Abstract
This paper investigates the interface between philosophy and biochemistry. While it is problematic to justify the application of a particular philosophical model to biochemistry, it seems to be even more difficult to develop a special “Philosophy for Biochemistry”. Alternatively, philosophy can be used in biochemistry based on an alternative approach that involves an interdependent iteration process at a philosophical and (bio)chemical level (“Exeter Method”). This useful iteration method supplements more abstract approaches at the interface between philosophy and natural sciences, and serves the biochemical community to systematically locate logical inconsistencies that arise from more theoretical aspects of the scientific process. Initial cycles of this iteration process identify the in vitro–in vivo problem as a central epistemological difficulty in biochemical research. While previous attempts have generated ad hoc rules to mend the gap between chemistry, biochemistry and biology in order to justify in vitro experimentation, this paper concludes that in vitro experimentation is heavily based on chemistry and cannot derive definite statements about biological processes. It can, however, generate results that will influence the direction of future biological research. The consequence is that the relationship between in vitro and in vivo experimentation is more of a psychological or social one than of a logical nature. Apart from highlighting these inconsistencies in biochemical thinking (“problem awareness”), the Exeter Method demands an improvement of biochemical terminology that contains separate and unequivocally defined terms for in vitro and in vivo systems.
Similar content being viewed by others
REFERENCES
F.M. Akeroyd. Popper and the Biochemical Sciences. In N. Psarros and K. Gavroglu (Eds.), Ars Mutandi – Issues in Philosophy and History of Chemistry, pp. 1–5. Leipzig: Leipziger Universitätsverlag, 1999.
F.M. Akeroyd. Fuzzy Model. Hyle 6: 161–173, 2000.
G.E. Arteel, S. Franken, J. Kappler and H. Sies. Binding of Selenoprotein P to Heparin: Characterization with Surface Plasmon Resonance. Biological Chemstry 381: 265–268, 2000.
J.H. Beattie, A.M. Wood, A.M. Newman, I. Bremner, K.H. Choo, A.E. Michalska, J.S. Duncan and P. Trayhurn. Obesity and Hyperleptinemia in Metallothionein (-I and-II) Null Mice. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 95: 358–363, 1998.
B. Bensaude-Vincent and I. Stengers. A History of Chemistry. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1996.
J.R. Brown. Scientific Rationality: The Sociological Turn. Dordrecht: Reidel, 1984.
E.H. Fischer and E.W. Davie. Recent Excitement Regarding Metallothionein. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 95: 3333–3334, 1998.
R.J. Good. Why are Chemists ‘Turned Off’ by Philosophy of Science? Foundations of Chemistry 1: 185–215, 1999.
M. Gutmann and G. Hanekamp. Abstraction and Ideation – the Semantics of Chemical and Biological Fundamental Concepts. Journal of General Philosophy of Science 27: 29–53, 1996.
D. Hartmann. Protoscience and Reconstruction. Journal of General Philosophy of Science 27: 55–69, 1996.
S. Holmes. Henderson's Dictionary of Biological Terms. London: Longman, 1979.
J. Hudson. The History of Chemistry. New York: Chapman &;; Hall, 1992.
D.L. Hull and M. Ruse (Ed.). The Philosophy of Biology. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1998.
C. Jacob. Protochemie – die konstruktivistische Grundlegung der Chemie (M.A. thesis). Hagen: University of Hagen, 1998a.
C. Jacob, W. Maret and B.L. Vallee. Control of Zinc Transfer between Thionein, Metallothionein and Zinc Proteins. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 95: 3489–3494, 1998b.
C. Jacob. 4th Summer Symposium on the Philosophy of Chemistry and Biochemistry. The Exeter Theory – an Iterative Meta-Theory of Chemistry, Poznań, Poland, 7–10th of August 2000.
L.J. Jiang, W. Maret and B.L. Vallee. The ATP-metallothionein Complex. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 95: 9146–9149, 1998.
I. Lakatos and A. Musgrave. Criticism and the Growth of Knowledge. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1970.
A.L. Lehninger. Biochemistry. New York: Worth Publishers Inc., 1979.
J. Liu, Y. Liu, S.S. Habeebu and C.D. Klaassen. Metallothionein-null Mice are Highly Susceptible to the Hematotoxic and Immunotoxic Effects of Chronic CdCl2 Exposure. Toxicology and Applied Pharmacology: 98–108, 1999.
W. Maret and B.L. Vallee. Thiolate Ligands in Metallothionein Confer Redox Activity on Zinc Clusters. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 95: 3478–3482, 1998.
L. McIntyre. The Emergence of the Philosophy of Chemistry. Foundations of Chemistry 1: 57–63, 1999.
D.A. McQuarrie and P.A. Rock. General Chemistry. New York: W.H. Freeman &;; Co., 1987.
R.D. Palmiter. The Elusive Function of Metallothioneins. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 95: 8428–8430, 1998.
N. Psarros. The Constructive Approach to the Philosophy of Chemistry. Epistemologia XVIII: 27–38, 1995.
H.-J. Rheinberger. Towards a History of Epistemic Things. Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1997.
E.R. Scerri. Editorial. Foundations of Chemistry 1: 1–5, 1999.
E. Sober. Philosophy of Biology. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1993.
R. Strand. Towards a Useful Philosophy of Biochemistry: Sketches and Examples. Foundations of Chemistry 1: 271–294, 1999a.
R. Strand. In vitro vs. in vivo: The Problem of Justifying the Biological Relevance of Biochemical Studies. In N. Psarros and K. Gavroglu (Eds.), Ars Mutandi – Issues in Philosophy and History of Chemistry, pp. 145–152. Leipzig: Leipziger Universitätsverlag, 1999b.
R. Strand, R. Fjelland and T. Flatmark. In vivo Interpretation of in vitro Effect Studies with a Detailed Analysis of the Method of in vitro Transcription in Isolated Cell Nuclei. Acta Biotheoretica 44: 1–21, 1996.
L. Stryer. Biochemistry. New York: W.H. Freeman and Company, 1995.
J. van Brakel. On the Neglect of the Philosophy of Chemistry. Foundations of Chemistry 1: 111–174, 1999.
J.B. Vincent. Elucidating a Biological Role for Chromium at a Molecular Level. Accounts of Chemical Research 33: 503–507, 2000.
R.J.P. Williams. The Natural Selection of the Elements. Chemistry in Britain: 42–45, 1996.
I. Wilmut, A.E. Schnieke, J. McWhir, A.J. Kind and K.H. Campbell. Viable Offspring Derived from Fetal and Adult Mammalian Cells. Nature: 810–813, 1997.
K. Zangger, G. Oz and I.M. Armitage. Re-evaluation of the Binding of ATP to Metallothionein. Journal of Biological Chemistry 275: 7534–7538, 2000.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Jacob, C. Philosophy and Biochemistry: Research at the Interface between Chemistry and Biology. Foundations of Chemistry 4, 97–125 (2002). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1016052605025
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1016052605025