Environmental Monitoring and Assessment

, Volume 73, Issue 1, pp 17–40 | Cite as

Forest Area in Costa Rica: A Comparative Study of Tropical Forest Cover Estimates over Time

Article

Abstract

Forest area figures, at a given point in time and for a given region of interest, differ considerably, affecting the calculation of deforestation rates and thus confuse the political and scientific discussion on the state and change of the resource forest. This article discusses the variation of published forest cover figures, using Costa Rica as an example. A list of published figures on the forest cover of Costa Rica from 1940 onwards is analyzed. Reasons for the differences are hypothesized and discussed. These differences are mainly in the definition of forest and forest classes included, in the type of the studies conducted (mapping and/or sampling), in the precision of the estimates, and in the information sources used. It is concluded that part of the problem is inherent in the nature of the resource `forest'. Quality and completeness of the presentation of the forest cover estimates are a clue to their correct understanding and interpretation. The latter point being especially relevant, as forest cover data have both a technical-scientific and a political meaning and are used as relevant arguments in many discussions. In the example of Costa Rica, a general downward trend is observed up to about 1985/1990, whereas after that forest area figures are on the average at a markedly higher level. Some hypotheses for this change in the trend are discussed.

Costa Rica forest definition forest inventory forest mapping tropical deforestation 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Calvo, J. C., Watson, V., Bolaños, R., Quesada, C., Sánchez, A., Gómez, P. and Ramírez, M.: 1999, 'Estudio de cobertura forestal de Costa Rica empleando imágenes LANDSAT 1986/87 y 1996/1997', in: Memorias del XI Congreso Nacional Agronómico 1999, pp. 461–466.Google Scholar
  2. Castro, R. and Tattenbach, F.: 1997, The Costa Rican Experience withMarket Instruments toMitigate Climate Change and Conserve Biodiversity, San José, Costa Rica. FUNDECOR and MINAE.Google Scholar
  3. CCAD: 1998, State of the Environment and Natural Resources in Central America 1999, (comp. by J. Rodriguez), First English version, San José, Costa Rica, 176 p.Google Scholar
  4. CCAD, USAID: 1998, Estimación de la cantidad de carbono almacenado y captado (masa aérea) por los bosques de Costa Rica, 50 p.Google Scholar
  5. CCAD, CCAB-AP, IUCN-HORMA: 1997/1998, Diagnóstico forestal de Costa Rica, Preliminary version, San José.Google Scholar
  6. CCT, CIEDES: 1998, Estudio de cobertura forestal actual (1996/1997) y de cambio de cobertura para el Período entre 1986/1987 y 1996/1997 para Costa Rica, San José, Costa Rica, 19 p. + annexos.Google Scholar
  7. Congalton, R. and Green, K.: 1999, Assessing the Accuracy of Remotely Sensed Data: Principles and Practices, CRC Press, Inc. 137 p.Google Scholar
  8. Cunia, T.: 1978, 'On the Objectives and Methodology of National Forest Inventory Systems', in Proceedings of the IUFRO S4.02 and S4.04 Joint Meeting on National Forest Inventory, June 18-24 1978, Bukarest, Romania, p. XI–XXVIII.Google Scholar
  9. DeVries, P. G.: 1986, Sampling Theory for Forest Inventory, Berlin, Springer, 399 p.Google Scholar
  10. Escofet, G.: 1998, Forest Report Disputed, The Tico Times, March 20, 1998, San José, Costa Rica.Google Scholar
  11. European Commission: 1997, Study on European Forestry Information and Communication System. Reports on forest inventory and survey systems, Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities, 2 Vol., 1328 p.Google Scholar
  12. FAO: 1981, Manual of Forest Inventory, FAO Forestry Paper 27, 200 p.Google Scholar
  13. FAO: 1993, Forest resources assessment 1990, Tropical countries, FAO Forestry Paper 112, 61 p. + annexes.Google Scholar
  14. Flores Rodas, J. G.: 1985, Diagnóstico del sector industrial forestal, Editorial Universidad Estatal a Distancia, 116 p.Google Scholar
  15. FONAFIFO, PNUD: 1999, El Desarrollo del Sistema de Pago de Servicios Ambientales en Costa Rica. Fondo Nacional de Financiamiento Forestal y Programa de las Naciones Unidas para El Desarrollo, San José, Costa Rica.Google Scholar
  16. Harcourt, C. S. and Sayer, J. A.: 1996, The Conservation Atlas of Tropical Forests: The Americas, London, U.K., Macmillan, 333 p.Google Scholar
  17. Harrison, S.: 1991, 'Population growth, land use and deforestation in Costa Rica, 1950-1984', Intersciencia 16(1), 83–93.Google Scholar
  18. Hartshorn, G. and 16 further authors: 1982, Costa Rica - Country Environmental Profile. A Field Study, Tropical Science Center. San José, Costa Rica, 123 p.Google Scholar
  19. Holdridge, L. R., Grenke, W. C., Hatheway, W. H., Liang, T. and Tosi Jr., J. A.: 1970, Forest Environments in Tropical Life Zones. A Pilot Study, Pergamon Press, Oxford, 747 p.Google Scholar
  20. Husch, B.: 1971, Planificación de un Inventario Forestal, FAO, Roma, Italia, 134 p.Google Scholar
  21. Husch, B.: 1978, 'Why Carry out National Forest Inventories?', in Proceedings of the IUFRO S4.02 and S4.04 Joint Meeting on National Forest Inventory, June 18-24, 1978, Bucarest, Romania, p. 134–143.Google Scholar
  22. Iles, K.: 1994, 'Some directions in forest inventory', J. Forestry 92(12), 12–15.Google Scholar
  23. Junkov, M.: 1984, Localización y valorización de la masa forestal en Costa Rica (Primera Fase). Localización y caracterización, DGF/PNUD/FAO/COS/79/001, Ministerio de Agricultura y Ganaderia, San José, Costa Rica, 79 p.Google Scholar
  24. Junkov, M., 1984/1985, Localización y valoración de la masa forestal en Costa Rica, Costa Rica, Dirección General Forestal (based on a report DGF-PNUD-FAO-COS/79/001 from March 1984, San José, Costa Rica, 79 p.).Google Scholar
  25. Kaimowitz, D.: 1998, 'Forests, Policies and People on the Central American Agricultural Frontier', in M. Palo and J. Uusivouori (eds.), Worlds Forests, Society and Environment, Vol. 1, Kluwer, 430 p., pp. 247–253.Google Scholar
  26. Keogh, R. M.: 1984, 'Changes in the forest cover of Costa Rica through history', Turrialba 34(3), 325–331.Google Scholar
  27. Kleinn, C.: 1991, Zum Waldbegriff in Forstlichen Großrauminventuren (On forest definitions in large area forest inventories. In German with English abstract), AFJZ, 162. Jg., S. 201–210.Google Scholar
  28. Kleinn, C.: 1992, 'On the Compatibility of Forest Inventory Results', Proceedings of the IUFRO Conference on Integrating Forest Management over Space and Time, Canberra, Australia, 13-17 January 1992, pp. 278–285.Google Scholar
  29. Köhl, M., Traub, B. and Päivinen, R.: 2000, ‘Harmonisation and standardisation in multi-national environmental statistics - mission impossible?' Environ. Monit. Assess. 63(2), 361–380.Google Scholar
  30. Lammerts Van Beuren, E. M. and Blom, E. M.: 1997, Principles, Criteria, Indicators: Hierarchical Framework for the Formulation of Sustainable Forest Management Standards, Tropenbos Foundation, The Netherlands, 82 pp.Google Scholar
  31. Leonard, H. J.: 1986, Recursos Naturales y Desarrollo Económico en América Central. Un Perfil Ambiental Regional, Seria técnica, informe técnico/CATIE, No. 127, 267 p.Google Scholar
  32. Loetsch, F., Zöhrer, F. and Haller, K. E.: 1973, Forest Inventory, Volume II, BLV, München, 468 p.Google Scholar
  33. Lund, G. and Boley, M.: 1995, 'National resource inventorying and monitoring needs: The said and unsaid from UNCED', Schweizrische Zeitschrift für Forstwesen 146(12), 953–964.Google Scholar
  34. MAG: 1996, From http://www.mideplan.go.cr/~sideamb/sides/ambiental/01-04.htm.Google Scholar
  35. Malleux, J., 1982, Inventarios Forestales en Bosques Tropicales, Costa Rica, 414 p.Google Scholar
  36. Mayaux, P., Achard, F. and Malingreau, J. P.: 1998, 'Global tropical forest area measurements derived from coarse resolution satellite imagery: A comparison with other approaches', Environ. Cons. 25(1), 37–52.Google Scholar
  37. MINAE: 1996, Información Estadística Relevante sobre el Sector Forestal 1972-1995, San José, Costa Rica, Enero 1996, 48 p.Google Scholar
  38. MINAE, FONAFIFO: (no year), Costa Rica: Toward the Sustainability of its Forest Resources, San José, Costa Rica, 23 p.Google Scholar
  39. Myers, N.: 1981, 'The hamburger connection: How Central America's forests become North America's hamburgers', AMBIO 10(1), 3–8.Google Scholar
  40. OPSA: 1978, Comportamiento del Sector Forestal durante el Período de 1950-1977, (Worked out by S. Pérez and F. Protti). DOC-OPSA-15. Oficina de Planificación Sectorial Agropecuario, Julio 27, 1978, 59 p.Google Scholar
  41. Ortiz Valverde, R.: 1996, Bosque Secundario por abandono de Pastizales en la Región Huetar Norte de Costa Rica: Análisis de Algunos Criterios Económicos y Ambientales, Tésis de Maestría, Universidad Nacional, Heredia, Costa Rica, 112 p.Google Scholar
  42. Pedroni, L.: 1992, Diagnóstico Forestal de Costa Rica y Propuestas de Trabajo, Informe de Intercooperación (IC), (Unión Mundial para la Naturaleza (UICN), Oficina Regional para Centro América (ORCA) para la Cooperación Suiza para el Desarrollo (COSUDE), 193 p. + Anexos.Google Scholar
  43. Pedroni, L.: 1999, Implementación Conjunta y Desarrollo Limpo: Antecedentes a Nivel Mundial, Manejo Forestal Tropical No. 10. Octubre 1999, CATIE, 7 p.Google Scholar
  44. Pedroni, L. and Velasquez, S.: 1998, 'Medición y diagnóstico de cobertura boscosa: ¿Qué tan Útiles son las imágenes de satélite en nuestro medio?', In: Memorias del Simposio Conservación del Bosque en Costa Rica, Oct. 30-31 1997. Academia Nacional de Ciencias. San José, Costa Rica, pp. 85–99.Google Scholar
  45. Prodan, M., Peters, R., Cox, F. and Real, P.: 1997, Mensura Forestal, IICA/BMZ/GTZ. Serie Investigación y Educación en Desarrollo Sostenible, San José, Costa Rica, 561 p.Google Scholar
  46. Sader, S. A. and Joyce, A. T.: 1988, 'Deforestation rates and trends in Costa Rica, 1940 to 1983', Biotrop. 2(1), 11–19.Google Scholar
  47. Sánchez, G.: 1997, Assessing Land Use/Cover Change in Costa Rica, CIEDES 1-97, Universidad de Costa Rica, 181 p.Google Scholar
  48. Schreuder, H. T., Gregoire, T. G. and Wood, G. B.: 1993, Sampling Methods for Multiresource Forest Inventories, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 446 p.Google Scholar
  49. Segura, O., Kaimowitz, D., and Rodriguez, J. (eds): 1997, Políticas Forestales en Centro América: Análisis de las Restricciones para el Desarrollo del Sector Forestal, IICA-Holanda/LADERAS C.A., CCAB-AP, Frontera Agrícola. 348 p.Google Scholar
  50. Shiver, B. D., Borders, B. E.: 1996, Sampling Techniques for Forest Resource Inventory, Wiley & Sons. 356 p.Google Scholar
  51. Sutherland, W. (ed.).: 1996, Ecological Census Techniques. A Handbook, Cambridge University Press. Cambridge, UK. 336 p.Google Scholar
  52. Stehman, S. V.: 1997, 'Selecting and interpreting measures of thematic classification accuracy', Remote Sens. Environ. 62, 77–89.Google Scholar
  53. Stehman, S. V. and Czaplewski, R. L.: 1998, 'Design and analysis for thematic map accuracy assessment: fundamental principles', Remote Sens. Environ. 64, 331–344.Google Scholar
  54. Sylvander, R. B.: 1981, Bosques del país y su distribución por provincias, Universidad Estatal a Distancia, San José, Costa Rica. 120p. (= Documento de trabajo No. 15/1978 DGF/PNUD/FAO/72/013).Google Scholar
  55. Tattenbach, F. and Pedroni, L.: 1999, Implementación conjunta y desarrollo limpo: La experiencia de Centroamérica, Manejo Forestal Tropical No.11. Octubre 1999. CATIE. 7 p.Google Scholar
  56. Thrupp, L.: 1980, Deforestation, Agricultural Development, and Cattle Expansion in Costa Rica, Honors Thesis. Human Biology Program. Latin American Studies. Stanford, USA. 160 p.Google Scholar
  57. Tosi, J. A. 1974: Los recursos forestales de Costa Rica, Centro Científico Tropical. San José, Costa Rica. 17 p.Google Scholar
  58. Tuomasjukka: 1997, Síntesis del Estado del Sector Forestal en Centroamérica, CCAD, CCAB-AP, IUCN-ORMA. November 1997.Google Scholar
  59. UNDP/FAO: 1973, Estudio y Desarrollo de zonas forestales selectas, Costa Rica. Informe de Terminación. FAO/SF:73/COS 3. 175 p.Google Scholar
  60. Utting, P.: 1991, The social origins and impact of deforestation in Central America, United Nations Research Institute for Social Development UNRISD. Geneva, Switzerland. Discussion Paper No. 24. 43p.Google Scholar
  61. Wendland, A. and Bawa, K. S.: 1996, 'Tropical forestry: the Costa Rica experience in management of forest resources', J. Sustain. Forestry 3(2/3): 91–156.Google Scholar

Sources that were referred to in the references above but were not consulted as original source.

  1. Flores Rodas, J. G.: 1984, Diagnóstico del sector industrial forestal y alternativas de solución, Dirección General Forestal, Ministerio de Agricultura y Ganadería, San José, Costa Rica. (cited in Sader 1988; identical with Flores Rodas 1985).Google Scholar
  2. Garrita, D.: 1987, Forest cover map of Costa Rica.Google Scholar
  3. Gonzales: 1993, La cobertura forestal en Costa Rica, MIRENEM. San José, Costa Rica.Google Scholar
  4. Gonzales: 1995, Breve Reseña Histórica de la Dirección General Forestal, MIRENEM. San José, Costa Rica.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2002

Authors and Affiliations

  • Christoph Kleinn
    • 1
  • Lenin Corrales
    • 2
  • David Morales
    • 1
  1. 1.Statistics SubunitTropical Agricultural Research and Higher Education Center (CATIE)TurrialbaCosta Rica
  2. 2.San JoséCosta Rica

Personalised recommendations