Abstract
This paper explores the efficacy of the driver-based incident detection using the vehicle-to-roadside communication (VRC) system. The proliferation of vehicle tags in the US for automatic toll collection, traffic monitoring, and vehicle navigation and information systems has created an infrastructure capable of supporting a driver-based incident detection system. The research reported herein investigated the use of "activatable" vehicle tags by drivers to send an incident signal to the Traffic Management Center through VRC reader stations spaced uniformly on a highway. The simulation results showed that good detection performance was achieved even at lower levels of market penetration of vehicle tags. The results further showed that detection performance is significantly affected by the severity of the incident in terms of number of lanes closed, the spacing of the VRC reader stations, traffic volume at the time of the incident, and the reporting propensity of the traveling public.The performance of the VRC-based incident reporting system was compared to the performance of two incident detection algorithms that rely on traffic data collected through the automatic vehicle identification (AVI) system. The comparison showed that the VRC-based incident reporting system attained shorter detection times and higher detection rates under fairly similar simulated conditions. The paper also discusses issues that need further study through simulation and field experimentation of the VRC-based incident reporting system.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Dudek CL & Messer CJ (1974) Incident detection on urban freeways. Transportation Research Record 495: 12–24.
Halati A, Torres JF & Mikhalkin B (1990) FRESIM Technical Report. Final Report-FHWA Contract DHFH61-85-C-00094, JFT Associates, Pacific Palisades, California, February.
Hellinga B & Knapp G (2000) AVI based freeway incident detection. Paper presented at the 79th Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board (TRB), Washington, DC, January 7-11.
Larsen, R (1996) Using cellular phones as traffic probes. Traffic Technology International magazine, International Press, UK, August/September: 46-50.
Larue P (1995) Traffic monitoring and traveler information in a metropolitan area. Traffic Technology International magazine, International Press, UK: 68–72.
Mussa R, Matthias JS, Upchurch JE, Rollier DA & Zaniewski JP (1998) Modeling detection of incidents by drivers. Transportation Research Part C 6C(1/2): 129–139.
Parkany E & Bernstein D (1995) Design of incident detection algorithms using Vehicle-to-Roadside communication sensors. Transportation Research Record 1494, Transportation Research Board, Washington, DC: 67–74.
Payne HJ, Goodwin DN & Teener MD (1975) Evaluation of existing incident detection algorithms. FHWA Report Number FHWA-RD-75-39, Federal Highway Administration, US Department of Transportation, Washington, DC.
Payne HJ & Knobel HC (1976) Development and testing of incident detection algorithms, Volume 3. FHWA Report Number FHWA-RD-76-21, Washington, DC: Federal Highway Administration, US Department of Transportation: p. 28.
Persaud BN & Hall FL (1989) Catastrophe theory and patterns in 30-second freeway traffic data-implications for incident detection. Transportation Research: Part A-General 23A(2): 103–113.
Stephanedes YJ & Chassiakos PA (1993) Application for filtering techniques for incident detection. Journal of Transportation Engineering 119(1): 13–26.
Transportation Research Board (TRB) (1998) Highway capacity manual. Special Report 209, National Research Council, Washington, DC: 3–11.
Tsai J & Case ER (1979) Development of freeway incident detection algorithms by using pattern recognition techniques. Transportation Research Record 722: 113–116.
Walters CH, Wiles PB & Cooner SA (1999) Incident detection primarily by cellular phones-an evaluation of a system for Dallas, Texas. Paper presented at the 78th Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board, Washington, DC, January.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Mussa, R.N., Upchurch, J.E. Simulator evaluation of incident detection by transponder-equipped vehicles. Transportation 29, 287–305 (2002). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1015625801212
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1015625801212