Abstract
Bogen and Woodward (1988) advance adistinction between data and phenomena. Roughly, theformer are the observations reported by experimentalscientists, the latter are objective, stable featuresof the world to which scientists infer based onpatterns in reliable data. While phenomena areexplained by theories, data are not, and so theempirical basis for an inference to a theory consistsin claims about phenomena. McAllister (1997) hasrecently offered a critique of their version of thisdistinction, offering in its place a version on whichphenomena are theory laden, and hence on which theempirical support for inferences to theories is also,unavoidably, theory laden. In this commentary I arguethat McAllister and Bogen and Woodward are mistaken inthinking that the distinction is necessary, and thatthe empirical support for inferences to theories isnot necessarily theory laden in the way McAllister'saccount entails they are.
Similar content being viewed by others
REFERENCES
Bogen, J. and J. Woodward: 1988, 'Saving the Phenomena', Philosophical Review 97, 303-352.
Hellman, G.: 1997a, 'Bayes and Beyond', Philosophy of Science 64, 191-221.
Hellman, G.: 1997b, 'Responses to Maher, and to Kelly, Schulte and Juhl', Philosophy of Science 64, 317-322.
Kelly, K.: 1996, The Logic of Reliable Inquiry, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Kelly, K., O. Schulte and Cory Juhl: 1997, 'Learning Theory and the Philosophy of Science', Philosophy of Science 64, 306-316.
Korb, K. and C. Wallace: 1997, 'In Search of the Philosopher's Stone: Remarks on Humphreys and Freedman's Critique of Causal Discovery', British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 48, 543-553.
McAllister, J.: 1997, 'Phenomena and Patterns in Data Sets', Erkenntnis 47, 217-228.
Spirtes, P., C. Glymour and R. Scheines: 1993, Causation, Prediction and Search, Springer-Verlag, New York.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Glymou, B. Data And Phenomena: A Distinction Reconsidered. Erkenntnis 52, 29–37 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1005499609332
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1005499609332