Biology and Philosophy

, Volume 18, Issue 1, pp 169–194 | Cite as

The Neural Mechanisms of Moral Cognition: A Multiple-Aspect Approach to Moral Judgment and Decision-Making

  • William D. Casebeer
  • Patricia S. Churchland
Article

Abstract

We critically review themushrooming literature addressing the neuralmechanisms of moral cognition (NMMC), reachingthe following broad conclusions: (1) researchmainly focuses on three inter-relatedcategories: the moral emotions, moral socialcognition, and abstract moral reasoning. (2)Research varies in terms of whether it deploysecologically valid or experimentallysimplified conceptions of moral cognition. Themore ecologically valid the experimentalregime, the broader the brain areas involved.(3) Much of the research depends on simplifyingassumptions about the domain of moral reasoningthat are motivated by the need to makeexperimental progress. This is a valuablebeginning, but as more is understood about theneural mechanisms of decision-making, morerealistic conceptions will need to replace thesimplified conceptions. (4) The neuralcorrelates of real-life moral cognition areunlikely to consist in anything remotely like a``moral module'' or a ``morality center.'' Moralrepresentations, deliberations and decisionsare probably highly distributed and notconfined to any particular brainsub-system. Discovering the basic neuralprinciples governing planning, judgment anddecision-making will require vastly more basicresearch in neuroscience, but correlatingactivity in certain brain regions withwell-defined psychological conditions helpsguide neural level research. Progress on socialphenomena will also require theoreticalinnovation in understanding the brain'sdistinctly biological form of computationthat is anchored by emotions, needs, drives,and the instinct for survival.

affect amygdala ethics evolution hippocampus moral cognition moral psychology naturalization neuroscience neurobiology prefrontal cortex theory of mind 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Adolphs, R.: 2002, ‘Trust in the Brain’, Nature Neuroscience 5(3), March, 192-193.Google Scholar
  2. Adolphs, R., Tranel, D. and Damasio, A.R.: 1998, ‘The Human Amygdala in Social Hudgment’, Nature 393, June 4, 470-474.Google Scholar
  3. Anderson, S.W., Bechara, A., Damasio, H., Tranel, D. and Damasio, A.R.: 1999, ‘Impairment of Social and Moral Behavior Related to Early Damage in Human Prefrontal Cortex’, Nature Neuroscience 2(11), November, 1032-1037.Google Scholar
  4. Anscombe, G.E.M.: 1958, ‘Modern Moral Philosophy’, Philosophy 33 (reprinted in (1997), R. Crisp and M. Slote (eds), Virtue Ethics: Oxford Readings in Philosophy, Oxford University Press, New York.Google Scholar
  5. Baxter, M.G. and Murray, E.A.: 2002, ‘The Amygdala and Reward’, Nature Reviews: Neuroscience 3, July, 563-573.Google Scholar
  6. Bechara, A., Damasio, A.R., Damasio, H. and Anderson, S.W.: 1994, ‘Insensitivity to Future Consequences Following Damage to Human Prefrontal Cortex’, Cognition 50, 7-15.Google Scholar
  7. Bechara, A.: 2002, ‘The Neurology of Social Cognition’, Brain 125, 1673-1675.Google Scholar
  8. Berthoz, S., Armony, J.L., Blair, R.J.R. and Dolan, R.J.: 2002, ‘An fMRI Study of Intentional and Unintentional (Embarrassing) Violations of Social Norms’, Brain 125, 1696-1708.Google Scholar
  9. Brothers, L.: 1997, Friday's Footprint: How Society Shapes the Human Mind, Oxford University Press, New York.Google Scholar
  10. Bunge, S.A., Ochsner, K.N., Desmond, J.E., Glover, G.H. and Gabireli, J.D.E.: 2001, ‘Prefrontal Regions Involved in Keeping Information In and Out of Mind’, Brain 124(10), October, 2074-2086.Google Scholar
  11. Call, J.: 2001, ‘Chimpanzee Social Cognition’, Trends in Cognitive Science 5, 388-393.Google Scholar
  12. Canessa, N., Gorinin, A., Perani, D., Danna, M., Scifo, P., Cappa, S.F., Piattelli-Palmarinin, M. and Fazio, F.: 2002, ‘Social Cognition and Reasoning: Neuroimaging Evidence’, NeuroImage Human Brain Mapping 2002 Meeting, abstract #1025.Google Scholar
  13. Casebeer, W.D.: forthcoming, Natural Ethical Facts: Evolution, Connectionism, and Moral Cognition, The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.Google Scholar
  14. Caspi, A., McClay, J., Moffitt, T.E., Mill, J., Martin, J., Craig, I.W., Taylor, A. and Poulton, R.: 2002, ‘Role of Genotype in the Cycle of Violence in Maltreated Children’, Science 297, 851–854.Google Scholar
  15. Churchland, P.S.: 2002, Brain-Wise: Studies in Neurophilosophy, The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.Google Scholar
  16. Churchland, P.S.: 1995, ‘Feeling Reasons’, in A.R. Damasio, H. Damasio and Y. Christen (eds), Decision-Making and the Brain, Springer-Verlag, Berlin.Google Scholar
  17. Churchland, P.S.: 1986, Neurophilosophy: Towards a Unified Science of the Mind/Brain, The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.Google Scholar
  18. Churchland, P.: 1998, ‘Towards a Cognitive Neurobiology of the Moral Virtues’, Topoi 17, 83-96.Google Scholar
  19. Coolidge, F.L. and Wynn, T.: 2001, ‘Executive Functions of the Frontal Lobes and the Evolutionary Ascendancy of Homo Sapiens’, Cambridge Archaeological Journal 11, 2.Google Scholar
  20. Cytowic, R.E.: 1996, The Neurological Side of Neuropsychology, The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.Google Scholar
  21. Damasio, A.R.: 1994, Descartes' Error: Emotion, Reason, and the Human Brain, G. P. Putnam and Sons, New York.Google Scholar
  22. Damasio, A.R.: forthcoming, Looking for Spinoza, G. P. Putnam and Sons, New York.Google Scholar
  23. Dolan, R.J.: 1999, ‘On the Neurology of Morals’, Nature neuroscience 2(11), November 1999, 927-929.Google Scholar
  24. The Economist: 2002, ‘The Ethics of Brain Science: Open Your Mind’. May 23.Google Scholar
  25. Fantz, R.L.: 1961, ‘The Origins of Form Perception’, Scientific American 204, 66-72.Google Scholar
  26. Fantz, R.L.: 1965, ‘Visual Perception from Birth as Shown by Pattern Selectivity’, Annals of the New York Academy of Science 118, 793-814.Google Scholar
  27. Fincham, J.M., Carter, C.S., van Veen, V., Stenger, V.A. and Anderson, J.R.: 2002, ‘Neural Mechanisms of Planning: A Computational Analysis Using Event-related fMRI’, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 99(5), March 5, 3346-3351.Google Scholar
  28. Fleischman, J.: 2002, Phineas Gage: A Gruesome but True Story About Brain Science, Houghton Mifflin Co.Google Scholar
  29. Fuster, J.M.: 1995, Memory in the Cerebral Cortex: An Empirical Approach to Neural Networks in the Human and Nonhuman Primate, The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.Google Scholar
  30. Gehring, W.J. and Willoughby, A.R.: 2002, ‘The Medial Frontal Cortex and the Rapid Processing of Monetary Gains and Losses’, Science 295, March 22, 2279-2282.Google Scholar
  31. Goodenough, O.R.: 2001, ‘Mapping Cortical Areas Associated With Legal Reasoning and Moral Intuition’, Jurimetrics 41,Summer, J. 429.Google Scholar
  32. Goldman-Rakic, P.S.: 1987, ‘Circuitry of the Pre-Frontal Cortex and the Regulation of Behavior by Representational Memory’, in F. Plum and V. Mountcastle (eds), Higher Cortical Function: Handbook of Physiology, American Physiological Society, pp. 373-417.Google Scholar
  33. Gopnik, A.: 1999, ‘Theory of Mind’, in R.A. Wilson and F.C. Keil (eds), The MIT Encyclopedia of the Cognitive Sciences, The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, pp. 838–841.Google Scholar
  34. Greene, J.D., Sommerville, R.B., Nystrom, L.E., Darley, J.M. and Cohen, J.D.: 2001, ‘An fMRI Investigation of Emotional Engagement in Moral Judgment’, Science 293, September 14.Google Scholar
  35. Hamann, S.B., Ely, T.D., Hoffman, J.M. and Kilts, C.D.: 2002, ‘Ecstasy and Agony: Activation of the Human Amygdala in Positive and Negative Emotion’, Psychological Science 13(2), March.Google Scholar
  36. Hobson, A. and Pace-Schott, E.F.: 2002, ‘The Cognitive Neuroscience of Sleep: Neuronal Systems, Consciousness, and Learning’, Nature Reviews: Neuroscience 3, 679–693.Google Scholar
  37. Houde, O., Zago, L., Crivello, F., Moutier, S., Pineau, A., Mazoyer, B. and Tzourio-Mazoyer, N.: 2001, ‘Access to Deductive Logic Depends on a Right Ventromedial Prefrontal Area Devoted to Emotion and Feeling: Evidence from a Training Paradigm’, NeuroImage 14, 1486–1492.Google Scholar
  38. Johnson, M.H. and Morton, J.: 1991, Biology and Cognitive Development: The Case of Face Recognition, Blackwell, New York.Google Scholar
  39. Johnson, S.C., Baxter, L.C., Wilder, L.S., Pipe, J.G., Heiserman, J.E. and Prigatano, G.P.: 2002, ‘Neural Correlates of Self-reflection’, Brain 125(8), 1808–1814.Google Scholar
  40. Kahn, D., Pace-Schott, E. and Hobson, J.A.: 2002, ‘Emotion and Cognition: Feeling and Character Identification in Dreaming’, Consciousness and Cognition 11, 34–50.Google Scholar
  41. Laakso, M.P., Vaurio, O., Koivisto, E., Savolainen, L., Eronen, M., Aronen, H.J., Hakola, P., Repo, E., Soininen, H. and Tiihonen, J.: 2001, ‘Psychopathy and the Posterior Hippocampus’, Behavioural Brain Research 118, 187–193.Google Scholar
  42. MacDonald, A.W. III, Cohen, J.D., Stenger, V.A. and Carter, C.S.: 2000, ‘Dissociating the Role of the Dorsolateral Prefrontal and Anterior Cingulate Cortex in Cognitive Control’, Science 288, June 9, 1835–1838.Google Scholar
  43. Macmillan, M.: 2000, An Odd Kind of Fame; Stories of Phineas Gage, The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.Google Scholar
  44. Manes, F., Sahakian, B., Clark, L., Rogers, R., Antoun, N., Aitken, M. and Robbins, T.: 2002, ‘Decision-making Processes Following Damage to the Prefrontal Cortex’, Brain 125(3), March, 624–639.Google Scholar
  45. McCabe, K., Houser, D., Ryan, L., Smith, V. and Trouard, T.: 2001, ‘A Functional Imaging Study of Cooperation in Two-person Reciprocal Exchange’, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 98(20), September 25, 11832–11835.Google Scholar
  46. Miller, G.: 2002, ‘Gene's Effect Seen in Brain's Fear Response’, Science 297, July 19.Google Scholar
  47. Miller, G.: 2002, ‘The Good, the Bad, and the Anterior Cingulate’, Science 295, March 22, 2193–2194.Google Scholar
  48. Moll, J., Slinger, P.J. and de Oliveira-Souza, R.: 2001, ‘Front Polar and Anterior Temporal Cortex Activation in a Moral Judgment Task’, Arm. Neuropsiquiatry 59(3-B), 657–664.Google Scholar
  49. Moll, J., de Oliveira-Souza, R., Eslinger, P.J., Bramati, I.E., Mourao-Miranda, J., Andreiuolo, P.A. and Pessoa, L.: 2002, ‘The Neural Correlates of Moral Sensitivity: A Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging Investigation of Basic and Moral Emotions’, The Journal of Neuroscience 22(7), April 1, 2730–2736.Google Scholar
  50. Moll, J., de Oliveira-Souza, R., Bramati, I.E. and Grafman, J.: 2002, ‘Functional Networks in Emotional Moral and Non-Moral Social Judgments’, unpublished manuscript.Google Scholar
  51. Montague, P.R., Berns, G.S., Cohen, J.D., McClure, S.M., Pagnoni, G., Dhamala, M., Wiest, M.C., Karpov, I., King, R.D., Apple, N. and Fisher, R.E.: 2002, ‘Hyperscanning: Simultaneous fMRI during Linked Social Interactions’, NeuroImage 16(4), August 1, 1159–1164.Google Scholar
  52. Nichols, S.: 2002, ‘Norms with Feeling: Towards a Psychological Account of Moral Judgment’, Cognition 84, 221–236.Google Scholar
  53. Oliveira-Souza, R. and Moll, J.: 2000, ‘The Moral Brain: A Functional MRI Study of Moral Judgment’, Neurology 2000 54(7), A104.Google Scholar
  54. Pare, D., Collins, D.R. and Pelletier, J.G.: 2002, ‘Amygdala Oscillations and the Consolidation of Emotional Memories’, Trends in Cognitive Sciences 6(7), July, 306–314.Google Scholar
  55. Paulus, M.P., Hozack, N., Zauscher, B., McDowell, J.E., Frank, L., Brown, G.S. and Braff, D.L.: 2001, ‘Prefrontal, Parietal, and Temporal Cortex Networks Underlie Decision-Making in the Presence of Uncertainty’, NeuroImage 13, 91–100.Google Scholar
  56. Peoples, L.L.: 2002, ‘Will, Anterior Cingulate Cortex, and Addiction’, Science 296(31), May, 1623–1624.Google Scholar
  57. Preston, S.D. and de Waal, F.B.M.: forthcoming, ‘Empathy: Its Ultimate and Proximate Bases’, Behavioral and Brain Sciences (available as a preprint at http://www.bbsonline. org/Preprints/Preston/Referees/)Google Scholar
  58. Reider, L.: 1998, ‘Toward a New Test for the Insanity Defense: Incorporating the Discoveries of Neuroscience into Moral and Legal Theories’, UCLA Law Review 46, 289.Google Scholar
  59. Rilling, J.K., Gutman, D.A., Zeh, T.R., Pagnoni, G., Berns, G.D. and Kilts, C.D.: 2002, ‘A Neural Basis for Social Cooperation’, Neuron 35, 395–405.Google Scholar
  60. Rizzolatti, G., Fogassi, L. and Gallese V., 2001, ‘Neurophysiological Mechanisms Underlying the Understanding and Imitation of Action’, Nature Reviews: Neuroscience 2, 661–670.Google Scholar
  61. Shidara, M. and Richmond, B.J.: 2002, ‘Anterior Cingulate: Single Neuronal Signals Related to Degree of Reward Expectancy’, Science 296, 31 May, 1709–1711.Google Scholar
  62. Stich, S.: 1993, ‘Moral Philosophy and Mental Representation’, in M. Hechter, L. Nadel and R.E. Michod (eds), The Origin of Values, Aldine de Gruyter, New York, pp. 215–228.Google Scholar
  63. Stone, V.E., Cosmides, L., Tooby, J., Kroll, N. and Knight, R.T.: 2002, ‘Selective Impairment of Reasoning about Social Exchange in a Patient with Bilateral Limbic System Damage’, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 99(17), August 20, 11531–11536.Google Scholar
  64. Van Veen, V. and Carter, C.S.: 2002, ‘The Timing of Action-Monitoring Processes in the Anterior Cingulate Cortex’, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience, 14, 593–602.Google Scholar
  65. Van Veen, V., Cohen, J.D., Botvinick, M.M., Stenger, V.A. and Carter, C.S.: 2001, ‘Anterior Cingulate Cortex, Conflict Monitoring, and Levels of Processing’, NeuroImage 14(6), December, 1302–1308.Google Scholar
  66. Waldbauer, J.R. and Gazzaniga, M.S.: 2001, ‘The Divergence of Neuroscience and Law’, Jurimetric J. 41,Spring, 357.Google Scholar
  67. Wallis, J.D., Anderson, K.C. and Miller, E.K.: 2001, ‘Single Neurons in Prefrontal Cortex Encode Abstract Rules’, Nature 411, June 21, 953–956.Google Scholar
  68. Winston, J.S., Strange, B.A., O'Doherty, J. and Dolan, R.J.: 2002, ‘Automatic and Intentional Brain Responses during Evaluation of Trustworthiness of Faces’, Nature Neuroscience 5(3), March, 277–283.Google Scholar
  69. Yamasaki, H., LaBar, K.S. and McCarthy, G.: ‘Dissociable Prefrontal Brain Systems for Attention and Emotion’, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 99(17), August 20, 11447–11451.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2003

Authors and Affiliations

  • William D. Casebeer
    • 1
  • Patricia S. Churchland
    • 1
  1. 1.Department of Philosophy, HQ USAFA/DFPYUS Air Force AcademyU.S.A.

Personalised recommendations