The introduction of contraceptive technologies hasresulted in the separation of sex and procreation. Theintroduction of new reproductive technologies (mainlyIVF and embryo transfer) has led not only to theseparation of procreation and sex, but also to there-definition of the terms mother and family.For the purpose of this essay, I will distinguishbetween:1. the genetic mother – the donor of the egg;2. the gestational mother – she who bears and gives birth to the baby;3. the social mother – the woman who raises the child.This essay will deal only with the form of gestationalsurrogacy in which the genetic parents intend to bethe social parents, and the surrogate mother has nogenetic relationship to the child she bears anddelivers. I will raise questions regarding medicalethical aspects of surrogacy and the obligation(s) ofthe physician(s) to the parties involved. I will arguethat the gestational surrogate is “a womb to rent,”that there is great similarity between gestationalcommercial surrogacy and organ transplant marketing.Furthermore, despite claims to freedom of choice andfree marketing, I will claim that gestationalsurrogacy is a form of prostitution and slavery,exploitation of the poor and needy by those who arebetter off. The right to be a parent, although notconstitutional, is intuitive and deeply rooted.However, the issue remains whether this rightoverrules all other rights, and at what price to theparties involved. I will finally raise the followingprovocative question to society: In the interim periodbetween today's limited technology and tomorrow'sextra-corporeal gestation technology (ectogenesis),should utilizing females in PVS (persistent vehetativestate) for gestational surrogacy be sociallyacceptable/permissible – provided they have leftpermission in writing?
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution.
Buy single article
Instant access to the full article PDF.
Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.
The Old Testament, book of Genesis, chapter 1, verse 28.
Beauchamp T.L. and Childress J.F., eds. Principles of Biomedical Ethics. University Press, 1989.
Heyd D. Genethics-the Field Concerned with the Morality of Creating People. University California Press, 1992.
Speroff L., Glass R.H. and Kase N.G. Clinical Gynecologic Endocrinology and Infertility. Charles Mitchell ed., 5th edn. Williams and Wilkins, Baltimore, MD, 1994.
Hanson M.J. and Callahan D. The Goals of Medicine: The Forgotten Issues in Health Care Reform. Georgetown University Press, Washington D.C. 1999.
The Old Testament, book of Genesis, chapter 16, verses 1–3.
The Old Testament, book of Genesis, chapter 30, verses 3–12.
Handyside A.H., Lesko J.G., Tarin J.J., Winston R.M.L. and Hughes M.R. Birth of a Normal Girl After in vitro Fertilization and Preimplantation Diagnostic Testing for Cystic Fibrosis. New England Journal of Medicine 1992; 327: 905–909.
Childbearing Agreements (Approval of Agreement and Status of New-Born) Law, 5756, 1996. [Commonly known as Israeli Surrogacy Agreements Law]. Laws of Israel, vol. 5756, p. 176, 1996.
The Age (Melbourne) 09.08.96, page 4, Canberra Celebrates its First Legal Surrogacy. The Canberra Times 09.08.96, pages 1–2, Surrogate Baby Very Special.
Newton Verrier N. The PrimalWound-Legacy of the Adopted Child. Presented at the American Adoption Congress International Convention, Garden Grove, CA, April 1991.
Panuthos C. and Romeo C. Ended Beginnings-Healing Childbearing Losses. Bergin and Garvey, MA, 1984.
Klaus M.H. and Kennell J.H. Maternal-Infant Bonding. The C.V. Mosby Company, Saint Louis, 1976.
Woods Jr., J.R. and Esposito Woods J.L. eds., Loss During Pregnancy or in the Newborn Period: Principles of Care with Clinical Cases and Analyses. Jannetti, Pitman, N.J., 1997.
The Old Testament, book of Kings I, chapter 3, verses 16–28.
Parker P.J. Motivation of Surrogate Mothers-initial findings. Am. J. Psychiatry 1983; 140: 117–118.
Ragone H. Surrogate Motherhood-Conception in the Heart. Westview Press, Boulder, Oxford, 1994.
Shalev C. Halacha and Patriarchal Motherhood-an Anatomy of the New Israeli Surrogacy Law. Israel Law Review, vol. 32, #1, pp. 51–80, 1998 [A revised version of: Surrogate Motherhood-The Commerce in Reproductive Services. Social security, vol. 46, September 1996 (in Hebrew)].
Ben-Dror A. Adoption and Surrogacy. Cook Publishers, Tel-Aviv, Israel, 1994 (in Hebrew).
Kluge E.-H.W. Readings on Biomedical Ethics-a Canadian Focus. Prentice Hall Canada, Scarborough, ON, 1995.
Sanbar S.S., Gibofsky A., Firestone M.H., Leblang Th.R., eds. Legal Medicine-American College of Legal Medicine Committee. Mosby, 1995.
Rowland R. Living Laboratories-Women and Reproductive Technologies. Sun, Australia, 1992.
Hepburn L. Ova-Dose? Allen and Unwin, Australia, 1992.
Shalev C. Birth Power-the Case for Surrogacy. Yale University Press, 1989.
Robertson J.A. Children of Choice-Freedom and New Reproductive Technologies. Princeton Univ. Press, Princeton, 1994. Reference to: (a) Uhno N et al., Development of an Artificial Placenta in Artificial Organs 1993; 17: 996, and (b) Kuwabara Y. Approach to the Management of Fetuses and Immature Babies-Development of the Extra-Uterine Fetal Incubator in Asian Med. J. 1989; 32: 419.
Noren H. and Lindblom B. A unique case of Abdominal Pregnancy: What Are the Minimal Requirements for Placental Contact with the Maternal Vascular Bed? Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 1986; 155: 394–396.
Delke I., Veridiano N.P. and Tancer M.L. Abdominal Pregnancy: Review of Current Management and Addition of Ten Cases. Obstet. Gynecol. 1982; 60: 200–204.
Akabayashi A. and Morioka M. Ethical Issues Raised by Medical Use of Brain-Dead Bodies in the 1990s. Biolaw 1991; 11(S): 531–538.
Truog R.D. Is it time to abandon brain death? Hastings Center Report 1997; 27: 29–37.
In the Matter of Karen Anne Quinlan. 70 NJ 10, 355 A2d647 (1976)
Cruzan V. Director, Missouri Department of Health. 110 Sct 2841 (1990) and 497 US.261 (1990).
Bruni F. Woman, 29, Still in 10 Year Coma, is Pregnant by Rapist. New York Times, New York, Jan 25, 1996.
Frankel B. Rape Pregnancy and Birth: Woman in Coma Sparks Debate. USA Today, Washington, DC, Jan 29, 1996.
Roberts J. US Rape Case Leaves Ethical Uproar. BMJ 1996; 312; 329.
Coma Victim Gives Birth in Strong Memorial Hospital in Rochester. New York Times, March 19, 1996.
Woman Who Gave Birth in Coma Dies. New York Times, March 18, 1997.
Cole C.L. Premature Baby Born to Comatose Patient. Boston Globe, Boston, MA, Oct 25, 1998.
Crittenden J. and Martinez. Comatose Woman Gives Birth-Police Seek Suspect in Nursing Home Rape. Boston Herald, Boston, MA, Oct 25, 1998.
Laufer Z. Open Adoption and Long-Term Foster Care: In the Best Interest of Whom? Paper presented at IFCO conference, Vancouver BC, Canada, July 1997.
Silver L.M. New Reproductive Technologies in the Treatment of Human Infertility and Genetic Disease. Theoretical Medicine 1990; 11: 103–110.