The 16-City Study analyzed for gas-phase environmental tobacco smoke (ETS) constituents (nicotine, 3-ethenyl pyridine [3-EP], and myosmine) and for particulate-phase constituents (respirable particulate matter [RSP], ultraviolet-absorbing particulate matter [UVPM], fluorescing particulate matter [FPM], scopoletin, and solanesol). In this second of three articles, we discuss the merits of each constituent as a marker for ETS and report pair-wise comparisons of the markers. Neither nicotine nor UVPM were good predictors for RSP. However, nicotine and UVPM were good qualitative predictors of each other. Nicotine was correlated with other gas-phase constituents. Comparisons between UVPM and other particulate-phase constituents were performed. Its relation with FPM was excellent, with UVPM approximately 1 1/2 times FPM. The correlation between UVPM and solanesol was good, but the relationship between the two was not linear. The relation between UVPM and scopoletin was not good, largely because of noise in the scopoletin measures around its limit of detection. We considered the relation between nicotine and saliva cotinine, a metabolite of nicotine. The two were highly correlated on the group level. That is, for each cell (smoking home and work, smoking home but nonsmoking work, and so forth), there was high correlation between average cotinine and 24-hour time-weighted average (TWA) nicotine concentrations. However, on the individual level, the correlations, although significant, were not biologically meaningful. A consideration of cotinine and nicotine or 3-EP on a subset of the study whose only exposure to ETS was exclusively at work or exclusively at home showed that home exposure was a more important source of ETS than work exposure.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in to check access.
NRC (National Research Council), Committee on Passive Smoking, Environmental Tobacco Smoke: Measuring Exposures and Assessing Health Effects(National Academy Press, Washington, D.C., 1986).
R. A. Jenkins, M. R. Guerin, A. Palausky, R. W. Counts, C. K. Bayne, and A. B. Dindal, "Determination of Human Exposure to Environmental Tobacco Smoke (ETS): A Study Conducted in 16 U.S. Cities," draft final report by Oak Ridge National Laboratory for Center for Indoor Air Research, Linthicum, Maryland (1996a).
R. A. Jenkins, A. Palausky, R. W. Counts, C. K. Bayne, A. B. Dindal, and M. R. Guerin, "Exposure to Environmental Tobacco Smoke in Sixteen Cities in the United States as Determined by Personal Breathing Zone Air Sampling," J.Exposure Anal.Environ.Epidemiol. 6(4), 473-502 (1996b).
M. R. Guerin, R. A. Jenkins, and B. A. Tomkins, The Chemistry of Environmental Tobacco Smoke: Composition and Measurement(Lewis Publishers, Chelsea, Michigan, 1992).
D. L. Heavner, W. T. Morgan, and M. W. Ogden, "Determination of Volatile Organic Compounds and Respirable Suspended Particulate Matter in New Jersey and Pennsylvania Homes and Workplaces," Environ.Int. 22(2), 159-183 (1996).
M. W. Ogden, D. L. Heavner, T. L. Foster, K. C. Maiolo, S. L. Cash, J. D. Richardson, P. Martin, P. S. Simmons, F. W. Conrad, and P. R. Nelson, "Personal Monitoring System for Measuring Environmental Tobacco Smoke Exposure," Environ.Technol. 17239-250 (1996).
D. J. Eatough, C. L. Benner, J. M. Bayona, G. Richards, J. D. Lamb, M. L. Lee, E. A. Lewis, and L. D. Hansen, "Chemical Composition of Environmental Tobacco Smoke. 1. GasPhase Acids and Bases," Environ.Sci.Technol. 23(6), 679-687 (1989).
C. L. Benner, J. M. Bayona, F. M. Caka, H. Tang, L. Lewis, J. Crawford, J. D. Lamb, M. L. Lee, E. A. Lewis, L. D. Hansen, and D. J. Eatough, "Chemical Composition of Environmental Tobacco Smoke. 2. ParticulatePhase Compounds," Environ.Sci.Technol. 23688-699 (1989).
N. L. Benowitz, "Pharmacokinetics and Pharmacodynamics of Nicotine," in M. J. Rand and K. Thurau (eds.), The Pharmacology of Nicotine. ICSU Symposium Series 93-18 (IRL Press, Oxford, United Kingdom/Washington, D.C., 1988).
N. L. Benowitz and P. Jacob III, "Metabolism, Pharmacokinetics, and Pharmacodynamics of Nicotine in Man," in W. R. Martin, G. R. vanLoon, E. T. Iwamoto, and D. L. Davis (eds.), Advances in Behavioral BiologyTobacco Smoking and Nicotine: A Neurobiological Approachpp. 357-373 (Plenum Press, New York, 1987).
C. J. Proctor and G. Smith, "Considerations of the Chemical Complexity of ETS With Regard to Inhalation Studies," Ex.Pathol. 37164-169 (1989).
B. P. Leaderer and S. K. Hammond, "Evaluation of VaporPhase Nicotine and Respirable Suspended Particle Mass as Markers for Environmental Tobacco Smoke," Environ.Sci.Technol. 25(4), 770-777 (1991).
E. A. Miesner, S. N. Rudnick, F. C. Hu, and J. D. Spengler, "Particulate and Nicotine Sampling in Public Facilities and Offices”, JAPCA J. 39(12), 1577-1582 (1989).
N. L. Nagda, R. C. Fortmann, M. D. Koontz, S. R. Baker, and M. E. Ginevan, "Airliner Cabin Environment: Contaminant Measurements, Health Risks and Mitigation Options" (DOT P-15-89-5, U.S. Department of Transportation, Washington, D.C., December 1989).
M. J. Reasor, "The Composition and Dynamics of Environmental Tobacco Smoke," J.Environ.Health 50(1), 20-24 (1987).
M. W. Ogden and K. C. Maiolo, "Comparative Evaluation of Diffusive and Active Sampling Systems for Determining Airborne Nicotine and 3Ethenylpyridine," Environ.Sci.Technol. 26(6), 1226-1234 (1992).
W. S. Rickert and Labstat, Inc. "Some Considerations When Estimating Exposure to Environmental Tobacco Smoke (ETS) with Particular Reference to the Home Environment," Can.J.Public Health 79S33S39 (1988).
N. J. Balter, D. J. Eatough, and S. L. Schwartz, "Application of Physiological Pharmacokinetic Modeling to the Design of Human Exposure Studies with Environmental Tobacco Smoke," in R. Perry and P. W. Kirk (eds.), Indoor and Ambient Air Qualitypp. 179-187 (Selper Ltd., Chiswick, London, United Kingdom, 1988).
P. R. Nelson, D. L. Heavner, and G. B. Oldaker III, "Problems with the Use of Nicotine as a Predictive Environmental Tobacco Smoke Marker," in R. K. M. Jayanty and B. W. Gray Jr. (program chairs), Proceedings of the 1990 EPA/Air and Waste Management Association International Symposiumpp. 550-555 (Raleigh, North Carolina, 1990).
P. R. Nelson, D. L. Heavner, B. B. Collie, K. C. Maiolo, and M. W. Ogden "Effect of Ventilation and Sampling Time on Environmental Tobacco Smoke Component Ratios," Environ.Sci.Technol. 26(10), 1909-1915 (1992).
S. K. Hammond, "Personal Monitoring System for Measuring Environmental Tobacco Smoke Exposure," Environ.Technol. 17239-250 (1993).
J. M. Conner, G. B. Oldaker III, and J. J. Murphy, "Method for Assessing the Contribution of Environmental Tobacco Smoke to Respirable Suspended Particles in Indoor Environments, " Environ.Technol. 11189-196 (1990).
H. Tang, G. Richards, C. L. Benner, J. P. Tuominen, M. L. Lee, E. A. Lewis, L. D. Hansen, and D. J. Eatough, "Solanesol: A Tracer for Environmental Tobacco Smoke Particles," Environ.Sci.Technol. 24848-852 (1990).
M. W. Ogden and K. C. Maiolo, "Collection and Determination of Solanesol As a Tracer of Environmental Tobacco Smoke in Indoor Air," Environ.Sci.Technol. 23(9), 1148-1154 (1989).
C. H. Risner, "The Determination of Scopoletin in Environmental Tobacco Smoke by HighPerformance Liquid Chromatography,"J.Liquid Chromatogr. 17(12), 2723-2736 (1994).
O. Obidoa and S. C. Obasi, "Coumarin Compounds in Cassava Diets: 2. Health Implications of Scopoletin in Gari," Plant Foods Human Nutr. 41283-289 (1991).
J. Shani, A. Goldschmied, B. Joseph, Z. Ahronson, and F. G. Sulman, "Hypoglycaemic Effect of Trigonella Foenum Graecumand Lupinus Termis(Leguminosae) Seeds and Their Major Alkaloids in AlloxanDiabetic and Normal Rats," Arch.Int.Pharmacodyn. 21027-37 (1974).
F. J. C. Roe and R. Perry, "The Physical and Chemical Characteristics of Environmental Tobacco Smoke with Special Reference to Exposure Dose," in A. K. Armitage (ed.), Other People's Tobacco Smokepp. 21-39, (Galen Press, East York, United Kingdom, 1991).
J. J. McAughey, D. A. Knight, A. Black, and C. J. Dickens, "Environmental Tobacco Smoke Retention in Humans from Measurements of Exhaled Smoke Composition," Inhal.Toxicol. 6(6), 615-631 (1994).
M. J. Jarvis and M. A. H. Russell, "Measurement and Estimation of Smoke Dosage to Nonsmokers from Environmental Tobacco Smoke," Eur.J.Respir.Dis. 65(Suppl 133), 68-75 (1984).
R. A. Etzel, "A Review of the Use of Saliva Cotinine as a Marker of Tobacco Smoke Exposure," Prevent.Med. 19(2), 190-197 (1990).
D. B. Coultas, C. A. Howard, G. T. Peake, B. J. Skipper, and J. M. Samet, "Salivary Cotinine Levels and Involuntary Tobacco Smoke Exposure in Children and Adults in New Mexico," Am.Rev.Respir.Dis. 136(1): 305-309 (1987).
K. Phillips, M. C. Bentley, D. A. Howard, and G. Alva´ n "Assessment of Air Quality in Stockholm by Personal Monitoring of Nonsmokers for Respirable Suspended Particles and Environmental Tobacco Smoke," Scand.J.Work Environ.Health 22(Suppl 1), 1-24 (1996)
M. W. Ogden, W. T. Morgan, D. L. Heavner, R. A. Davis, and T. J. Steichen, "National Incidence of Smoking and Misclassification Among the U. S. Married Female Population," J.Clin.Epidemiol. 50(3), 253-263 (1997).
E. Di Giusto and I. Eckhard, "Some Properties of Saliva Cotinine Measurements in Indicating Exposure to Tobacco Smoking," Am.J.Public Health 76(10), 1245-1246 (1986).
J. L. Pirkle, K. M. Flegal, J. T. Bernert, D. J. Brody, R. A. Etzel, and K. R. Maurer, "Exposure of the U.S. Population to Environmental Tobacco Smoke," JAMA 275(16), 1233-1240 (1996).
G. E. Swan, K. Habina, B. Means, J. B. Jobe, and J. L. Esposito, "Saliva Cotinine and Recent SmokingEvidence for a Nonlinear Relationship," Pub.Health Rep. 108(6), 779-783 (1993).
H. Schievelbein, "Nicotine, Resorption and Fate," Pharmacol.Ther. 18233-248 (1982).
J. Lewtas, C. G. Hayes, G. Goldstein, J. Mumford, R. R. Watts, L. Claxton, A. Collier, F. W. Henderson, G. Lofroth, S. K. Hammond, J. F. McCarthy, J. D. Spengler, D. B. Coultas, and J. M. Samat, "Human Exposure and Dosimetry of Environmental Tobacco Smoke" (U.S. EPA, Office of Research and Development, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina, Deliverable #2521, 1989).
N. J. Haley, D. W. Sepkovic, and D. Hoffinann, "Elimination of Cotinine from Body Fluids: Disposition in Smokers and Nonsmokers," Am.J.Public Health 79(8), 1046-1048 (1989).
L. Jarczyk, G. Scherer, I. Hoepfiner, H. T. Luu, and F. Adlkofer, "Intake of Nicotine from Environmental Tobacco Smoke (ETS) via Different Inhalation Routes," in B. Seifert, H. Esdorn, M. Fischer, H. Ru¨ den, and J. Wegner (eds.), Indoor Air 87, Vol. 2pp. 80-84 (Oraniendruck GMBH, Berlin, Germany, 1987).
L. Jarczyk, G. Scherer, C. VonMaltzan, H. T. Luu, and F. Adlkofer, "Comparison of Intake of Nicotine from Environmental Tobacco Smoke Between Nose and Mouth Breathers," Environ.Int. 15, 35-40 (1989).
J. R. Idle, "Titrating Exposure to Tobacco Smoke Using Cotinine A Minefield of Misunderstanding," J.Clin.Epidemiol. 43(4), 313-317 (1990).
C. Feyerabend, R. M. J. Ings, and M. A. H. Russell, "Nicotine Pharmacokinetics and Its Application to Intake from Smoking, "Br.J.Clin.Pharmacol. 19239-247 (1985).
D. E. Robinson, N. J. Balter, and S. L. Schwartz, "A Physiologically Based Pharmacokinetic Model for Nicotine and Cotinine in Man," J.Pharmacokin.Biopharmaceut. 20(6), 591-609 (1992).
S. Zevin, P. Jacob, III, and N. Benowitz, "Cotinine Effects on Nicotine Metabolism," Clin.Pharmacol.Ther. 61649-654 (1997).
L. E. Wagenknecht, G. R. Cutter, N. J. Haley, S. Sidney, T. A. Manolio, G. H. Hughes, and D. R. Jacob, "Racial Differences in Serum Cotinine Levels Among Smokers in the Coronary Artery Risk Development in (Young) Adults Study," Am.J.Public Health 80(9), 1053-1056 (1990).
D. B. Coultas, G. T. Peake, and J. M. Samet, "Questionnaire Assessment of Lifetime and Recent Exposure to Environmental Tobacco Smoke," Am.J.Epidemiol. 130(2), 338-347 (1989).
D. J. Ecobichon, L. C. Holcomb, R. A. Jenkins, Y. S. Kim, S. Liao, T. Malmfors, D. Moschandreas, R. Perry, and J. M. Wu, "Panel Discussion on Exposure and Dose," in D. J. Ecobichon and J. M. Wu (eds.), Environmental Tobacco Smoke: Proceeding of International Symposium at McGill Universitypp. 79-96. (Lexington Books, Lexington, Massachusetts/Toronto, Canada, 1989).
J. D. deBethizy, L. E. Bates, R. A. Davis, D. L. Heavner, P. R. Nelson, J. C. Walker, and J. H. Robinson, "Nicotine Absorption in Humans Following Exposure to Environmental Tobacco Smoke Generated from Different Types of Cigarettes, " in C. J. Bieva, Y. Courtois, and M. Govaerts (eds), Present and Future of Indoor Air Quality.Excerpta Medica International Conference Series 860pp. 269-276 (Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1989).
K. M. Chang and J. D. deBethizy, "Applying Nicotine Pharmacokinetic Modeling to Assess the Suitability of Using Plasma Nicotine and Cotinine as Quantitative Biomarkers for ETS Exposure," Society of Toxicology 1997 Annual Meeting Abstracts, No. 150 (1997).
N. L. Benowitz, "Cotinine as a Biomarker of Environmental Tobacco Smoke,”Epidemiol.Rev. 18(2), 188-204 (1996).
H. Van Vunakis, D. P. Tashkin, B. Rigas, M. Simmons, H. B. Gjika, and V. A. Clark, "Relative Sensitivity and Specificity of Salivary and Serum Cotinine in Identifying TobaccoSmoking Status of SelfReported Nonsmokers and Smokers of Tobacco and/or Marijuana," Arch.Environ.Health 44(1), 53-58 (1989).
About this article
Cite this article
LaKind, J.S., Jenkins, R.A., Naiman, D.Q. et al. Use of Environmental Tobacco Smoke Constituents as Markers for Exposure. Risk Anal 19, 359–373 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1007088209811
- 16-City Study
- environmental tobacco smoke
- personal monitoring
- saliva cotinine
- workplace exposure