Abstract
Most ethics studies employing accounting subjects have utilized the Defining Issues Test (DIT), generally finding the moral judgment abilities of accounting students and accountants to be less advanced than those of the general population (Ponemon and Gabhart, 1994). This study assesses the validity of the DIT by examining whether an individual can achieve a higher moral judgment score on the DIT by responding from the role of a political liberal. Accounting undergraduates, defining themselves as liberal, moderate or conservative, completed the DIT once from their own perspective and once from either an "extremely conservative" or "extremely liberal" perspective.
The results indicate that DIT scores can be influenced by an aspect of political ideology not reflecting maturation in moral judgment. Subjects decreased their moral judgment scores when responding to the DIT dilemmas from a conservative perspective. Contrary to moral development theory, subjects were able to increase their moral judgment scores when responding from the perspective of a political liberal. These results imply that, given the generally conservative political orientation of the profession, the DIT may systematically understate the moral judgment abilities of accounting students and accountants.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution.
References
Armstrong, M.: 1987, ‘Moral Development and Accounting Education’, Journal of Accounting Education 5, 27–43.
Colby, A. and L. Kohlberg: 1987, The Measurement of Moral Judgement(Cambridge University Press, New York).
Cushing, B. E.: 1990, ‘Discussion of Auditor Independence Judgments: A Cognitive Developmental Model and Experimental Evidence’, Contemporary Accounting Research 7, 252–260.
Emler, N. P. and R. Hogan: 1981, ‘Developing Attitudes to Law and Justice: An Integrative Review’, in S. S. Brehm, S. M. Kassin and F. X. Gibbons (eds.), Development Social Psychology(Oxford University Press, New York), pp. 298–314.
Emler, N. P., S. Renwick and B. Malone: 1983, ‘The Relationship Between Moral Reasoning and Political Orientation’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 45, 1073–1080.
Fisher, D. G. and R. L. Ott: 1996, ‘A Study of the Relationship Between Accounting Students' Moral Reasoning and Cognitive Styles’, Research on Accounting Ethics 2, 51–71.
Fishkin, J., K. Keniston and C. MacKinnon: 1973,’ Moral Reasoning and Political Ideology’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 27, 109–119.
Gaa, J. C.: 1993, ‘The Auditor's Role: The Philosophy and Psychology of Independence and Objectivity’, in Proceedings of the 1992 Deloitte and Touche/University of Kansas Symposium on Auditing Problems(School of Business, University of Kansas), pp. 7–43.
Kohlberg, L.: 1969, ‘Stage and Sequence: The Cognitive Developmental Approach to Socialization’, in D. A. Goslin (ed.), Handbook of Socialization Theory and Research(Rand McNally, Chicago, IL), pp. 347–480.
Kohlberg, L.: 1981, The Philosophy of Moral Development(Harper & Row, Publishers, San Francisco, CA).
Kohlberg, L.: 1984, Essays in Moral Development Volume Two: The Psychology of Moral Development (Harper & Row, New York).
Kohlberg, L. and R. Kramer: 1969, ‘Continuities and Discontinuities in Childhood and Adult Moral Development’, Human Development 12, 93–120.
Lampe, J. C. and D. W. Finn: 1992, ‘A Model of Auditors' Ethical Decision Processes’, Auditing: A Journal of Practice and Theory 11, 33–59.
Markoulis, D.: 1989, ‘Political Involvement and Socio-moral Reasoning: Testing Emler's Interpretation’, British Journal of Social Psychology 28, 203–212.
McGeorge, C.: 1975, ‘The Susceptibility to Faking of the Defining Issues Test of Moral Development’, Developmental Psychology 44, 108.
Miller, A. S.: 1992, ‘Are Self-proclaimed Conservatives Really Conservative? Trends in Attitudes and Self-identification Among the Young’, Social Forces 71, 195–210.
Nassi, A. J., S. I. Abramowitz and J. E. Youmans: 1983, ‘Moral Development and Politics a Decade Later: A Replication and Extension’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 45, 1127–1135.
Ponemon, L. A.: 1990, ‘Ethical Judgments in Accounting: A Cognitive Developmental Perspective’, Critical Perspectives on Accounting 1, 191–215.
Ponemon, L. A.: 1992, ‘Ethical Reasoning and Selection-Socialization in Accounting’, Accounting, Organizations and Society 17, 239–258.
Ponemon, L. A.: 1993, ‘Can Ethics Be Taught in Accounting?’ Journal of Accounting Education 11, 185–209.
Ponemon, L. A. and D. Gabhart: 1993, Ethical Reasoning in Accounting and uditing, Research Monograph No. 21 (CGA-Canada Research Foundation, Vancouver, B. C.).
Ponemon, L. A. and D. Gabhart: 1994, ‘Ethical Reasoning Research in the Accounting and Auditing Professions’, in J. R. Rest and D. Narvaez (eds.), Moral Development in the Professions: Psychology and Applied Ethics(Laurence Erlbaum Associates, Hiilsdale, New Jersey), pp. 101–119.
Ponemon, L. A. and A. Glazer: 1990, ‘Accounting Education and Ethical Development: The Influence of Liberal Learning on Students and Alumni in Accounting Practice’, Issues in Accounting Education 5, 195–208.
Rest, J. R.: 1976, ‘New Approaches in the Assessment of Moral Judgment’, in T. Lickona (ed.), Moral Development and Behavior(Holt, Rinehart & Winston, New York), pp. 198–220.
Rest, J. R.: 1979, Development in Juding Moral Issues (University of Minnoesota Press, Minneapolis, MN).
Rest, J. R.: 1986, Moral Development: Advances in Research and Theory(Prager Press, New York).
Rest, J. R.: 1993, Guide for the Defining Issues Test, Version 1.3(University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN).
Rest, J. R. and S. Thoma, ‘Relation of Moral Judgment Development to Formal Education’, Developmental Psychology 21, 709–714.
Shaub, M. K.: 1991, ‘An Analysis of the Association of Traditional Demographic Variables with the Moral Reasoning of Auditing Students and Auditors’, Journal of Accounting Education 12, 1–26.
Sparks, P. and K. Durkin: 1987, ‘Moral Reasoning and Political Orientation: The Context Sensitivity of Individual Rights and Democratic Principles’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 52, 931–936.
Sweeney, J. T.: 1995, ‘The Moral Expertise of Auditors: An Exploratory Analysis’, Research in Accounting Ethics 1, 213–234.
St. Pierre, K., E. Nelson and A. Gabbin: 1990, ‘A Study of the Ethical Development of Accounting Majors in Relation to Other Business and Nonbusiness Disciplines’, Accounting Educators Journal 8, 23–25.
Tetlock, P. E. and G. Mitchell: 1993, ‘Liberal and Conservative Approaches to Justice: Conflicting Psychological Portraits’, in B. A. Mellers and J. Baron (eds.), Psychological Perspectives on Justice (Cambridge University Press, New York), pp. 234–255.
White, C. B.: 1988, ‘Age, Education, and Sex Effects on Adult Moral Reasoning’, International Journal of Aging and Human Development 27, 271–281.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Fisher, D.G., Sweeney, J.T. The Relationship Between Political Attitudes and Moral Judgment: Examining the Validity of the Defining Issues Test. Journal of Business Ethics 17, 905–916 (1998). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1005737508336
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1005737508336
Keywords
- General Population
- Economic Growth
- Development Theory
- Moral Judgment
- Political Orientation