Skip to main content
SpringerLink
Log in

growing pains: a conceptual framework for considering integrated assessments

  • Published:
Environmental Monitoring and Assessment Aims and scope Submit manuscript

Abstract

Policy concerns related to the environment have grown in the past decadesfrom relatively local and well-defined problems to increasingly complex andglobal issues. With this has grown the need to develop the capacity tointegrate, reconcile, organize, and communicate knowledge across scientificdisciplines, as well as to make this knowledge available and useful for policy-makers. One response to this has been the growing field ofIntegrated Assessment (IA). Our goal in this paper is to reflect on the purpose and valueof IA in principle. We propose a conceptual framework within whichindividual IA studies, and the practice of IA as a whole, can be placed andevaluated. The framework addresses both the integrative nature of IAs andtheir policy usefulness, including a self-awareness of their role and capabilities. We illustrate several stages in the evolution of integrated assessments: fromlinear to more complex chains of analysis, from non-adaptive to perfectly-adaptive to realistically-adaptive agents, from simplistic to sophisticated to pluralistic consideration of alternative underlying development paths, from strictly quantitative to quantitative and qualitative analyses, from science-driven to policy-driven, and from analyses that dictate to users to those that involvethose users in the actual assessment process. By so doing, we argue for botha richer form and process of IA. Ultimately, we feel that it may also benecessary to reconsider the framing of the questions that IAs have been askedto address, perhaps leading to the consideration of the use of other forms of mandated science.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this article

Log in via an institution

Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.

Instant access to the full article PDF.

Institutional subscriptions

Similar content being viewed by others

References

  • Bailey, P. B., Gough, C. A., Chadwick, M. J. and McGranahan, G.: 1995, ‘Methods for Integrated Environmental Assessment: Research Directions for the European Union’, discussion paper for the European Comission Directorate General for Science, Research and Development XII/D-5 Workshop on Integrated Environmental Assessment, 18–20 May, Brussels.

  • Baumgartner, T. and Midttun, A.: 1987, The Politics of Energy Forecasting: A Comparative Study of Energy Forecasting in Western Europe and North America, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

    Google Scholar 

  • Berkes, F. and Fast, H.: 1996, ‘Aboriginal Peoples: Understanding the Basis for Policy-Making Towards Sustainable Development, with Focus on the Hudson Bay Bioregion’, in Ann Dale and John Robinson (eds.), Achieving Sustainable Development. Volume 1. Vancouver: UBC Press.

    Google Scholar 

  • Chen, R. S., Linville, C. and Tuttle, D.: (forthcoming), ‘Introduction/Issues’, in R. S. Chen, C. Linville and D. Tuttle (eds.), Integrated Assessment of Global Environmental Change: Science and Policy, proceedings of the NATO Advanced Research Workshop on Integrated Assessment of Global Environmental Change: Science and Policy’, 13 October, 1995.

  • Clark, A. E. and Fujimura, J. H.: 1992, ‘What Tools, Which Jobs? Why Right?’, in A. E. Clark and J. H. Fujimura (eds.), The Right Tools for the Job: At Work in Twentieth-Century Life Sciences. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

    Google Scholar 

  • Cohen, S. J.: 1995, ‘An Interdisciplinary Assessment of Climate Change on Northern Ecosystems: The Mackenzie Basin Impact Study (MBIS)’, in D. L. Peterson and D. R. Johnson (eds.), Human Ecology and Climatic Change: People and Resources in the Far North. Bristol, CT: Taylor and Francis. pp. 301–316.

    Google Scholar 

  • Cohen, S. J.: (forthcoming), ‘Integrated Assessment of Climate Change Impacts: Bringing it Closer to Home’, in R. S. Chen, C. Linville and Dale Tuttle (eds.), Integrated Assessment of Global Environmental Change: Science and Policy, proceedings of the NATO Advanced Research Workshop on Integrated Assessment of Global Environmental Change: Science and Policy, 13 October 1995.

  • Dowlatabadi, H.: 1995, ‘Integrated Assessment Models of Climate: An Incomplete Overview’, Energy Policy 23(4), 1–8.

    Google Scholar 

  • Downing, T. E.: (forthcoming), ‘Integrated Regional Climate Impact Assessment: Users, Policies and Methodologies’, in R. S. Chen, C. Linville and D. Tuttle (eds.), Integrated Assessment of Global Environmental Change: Science and Policy, proceedings of the NATO Advanced Research Workshop on Integrated Assessment of Global Environmental Change: Science and Policy, 13 October 1995.

  • Emmelin, L.: 1982, Painting the Future: Visual Impact Analysis of Changes in the Swedish Landscape, Stockholm: Delegationen för Långsiktsmotiverad Forskning, Forskningsrådsnämnden (FRN).

    Google Scholar 

  • European Commission: 1995, Workshop on Integrated Environmental Assessment, convened by the European Commission, DGXII/D-5 and the Joint Research Center, Brussels, Belgium, 18–20 May.

    Google Scholar 

  • Frederick, K. D.: 1994, ‘Integrated Assessments of the Impacts of Climate Change on Natural Resources: An Introductory Essay’, Climatic Change 28(1–2), 1–14.

    Google Scholar 

  • Funtowicz, S. O. and Ravetz, J. R.: 1990, Uncertainty and Quality in Science for Policy, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht.

    Google Scholar 

  • Funtowicz, S. O. and Ravetz, J. R.: 1994, ‘The Worth of a Song-Bird: Ecological Economics as a Post-Normal Science’, Ecological Economics 10(3), 197–207.

    Google Scholar 

  • Hourcade, J. C., Richels, R., Robinson, J., Chandler, W., Davidson, O., Finon, D., Grubb, M., Halsnaes, K., Hogan, K., Jaccard, M., Jorgenson, D., Krause, F., La Rovere, E., Montgomery, E. D., Nastari, P., Pegov, A., Richards, K., Schrattenholzer, L., Siniscalco, D., Shukla, P. R., Sokona, Y., Sturm, P. and Tudini, A.: 1996, ‘Estimating the Costs of Mitigating Greenhouse Gases’, in J. Bruce, H. Lee and E. Haites (eds.), Climate Change 1995: Economic and Social Dimensions of Climate Change, pp. 263–296.

  • International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis: 1993, Workshop on the State of the Art of Integrated Socioeconomic-Biophysical Assessments of Climate Change, Laxenburg, Austria, October.

  • Jäger, J., Sontag, N., Bernard, D. and Kurz, W.: 1990, The Challenge of Sustainable Development in a Greenhouse Works: Some Visions of the Future. Report of a Policy Exercis held in Bad Bleiberg, Austria, September 2–7, 1990, Published by the Stockholm Environment Institute, Stockholm, Sweden.

    Google Scholar 

  • Janssen, M. A.: 1995, ‘The Battle of Perspectives’, GLOBO Working Paper GWP95-3, RIVM, The Netherlands.

    Google Scholar 

  • Jasanoff, S. et al. (eds.): 1995, Handbook of Science and Technology Studies, Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, CA.

    Google Scholar 

  • Kearney, A. R.: 1994, ‘Understanding Global Change: A Cognitive Perspective on Communicating Through Stories’, Climatic Change 27(4), 419–441.

    Google Scholar 

  • Mendelsohn, R. and Rosenberg, N. J.: 1994, ‘Framework for Integrated Assessments of Global Warming Impacts’, Climatic Change 28(1–2), 15–44.

    Google Scholar 

  • Mortsch, L. D. and Mills, B. (eds.): 1996, Great Lakes — St. Lawrence Basin Project on Adapting to the Impacts of Climate Change and Variability — Progress Report One, Environment Canada.

  • Munn, R. E. (ed.): 1995, ‘Atmospheric Change in Canada: Assessing the Whole as well as the Parts’, summary report of a workshop sponsored by Atmospheric Environment Service (Environment Canada), Environmental Conservation Service (Environment Canada), and Institute for Environmental Studies (University of Toronto).

  • NATO: 1995, Advanced Research Workshop on Integrated Assessment of Global Environmental Change: Science and Policy. Duke University, Durham, North Carolina, 15–19 October.

    Google Scholar 

  • Newby, H.: 1993, ‘Global Environmental Change and the Social Sciences: Retrospect and Prospect’, paper presented to the IGFA Preparatory Meeting, Noordwijk, The Netherlands, November.

  • O'Riordan, T.: 1991, ‘Towards a Vernacular Science of Environmental Change’, in L. Roberts and A. Weale (eds.), Innovation and Environmental Risk, Belhaven Press, London. pp. 149–162.

    Google Scholar 

  • O'Riordan, T.: 1994, ‘Civic Science and Global Environmental Change’, Scottish Geographical Magazine 110(1), 4–12.

    Google Scholar 

  • Parson, E. A.: 1994, ‘Searching for Integrated Assessment: A Preliminary Investigation of Methods and Projects in the Integrated Assessment of Global Climate Change’, Paper presented to the third meeting of the Harvard-CIESIN Commission on Global Environmental Change Information Policy, NASA Headquarters, Washington, D.C., 17–18 February.

    Google Scholar 

  • Parson, E. A.: 1995, ‘Integrated Assessment and Environmental Policy Making’, Energy Policy 23(4/5), 463–475.

    Google Scholar 

  • Risbey, J., Kandlikar, M. and Patwardhan, A.: 1996, ‘Assessing Integrated Assessments’, Climatic Change 34(3–4), 369–395.

    Google Scholar 

  • Robinson, J. B.: 1988, ‘Unlearning and Backcasting: Rethinking Some of the Questions We Ask about the Future’, Technological Forecasting and Social Change 33(4), 325–338.

    Google Scholar 

  • Robinson, J. B.: 1991, ‘Modelling the Interactions Between Human and Natural Systems’, The International Social Science Journal 43(4), 629–647.

    Google Scholar 

  • Robinson, J. B.: 1992a, ‘Risks, Predictions and Other Optical Illusions: Rethinking the Use of Science in Social Decision-Making’, Policy Sciences 25(3), 237–254.

    Google Scholar 

  • Robinson, J. B.: 1992b, ‘Of Maps and Territories: The Use and Abuse of Socioeconomic Modeling in Support of Decision Making’, Technological Forecasting and Social Change 42(2), 147–164.

    Google Scholar 

  • Robinson, J. and Timmerman, P.: 1993, ‘Myths, Rules, Artifacts, Ecosystems: Framing the Human Dimensions of Global Change’, in S. D. Wright, T. Dietz, R. Borden, G. Young and G. Guagnano (eds.), Human Ecology: Crossing Boundaries, Selected Papers from the Sixth Conference of the Society for Human Ecology, Snowbird, Utah, October 2–4, 1992. The Society for Human Ecology, CO, pp. 236–246.

    Google Scholar 

  • Robinson, J. B. and Tinker, J.: 1995, ‘Reconciling Ecological, Economic, and Social Imperatives: Towards an Analytical Framework’, prepared for the International Development Research Institute, SDRI Discussion Paper Series 95-1, September.

  • Rothman, D. S. and Robinson, J. B.: 1996, ‘Review of Great Lakes — St. Lawrence Basin Project on Adapting to the Impacts of Climate Change and Variability’, in Climate Change Impact Assessment: Assessing the Methodologies for Future Directions, proceedings of a workshop sponsored by the Canadian Climate Program Board's Socio-Economic Impacts Committee and Environment Canada's Environmental Adaptations Research Group, Nov. 9, 1995, Downsview, Ontario.

  • Rotmans, J., Dowlatabadi, H. and Parson, E. A.: 1995, ‘Integrated Assessment of Climate Change: Evaluation of Methods and Strategies’, in SOAR Report, June.

  • Salter, L.: 1988, Mandated Science: Science and Scientists in the Making of Standards, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston.

    Google Scholar 

  • SDRI: 1995, QUEST — A Quasi-Understandable Ecosystem Scenario Tool, October.

  • Shackley, S. and Wynne, B.: 1995, ‘Integrating Knowledges for Climate Change: Pyramids, Nets and Uncertainties’, Global Environmental Change 5(2), 113–126.

    Google Scholar 

  • Smit, B., McNabb, D., Smithers, J., Swanson, E., Blain, R. and Keddie, P.: 1996, ‘Farming Adaptations to Climatic Variation’, in L. Mortsch and B. Mills (eds.), Great Lakes — St. Lawrence Basin Project on Adapting to the Impacts of Climate Change and Variability: Progress Report One, pp. 125–135.

  • Svedin, U. and Aniansson, B. H. (eds.): 1986, Surprising Futures: Notes from an International Workshop on Long-Term World Development, Friibergh Manor, Sweden, January.

    Google Scholar 

  • Tague, C.: 1995, ‘Embodying Ecological Scientific Information: A Sociology of Scientific Knowledge Perspective’, Sustainable Development Research Institute.

  • Timmerman, P.: 1994, ‘The Social Dimensions of Climate Change Research: From Impacts to Strategies’, in C. M. Ryan, F. H. Quinn and M. Donahue (eds.), Great Lakes Climate Change: Research Priorities for Assessing the Impacts of Climate Change in the Great Lakes Basin, proceedings of the Great Lakes Climate Change Workshop, Dec. 6–8, 1993, Ypsilanti, Michigan, 22–32.

  • Tol, R. S. J.: (forthcoming), ‘Integrated Assessments of Climate Change and Policy Making: Don't Believe the Numbers’, in R. S. Chen, C. Linville and D. Tuttle (eds.), Integrated Assessment of Global Environmental Change: Science and Policy, proceedings of the NATO Advanced Research Workshop on Integrated Assessment of Global Environmental Change: Science and Policy’, 13 October 1995.

  • Toth, F. L.: 1995, ‘Practice and Progress in Integrated Assessments of Climate Change. A Workshop Overview’, Energy Policy 23(4/5), 253–268.

    Google Scholar 

  • Weyent, J., Davidson, O., Dowlatabadi, H., Edmonds, J., Grubb, M., Richels, R., Rotmans, J., Shukla, P., Cline, W., Fankhauser, S., Tol, R. and Parson, E. A.: 1996, ‘Integrated Assessment of Climate Change: An Overview and Comparison of Approaches and Results’, in J. Bruce, H. Lee and E. Haites (eds.), Climate Change 1995: Economic and Social Dimensions of Climate Change, pp. 367–396.

  • Wynne, B.: 1992, ‘Uncertainty and Environmental Learning: Reconceiving Science and Policy in the Preventative Paradigm’, Global Environmental Change 5(3), 111–127.

    Google Scholar 

  • Yergin, D. and Gustafson, T.: 1993, Russia 2010 and What It Means for the World, Randon House, New York.

    Google Scholar 

Download references

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

  1. Sustainable Development Research Institute, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada

    DALE S. ROTHMAN & JOHN B. ROBINSON

Authors
  1. DALE S. ROTHMAN
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

  2. JOHN B. ROBINSON
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Cite this article

ROTHMAN, D.S., ROBINSON, J.B. growing pains: a conceptual framework for considering integrated assessments. Environ Monit Assess 46, 23–43 (1997). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1005779717065

Download citation

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1005779717065

Search

Navigation