asian-Pacific and Latin American immigrants. J Genet Counsel, 7(1): 49-70.
National Academy of Sciences and National Research Council [NAS]. (1975). Genetic screening: Programs, principles and research. Washington, DC: National Academy of Sciences.
National Institutes of Health (United States) [NIH]—Working Group on Ethical, Legal, and Social Implications of the Human Genome Research [ELSI] Task Force on genetic testing (Neil A. Holtzman, chair). (1997). Promoting safe and effective genetic testing in the United States: Principles and recommendations. National Institutes of Health.
National Society of Genetic Counselors, US. (1997). What is genetic counseling? Wallingford, PA: Author.
Panter-Brick, C. (1991). Parental responses to consanguinity and genetic disease in Saudi-Arabia. Soc Sci Med, 33, 1295-1302.
Parens, E, & Asch, A. (Eds.). (2000). Prenatal testing and disability rights. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.
Pilnick, A. (2002). There are no rights and wrongs in these situations: Identifying interactional difficulties in genetic counseling. Sociol Health Illness, 24(1), 66-88.
President's Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research, Screening and Counseling for Genetic Conditions. (1983). The ethical, social and legal implications of genetic screening, counseling, and education programs (18). Washington, D.C.
Raz, A. (in press). Status disclosure: Genetic counseling as an arena for negotiation. Stud Symbolic Interaction, 26, 147-167.
Raz, A. (in press). Aysha: Genetics education and community engagement in a consanguineous Arab-Bedouin population in Israel. Health: Interdisciplin J Soc Study Health Illness.
Resta, R. (1997). Eugenics and nondirectiveness in genetic counseling. J Genet Counsel, 6, 255-258.
Sharp, R., & Foster, M. (2000). Involving study populations in the review of genetic research. J Law Med Ethics, 28(1), 41-51.
Shiloh, S., et al. (1995). Premarital genetic counseling to consanguineous couples. Soc Sci Med, 41(9), 1301-1310.
Stamatoyannopoulos, G. (1974). Problems of screening and counselling in the hemoglobinopathies. In: A. G. Motulsky & W, Lenz (Eds.), Birth defects. Amsterdam: Excerpta Medica.
Sue, D., & Sue, D. (1990). Counseling the culturally different: Theory and practice. New York: Wiley.
Tan Alora, A., & Lumitao, J. M. (Eds.). (2001). Beyond a western bioethics: Voices from the developing world. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.
Wang, V., & Marsh, F. (1992). Ethical principles and cultural integrity in health care delivery: Asian ethnocultural perspectives in genetic services. J Genet Counsel, 1, 81-92.
Weil, J. (2001). Multicultural education and genetic counseling. Clin Genet, 59, 143-149.
Weil, J., & Mittman, I. (1993). A teaching framework for cross-cultural genetic counseling. J Genet Counsel, 2(3), 159-169.
Weitzman, D., Shoham-Vardi, I., ElBedour, K., Belmaker, I., Siton, Y., & Carmi, R. (2000). Factors affecting utilization of prenatal testing for fetal abnormalities in a traditional society. Community Genet 3(2), 45-92.
Wertz, D., & Fletcher, J. (1989). Ethics and human genetics: A cross-cultural perspective. Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag.
Wertz, D. (1998). Eugenics is alive and well: A survey of genetic professionals around the world. Science Context, 11(3/4), 493-510.
WHO. (1985). Community approaches to the control of hereditary diseases (Unpublished WHO document HMG/AG/85.10). Geneva: Hereditary Diseases Program.
WHO. (1997). Community control of genetic and congenital disorders (EMRO Technical Publications, Series 24). Alexandria: Author.
WHO. (2002). Genomics and world health: Report of the advisory committee on Health Research Geneva: Author.
Wolff, G., & Jung, C. (1995). Nondirectiveness and genetic counseling. J Gen Counsel, 4, 3-25.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Raz, A.E., Atar, M. Nondirectiveness and Its Lay Interpretations: The Effect of Counseling Style, Ethnicity and Culture on Attitudes Towards Genetic Counseling Among Jewish and Bedouin Respondents in Israel. Journal of Genetic Counseling 12, 313–332 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1023901005451
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1023901005451