Abstract
The debate on the origins of modern humans is one of the oldest and most controversial in the field of palaeoanthropology. In the 1860s the debate was established in the evolutionary context and, as a conflict between two major schools and various sub-schools, it has continued up until the present day. The opposing schools were and still are, at best, in only partial alignment on the major scientific issues. Each of them is founded in its own metaphysics and focuses on an exclusive set of observations that it is capable of explaining. It would appear, therefore, that the history and present state of modern human origins research may be interpreted, in terms of Kuhn's philosophy of science, as an example of a pre-paradigm scientific dispute. This interpretation shows the immaturity of modern human origins research and calls for the re-examination of palaeoanthropology's basic theoretical propositions as well as of this sciencie's controversial relationship with the society.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
REFERENCES
Barkan, E. (1992). The retreat of scientific racism. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Brace, C. L. (1981). Tales of phylogenetic woods: the evolution and significance of evolutionary trees. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 56: 411–429.
Cann, R. L., M. Stoneking, and A. C. Wilson (1987). Mitochondrial DNA and human evolution. Nature 325: 31–36.
Clark, G. A. (1988). Some thoughts on the Black skull: an archaeologist's assessment of WT-17000 (A. boisei) and systematics in human paleontology. American Anthropologist 90: 357–371.
Coon, C. S. (1962). The Origin of Races. New York, Knopf.
Coon, C. S. (1982). Racial adaptations. Chicago, Nelson-Hall.
Deniker, J. (1900). The races of man. London, Walter Scott.
Fayerabend, P. (1975). How to defend society against science. Radical Philosophy 2: 5–14.
Frayer D. W., M. H. Wolpoff, F. H. Smith and G. G. Pope (1993). Theories of modern human origins: the paleontological test. American Anthropologist 95: 14–50.
Keith, A. (1948). Theory of human evolution. London, Watts & Co.
Krings, S. M., M. Stone, R. W. Schmitz, H. Krainitzki, M. Stoneking, and S. Paabo (1997). Neandertal DNA sequences and the origin of modern humans. Cell 90: 19–30.
Kuhn, T. (1970). The structure of scientific revolutions. 2nd edn. Chicago, University of Chicago Press.
Landau, M. (1984). Human evolution as narrative. American Scientist 72: 262–267.
Landau, M. (1991). Narratives of human evolution. New Haven and London, Yale University Press.
Myers, J. L. (1916). The Influence of politics on the course of political science. Berkeley, University of California Press.
Parusnikova, Z. (1992). Is a postmodern philosophy of science possible? Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 23: 21–37.
Reynolds, T. L. and L. Lieberman (eds.) (1996). Race and other misadventures: essays in honour of Ashley Montagu. Dix Hills, General Hall.
Shipman, P. (1994). The evolution of racism: human differences and the use and abuse of science. New York, Simon and Schuster.
Shreeve, J. (1995). The Neandertal enigma: solving the mystery of human origins. New York, William Morrow.
Slotkin, J. S. (1965). Readings in early anthropology. Viking Found Publications in Anthropology, 40. New York, Wenner-Gren Foundation for Anthropological Research.
Smith, S. L. and F. B. Harrold (1997). A paradigm's worth of difference? Understanding the impasse over modern human origins. Yearbook of Physical Anthropology 40: 113–134.
Stringer, C. B. (1989). The origin of early modern humans: a comparison of the European and non-European evidence. In: P. Mellars and C. Stringer (eds.): The human revolution: behaviourial and biological perspectives on the origins of modern humans. Edinburgh, Edinburgh University Press, pp. 232–244.
Stringer, C. B. (1992). Replacement, continuity and the origin of Homo sapiens. In: G. Brauer and F. H. Smith (eds.): Continuity or replacement: controversies in Homo sapiens evolution. Brookfield, A. A. Balkema, pp. 9–24.
Stringer, C. B. (1993). Reconstructing recent human evolution. In: M. J. Aitken, C. B. Stringer and P. A. Mellars (eds.): The origins of modern humans and the impact of chronometric dating. Princeton, Princeton University Press, pp. 179–195.
Stringer, C. B. (1994). Out of Africa — a personal history. In: M. H. Nitecki and D. V. Nitecki (eds.): Origins of anatomically modern humans. New York, Plenum, pp. 149–172.
Stringer, C. B. (1995). The evolution and dispersal of Later Pleistocene human populations. In: E. Vrba, G. H. Denton, T. C. Partridge and L. H. Burckle (eds.): Paleoclimate and evolution with special reference to human origins. New Haven, Yale University Press, pp. 534–532.
Stringer, C. B. and P. Andrews (1988). Genetic and fossil evidence for the origin of modern humans. Science 239: 1263–1268.
Strkalj. G. (1998). Where was Raymond Dart wrong? African Studies 5: 107–111.
Tattersall, I. (1995). The fossil trail. Oxford, Oxford University Press.
Thorne, A. G. and M. H. Wolpoff (1981). Regional continuity in Australasian Pleistocene hominid evolution. American. Journal of Physical Anthropology 55: 337–350.
Ward, R. and C. B. Stringer (1997). A molecular handle on the Neanderthals. Nature 388: 225–226.
Wallace, A. R. (1864). The origin of human races and the antiquity of man deduced from the theory of “natural selection”. Anthropological Review II: clviii–clxxxvii
Wallace, A. R. (1891). Natural selection and tropical nature. London, Macmilland and Co.
Weidenreich, F. (1947). The trend of human evolution. Evolution 1: 221–236.
Willermet, C. M. and G. A. Clark (1995). Paradigm crisis in modern human origins research. Journal of Human Evolution 29: 487–490.
Wolpoff, M. H. (1989). Multiregional evolution: the fossil alternative to Eden. In: P. Mellars and C. Stringer (eds.): The human revolution: behaviourial and biological perspectives on the origins of modern humans. Edinburgh, Edinburgh University Press. pp. 62–108.
Wolpoff, M. H. (1992). Theories of modern human origins. In: G. Brauer and F. H. Smith (eds.): Continuity or replacement: controversies in Homo sapiens evolution. Brookfield, A. A. Balkema, pp. 9–24.
Wolpoff, M. H., Wu Xinzhi and A. G. Torne (1984). Modern Homo sapiens origins: a general theory of hominid evolution involving the fossil evidence from East Asia. In: F. H. Smith and F. Spencer (eds.): The origins of modern humans: a world survey of the fossil evidence. New York, Alan R. Liss, pp. 411–483.
Wolpoff, M. H., A. G. Thorne, F. H. Smith, D. W. Frayer and G. G. Pope (1994). Multiregional evolution: a worldwide source for modern human populations. In: M. H. Nitecki and D. V. Nitecki (eds.): Origins of anatomically modern humans. New York, Plenum, pp. 175–199.
Wolpoff, M. H. and Caspari R. (1996). Race and human evolution: a fatal attraction. New York, Simon and Schuster.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Strkalj, G. The Conflict of Pre-Paradigm Schools in Modern Human Origins Research. Acta Biotheor 48, 65–71 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1002611919680
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1002611919680