Abstract
The web creates manyopportunities for encroachment on intellectualproperty including trademarks. Our principaltask in this paper is an investigation into anunusual form of such encroachment: theimproper use of metatags. A metatag is a pieceof HTML code that provides summary informationabout a web page. If used in an appropriatemanner, these metatags can play a legitimaterole in helping consumers locate information. But the ``keyword'' metatag is particularlysusceptible to manipulation. These tags can beeasily abused by web site creators anxious tobait search engines and bring scores ofvisitors to their sites. The law aboutmetatags is far from settled and many legalscholars are uncomfortable with the conclusionthat the unauthorized use of a trademark in ametatag represents infringement. How should weassess this practice known as ``spamdexing'' froma normative perspective? Is it commercial fairplay or something more sinister? We make thecase here that there are salient moral problemswith spamdexing since it exploits thereputational goodwill of trademark owners andconfuses consumers. It violates basic moralduties and it flouts the golden rule principle. Hence unauthorized use of a competitor'strademark in a metatag is not morallyacceptable.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
M. Allen. The Scope of Confusion Actionable Under Federal Trademark Law: Who Must be Confused and When. Wake Forest Law Review, 26: 321, 1991.
A. Best. Monetary Damages for False Advertising. U. Pitt. Law Review, 49: 38, 1987.
Brookfield Communications Inc. v. West Coast Entertainment Corp. 174 F. 3d 1036 (9th Cir), 1999.
H. Gensler. Formal Ethics. Routledge, London, 1996.
B. Gert. Common Morality and Computing. CEPE Proceedings, London School of Economics, London, 1998. (See also B. Gert. Morality: Its Nature and Justification. Oxford University Press, New York, pp. 109-129).
M. Greenfield. Restatement (Third) of Unfair Competition Sec. 3.3.2.4, 1995.
B. McCoy. An Invisible Mark: A Meta-Tag Controversy. Journal of Small Engineering and Business Law, 2: 377, 1998.
D. McCuaig. Halve the Baby: An Obvious Solution to the Troubling Use of Trademarks as Metatags. John Marshall Journal of Computer and Information Law, 18: 643, 2000.
J. Mrsich and M. Jun. Terms You Need to Know: Search Engines. MultiMedia Strategist, 3, May, 1997.
OBH Inc. v. Spotlight Magazine, Inc. 86 F.Supp.2d 176, 179, 2000.
M. O'Rourke. Defining the Limits of Free-Riding in Cyberspace: Trademark Liability for Metatagging. Gonzaga Law Review, 33: 227, 1997.
R. Posner. Manipulative Metatagging, Search Engine Baiting, and Initial Interest Confusion. Columbia Journal of Law and Social Problems, 33: 439, 2000.
T. Presson and J. Barney. Trademarks asMetatags: Infringement or Fair Use? AIPLA Q.J., 26: 147, 1998.
Rehabilitation Specialists v. Koering. 404 N.W. 21 301 (Minn. Ct. App), 1987.
G. Salton. Another Look at Automatic Text-Retrieval Systems. Communications of the ACM, 29(7): 648, 1986.
D. Shenk. Data Smog. Harper Collins, New York, 1997.
J. Warner. Trademark Infringement Online: Appropriate Federal Relief from the Illicit Use of Trademarked Material in Web Site Metatags. Thomas Jefferson Law Review, 22: 133, 2000.
E. Weise. Some Web Pages Take Search Engines for a Ride. USA TODAY: 4D, September 29, 1997.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Spinello, R.A. The use and abuse of metatags. Ethics and Information Technology 4, 23–30 (2002). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1015279707974
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1015279707974