Abstract
In ยง54 of the Grundlagen, Frege advances an interesting proposal on how to distinguish among different sorts of concepts, only some of which he thinks can be associated with number. This paper is devoted to an analysis of the two criteria he offers, isolation and non-arbitrary division. Both criteria say something about the way in which a concept divides its extension; but they emphasize different aspects. Isolation ensures that a concept divides its extension into discrete units. I offer two construals of this: isolation as discreteness, i.e. absence of overlap, between the objects to be counted; and isolation as the drawing of conceptual boundaries. Non-arbitrary division concerns the internal structure of the units we count: it makes sure that we cannot go on dividing them arbitrarily and still find more units of the kind. Non-arbitrary division focuses not only on how long something can be divided into parts of the same kind; it also speaks to the way in which these divisions are made, arbitrarily or non-arbitrarily, as well as to the compositional structure of the objects divided.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution.
REFERENCES
Bunt, H. C.: 1979, 'Ensembles and the Formal Semantic Properties of Mass Terms', in Francis Jeffry Pelletier (ed.), Mass Terms: Some Philosophical Problems, D. Reidel Publishing Co., Dordrecht, Holland, pp. 249โ277.
Bunt, H. C.: 1985, Mass Terms and Model-Theoretic Semantics, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Burge, T.: 1972, 'Truth and Mass Terms', The Journal of Philosophy LXIX, 263โ82.
Burge, T.: 1975, 'Mass Terms, Count Nouns and Changec', Synthese 31, 459โ78.
Cartwright, R.: 1994a, 'Notes on Aquinas' Metaphysics', unpublished manuscript, draft of September 1994.
Cartwright, R.: 1994b, 'Speaking of Everything', Nous 28, 1โ20.
Cartwright, H. M.: 1963, Classes, Quantities and Non-Singular Reference, unpubl. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor.
Cartwright, H. M.: 1965, 'Heraclitus and the Bath Water', Philosophical Review 74, 466โ85.
Cartwright, H. M.: 1970, 'Quantities', Philosophical Review 79, 25โ42.
Cartwright, H. M.: 1975a, 'Some Remarks About Mass Nouns and Plurality', Synthese 31, 395โ410.
Cartwright, H. M.: 1975b, 'Amounts and Measures of Amounts', Nous 9, 143โ64.
Cheng, C. Y.: 1973, 'Response to Moravcsik', in J. Hintikka et al. (eds.), Approaches to Natural Language, D. Reidel Publishing Co., Dordrecht, Holland, pp. 286โ88.
Cocchiarella, N.: 1976, 'On the Logic of Natural Kinds', Philosophy of Science 43, 202โ22.
Dummett, M.: 1973, Frege: Philosophy of Language, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
Dummett, M.: 1981, The Interpretation of Frege's Philosophy, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
Dummett, M.: 1991, Frege: Philosophy of Mathematics, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
Frege, G.: 1980, The Foundations of Arithmetic, transl. by J. L. Austin, Northwestern University Press, Chicago.
Geach, P. T.: 1962, Reference and Generality, Cornell University Press, Cornell, NY.
Geach, P. T.: 1973, 'Ontological Relativity and Relative Identityโ, in Milton Munitz (ed.), Logic and Ontology, NYU Press, pp. 287โ302.
Gillon, B. S.: 1992, 'Towards a Common Semantics for English Count and Mass Nouns', Linguistics and Philosophy 15, 597โ639.
Goodman, N.: 1951, The Structure of Appearance, D. Reidel Publishing Co., Dordrecht, Holland.
van Heijenoort, J.: 1986, 'Frege and Vagueness', in L. Haaparanta and J. Hintikka (eds.), Frege Synthesized, D. Reidel Publishing Co., Dordrecht, Holland, pp. 31โ45.
Higginbotham, J.: 1994, 'Mass and Count Quantifiers', Linguistics and Philosophy 17, 447โ80.
Johnston, M.: 1992, 'Constitution Is Not Identity', Mind 101, 89โ105.
Koslicki, K.: 1995, Talk about Stuffs and Things: The Logic of Mass and Count Nouns, unpubl. Ph.D. Thesis, MIT.
Koslicki, K.: 1997a, 'The Semantics of Mass-Predicates', unpubl. manuscript.
Koslicki, K.: 1997b, 'Homogeneity and the Problem of Minimal Parts', unpubl. manuscript.
Landman, F.: 1991, Structures for Semantics, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, Holland.
Laycock, H.: 1972, 'Some Questions of Ontology', Philosophical Review 81, 3โ42.
Laycock, H.: 1975, 'Theories of Matter', Synthese 31, 411โ42.
Leonard, H. S. and N. Goodman: 1940, 'The Calculus of Individuals and Its Uses', Journal of Symbolic Logic 5, 45โ55.
Link, G: 1983, 'The Logical Analysis of Plurals and Mass Terms: A Lattice-Theoretical Approach', in R. Bรคuerle et al. (eds.), Meaning, Use and Interpretation of Language, De Gruyter, Berlin, pp. 302โ23.
Lรธnning, J. T.: 1987, 'Mass Terms and Quantification', Linguistics and Philosophy 10, 1โ52.
Moravcsik, J.: 1973, 'Mass Terms in English', in J. Hintikka et al. (eds.), Approaches to Natural Language, D. Reidel Publishing Co., Dordrecht, Holland, pp. 263โ85.
Pelletier, F. J.: 1975, 'Non-Singular Reference: Some Preliminaries', Philosophia 5, 451โ65.
Pelletier, F. J. (ed.): 1979, Mass Terms: Some Philosophical Problems, D. Reidel Publishing Co., Dordrecht, Holland.
Pelletier, F. J. and L.K. Schubert: 1989, 'Mass Expressions', in D. Gabbay and F. Guenthner (eds.), Handbook of Philosophical Logic, D. Reidel Publishing Co., Dordrecht, Holland, pp. 327โ407.
Quine, W. v. O.: 1960, Word and Object, M.I.T. Press, Cambridge, MA.
Roeper, P.: 1983, 'Semantics for Mass Terms with Quantifiers', Nous 17, 251โ65.
ter Meulen, A.: 1981, 'An Intensional Logic for Mass Terms', Philosophical Studies 40, 105โ25.
Sharvy, R.: 1978, 'Maybe English Has No Count Nouns: Notes on Chinese Semantics; An Essay in Metaphysics and Linguistics', Studies in Language 2, 345โ65.
Sharvy, R.: 1979, 'The Indeterminacy of Mass Predication', in Francis Jeffry Pelletier (ed.), Mass Terms: Some Philosophical Problems, D. Reidel Publishing Co., Dordrecht, Holland, pp. 47โ61.
Simons, P.: 1982, 'Three Essays in Formal Ontology', in Barry Smith (ed.), Parts and Moments, Studies in Logic and Formal Ontology, Philosophia Verlag, Munich, pp. 111โ260.
Stalnaker, R.: 1988, 'Vague Identity', in D. F. Austin (ed.), Philosophical Analysis, Kluwer, Dordrecht, pp. 349โ60.
Stone, J.: 1987, โWhy Potentiality Mattersโ, Canadian Journal of Philosophy 17, 815โ30.
Strawson, P. F.: 1953/54, 'Particular and General', Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society LIV, 233โ60.
Ware, R. X.: 1975, 'Some Bits and Pieces', Synthese 31, 379โ93.
Wiggins, D.: 1980, Sameness and Substance, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
Williamson, T.: 1994, Vagueness, Routledge, London.
Zimmerman, D.W.: 1995, 'Theories of Masses and Problems of Constitution', Philosophical Review 104, 53โ110.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Koslicki, K. Isolation and Non-Arbitrary Division: Frege's Two Criteria for Counting. Synthese 112, 403โ430 (1997). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1004903625876
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1004903625876
Keywords
- Internal Structure
- Compositional Structure
- Discrete Unit
- Conceptual Boundary