Abstract
Growth of trees and seasonal yields of understory crops were measured over a 5-year period for 4 crops grown under 17 tree species at 8 × 8 m spacing in wetland rice fields. All tree species grew well in rice fields, at rates comparable to their growth in forest plantations. Top and root pruning reduced average tree girths by up to 19% and average tree volumes by up to 41%, depending on intensity of pruning. The crops monitored were Oryza sativa, Triticum aestivum, Corchorus olotorius, and Lens culinaris. Crop yields under the trees averaged 93% of the corresponding yields outside the tree canopy. The most important factor affecting the yields of undercrops was tree size (height and/or girth). Differences among tree species and the interaction with species of undercrops were not significant after controlling for tree size. Pruning of roots and branches significantly improved crop yields under trees by amounts proportional to the intensity of root or top pruning.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Alemaychu G, Guzman R, Musanya J, Knoche U, Treagust S and Wongchanapai P (1992) Analysis of constraints and potential for rural diversification in rainfed rice based farming systems, Nakhon Sawan Province, Thailand. Working Document, International Centre for Development Oriented Research in Agriculture No. 22
Dagar JC, Gurbachan Singh, Singh NT and Singh G (1995) Evaluation of crops in agroforestry with teak (Tectona grandis), maharukh (Ailanthus excelsa) and tamarind (Tamarindus indica) on reclaimed salt affected soils. Journal of Tropical Forest Science 7(4): 623–634
Dawkins HC (1963) Crown diameters: their relatino to bole diameter in tropical forest trees. Comm For Rev 42: 318–333
Dhukia RS, Lodhi GP, Jatasra DS and Ram S (1988) Productivity of forage and food crops in agroforestry system under shisham and siris trees. Indian Journal of Range Management 9: 53–57
Harris RW and Davis WB (1971) Root pruning improves nursery tree quality. J Amer Soc Hort Sci 96(1): 105–108
Hocking D and Islam MK (1994) Trees in Bangladesh paddy fields and Homesteads. 1. Participatory action research towards a model design. Agrofor Syst 25: 193–216
Hocking D and Islam MK (1995) Trees in Bangladesh paddy fields. 2. Survival of trees planted in crop fields. Agrofor Syst 31: 39–57
Hocking D and Islam MK (1997) Growth of agroforestry trees in wetland rice fields, as influenced by top and root pruning to regulate impact on crops. Bangladesh Journal of Forest Science (submitted for publication)
Hocking D, Hocking A and Islam MK (1996) Trees on farms in Bangladesh. 3. Farmers' species preferences for homestead trees, survival of new tree planting, and main causes of tree death. Agrofor Syst 26: 231–247
Hocking D, Sarwar MG and Ahamad Yousuf MS (1997) Trees on farms in Bangladesh. 4. Crop yields underneath traditionally managed mature trees. Agrofor Syst 35: 1–13
Huxley PA (1993) Tree crop interface orientation experiment with Grevillea robusta hedgerows and maize. Agrofor Syst 26: 23–45
Jiang ZL, Gao LC, Fang YJ and Sun XW (1994) Analysis of Paulownia intercropping types and their benefits in Woyang County of Anhui Province. Forest Ecology and Management 67(13): 329–337
Jimenez VG, Navarro LA and Enriquez GA (1988) Sistemas de produccion con frutales, asociados al cultivo del cacao en la Region Brunca de Costa Rica. [Cropping systems with fruit trees grown in association with cocoa in the Brunca region of Costa Rica.] Proceedings of the Tenth International Cocoa Research Conference, Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic, 17–23 May 1987
Karschon R (1960) Nursery techniques for Eucalyptus. II. Combined top and root pruning. Leafl. No. 13, Dept Forestry, Israel; Tel Aviv, 6 pp
Keli Zagbahi J, Omont H, Hainnaux G and Zagbahi JK (1990) L'association temporaire heveas vivriers dans le sud de la Cote d'Ivoire. [The temporary association of rubber and food crops in south Cote d'Ivoire.] Revue Generale des Caoutchoucs et Plastiques No. 701: 181–187
Khan FS (1993) Bioeconomic interaction of single scattered trees on farmlands. Pakistan Journal of Forestry 43(3): 173–180
Khan GS and Ehrenreich JH (1994) Effect of increasing distance from Acacia nilotica trees on wheat yield. Agrofor Syst 25(1): 23–29
Khybri ML, Gupta RK, Sewa Ram, Tomar HPS and Ram S (1992) Crop yields of rice and wheat grown in rotation as intercrops with three tree species in the outer hills of Western Himalaya. Agrofor Syst 17(3): 193–204
Miah MG (1993) Performance of selected multipurpose tree species and field crops grown in association as affected by tree branch pruning. Ph.D. Thesis, University of the Philippines, Los Banos
Osman KT, Haque SMS and Rahman MM (1995) Effect of forest plantations on soil properties at Keochia Silvicultural Research Station, Chittagong. Indian Forester 121: 1108–1116
Quddus MA, Hussain MS, Hocking D, Abedin MZ and Islam MS (1995) Homestead and crop field agroforestry systems of different farm sizes in northwestern Bangladesh. Bangladesh J Agric Sci 20(2): 152–167
Sae-Lee S, Vityakon P and Prachaiyo B (1992) Effects of trees on paddy bund on soil fertility and rice growth in Northeast Thailand. Agrofor Syst 18: 213–223
Salazari A, Szott LT and Palm CA (1993) Crop tree interactions in alley cropping systems on alluvial soils of the Upper Amazon Basin. Agrofor Syst 22(1): 67–82
Sharma KK and Singh RK (1992) Studies on the tree-crop interaction in Populus deltoides ‘G-3’ bund plantation under irrigated conditions. Indian Forester 118(2): 102–108
Singhal RM and Panwar BPS (1991) A study of cropping pattern of poplar (Populus deltoides Marsh) based agro forestry system in North Western Uttar Pradesh. Van Vigyan 29(3): 187–191
Sunil Puri, Bangarwa KS, Shambhu Singh, Puri S and Singh S (1995) Influence of multipurpose trees on agricultural crops in arid regions of Haryana, India. Journal of Arid Environments 30(4): 441–451
Takeda S (1990) Lac cultivation and host tree plantation in northern Thailand. Southeast Asian Studies 28(2): 182–205
UNDP/FAO (1988) Agroecological regions of Bangladesh. Technical Report 2. Project BDG/81/035; FAO, Rome
Vityakon P, Sae Lee S and Seripong S (1993) Effects of tree leaf litter and shading on growth and yield of paddy rice in northeast Thailand. Kasetsart Journal, Natural Sciences 27(2): 219–222
Vityakon P, Smutkupt S, Prachaiyo B and Charoenwatana T (ed.), Rambo AT (ed.), Jintrawet A (ed.) and Sornsrivichai P (1988) Trees in paddy fields: their contribution to soil fertility, and sustainability of the paddy rice system. Sustainable rural development in Asia. Proceedings of the SUAN IV regional symposium on agroecosystem research, held at Khon Kaen University, July 4–7, 1988, pp 65–86
Wahid Rashid, Mohammad Hafeez, Rashid W and Hafeez M (1991) Effect of shisham (Dalbergia sissoo) trees on the yield of wheat: crop 1. Pakistan Journal of Forestry 41(2): 82–88
Wang QB and Shogren JF (1992) Characteristics of the crop-paulownia system in China. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 39(3–4): 145–152
Willey RW (1979) Intercropping — its importance and research needs. II. Agronomy and research approaches. Field Crop Abstracts 32: 73–85
Wu, Ying (1996) Paulownia agroforestry in China: a contribution to adaptive research. Ph. D. Thesis; Cranfield University, Silsoe, UK
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hocking, D., Islam, K. Trees on farms in Bangladesh: 5. Growth of top- and root-pruned trees in wetland rice fields and yields of understory crops. Agroforestry Systems 39, 101–115 (1997). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1005999225770
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1005999225770