Abstract
New bio-technologies are currently forcing medicine to cross boundaries that might have seemed insuperable sometime ago. Specifically, they now help to prolong human life beyond its natural process and to maintain it almost indefinitely. Consequently, death takes on new meanings. For some it simply appears like an eventuality that can be postponed while, for others, death become synonymous to extended suffering, to dehumanization and to anguish. This apprehension gives rise to a wave of compassion for the dying person which is being translated into a new discourse around the notions of “quality of life” and “dying with dignity”. In this movement, the question of assisted suicide resurfaces. Through an extensive study of the Sue Rodriguez case in the Supreme Court of Canada (1993), the author shows that this particular case forced the Canadian society to rethink some of its long-standing socio-legal boundaries. First, the current social debate on assisted suicide poses new demands on Criminal Law, particularly on the judicial tradition since the courts are presently ill-equipped to respond to cases which demand to give content to new “human rights” that do not yet have a legal substance. Second, the Rodriguez case revealed the emergence, on the judicial and political scenes, of certain community groups that restructures the traditional power relations linked to the social regulation of assisted suicide. Finally, the study shows a change in the boundaries surrounding the accepted use of Criminal Law toward an administrative (risk management) rather than punitive use.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aktouf, Omar, Méthodologie des sciences sociales et approche qualitative des organisations. (Québec: Presses de l'Université du Québec, 1987).
Anderson, Olive, Suicide in Victorian and Edwardian England. (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1987).
Beauchemin, Jacques, Gilles Bourque, Jules Duchastel, Gérard Boismenu and Alain Noël, “Présentation. L'État dans la tourmente", Cahiers de recherche sociologique, 1995 (24), 7-13.
Bopp, James, Richard E. Coleson, “Roe v. Wade and the Euthanasia Debate”, Issues in Law and Medicine, 1997 (12:4), 343-354.
Bzdera, André, "Perspectives québécoises sur la cour suprOeme du Canada", Canadian Journal of Law and Society, 1992 (7:2), 1-21.
Caillé, Alain, "La bioéthique, le risque écologique et les deux démocraties (recherche d'un principe normatif non utilitariste)”, Droits, 1991 (13:1), 99-109.
Chambliss, W.J., "Elites and the Creation of Criminal Laws" in W.J. Chambliss (ed), Sociological Readings in the Conflict Perspective(Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley, 1973), 430-444.
Clairborne, William "A Harsh Look at Assisted Suicide; Oregon Opponents Try Graphic Approach". Washington Post, Nov. 1, 1997, at A13.
Cohen, Mariette Block, The Origins of Social and Legal Policies on Suicide in Western Civilization. Ph.D. Dissertation, (Waltham, MA, Brandeis University, 1988), 327 pages.
Curran, Patrick M., "Regulating Death: Oregon's Death with Dignity Act and the Legalization of Physician-Assisted Suicide", Georgetown Law Journal, 1988 (86:3), 725-749.
Hoffman, Dennis E. and Vincent J. Webb, "Suicide as Murder at Common Law. Another Chapter in the Falsification of Consensus Theory", Criminology, 1981 (19:3), 372-384.
Humphry, Derek, Final Exit. The Practicalities of Self-Deliverance and Assisted Suicide for the Dying. (New York: Dell Paperbacks, 1991).
Jochemsen, Henk, "Dutch Court Decisions on Nonvoluntary Euthanasia Critically Reviewed", Issues in Law and Medicine, 1998 (13:4), 447-458.
Laberge, Danielle and Pierre Landreville, "Du droit libéral au droit bureaucratique", Cahiers de recherche sociologique, 1989 (13), 73-92.
Lascoumes, Pierre, Pierrette Poncela, and Pierre Lenoël, Les grandes phases d'incrimination(Ministère de la Justice, Paris: G.A.P.P.-C.N.R.S. Paris X, 1992).
Lascoumes, Pierre, "La ‘nature’ comme intérêt protégé par le droit pénal: les trois étapes d'un parcours incertain" in Collectif, Acteur social et délinquance: une grille de lecture du système de justice pénale. (Bruxelles: Mardaga, 1993), 145-163.
Linville, John E., "Physician-Assisted Suicide as a Constitutional Right", Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics, 1996 (24:3), 198-206.
MacDonald, Michael and Terence R. Murphy, Sleepless Souls: Suicide in Early Modern England. (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1990).
Marra, Realino and Marco Orrù, "Social Images of Suicide". British Journal of Sociology, 1991 (42:2), 273-288.
Martel, Joane, Transformations du droit pénal et des rapports sociaux en matière de suicide assisté. Une analyse de l'affaire Sue Rodriguez devant la Cour Suprême du Canada. Ph.D. Dissertation, (Montréal, Québec, Canada, UQAM, 1996), 415 pages.
____, Martin's Criminal Code(Toronto: Canada Law Book, 1955).
Perkins, Rollin Morris, Criminal Law. 2nd ed.(New York: The Foundation Press, 1969).
Quill, T.E., "Death and Dignity: A Case of Individualized Decision Making", New England Journal of Medicine, 1991 (324), 691-694.
Quinn Patton, Michael, How to Use Qualitative Methods in Evaluation(Newbury Park, CA: Sage, 1987).
Quivy, Raymond and Luc Van Campenhoudt, Manuel de recherche en sciences sociales(Paris: Dunod, Bordas, 1988).
Rich, Robert M., The Sociology of Criminal Law(Toronto: Butterworth, 1979).
Schwartz, Jack, "Writing the Rules of Death: State Regulation of Physician-Assisted Suicide", Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics, 1996 (24:3), 207-216.
Sloss, David L., "The Right to Choose How to Die: A Constitutional Analysis of State Laws Prohibiting Physician-Assisted Suicide", Stanford Law Review, 1996 (48:4), 937-973.
Snell, James G. and Frederick Vaughan, The Supreme Court of Canada. History of the Institution(Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1985).
Stephen, Henry John, New Commentaries on the Laws of England(London: Butterworth, 1845) (4), 108-111.
Touraine, Alain, Production de la société(Paris: Éditions du Seuil, 1973).
Vandycke, Robert, "Les droits de l'homme et leurs modes d'emploi: à propos de la charte constitutionnelle de 1982", Sociologie et sociétés, 1986 (18:1), 139-151.
Van Hooff, Anton J.L., From Autothanasia to Suicide: Self-killing in Classical Antiquity(London/New York: Routledge, 1990).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Martel, J. Bouncing boundaries and breaking boundaries. Crime, Law and Social Change 30, 131–162 (1998). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1008301804495
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1008301804495