Skip to main content
SpringerLink
Log in

Are plant hybrid zones centers of vertebrate biodiversity? A test in the Quercus grisea × Quercus gambelii species complex

  • Published:
Biodiversity & Conservation Aims and scope Submit manuscript

Abstract

The plant-hybrid-zones-as-centers-of-biodiversity (hereafter, PHZCB) hypothesis posits that plant hybrid zones represent areas of elevated biodiversity, and supports the inclusion of plant hybrid zones in conservation efforts. Support for the PHZCB hypothesis is limited to a handful of cases involving insect and fungal species and to two studies involving higher trophic levels. The PHZCB hypothesis requires further testing before plant hybrid zones can be established with any certainty as centers of biodiversity. We test whether the PHZCB hypothesis holds for higher trophic levels by examining the community structure of birds and reptiles associated with the Quercus grisea × Quercus gambelii species complex. Specifically, we compare patterns of species richness and abundance of these taxa in 10 hybrid zones and 11 contact zones (i.e., zones where both parental species occur but hybrids do not). In contrast to predictions of the PHZCB hypothesis, contact zones supported significantly more species of birds and reptiles than did hybrid zones. Species abundances exhibited idiosyncratic responses to zone type, but were higher generally in the contact zones.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this article

Log in via an institution

Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.

Instant access to the full article PDF.

Institutional subscriptions

Similar content being viewed by others

References

  • Aguilar JM and Boecklen WJ (1991) Patterns of herbivory in the Quercus grisea×Quercus gambelii species complex. Oikos 64: 498-504

    Google Scholar 

  • Balda RP (1969) Foliage use by birds of the oak-juniper woodland and ponderosa pine forest in southeastern Arizona. Condor 71: 399-412

    Google Scholar 

  • Baltosser WH and Best TL (1990) Seasonal occurrence and habitat utilization by lizards in southwestern New Mexico. Southwestern Naturalist 35: 377-384

    Google Scholar 

  • Bibby CJ, Burgess ND and Hill DA (1992) Bird Census Techniques. Academic Press, San Diego, California

    Google Scholar 

  • Boecklen WJ and Larson KC (1994) Gall forming wasps (Hymenoptera: Cynipidae) in an oak hybrid zone: testing hypotheses about hybrid susceptibility to herbivores. In: Price PW, MattsonWD and Baranchikov YN (eds) The Ecology and Evolution of Gall Forming Insects, pp 110-120. General Technical Report NC-174. United States Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, North Central Forest Experiment Station, St Paul, Minnesota

    Google Scholar 

  • Boecklen WJ and Spellenberg R (1990) Structure of herbivore communities in two oak (Quercus spp.) hybrid zones. Oecologia 85: 92-100

    Google Scholar 

  • Brawn JD and Balda RP (1988) The influence of silvicultural activity on ponderosa pine forest bird communities in the southwestern United States. In: Jackson JA (ed) Bird Conservation 3, pp 3-21. University of Wisconsin Press, Madison, Wisconsin

    Google Scholar 

  • Campbell HW and Christman SP (1982) Field techniques for herpetofaunal community analysis. In: Scott Jr NJ (ed) Herpetological Communities, pp 193-200. US Department Interior, Fish andWildlife Service. Wildlife Research Report 13

    Google Scholar 

  • Christensen KM and Whitham TG (1991) Indirect herbivore mediation of avian seed dispersal in pinyon pine. Ecology 72: 534-542

    Google Scholar 

  • Christensen KM and Whitham TG (1993) Impact of insect herbivores on competition between birds and mammals for pinyon pine seeds. Ecology 74: 2270-2278

    Google Scholar 

  • Christensen KM, Whitham TG and Keim P (1995) Herbivory and tree mortality across a pinyon pine hybrid zone. Oecologia 101: 29-36

    Google Scholar 

  • Clary WP (1978) Producer-consumer biomass in Arizona ponderosa pine. USDA For. Serv Gen. Tech. Rep. RM-56, Fort Collins, Colorado

  • Cunningham JB, Balda RP and Gaud WS (1980) Selection and use of snags by cavity-nesting birds of the ponderosa pine forest USDA For. Serv. Res. Pap. RM-222, Fort Collins, Colorado

  • Dawson DK (1981) Sampling in rugged terrain. Studies in Avian Biology 6: 311-315

    Google Scholar 

  • Dickson JG and Segelquist CA (1979) Breeding bird populations in pine and pine-hardwood forests in Texas. Journal of Wildlife Management 43: 549-555

    Google Scholar 

  • Dickson JG, Thompson III FR, Conner RN and Franzreb KE (1995) Silviculture in central and southeastern oak-pine forests. In: Martin TE and Finch DM (eds) Ecology and Management of Neotropical Migratory Birds: A Synthesis and Review of Critical Issues, pp 245-266. Oxford University Press, New York

    Google Scholar 

  • Dickson LL and Whitham T (1996) Genetically based plant resistance traits affect arthropods fungi and birds. Oecologia 106: 400-406

    Google Scholar 

  • Drake DW (1981) Reproductive success of two Eucalyptus hybrid populations. II Comparison of predispersal seed parameters. Australian Journal of Botany 29: 37-48

    Google Scholar 

  • Floate KD, Kearsley MJC and Whitham TG (1993) Elevated herbivory in plant hybrid zones: Chrysomela confluens Populus and phenological sinks. Ecology 74: 2056-2065

    Google Scholar 

  • Floate KD, Martinsen GD and Whitham TG (1997) Cottonwood hybrid zones as centres of abundance for gall aphids in western North America: importance of relative habitat size. Journal of Animal Ecology 66: 179-188

    Google Scholar 

  • Fritz RS, Nichols-Orians CM and Brunsfeld SJ (1994) Interspecific hybridization of plants and resistance to herbivores: hypotheses, genetics, and variable responses in a diverse herbivore community. Oecologia 97: 106-117

    Google Scholar 

  • Fritz RS, Moulia C and Newcombe G (1999) Resistance of hybrid plants and animals to herbivores, pathogens and parasites. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 30: 565-591

    Google Scholar 

  • Gange AC (1995) Aphid performance in an alder (Alnus) hybrid zones. Ecology 76: 2074-2083

    Google Scholar 

  • Gaylord ES, Preszler RW and Boecklen WJ (1996) Interactions between host plants, endophytic fungi and a phytophagous insect in an oak (Quercus grisea×Quercus gambelii) hybrid zone. Oecologia 105: 336-342

    Google Scholar 

  • Graham JH, Freeman DC and McArthur ED (1995) Narrow hybrid zone between two subspecies of big sagebrush (Artemisia tridentata: Asteraceae). II. Selection gradients and hybrid fitness. American Journal of Botany 82: 709-716

    Google Scholar 

  • Hanhimäki S, Senn J and Haukioja E (1994) Performance of insect herbivores on hybridizing trees: the case of the subarctic birches. Journal of Animal Ecology 63: 163-175

    Google Scholar 

  • Harrison RG (1986) Pattern and process in a narrow hybrid zone. Heredity 56: 337-349

    Google Scholar 

  • Howard DJ, Preszler RW, Williams J, Fenchel S and Boecklen WJ (1997) How discrete are Oak species? Insights from a hybrid zone between Quercus grisea and Q. gambelii. Evolution 51: 747-755

    Google Scholar 

  • Hutto RL, Pletschet SM and Hendricks P (1986) A fixed-radius point count method for nonbreeding and breeding season use. Auk. 103: 593-602

    Google Scholar 

  • James FC and Shugart HH (1970) A quantitative method of habitat description. Audubon Field Notes 24: 727-736

    Google Scholar 

  • James FC and Wamer NO (1982) Relationships between temperate forest bird communities and vegetation structure. Ecology 63: 159-171

    Google Scholar 

  • Johnson AS and Landers JL (1982) Habitat relationships of summer resident birds in slash pine flatwoods. Journal of Wildlife Management 46: 416-428

    Google Scholar 

  • Johnston DW and Odum EP (1956) Breeding bird populations in relation to plant succession on the Piedmont of Georgia. Ecology 37: 50-62

    Google Scholar 

  • Lillywhite HB (1977) Effects of chaparral conversion on small vertebrates in southern California. Biological Conservation 11: 171-184

    Google Scholar 

  • MacArthur RH and MacArthur JW (1961) On bird species diversity. Ecology 42: 594-598

    Google Scholar 

  • Manley AM and Fowler DP (1969) Spruce budworm defoliation in relation to introgression in red and black spruce. Forest Science 15: 365-366

    Google Scholar 

  • Martin TE (1988) Habitat and area effects on forest bird assemblages: is nest predation an influence? Ecology 69: 74-84

    Google Scholar 

  • Martinsen GD and Whitham TG (1994) More birds nest in hybrid cottonwood trees. Wilson Bulletin 106: 474-481

    Google Scholar 

  • Morrison ML and Meslow EC (1984) Response of avian communities to herbicide-induced vegetation changes. Journal of Wildlife Management 48: 14-22

    Google Scholar 

  • Morrison ML, Mannan RW and Dorsey GL (1981) Effects of number of circular plots on estimates of avian density and species richness. Studies in Avian Biology 6: 405-408

    Google Scholar 

  • Morrow PA, Whitham TG, Potts BM, Ladiges P, Ashton DH and Williams JB (1994) Gall-forming insects concentrate on hybrid phenotypes of Eucalyptus. In: Price PW, Mattson WD and Baranchikov YN (eds) The Ecology and Evolution of Gall-forming Insects, pp 121-134. General Technical Report NC-174. United States Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, North Central Forest Experiment Station, St Paul, Minnesota

    Google Scholar 

  • Nixon KC (1993) Infrageneric classification of Quercus (Fagaceae) and typification of sectional names. Annales des Sciences Forestières 50(Suppl 1): 25s-34s

    Google Scholar 

  • O'Brien SJ and Mayr E (1991) Bureaucratic mischief: recognizing endangered species and subspecies. Science 251: 1187-1188

    Google Scholar 

  • Pianka ER (1966) Convexity desert lizards and spatial heterogeneity. Ecology 47: 1055-1059

    Google Scholar 

  • Pianka ER (1967) On lizard species diversity: North American flatland deserts. Ecology 48: 333-351

    Google Scholar 

  • Pianka ER (1973) The structure of lizard communities. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 4: 53-74

    Google Scholar 

  • Popper KR (1959) The Logic of Scientific Discovery. Hutchinson, London

    Google Scholar 

  • Preszler RW and Boecklen WJ (1994) A three-trophic-level analysis of the effects of plant hybridization on a leaf mining moth. Oecologia 100: 66-73

    Google Scholar 

  • Ralph CJ, Droege S and Saur JR (1992) Managing and monitoring birds using point counts: standards and applications. In: Ralph CJ, Saur JR and Droege S (eds) Monitoring Landbirds with Point Counts. General Technical Report PSW. USDA Forest Service, St Paul, Minnesota

    Google Scholar 

  • Reynolds RT, Scott JM and Nussbaum RA (1980) A variable circular plot method for estimating bird numbers. Condor 82: 309-313

    Google Scholar 

  • Rice J, Anderson BW and Ohmart RD (1984) Comparison of the importance of different habitat attributes to avian community organization. Journal of Wildlife Management 48: 895-911

    Google Scholar 

  • Robbins CS (1981a) Effect of time of day on bird activity. Studies in Avian Biology 6: 275-286

    Google Scholar 

  • Robbins CS (1981b) Bird activity levels related to weather. Studies in Avian Biology 6: 301-310

    Google Scholar 

  • Rosenstock SS (1996) Habitat relationships of breeding birds in northern Arizona ponderosa pine and pine-oak forests. Arizona Game and Fish Dept Tech Rep 23 Phoenix, Arizona

  • Rosenstock SS (1998) Influence of Gambel oak on breeding birds in ponderosa pine forests of northern Arizona. Condor 100: 485-492

    Google Scholar 

  • Rotenberry JT and Wiens JA (1980) Habitat structure, patchiness and avian communities in North American steppe vegetation: a multivariate analysis. Ecology 61: 1228-1250

    Google Scholar 

  • Scheibe JS (1987) Climate competition and the structure of temperate zone lizard communities. Ecology 68: 1424-1436

    Google Scholar 

  • Scott JM and Ramsey FL (1981) Length of count period as a possible source bias in estimating bird densities. Studies in Avian Biology 6: 409-413

    Google Scholar 

  • Southwood TRE (1961) The number of species of insects associated with various trees. Journal of Animal Ecology 30: 1-8

    Google Scholar 

  • Strauss SY (1994) Level of herbivory and parasitism in host hybrid zones. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 9: 209-214

    Google Scholar 

  • Szaro RC and Balda RP (1979) Bird community dynamics in a ponderosa pine forest. Studies in Avian Biology 3: 1-66

    Google Scholar 

  • Tucker JM (1961) Studies in the Quercus undulata species complex I: a preliminary statement. American Journal of Botany 48: 202-208

    Google Scholar 

  • Verner J (1985) Assessment of counting techniques. In: Johnston RF (ed) Current Ornithology, pp 247-302. Plenum Press, New York

    Google Scholar 

  • Whitham TG (1989) Plant hybrid zones as sinks for pests. Science 244: 1490-1493

    Google Scholar 

  • Whitham TG and Maschinski J (1996) Current hybrid policy and the importance of hybrid plants in conservation. In: Maschinski J, Hammond DH and Holter L (eds) Southwestern Rare and Endangered Plants: Proceedings of the Second Conference; (1995 September 11-14, Flagstaff, Arizona), pp 103-112. USDA, For Ser RM-GTR-283, R M For and Range Exp Sta, Ft Collins, Colorado

  • Whitham TG, Morrow PA and Potts BM (1991) Conservation of hybrid plants. Science 254: 779-780

    Google Scholar 

  • Whitham TG,M orrow PA and Potts BM (1994) Plant hybrid zones as centers of biodiversity: the herbivore community of two endemic Tasmanian eucalypts. Oecologia 97: 481-490

    Google Scholar 

  • Whitham TG, Martinsen GD, Floate KD, Dungey HS, Potts BM and Keim P (1999) Plant hybrid zones affect biodiversity: tools for a genetic-based understanding of community structure. Ecology 80: 416-428

    Google Scholar 

  • Wiens JA (1989) The Ecology of Bird Communities, Vol 1. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge

    Google Scholar 

  • Wiens JA and Rotenberry JT (1982) Habitat associations and community structure of birds in shrubsteppe environments. Ecological Monographs 51: 21-41

    Google Scholar 

  • Willson MF (1974) Avian community organization and habitat structure. Ecology 55: 1017-1029

    Google Scholar 

  • Wu HX, Yeng CC and Muir JA (1996) Effect of geographic variation and jack pine introgression on disease and insect resistance in lodgepole pine. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 26: 711-726

    Google Scholar 

Download references

Author information

Author notes

  1. Steven P. Campbell

    Present address: University of Maine, 5755 Nutting Hall, Orono, ME, 04469-5755, USA

Authors and Affiliations

  1. Department of Biology, MSC 3AF, New Mexico State University, P.O. Box 30001, Las Cruces, NM, 88003-8001, USA

    Steven P. Campbell & William J. Boecklen

  2. Department of Experimental Statistics, MSC 3CQ, New Mexico State University, P.O. Box 30001, Las Cruces, NM, 88003-8001, USA

    Steven P. Campbell & William J. Boecklen

Authors
  1. Steven P. Campbell
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

  2. William J. Boecklen
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Campbell, S.P., Boecklen, W.J. Are plant hybrid zones centers of vertebrate biodiversity? A test in the Quercus grisea × Quercus gambelii species complex. Biodiversity and Conservation 11, 443–467 (2002). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1014840915535

Download citation

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1014840915535

Search

Navigation