Abstract
In this paper the role of incomprehensibility in the conceptualization of the DSM-IV definition of delusion is discussed. According to the analysis, the conceptual dependence of DSM-IV definition of delusion on “incomprehensibility” is manifested in several ways and infested with ambiguity. Definition of “bizarre” delusions is contradictory and gives room for two incompatible readings. Also the definition of delusion manifests internal inconsistencies and its tendency to account for delusions in terms of misinterpretation is bound to miss the content of the traditional comprehension of delusionality. It is suggested that the ambiguities in defining delusions has to do with the question whether psychiatric practice is better accounted for in terms of the grammar of “incorrectness” or of “incomprehensibility”.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
American Psychiatric Association: 1994, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders: DSM-IV, ed 4. Washington, DC: APA.
Berrios, G.E. and Marková, I.S.: 1998, 'Insight in the Psychoses: A Conceptual History', in: X.F. Amador and A.S. David (eds.), Insight and Psychosis. New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 33–46.
Blankenburg, W.: 1984, 'Unausgeschöpftes in der Psychopathologie von Karl Jaspers', Nervenartz 55, 447–460.
Bleuler, E.: 1949, Lehrbuch der Psychiatrie, Achte Auflage, umgearbeitet von Manfred Bleuler. Berlin: Springer Verlag.
Butler, R.W. and Braff, D.L.: 1991, 'Delusions: A Review and Intergration', Schizophrenia Bulletin 17, 633–647.
Corin, E. and Lauzon, G: 1992, 'Positive Withdrawal and the Quest for Meaning: The Reconstruction of Experience Among Schizophreniacs', Psychiatry 55, 266–278.
Coulter, J.: 1973, Approaches to Insanity. London: Martin Robertson.
De Nerval, G.: 1966, Aurélia et les autres contes fantastiques. Verviers, Belgium: Gerard & co.
De Nerval, G.: 1996, Aurélia. Translated by G.Warner. Boston: Exact Change.
Diamond, C.: 1986, 'What Nonsense Might Be', in: S. Shanker (ed.), Ludwig Wittgenstein: Critical Assessments. Volume two: From Philosophical Investigations to On Certainty: Wittgenstein's later philosophy.Croom Helm.
Fulford, K.W.M.: 1989, Moral Theory and Medical Practice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Jaspers, K. 1962: General Psychopathology. Translated by J. Hoening and M.W. Hamilton. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
Maj, M.: 1998, 'Critique of the DSM-IV Operational Diagnostic Criteria for Schizophrenia', British Journal of Psychiatry 173, 458–460.
Rudnick, A.: 1997, 'On the Notion of Psychosis: the DSM-IV in Perspective', Psychopathology 30, 298–302.
Spitzer, M.: 1990, 'On Defining Delusions', Comprehensive Psychiatry 31, 377–397.
Spitzer, M., U. Braun, L. Hermle and S. Maier: 1993, 'Associative Semantic Network Dysfunction in Thoughtdisordered Schizophrenic Patients: Direct Evidence from Indirect Semantic Priming', Biological Psychiatry 34, 864–877.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Heinimaa, M. Incomprehensibility: The role of the concept in DSM-IV definition of schizophrenic delusions. Med Health Care Philos 5, 291–295 (2002). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1021164602485
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1021164602485