Abstract
Recent work has demonstrated the competitive relationship between credit unions and banks in consumer financial services. One issue underlying the nature of competition between the two, however, concerns the most appropriate way to model their interactions.Two possible approaches are the dominant-firm price-leadership model and the generalized Cournot model. In the former model, credit unions act as fringe suppliers who are price-takers in a homogeneous product market. In the latter, they possess (limited) market power. Oneway to distinguish the two is by examining the impact of credit union market shares on their pricing, as the two models imply differing effects. Our results are more consistent with the ``credit unions as fringe suppliers'' view. Using a pooled cross-section time seriesof 77 small local consumer lending markets throughout the U.S., each with 10 observations over 5 years, the focus is on a loan product ex ante thought to be sold in local markets, unsecured (non-credit card) loans. For this product, increasing credit union market sharesreduces credit union loan rates, consistent with a fringe supplier hypothesis.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Amel, Dean F., and Timothy H. Hannan (1999) ‘Establishing Banking Market Definitions through Estimation of Residual Deposit Supply Equations’, Journal of Banking & Finance, 23, 1667–1690.
Audretsch, David B., and A. Roy Thurik (1999) Innovation, Industry Evolution and Employment. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Berger, Allen, and Timothy Hannan (1989) ‘The Price-Concentration Relationship in Banking’, Review of Economics and Statistics, 71, 291–299.
Bundt, Thomas, and Barry Keating (1988) ‘Depository Institution Competition in the Deregulated Environment: The Case of the Larger Credit Union’, Applied Economics, 20, 1333–1342.
Feinberg, Robert M. (2001) ‘The Competitive Role of Credit Unions in Small Local Financial Services Markets’, Review of Economics and Statistics, 83, 560–563.
Feinberg, Robert M., and Joseph Shaanan (1997) ‘Disaggregated Domestic and Foreign Entry into U.S. Manufacturing Industries: Patterns and Price Effects’, Antitrust Bulletin, 42, 197–213.
Hannan, Timothy (1991) ‘Bank Commercial Loan Markets and the Role of Market Structure: Evidence from Surveys of Commercial Lending’, Journal of Banking and Finance, 15, 133–149.
Heaton, Gary G., and Constance R. Dunham (1985) ‘The Growing Competitiveness of Credit Unions’, New England Economic Review, May/June, pp. 19–34.
Humphrey, David B., and Lawrence B. Pulley (1997) ‘Banks' Responses to Deregulation: Profits, Technology, and Efficiency’, Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 29, 73–93.
Kaushik, Surendra K., and Raymond H. Lopez (1996) ‘Profitability of Credit Unions, Commercial Banks and Savings Banks: A Comparative Analysis’, The American Economist, 40, 66–78.
Kwoka Jr., John E. (1979) ‘The Effect of Market Share Distribution on Industry Performance’, Review of Economics and Statistics, 61, 101–109.
Rhoades, Stephen A. (1987) ‘The Effect of Nonbank Thrift Institutions on Commercial Bank Profit Performance in Local Markets’, Quarterly Review of Economics and Business, 27, 16–28.
Rhoades, Stephen A., ed. (1997) ‘special Issue on Industrial Organization Topics in Banking’, Review of Industrial Organization, 12.
Saving, Thomas (1970) ‘Concentration Ratios and the Degree of Monopoly’, International Economic Review, 11, 139–146.
Simons, Katerina, and Joanna Stavins (1998) ‘Has Antitrust Policy in Banking Become Obsolete?’, New England Economic Review, March/April, pp. 13–26.
Tokle, Robert J., and Joanne G. Tokle (2000) ‘The Influence of Credit Union and Savings and Loan Competition on Bank Deposit Rates in Idaho and Montana’, Review of Industrial Organization, 17, 427–439.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Feinberg, R.M. Credit Unions: Fringe Suppliers or Cournot Competitors?. Review of Industrial Organization 20, 105–113 (2002). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1013858830811
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1013858830811