Abstract
We provide a solution to the well-known “Shooting-Room” paradox, developed by John Leslie in connection with his Doomsday Argument. In the “Shooting-Room” paradox, the death of an individual is contingent upon an event that has a 1/36 chance of occurring, yet the relative frequency of death in the relevant population is 0.9. There are two intuitively plausible arguments, one concluding that the appropriate subjective probability of death is 1/36, the other that this probability is 0.9. How are these two values to be reconciled? We show that only the first argument is valid for a standard, countably additive probability distribution. However, both lines of reasoning are legitimate if probabilities are non-standard. The subjective probability of death rises from 1/36 to 0.9 by conditionalizing on an event that is not measurable, or whose probability is zero. Thus we can sometimes meaningfully ascribe conditional probabilities even when the event conditionalized upon is not of positive finite (or even infinitesimal) measure.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution.
REFERENCES
Bartha, P. and C. Hitchcock: 1999, 'No One Knows the Date or the Hour: An Unorthodox Application of the Rev. Bayes' Theorem', Philosophy of Science 66 (Proceedings), S339-S353.
Billingsley, P.: 1996, Probability and Measure, J. Wiley & Sons, New York,3rd edition.
de Finetti, B.: 1975, Theory of Probability, vols. 1 and 2,Wiley, New York. Trans. Antonio Machí and Adrian Smith.
Eckhardt, W.: 1997, 'A Shooting-Room View of Doomsday', Journal of Philosophy XCIII(5), 244-259.
Hájek, A.: 1999, 'What Conditional Probability Could Not Be', forthcoming in Synthese.
Hurd, A. E. and P. A. Loeb: 1985, An Introduction to Nonstandard Real Analysis, Academic Press, Orlando.
Leslie, J.:1996, The End of the World, Routledge, New York.
Lewis, D.: 1980, 'A Subjectivist's Guide to Objective Chance', in Richard C. Jeffrey (ed.), Studies in Inductive Logic and Probability, University of California Press, Berkeley, pp. 263-293.
Loeb, P. A.: 1975, 'Conversion from Nonstandard to Standard Measure Spaces and Applications in Probability Theory', Transactions of the American Mathematical Society 211, 113-122.
Royden, H. L.: 1968, Real Analysis, Macmillan, New York, 2nd edition.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bartha, P., Hitchcock, C. The Shooting-Room Paradox and Conditionalizing on Measurably Challenged Sets. Synthese 118, 403–437 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1005100407551
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1005100407551
Keywords
- Conditional Probability
- Prior Probability
- Subjective Probability
- Standard Part
- Outcome Space