Review of Accounting Studies

, Volume 5, Issue 2, pp 95–125 | Cite as

Discretionary and Non-Discretionary Revisions of Loss Reserves by Property-Casualty Insurers: Differential Implications for Future Profitability, Risk and Market Value

  • Kathy R. Petroni
  • Stephen G. Ryan
  • James M. Wahlen


We develop and estimate a PC-industry specific model in which proxies for both discretion and non-discretion are used to partition loss reserve revisions into discretionary and non-discretionary components. The use of such proxies enables us to test directional hypotheses about the relations between the revision components and future profitability, risk and market value. We predict and find that discretionary revisions are negatively associated with future profitability, positively associated with firm risk, and negatively associated with market-to-book ratios. We predict and find that non-discretionary revisions are positively associated with future profitability and risk but are not associated with market-to-book ratios.


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. AICPA Special Committee on Financial Reporting. (1994). Improving Business Reporting—A Customer Focus: Meeting the Informational Needs of Investors and Creditors. New York: AICPA.Google Scholar
  2. Anthony, J., and K. Petroni. (1997). “Accounting Estimation Disclosures and Firm Valuation in the Property-Casualty Insurance Industry.” Journal of Accounting, Auditing, and Finance (Summer), 257–281.Google Scholar
  3. Beaver, W., C. Eger, S. Ryan, and M. Wolfson. (1989). “Financial Reporting, Supplemental Disclosures, and Bank Share Prices.” Journal of Accounting Research 27(Autumn), 157–178.Google Scholar
  4. Beaver, W., and E. Engel. (1996). “Discretionary Behavior with Respect to Allowances for Loan Losses and the Behavior of Security Prices.” Journal of Accounting and Economics 22, 177–206.Google Scholar
  5. Beaver, W., P. Kettler, and M. Scholes. (1970). “The Association Between Market Determined and Accounting Determined Risk Measures.” The Accounting Review (October), 654–682.Google Scholar
  6. Beaver, W., and McNichols, M. (1998). “The Characteristics and Valuation of Loss Reserves of Property-Casualty Insurers.” Review of Accounting Studies, 73–95.Google Scholar
  7. Best's. (Annual 1985–1994). Insurance Reports: Property-Casualty Edition. Oldwick, N.J: A.M.Best.Google Scholar
  8. Blue Ribbon Committee on Improving the Effectiveness of Corporate Audit Committees. (1999). Report and Recommendations. New York Stock Exchange/National Association of Securities Dealers.Google Scholar
  9. Fama, E., and K. French. (1992). “The Cross-Section of Expected Stock Returns.” Journal of Finance (June), 427–465.Google Scholar
  10. Feltham, G., and J. Ohlson. (1995). “Valuation and Clean Surplus Accounting for Operating and Financial Activities.” Contemporary Accounting Research (Spring), 689–731.Google Scholar
  11. Gart, A. (1994). Regulation, Deregulation, Reregulation. New York: John Wiley & Sons.Google Scholar
  12. Grace, E. (1990). “Property-Liability Insurer Reserve Errors: A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis.” Journal of Risk and Insurance 57, 28–46.Google Scholar
  13. Guay, W., S. P. Kothari, and R. Watts. (1996). “A Market-Based Evaluation of Discretionary Accruals Models.” Journal of Accounting Research 34(Supplement), 83–105.Google Scholar
  14. Hamada, R. “The Effect of the Firm's Capital Structure on the Systematic Risk of Common Stocks.” Journal of Finance (May), 435–452.Google Scholar
  15. Hill, R. (1979). “Profit Regulation in Property-Liability Insurance.” Bell Journal of Economics 10, 172–191.Google Scholar
  16. Jones, J. (1991). “Earnings Management During Import Relief Investigations.” Journal of Accounting Research (Autumn), 193–228.Google Scholar
  17. Nelson, K. (1997). “The Discretionary Use of PresentValue-Based Measurements by Property-Casualty Insurers.” Research Paper No. 1428, Graduate School of Business, Stanford University.Google Scholar
  18. Penalva, F. (1998). “Loss Reserves and Accounting Discretion in the Property-Casualty Insurance Industry.” Working paper, University of California at Berkeley.Google Scholar
  19. Penman, S. (1991). “An Evaluation of Accounting Rate of Return.” Journal of Accounting, Auditing, and Finance (Spring), 233–256.Google Scholar
  20. Petroni, K. (1992). “Optimistic Reporting in the Property-Casualty Insurance Industry.” Journal of Accounting and Economics (December), 485–508.Google Scholar
  21. Petroni, K., and M. Beasley. (1996). “Errors in Accounting Estimates and their Relation to Audit Firm Type.”Journal of Accounting Research (Spring), 151–171.Google Scholar
  22. Prais, S., and C. Winsten. (1954). “Trend Estimators and Serial Correlation.” Cowles Commission Discussion Paper No. 383, Chicago.Google Scholar
  23. Ryan, S. (1997). “A Survey of Research Relating Accounting Numbers to Systematic Equity Risk, with Implications for Risk Disclosure Policy and Future Research.” Accounting Horizons (June), 82–95.Google Scholar
  24. Sommer, D. (1996). “The Impact of Firm Risk on Property-Liability Insurance Prices.” Journal of Risk andInsurance 63, 501–514.Google Scholar
  25. Subramanyam, K. (1996). “The Pricing of Discretionary Accruals.” Journal of Accounting and Economics 22, 249–181.Google Scholar
  26. Wahlen, J. (1994). “The Nature of Information in Commercial Bank Loan Loss Disclosures.” Accounting Review (July), 455–478.Google Scholar
  27. Winter, R. (1988). “The Liability Crisis and the Dynamics of Competitive Insurance Markets.” Yale Journal of Regulation (Summer), 455–499.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2000

Authors and Affiliations

  • Kathy R. Petroni
    • 1
  • Stephen G. Ryan
    • 2
  • James M. Wahlen
    • 3
  1. 1.Michigan State UniversityUSA
  2. 2.New York UniversityUSA
  3. 3.Indiana UniversityUSA

Personalised recommendations