Abstract
This study develops a theoretical tool for investigating the impact on cost effective coastal water management from explicit treatment of: coastal pollutant transports, stochastic pollutant transports in the catchment areas, and wetlands as a pollutant abatement option. It is applied to a relatively well investigated estuary, Himmerfjärden, south of the Swedish capital, Stockholm. The theoretical results indicate that all three factors influence cost effective allocation of measures and associated design of economic instruments. The consideration of stochastic pollutant transports will increase costs, but the direction of influence of the other two factors cannot be determined without empirical support. The application to nitrogen transport in Himmerfjärden shows that, for target nitrogen reductions given in terms of a percentage of pre-abatement loads, the inclusion of coastal transports in the cost calculations lowers the estimated total costs for targets interpreted in terms of nitrogen loads to the marine water. The alternative investigated target interpretation was in terms of nitrogen loads to coastal waters. Depending on the ability of wetlands to abate nitrogen and to change the variance in pollutant load to the coastal recipients, costs are either increased or decreased as compared to when wetlands are excluded as nitrogen abatement options.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
R. Elmgren and U. Larsson, Himmerfjärden. Changes in a nutrient enriched coastal ecosystem (in Swedish with an English summary), Swedish Environmental Protection Agency, Report No. 4565 (1997).
Helcom, The Baltic Sea joint comprehensive environmental action programme, Baltic Sea Environmental Proceedings, No. 48, Helsinki, Finland (1993).
O. Byström, H. Andersson and I.-M. Gren, Economic Criteria for Restoration of Wetlands under Uncertainty, Beijer Discussion Papers Series No. 114, Beijer International Institute of Ecological Economics, Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences, Stockholm (1998).
I.-M. Gren, The value of investing in wetlands for nitrogen abatement, European Review of Agricultural Economics 22 (1995) 157–172.
I.-M. Gren, T. Söderqvist and F. Wulff, Nutrient reductions to the Baltic Sea: Economics and ecology, Journal of Environmental Management 51 (1997) 123–143.
K.-G. Mäler, International environmental problems, in: Economic Policy Towards the Environment, ed. D. Helm (Blackwell, Oxford, 1991).
S. Barett, Self-enforcing international environmental agreements, Oxford Economic Papers 46 (1994) 878–894.
G. Chichilnisky and G. Heal, Global environmental risks, Journal of Economic Perspectives 7(4) (1993) 65–68.
V. Kaitala, K.-G. Mäler and H. Tulkens, The acid rain game as a resource allocation process with an application to the international cooperation among Finland, Russia, and Estonia, Scandinavian Journal of Economics 97(2) (1995) 325–343.
I.-M. Gren, P. Jannke and K. Elofsson, Cost effective nutrient reductions to the Baltic Sea, Environmental and Resource Economics 10(4) (1997a) 341–362.
B. Beavis and M. Walker, Achieving environmental standards with stochastic discharges, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 10 (1983) 103–111.
J.S. Shortle, The allocative efficiency implications of water pollution abatement cost comparisons, Water Resources Research 26(5) (1990) 793–797.
K. Segerson, Uncertainty and incentives for nonpoint pollution control, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 15 (1988) 88–98.
A.S. Malik, D. Letson and S.R. Crutchfield, Point/nonpoint source trading of pollution abatement: Choosing the right trading ratio, American Journal of Agricultural Economics 75 (1993) 959–967.
J.S. Shortle, R. Horan and D. Abler, Research Issues in nonpoint pollution control, Environmental and Resource Economics 11(3–4) (1998) 571–585.
O. Byström, The nitrogen abatement costs in wetlands, Ecological Economics 26 (1998) 321–331.
V. Cvetkovic, A.M. Shapiro and G. Dagan, A solute flux approach to transport in heterogeneous formations, 2, Uncertainty analysis, Water Resources Research 28 (1992) 1377–1388.
G. Destouni, Prediction uncertainty in solute flux through heterogeneous Soil, Water Resources Research 28 (1992) 793–801.
G. Destouni, Stochastic modelling of solute flux in the unsaturated zone at the field scale, Journal of Hydrology 143 (1993) 45–61.
G. Destouni and W. Graham, The influence of observation method on local concentration statistics in the subsurface, Water Resources Research 33 (1997) 663–676.
A. Marani, R. Rigon and A. Rinaldo, A note on fractal channel networks, Water Resources Research 27 (1991) 3041–3049.
A. Rinaldo, A. Marani and A. Bellin, On mass response functions, Water Resources Research 25 (1989) 1603–1617.
X. Foussereau, W. Graham, A. Aakpoji, G. Destouni and P.S.C. Rao, Stochastic analysis of transport in unsaturated heterogeneous soils under transient flow regimes, Water Resources Research 36 (2000) 911–921, 22.
A. Rinaldo, A. Marani and R. Rigon, Geomorphological dispersion, Water Resources Research 27 (1991) 513–525.
R. Brännlund and I.-M. Gren, Costs of differentiated and uniform charges on polluting inputs: An application to nitrogen fertilizers in Sweden, in: Environmental Economics and Regulation, eds. M. Boman, R. Brännlund and B. Kriström (Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht, 1998).
A. Charnes and W.W. Cooper, Chance-constrained programming, Operations Research 11(1) (1964) 18–39.
T. Tietenberg, Design lessons from existing air pollution control systems: The United States, in: Property Rights in a Social and Ecological Context-Case Studies and Design Applications, eds. S. Hanna and M. Munasinghe (The World Bank, Washington, DC, 1995).
A. Enqvist, Vatten-och närsaltut byte i hela Himmerfjärden, in: Himmerfjärden. Changes in a Nutrient Enriched Coastal Ecosystem (In Swedish with an English summary), eds. R. Elmgren and U. Larsson Swedish Environmental Protection Agency, Report No. 4565 (1997).
H. Johnsson and M. Hoffmann, Nitrogen Leaching from Swedish Arable Land, Report 4741, Swedish Environmental Protection Agency, Stockholm, Sweden (1997).
S. Johansson, Näringsämnesbelastning från Himmerfjärdens tillrinningsområde-En översikt av olika källor, Askölaboratoriet, Technical report No. 5, Sweden (1989).
B. Arrheimer, M. Brandt, G. Grahn, R. Roos and A. Sjöö, Modelled Nitrogen Transport, Retention and Source Apportionment for the South of Sweden, Swedish Meteorological and Hydrological Institute, Norrköping, Sweden (1997).
Björklund, Ltd., The Fluid beds at Himmerfjärdsverket, Box 858, 183 22 Täby, Sweden (1998).
I.-M. Gren, G. Destouni and O. Byström, Costs and instruments for management of stochastic water pollution, Working Paper Series no. 3, Department of Economics, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Uppsala (1998).
SLU info, Områdeskalkyler, Department of Economics, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Uppsala, Sweden (1998).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Gren, IM., Destouni, G. & Scharin, H. Cost effective management of stochastic coastal water pollution. Environmental Modeling & Assessment 5, 193–203 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1011588129892
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1011588129892