Abstract
Despite the early introduction of mandatory environmental impact assessment (EIA) in the planning systems of many countries in the Southeast Asia region successes in protecting the natural environment have been limited. Is this the failure of the EIA itself due to the use of an inappropriate western based model or is it more related to a lack of political will and implementation weakness? The facts indicate that the EIA is often used as a means to an end rather than as a beneficial planning tool in itself. The fiction relates to the impressive array of legislation and sophisticated processes on paper that are often ineffective in practice. This paper attempts to highlight the problem areas and suggests other techniques and strategies that may be introduced to solve them.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Ahmad Y.J. and Sammy G.K., 1985: Exploding Myths, Guidelines to Environmental Impact Assessment in Developing Countries. UNEP, Hodder and Stoughton, pp. 6-8.
APCEL 1996: Environmental impact assessment. Environmental legislation and sustainable development. Workshop Report. Asia Pacific Centre for Environmental Law. National University of Singapore December 13.
Briffett C., 1996: Monitoring the effectiveness of environmental impact assessment EIA in Southeast Asia. Asian Journal of Environmental Management 4(1): 53-63.
Briffett C., 1999: EIA in East Asia. Handbook of Environmental Impact Assessment, Volume 2, EIA in Practice: Impact and Limitations. Blackwell Science Publications, Oxford, UK.
Briffett C. (forthcoming): Status and scope of environmental assessment in East Asia. In: Briffett C. and Obbard (eds), Environmental Assessment Asia. Institute of Southeast Asia Studies.
Briffett C. and Malone L.L.C., 1992: The case for introducing environmental impact assessment in Singapore. Infrastructure: Impact on Development and Environment. The 1992 Convention of the Institute of Engineers, Singapore.
Brown A.L. and McDonald G.T., 1989 To make assessment work more effectively. Issues raised in a workshop on Environmental Assessment for Development Planning at Griffith University, Brisbane, Australia.
Campbell I., 1993: Environmental Impact Assessment. Where to from here? The future of EIA in developing countries. For discussion at the UNEP Consultative Meeting Paris.
de Souza S.P., 1980: Environmental impact assessment: An international review with particular reference to developing countries. MSc dissertation Department of Planning and Landscape, University of Manchester, UK.
Frost R., 1994: Project design beyond environmental impact statements. Environmental Assessment. Vol. 2,No. 1. Institute of Environmental Assessment.
Glasson J., Therivel R., Chadwick A., 1999: Introduction to Environmental Impact Assessment. Principles and Procedures, Process, Practice and Prospects. 2nd edn. The natural and built environment series. UCL Press, UK.
Harun H., 1993;: Environmental impact assessment — Malaysia's viewpoint. International Conference on Resource Development. The Key to Sustainable Development. Institute of Surveyors, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. Former Deputy Director General. Department of the Environment, Malaysia.
Horberry J., 1985: International organisation and EIA in developing countries. Environmental Impact Assessment Review 5: 207-222.
Hunter H.W., 1993: Environmental Impact Assessment — An International Viewpoint. International Symposium on Resource Development. The Key to Sustainable Development. Institute of Surveyors Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
IUCN, 1991: Creating a global alliance. Caring for the Earth. A Strategy for Sustainable Living. International Union for the Conservation of Nature. Gland, Switzerland.
Langkawi, 1989: The Langkawi declaration on environment. Langkawi, Malaysia 21 October, Heads of Government of the Commonwealth.
Lee N. and Colley R., 1991: Reviewing the quality of environmental statements: review methods and findings. Town Planning Review 62(2): 239-248.
Lim L.Y. and Briffett C., 1993: Environmental education for the building professionals. Green and healthy buildings. Centre for Building Performance and Construction. School of Building and Estate Management. National University of Singapore/Ministry of the Environment, Singapore.
McCormick J.F., 1993: Implementation of NEPA and environmental impact assessment in developing countries. In: Hildebrand S.G. (ed.), Environmental Analysis. The NEPA experience. Lewis Publishers, USA, p. 716.
Malone-Lee L.C., 1993: Environmental Planning. In: Briffett C. (ed.), Action Proposals Environmental Issues in Development and Conservation. School of Building and Estate Management, National University of Singapore. SNP Publisher Pte Ltd., Singapore, p. 15.
Nash J.M., 1993: Environmental monitoring and audit of a major construction project in Hong Kong: the West Kowloon Reclamation. Asian Journal of Environmental Management 2: 25.
Panayotou T., 1991: Why regulations don't work in developing countries. Economic incentives in Environmental Management and their relevance to developing countries. Environmental management in developing countries. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. Paris, France, p. 94.
Parnwell M. and Bryant R. (eds), 1996: Environmental change in Southeast Asia: People, politics and sustainable development. Routledge.
Perry M. and Singh S., 2000: Environmental policy in East Asia — The importance of regulation. Environmental Assessment in East Asia. Institute of Southest Asia Studies. Briffett and Obbard (ed.), forthcoming.
Pholpoke C.,1998: The Chiang Mai cable car project: local controversy over cultural and eco-tourism. In: Hirsch W. (ed.), The Politics of Environment in Southeast Asia: Resources and Resistance. Routledge, pp. 262-280.
Roberts R.D. and Roberts T.M. (eds), 1984: Planning procedures for environmental impact analysis, Planning and Ecology. Chapman and Hall, London, p. 100.
Spellerberg I., 1992: Evaluation and assessment in planning and development. Evaluation and Assessment for Conservation. Ecological Guidelines for Determining Priorities for Nature Conservation. Chapman and Hall, UK, p. 218.
Therivel R., Wilson E., Thompson S., Heaney D., and Pritchard D., 1992: Strategic Environmental Assessment, Earthscan, UK.
Tolba M.K., 1985: Preface. In: Ahamd Y.J. and Sammy G.K. (eds.), Guidelines to Environmental Impact Assessment in Developing Countries. UNEP, vi.
Warren C., 1998 Tanah Lot: the cultural and environmental politics of resort development in Bali. Tourism development. In: Hirsch W. (ed.), The Politics of Environment in Southeast Asia: Resources and Resistance. Routledge, pp. 229-261.
Werner G., 1992: Environmental Impact Assessment in Asia: vLessons from the past decade. Environmental Impact Assessment for Developing Countries. Proceedings of an international conference on environmental impact assessment. New Delhi, India. Butterworth, Heinemann Ltd. UK, p. 190.
Young K.M., 1993: Mitigating Environmental Impacts through Master Planning. International Symposium on Resource Management. The Key to Sustainable Development. Institution of Surveyors, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Briffett, C. Environmental impact assessment in Southeast Asia: fact and fiction?. GeoJournal 49, 333–338 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1007142422219
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1007142422219