The relationship between evidence-based medicine (EBM) and clinical judgement is the subject of conceptual and practical dispute. For example, EBM and clinical guidelines are seen to increasingly dominate medical decision-making at the expense of other, human elements, and to threaten the art of medicine. Clinical wisdom always remains open to question. We want to know why particular beliefs are held, and the epistemological status of claims based in wisdom or experience. The paper critically appraises a number of claims and distinctions, and attempts to clarify the connections between EBM, clinical experience and judgement, and the objective and evaluative categories of medicine. I conclude that to demystify clinical wisdom is not to devalue it. EBM ought not be conceived as needing to be limited or balanced by clinical wisdom, since if its language is translatable into terms comprehensible and applicable to individuals, it helps constitute clinical wisdom. Failure to appreciate this constitutive relation will help perpetuate medical paternalism and delay the adoption of properly evidence-based practice, which would be both unethical and unwise.
This is a preview of subscription content,to check access.
Access this article
Similar content being viewed by others
Anderson, J.: 1999, ' "Don't Confuse Me With Facts ...": Evidence-Based Practice Confronts Reality', Med J Aust 170, 465.
Bastian, H.: 2000, 'Allies or Enemies? Evidence-Based Medicine and Consumer Choice', Med J Aust 172, 5–6.
Callahan, D.: 2000, 'Universalism and Particularism. Fighting to a Draw', Hastings Center Report 1, 38.
Cassell, E.: 1998, 'Judgement Difficult', in: P. Baume (ed.), The Tasks of Medicine: An Ideology of Care. Sydney: MacLennan & Petty, p. 143.
Chan, J. and J. Chan: 2000, 'Medicine for the Millennium: The Challenge of Postmodernism', Med J Australia 172, 332–334.
Coiera, E.: 2000, 'Maximising the Uptake of Evidence into Clinical Practice: An Information Economics Approach', Med J Australia 174, 467–470.
Culpepper, L. and T. Gilbert: 1999, 'Evidence and Ethics', Lancet 353, 829.
Dwyer, P.: 1998, 'Legal Implications of Clinical Practice Guidelines', Med J Aust 169, 292–293.
Evidence-Based Medicine Working Group: 1992, 'Evidence-Based Medicine: A New Approach to Teaching the Practice of Medicine', JAMA 268, 2420–2425.
Fugelli, P.: 1998, 'Clinical Practice: Between Aristotle and Cochrane', Schweiz Med Wochenschr 128, 184–188.
Gibson, P.: 2001, 'Implementing Evidence-Based Guidelines', Med J Australia 174, 377–378.
Gillett, G.: 1995, 'Virtue and Truth in Clinical Science', J of Med & Phil 20, 285–298.
Glasziou, P. and L. Irwig: 1995, 'An Evidence-Based Approach to Individualising Treatment', BMJ 311, 1356–1359.
Goldner, E. and D. Bilsker: 1995, 'Evidence-Based Psychiatry', Can J Psych 40, 98.
Greenalgh, T.: 1999, 'Narrative Based Medicine in an Evidence Based World', BMJ 318, 323.
Hassed, C.: 2000, 'Whose Evidence? The Corporatisation of Medical Research', Aust Fam Physician 29, 1090–1091.
Holmes, J.: 2000, 'Narrative in Psychiatry and Psychotherapy: The Evidence?' J Med Ethics 26, 92–96.
Hope, T.: 1995, 'Evidence Based Medicine and Ethics', J Med Ethics 21, 259–260.
Hurwitz, B.: 1999, 'Legal and Political Considerations of Clinical Practice Guidelines', BMJ 318, 661.
Kenny, N.: 1997, 'Does Good Science Make Good Medicine?' Can Med Assoc J 157, 35.
Kerridge, I. et al.: 1998, 'Ethics and Evidence-Based Medicine', BMJ 316, 1151.
Little, M.: 1998, 'Assignments of Meaning in Epidemiology', Soc Sci Med 47, 1135–1145.
Macnaughton, R.J.: 1998, 'Evidence and Clinical Judgement', J Eval in Clin Prac 4, 91–92.
McDonald, C.: 1996, 'Medical Heuristics: The Silent Adjudicators of Clinical Practice', Ann Int Med 124, 56–62.
Moynihan, R. et al.: 2000, 'Coverage by the News Media of the Benefits and Risks of Medications', N Engl J Med 342(22), 1645–1650.
Nagel, T.: 1997, The Last Word. New York: Oxford, p. 95.
National Health and Medical Research Council: 1995.
Naylor, C.D.: 1995, 'Grey Zones of Clinical Practice: Some Limits to Evidence-based Medicine', Lancet 345, 841.
Pelly, J. et al.: 1998, 'Clinical Practice Guidelines Before the Law: Sword or Shield?', Med J Aust 169, 330–333.
Radden, J.: 1994, 'Recent Criticism of Psychiatric Nosology: A Review', Philosophy, Psychiatry and Psychology 1, 93–100.
Reilly, B. et al.: August 1998, 'Evidence-Based Medicine: A Passing Fancy or the Future of Primary Care?' DM, 370-399.
Rogers v Whitaker 175 CLR 479.
Rubin, G. and M. Frommer: 2001, 'Evidence-Based Medicine-Time for a Reality Check', Med J Australia 174, 214–215.
Sackett, D.L. et al.: 1996, 'Evidence Based Medicine: What It Is and What It Isn't', BMJ 312, 71–72.
Sackett, D.L. et al.: 1997, Evidence-Based Medicine: How to Practise and Teach EBM. New York: Churchill-Livingstone, p. 2.
Sadler, J. and G. Agich: 1995, 'Diseases, Functions, Values and Psychiatric Classification', Philosophy, Psychiatry and Psychology 2, 219–231.
Saltmann, D.: 1997, 'Guidelines: In Search of Certainty', Med J Australia 166, 62.
Scruton, R.: 1996, An Intelligent Person's Guide to Philosophy. London: Duckworth.
Scruton, R.: 1997, 'Kant', in: German Philosophers. Oxford: OUP.
Steiner, J.: 1999, 'Talking about Treatment: The Language of Populations and the Language of Individuals', Ann Int Med 130, 621.
Tanenbaum, S.J.: 1999, 'Evidence and Expertise: The Challenge of the Outcomes Movement to Medical Professionalism', Acad Med 74, 757–763.
Tovey, P.: 1998, 'Narrative and Knowledge Development in Medical Ethics', J Med Ethics 24, 177.
White, S.J.: 1997, 'Evidence-Based Practice and Nursing: The New Panacea?' Br J Nurs 6, 176.
Woolf, S.H. et al.: 1999, 'Potential Benefits, Limitations and Harms of Clinical Guidelines', BMJ 318, 529.
Young, R.: 1994, 'Autonomous Patients and Medical Professionalism', Med J Aust 160, 305–306.
About this article
Cite this article
Parker, M. Whither our art? Clinical wisdom and evidence-based medicine. Med Health Care Philos 5, 273–280 (2002). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1021116516342