Abstract
Following a Consultation exercise conducted by the Lord Chancellor's Department, the U.K. Government has announced its intention to amend the Children Act 1989 so that the unmarried father who jointly registers the birth with the mother will acquire parental responsibility automatically. In this paper, I draw on the responses made to the L.C.D. Consultation, in order critically to evaluate the arguments for and against reform. A poverty of relevant empirical research makes it impossible to reach a properly informed view on the positive or negative impacts of implementing the proposal. However, the principled arguments: that unmarried fathers and their children are subject to discrimination, or that it is unfair for men to pay child support, yet have no automatic rights with regard to their children, are ultimately unconvincing. I also attempt a more explicitly sociological exploration of the Consultation and reform process, focusing on what it can tell us about evolving social attitudes towards the statuses of `father' and `family' and how they should be valued and protected.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
REFERENCES
Anderson, L., Contact between Children and Violent Fathers: in Whose Best Interests? ( London: Rights of Women, 1997).
Bainham, A., “Parentage, Parenthood and Parental Responsibility: Subtle, Elusive Yet Important Distinctions”, in What is a Parent? A Socio-Legal Analysis, ed. A. Bainham,S. Day Sclater andM. Richards (Oxford: Hart Publishing, 1999), 25-46.
Barton, C. andDouglas, G., Law and Parenthood ( London: Butterworths, 1995).
Beck, U., Risk Society: Towards a New Modernity ( London: Sage, 1992).
Biggs, H., “Madonna Minus Child Or: Wanted: Dead or Alive! The Right to Have a Dead Partner' Child”, Feminist Legal Studies 5 (1997), 225-234.
Brophy, J., “Parental Rights and Children' Welfare: Some Problems of Strategy in the 1920s”, International Journal of the Sociology of Law 10 (1982), 149.
Burgess, A. andRuxton, S., Men and their Children: Proposals for Public Policy ( London: Institute for Public Policy Research, 1996).
Collier, R., Masculinity, Law and the Family ( London: Routledge, 1995).
Conway, H., “Parental Responsibility and the Unmarried Father”, New Law Journal 146 (1996), 782-784.
Deech, R., “The Unmarried Father and Human Rights”, Journal of Child Law 4 (1992), 3-10.
Department of Education, The Children Act 1989: A Guide for the Education Service ( Milton Keynes: Open University, 1991).
Department of Health, The Removal, Retention and Use of Human Organs and Tissue from Post-Mortem Examination: Advice from the Chief Medical Officer (London: The Stationery Office, 2001).
Diduck, A. andKaganas, F., Family Law, Gender and the State: Text, Cases and Materials (Oxford: Hart Publishing, 1999).
Douglas, G., “The Intention to be a Parent and the Making of Mothers”, Modern Law Rev. 57 (1994), 636.
Eekelaar, J., “Parental Responsibility: State of Nature or Nature of the State?”, Journal of Social Welfare and Family Law (1991), 37.
Eekelaar, J., “Do Parents Have a Duty to Consult?”, Law Quarterly Rev. 114 (1998), 337-341.
Eekelaar, J., “Parenthood, Social Engineering and Rights”, in Constituting Families: A Study in Governance, ed. D. Morgan andG. Douglas (Stuttgart: Franz Steiner Verlag, 1994).
Eekelaar, J. andMcLean, M., The Parental Obligation: A Study of Parenthood Across Households ( Oxford: Hart Publishing, 1997).
Faludi, S., Stiffed: the Betrayal of the Modern Man ( London: Chatto & Windus, 1999).
Ferri, E. andSmith, K., Parenting in the 1990s (London: Family Policy Studies Centre, 1996).
Fineman, M., “The Politics of Child Custody and Gender: Child Advocacy and the Transformation of Custody Decision Making in the USA”, in Child Custody and the Politics of Gender, ed. C. Smart andS. Sevenhuijsen (London and New York: Routledge, 1989).
Forder, C., Netherlands International Law Review (1998), 29.
Grand, A., “What is this Thing Called Parental Responsibility?”, Family Law (1994), 586.
Greer, G., The Whole Woman ( London: Anchor, 2000).
Hall, V., “Domestic Violence and Contact”, Fam. Law 27 (1997), 813-818.
Hayes, M., “Law Commission Working Paper No. 74: Illegitimacy”, Modern Law Rev. 43 (1980), 299-306.
Hester, M. andRadford, L., Domestic Violence and Child Contact in England and Denmark ( Bristol: Policy Press, University of Bristol, 1996).
Hill, J.L., “What Does It Mean to be a Parent?”, New York University Law Rev. 66 (1991), 353-420.
Home Office, Supporting Families: A Consultation Document ( London: H.M.S.O., 1998).
Karsten, I., “A typical Families and the Human Rights Act”, E.H.R.R. (1999) issue 2, 195.
Laqueur, T., “The Facts of Fatherhood”, in Conflicts in Feminism, ed. M. Hirsch andE. Fox Keller (New York and London: Routledge, 1990).
Law Commission, Illegitimacy, Working Paper No. 74 ( London: H.M.S.O., 1979).
Lord Chancellor' Department, Procedures for the Determination of Paternity and on the Law on Parental Responsibility for Unmarried Fathers ( London: H.M.S.O., 1998a).
Lord Chancellor' Department, Responses to Consultation: Procedures for the Determination of Paternity and on the Law on Parental Responsibility for Unmarried Fathers (provided by the L.C.D., 1998b).
Lord Chancellor' Department, Annex C: Response to L.C.D.' Consultation Paper on Paternity and Parental Responsibility. The Advisory Board on Family Law (1999). Available at http://www.open.gov.uk/lcd/family/annrep99/annex_c.htm
Lowe, N.V., “The Meaning and Allocation of Parental Responsibility-a Common Lawyer' Perspective”, International Journal of Law, Policy and the Family 11 (1997), 192-215.
Lowe, N.V., andDouglas, G., Bromley' Family Law, 9th edn. (London: Butterworths, 1998).
McGee, C., “Children' Experiences of Domestic Violence”, Child and Family SocialWork 2/1 (1997), 13-23.
McGee, C., Childhood Experiences of Domestic Violence ( London: Jessica Kingsley, 2000).
Masson, J., “Old Families into New: A Status for Step-Parents”, in State, Law and the Family, ed. M. Freeman (London: Tavistock, 1989).
Mooney, J., The Hidden Figure: Domestic Violence in North London ( London: Islington Police and Crime Prevention Unit, 1994).
Morgan, D.H.J., Family Connections ( Cambridge: Polity Press, 1996).
Morgan, D.H.J., “Risk and Family Practices: Accounting for Change and Fluidity in Family Life”, in The New Family? ed. E.B. Silva andC. Smart (London: Sage, 1999), 13-30.
Phillips, M., The Sex-Change Society: Feminised Brita in and the Neutered Male (London: The Social Market Foundation, 1999).
Pickford, R., Fathers, Marriage and the Law ( Cambridge: Family Policy Studies Centre, 1999a).
Pickford, R., “Unmarried Fathers and the Law”, in What is a Parent? A Socio-Legal Analysis, ed. A. Bainham,S. Day Sclater andM. Richards (Oxford: Hart Publishing, 1999b), 143-160.
Ruddick, S., “Thinking about Fathers”, in Conflicts in Feminism, ed. M. Hirsch andE. Fox Keller (New York and London: Routledge, 1990), 222-233.
Scottish Law Commission, Report on Family Law. No. 135 (1992).
Shaw, T., “Unmarried Fathers Get Equal Rights as a Parent”, Electronic Telegraph (3 July 1999).
Sheldon, S., “ 'sperm Bandits', Birth Control Fraud and the Battle of the Sexes”, Legal Studies (forthcoming 2001).
Silva, E.B. andSmart, C. (eds.), The New Family? ( London: Sage, 1999).
Smart, C., “Power and the Politics of Child Custody”, in Child Custody and the Politics of Gender, ed. C. Smart andS. Sevenhuijsen (London and New York: Routledge, 1989).
Smart, C. andNeale, B., Family Fragments? ( Cambridge: Polity, 1999).
Smart, C. andSevenhuijsen, S. (eds.), Child Custody and the Politics of Gender (London and New York: Routledge, 1989).
Standing, K., “Reasserting Fathers' Rights? Parental Responsibility and Involvement in Education and Lone Mother Families in the UK”, Feminist Legal Studies 7 (1999), 33-46.
Stanko, E.,Crisp, D.,Hale, C. andLucraft, H., Counting the Costs: Estimating the Impact of Domestic Violence in the London Borough of Hackney (London: Crime Concern, 1998).
Weeks, J., “Supporting Families”, The Political Quarterly (1999), 225-230.
Woolf, M., “Full Rights to Fathers Outside Marriage”, Electronic Telegraph (8 December 1999).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Sheldon, S. Unmarried Fathers and Parental Responsibility: A Case for Reform?. Feminist Legal Studies 9, 93–118 (2001). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1016701220289
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1016701220289