Abstract
Selecting an optimum sampling frequency is a key problem in fish telemetry studies. High frequency positioning gives an accurate idea of the actual mobility pattern of the animal but may be impossible due to environmental constraints, prohibitive cost or when using long life transmitters operating on duty cycles. Low frequency positioning may prove effective, but only for a minimum loss of accuracy (i.e. decrease in the estimates of home range or mobility). This paper analyses the respective benefits and limitations of the ‘high cost-high return’ and ‘low cost-unknown return’ strategies. It is based on a day-by-day tracking study of the cyprinid fish Barbus barbus (L.) in Belgian waters (River Ourthe, seven fish, 112 tracking days each), and re-examines the estimates of home range and distance travelled, as if the fish had been located at longer time intervals (2–28 d). The estimates are compared to the original data set, in order to quantify the resulting loss of accuracy, and to provide predictive models for future studies.
Increasing the time interval between successive locations from 2 to 28 d introduced losses of accuracy, which were higher for mobility (21.1 to 70.0%) than for home range estimates (0.5 to 35.3%). Based on cost-effectiveness, the rationale for tracking B. barbus was determined as once a week. This positioning frequency produced consistent home range estimates (5% of inaccuracy) but rather poor estimates of mobility (circa 40% of inaccuracy). A simple predictive model of loss of accuracy depending on time interval, and a multiple regression model, integrating the heterogeneity between subsamples, were generated and tested with an independent data set. Both substantially reduced the inaccuracy of estimates (from 39.4 to 14.1% with 7 d intervals and from 19.7 to 5.7% when using four parallel subsamples at 7 d intervals).
These results clearly indicate that positioning fish at intervals longer than one day always generates a bias, but may prove effective, at least when the resulting inaccuracy can be predicted and (partly) corrected. The analysis and proposed predictive models open promising perspectives for long term studies relying on the use of transmitters operating on duty cycles (e.g. reproductive homing, role of experience on behaviour, ...).
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Axelsen, B., M. Holm & M. Steinset, 1997. Developing a high-accuracy acoustic fish positioning system for monitoring migratory behaviour of small, non-schooling fish. In M. L. Bégout-Anras, G. Claireaux & J. P. Lagardère (eds), Abstracts of the Second Conference on Fish Telemetry in Europe, CREMA l'Houmeau, France, April 5–9, 1997: 4 (abstract).
Baras, E., 1992. Etude des stratégies d'occupation du temps et de l'espace chez le barbeau fluviatile, Barbus barbus (L.). Cah. Éthol. 12: 125–442.
Baras, E., 1993a. Etude par biotélémétrie de l'utilisation de l'espace, chez le barbeau fluviatile, Barbus barbus (L.). Caractérisation et implications des patrons saisonniers de mobilité. Cah. Éthol. 13: 135–138.
Baras, E., 1993b. A biotelemetry study of activity centres exploitation by Barbus barbus in the River Ourthe. Cah. Éthol. 13: 173–174.
Baras, E., 1994. Constraints imposed by high densities on behavioural spawning strategies in the barbel, Barbus barbus. Folia Zool. 43: 255–266.
Baras, E., 1995. Seasonal activities of Barbus barbus (L.) – Effect of temperature on time-budgeting. J. Fish Biol. 46: 816–828.
Baras, E., 1996. Selection of residence area selection and non-reproductive homing in a shoaling freshwater teleost, the barbel Barbus barbus (L.). In E. Baras & J. C. Philippart (eds), Underwater Biotelemetry, Proceedings of the First Conference and Workshop on Fish Telemetry in Europe. University of Liège, Belgium: 47–58.
Baras, E., C. Birtles, L. Westerloppe, X. Thoreau, M. Ovidio, D. Jeandrain & J. C. Philippart, 1998. A critical review of surgery techniques for implanting telemetry devices into the body cavity of fish. In Y. Le Maho (ed), Proceedings of the 5th European Conference on Wildlife Telemetry. Strasbourg, France, 26–30 August 1996: 10 pp, in press.
Baras, E. & J. P. Lagardère, 1995. Fish telemetry in aquaculture: review and perspectives. Aquacult. Int. 3: 1–26.
Beddow, T. A., C. Deary & R. S. McKinley, 1997. Migratory and reproductive activity of radio-tagged Arctic charr (Salveli-nus alpinus L.) in Northern Labrador. In M. L. Bégout-Anras, G. Claireaux & J. P. Lagardère (eds), Abstracts of the Second Conference on Fish Telemetry in Europe, CREMA l'Houmeau, France, April 5–9, 1997: 8 (abstract).
Boujard, T. & J. F. Leatherland, 1992. Circadian rhythms and feeding times in fishes. Envir. Biol. Fishes 35: 109–131.
Brown, R. S. & C. Mackay, 1995. Spawning ecology of cutthroat trout (Oncorhynchus clarki) in the Ram River, Alberta. Can. J. Fish. aquat. Sci. 52: 983–992.
Clapp, D. F., R. D. Clark & J. S. Diana, 1990. Range, activity and habitat of large, free-ranging brown trout in a Michigan Stream. Trans. am. Fish. Soc. 119: 1022–1034.
Clough, S., 1997. Preliminary results of using external attached miniature radio-transmitters to track the movements of Leuciscus leuciscus, in the River Frome, Dorset. In M. L. Bégout-Anras, G. Claireaux & J. P. Lagardère (eds), Abstracts of the Second Conference on Fish Telemetry in Europe, CREMA l'Houmeau, France, April 5–9, 1997: 14 (abstract).
Evans, D. M., 1994. Observations on the spawning behaviour of male and female adult sea trout, Salmo trutta L., using radio-telemetry. Fish. Mgmt. Ecol. 1: 91–105.
Fredrich, F., S. Ohmann & B. Curio, 1997. Spawning migrations and daily movements of chub (Leuciscus cephalus) in the Spree River. In M. L. Bégout-Anras, G. Claireaux & J.P. Lagardère (eds), Abstracts of the Second Conference on Fish Telemetry in Europe, CREMA l'Houmeau, France, April 5–9, 1997: 19 (abstract).
Gowan, C., M. K. Young, K. D. Fausch & S. C. Riley, 1994. Restricted movements in resident stream salmonids: a paradigm lost. Can. J. Fish. aquat. Sci. 51: 2626–2637.
Hancock, R. S., J. W. Jones & R. Shaw, 1976. A preliminary report on the spawning behaviour and the nature of sexual selection in the barbel, Barbus barbus (L.). J. Fish Biol. 9: 21–28.
Heggenes, J., O. M. W. Krog, O. R. Lindas, J. G. Dokk & T. Bremnes, 1993. Homeostatic behavioural responses in a changing environment: brown trout (Salmo trutta) become nocturnal during winter. J. anim. Ecol. 62: 295–308.
Helfman, G. S., 1986. Fish behaviour by day, night and twilight. In T. J. Pitcher (ed), The Behaviour of Teleost Fishes. London: Croom Helm: 366–387.
Huber, M. & A. Kirchhoffer, 1997. Radio telemetry as a tool to detect habitat preference in medium-sized rivers. A case study on the nase (Chondrostoma nasus), an endangered rheophilic cyprinid. In M. L. Bégout-Anras, G. Claireaux & J. P. Lagardère (eds), Abstracts of the Second Conference on Fish Telemetry in Europe, CREMA l'Houmeau, France, April 5–9, 1997: 22 (abstract).
Lagardère, J. P., J. J. Ducamp, L. Frikha & M. Sperandio, 1988. Ultrasonic tracking of common sole juveniles (Solea vulgaris Quensel, 1806) in a saltmarsh: methods and fish response to some environmental factors. J. appl. Ichthyol. 4: 87–96.
Lagardère, J. P., M. L. Bégout-Anras & V. Buchet, 1996. The acoustic positioning system as a valuable tool for estimating the well-being of fishes in aquaculture. In E. Baras & J. C. Philippart (eds), Underwater Biotelemetry, Proceedings of the First Conference and Workshop on Fish Telemetry in Europe. University of Liège, Belgium: 177–186.
Lucas, M. C. & E. Batley, 1996. Seasonal movements and behaviour of adult barbel Barbus barbus, a riverine cyprinid fish: implications for river management. J. appl. Ecol. 33, 1345–1358.
Lucas, M. C. & P. A. Frear, 1997. Effects of a flow-gauging weir on the migratory behaviour of adult barbel, a riverine cyprinid. J. Fish Biol. 50: 382–396.
Meyers, L. S., T. F. Thuemler & G. W. Kornely, 1992. Seasonal movements of brown trout in Northeast Wisconsin. N. am. J. Fish. Mgmt. 12: 433–441.
Økland, F., J. A. Jensen & B. O. Johnsen, 1996. Winter habitat and seaward migration of a Norwegian brown trout population. In E. Baras & J. C. Philippart (eds), Underwater Biotelemetry, Proceedings of the First Conference and Workshop on Fish Telemetry in Europe. University of Liège, Belgium: 161–171.
Ovidio, M., E. Baras, D. Goffaux, C. Birtles & J. C. Philippart, 1998. Environmental unpredictability rules the autumn migration of brown trout (Salmo trutta L.) in the Belgian Ardennes. Hydrobiologia 371/372: 263–274.
Ovidio, M., C. Birtles, E. Baras, J. C. Philippart & F. Giroux, 1998. Daily and seasonal movements of radio-tagged brown trout (Salmo trutta) in the Belgian Ardennes: mobility versus residency In Y. Le Maho (ed), Proceedings of the 5th European Conference on Wildlife Telemetry. Strasbourg, France, 26–30 August 1996: 8 pp, in press.
Philippart, J. C. & E. Baras, 1996. Comparison of tagging and tracking studies to estimate mobility patterns and home range in Barbus barbus. In E. Baras & J. C. Philippart (eds), Underwater Biotelemetry, Proceedings of the First Conference and Workshop on Fish Telemetry in Europe. University of Liège, Belgium: 3–12.
Priede, I. G. & S. M. Swift (eds), 1992. Wildlife telemetry: remote sensing and monitoring of animals. Ellis Horwood Ltd., Chichester, UK, 708 pp.
Smith, G. W., G. G. Urquhart, D. N. MacLennan & B. Sarno, 1997. A comparison of theoretical estimates of the errors associated with ultrasonic tracking using a fixed hydrophone array and field measurements. In M. L. Bégout-Anras, G. Claireaux & J. P. Lagardère (eds), Abstracts of the Second Conference on Fish Telemetry in Europe, CREMA l'Houmeau, France, April 5–9, 1997: 45 (abstract).
Summerfelt, R. C. & L. S. Smith, 1990. Anaesthesia, surgery, and related techniques. In C. B. Schreck & P. B. Moyle (eds), Methods for fish biology. American Fisheries Society, Bethesda, Maryland: 213–272.
Thorpe, J. E. (ed), 1978. Rhythmic activity of fishes. Academic Press, London.
Tito de Morais, L. & J. Raffray, 1996. Behaviour of Hoplias aimara during the filling phase of the Petit-Saut Dam (Sinnamary river, French Guyana, South America). In E. Baras & J. C. Philippart (eds), Underwater Biotelemetry, Proceedings of the First Conference and Workshop on Fish Telemetry in Europe. University of Liège, Belgium: 153–160.
Voegeli, F. A. & D. G. Pincock, 1996. Overview underwater acoustics as it applies to telemetry. In E. Baras & J. C. Philippart (eds), Underwater Biotelemetry, Proceedings of the First Conference and Workshop on Fish Telemetry in Europe. University of Liège, Belgium: 23–30.
Voegeli, F. A. & G. P. McKinnon, 1996. Recent developments in ultrasonic tracking systems. In E. Baras & J. C. Philippart (eds), Underwater Biotelemetry, Proceedings of the First Conference and Workshop on Fish Telemetry in Europe. University of Liège, Belgium: 235–241.
Winter, J. D., 1983. Underwater biotelemetry. In L. A. Nielsen & J. D. Johnsen (eds), Fisheries Techniques. Am. Fish. Soc. Bethesda, Maryland: 371–395.
Young, M. K., 1994. Mobility of brown trout in south-central Wyoming streams. Can. J. Zool. 72: 2078–2083.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Baras, E. Selection of optimal positioning intervals in fish tracking: an experimental study on Barbus barbus . Hydrobiologia 371, 19–28 (1998). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1017026127846
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1017026127846