Review of Industrial Organization

, Volume 24, Issue 3, pp 301–324 | Cite as

Gibrat's Law: Are the Services Different?

  • D.B. Audretsch
  • L. Klomp
  • E. Santarelli
  • A.R. Thurik


Several noted surveys on intra-industry dynamics have reached the conclusion from a large body of evidence that Gibrat's Law does not hold. However, almost all of these studies have been based on manufacturing or large scale services such as banking and insurance industries. There are compelling reasons to doubt whether these findings hold for small scale services such as the hospitality industries. In this paper we examine whether the basic tenet underlying Gibrat's Law– that growth rates are independent of firm size – can be rejected for the services as it has been for manufacturing. Based on a large sample of Dutch firms in the hospitality industries the evidence suggests that in most cases growth rates are independent of firm size. Validation of Gibrat's Law in some sub-sectors of the small scale services suggests that the dynamics of industrial organization for services may not simply mirror that for manufacturing. The present paper includes a survey of nearly 60 empirical studies on firm growth rates.

Firm growth Gibrat's Law service industries 


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Acs Z. J. and D. B. Audretsch (1990) Innovation and Small Firms. Cambridge, Massachusetts: The MIT Press.Google Scholar
  2. Acs Z. J. and C. Armington (2001) 'Gibrat's Law Reconsidered: The Relationship Between Firm Growth, Establishment Age, Establishment Size and Firm Size', Working Paper of the Regional Entrepreneurship Catalyst Kauffman Center for Entrepreneurial Leadership, Kansas City, MO.Google Scholar
  3. Almus M. and E. A. Nerlinger (2000) 'Testing Gibrat's Law for Young Firms-Empirical Results for West Germany', Small Business Economics, 15, 1–12.Google Scholar
  4. Amaral L. A. N, S. W. Buldyrev, S. Havlin, H. Leschhorn, P. Maass, M. A. Salinger, H. E. Stanley and M. H. R. Stanley (1997), 'Scaling Behavior in Economics: Empirical Results for Company Growth', Journal de Physique I, 7, 621–633.Google Scholar
  5. Amirkhalkhali S. and A. K. Mukhopadhyay (1993) 'The Influence of Size and R&D on the Growth of Firms in the U.S.', Eastern Economic Journal, 19, 223–233.Google Scholar
  6. Audretsch D. B. (1991) 'New Firm Survival and the Technological Regime', Review of Economics and Statistics, 73, 441–450.Google Scholar
  7. Audretsch D. B. (1995) Innovation and Industry Evolution. Cambridge, Massachusetts: The MIT Press.Google Scholar
  8. Audretsch D. B. and T. Mahmood (1994) 'Firm Selection and Industry Evolution: The Post-Entry Performance of New Firms', Journal of Evolutionary Economics, 4, 243–260.Google Scholar
  9. Audretsch D. B. and T. Mahmood (1995) 'New-Firm Survival: New Results Using a Hazard Function', Review of Economics and Statistics, 77, 97–103.Google Scholar
  10. Audretsch D. B., E. Santarelli and M. Vivarelli (1999) 'Start-up Size and Industrial Dynamics: Some Evidence from Italian Manufacturing', International Journal of Industrial Organization, 17, 965–983.Google Scholar
  11. Baldwin J.R. (1995) The Dynamics of Industrial Competition: A North American Perspective. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  12. Baldwin J.R. and M. Rafiquzzaman (1995) 'Selection versus Evolutionary Adaptation: Learning and Post-Entry Performance', International Journal of Industrial Organization, 13, 501–522.Google Scholar
  13. Becchetti, L. and G. Trovato (2002) 'The Determinants of Growth for Small and Medium Sized Firms', Small Business Economics, 19, 291–306.Google Scholar
  14. Bottazzi G., G. Dosi, M. Lippi, F. Pammolli and M. Riccaboni (2001) 'Innovation and Corporate Growth in the Evolution of the Drug Industry', International Journal of Industrial Organization, 19, 1161–1187.Google Scholar
  15. Bourlakis C. A. (1990) 'Probability of Survival and Firm Growth in Greek Manufacturing Industries', Paper Presented at the 17th Annual Conference of the European Association for Research in Industrial Economics (EARIE), mimeo, University of Leeds.Google Scholar
  16. Brock W. A. (1999) 'Scaling in Economics: A Reader's Guide', Industrial and Corporate Change, 8, 409–446.Google Scholar
  17. Buckley P.J., J.H. Dunning and R.D. Pearce (1984) 'An Analysis of the Growth and Profitability of the World's Largest Firms 1972-1977', Kyklos, 37, 3–26.Google Scholar
  18. Cabral L. (1995) 'Sunk Costs, Firm Size and Firm Growth', Journal of Industrial Economics, 43, 161–172.Google Scholar
  19. Cabral L. and J. Mata (2003) 'On the Evolution of the Firm Size Distribution: Facts and Theory', American Economic Review, 93, 1075–1091.Google Scholar
  20. Carree M. and A.R. Thurik (1991) 'Recent Developments in the Dutch Firm-Size Distribution', Small Business Economics, 3, 261–268.Google Scholar
  21. Caves R. E. (1998) 'Industrial Organization and New Findings on the Turnover and Mobility of Firms', Journal of Economic Literature, 36, 1947–1983.Google Scholar
  22. Chen J-R and W-C. Lu (2003) 'Panel Unit Root Tests of Firm Size and its Growth', Applied Economics Letters, 10, 343–345.Google Scholar
  23. Chesher A. (1979) 'Testing the Law of Proportionate Effect', Journal of Industrial Economics, 27, 403–411.Google Scholar
  24. Comanor W.S. and T.A. Wilson (1967) 'Advertising, Market Structure, and Performance', Review of Economics and Statistics, 49, 423–440.Google Scholar
  25. Contini B. and R. Revelli (1989) 'The Relationship between Firm Growth and Labor Demand', Small Business Economics, 1, 309–314.Google Scholar
  26. Cooley T. and V. Quadrini (2001) 'Financial Markets and Firm Dynamics', American Economic Review, 91, 1286–1310.Google Scholar
  27. Delmar F., P. Davidsson and W. B. Gartner (2003) 'Arriving at the High-growth Firm', Journal of Business Venturing, 18, 189–216.Google Scholar
  28. Del Monte A. and E. Papagni (2003) 'R & D and the Growth of Firms. An Empirical Analysis of a Panel of Italian Firms', Research Policy, 32, 1003–1014.Google Scholar
  29. Doms M., T. Dunne and M.J. Roberts (1995) 'The Role of Technology Use in the Survival and Growth of Manufacturing Plants', International Journal of Industrial Organization, 13, 523–542.Google Scholar
  30. Droucopoulos V. (1983) 'International Big Business Revisited: On the Size and Growth of the World's Largest Firms', Managerial and Decision Economics, 4, 244–252.Google Scholar
  31. Dunne P. and A. Hughes (1994) 'Age, Size, Growth and Survival: UK Companies in the 1980s', Journal of Industrial Economics, 42, 115–140.Google Scholar
  32. Dunne T., M.J. Roberts and L. Samuelson (1988) 'Patterns of Firm Entry and Exit in US Manufacturing Industries', Rand Journal of Economics, 19, 495–515.Google Scholar
  33. Dunne T., M. J. Roberts and L. Samuelson (1989) 'The Growth and Failure of US Manufacturing Plants', Quarterly Journal of Economics, 104, 671–698.Google Scholar
  34. Evangelista R. (2000) 'Innovation and Employment in Services. Results from the Italian Innovation Survey', in M. Vivarelli and M. Pianta eds., The Employment Impact of Innovation. Evidence and Policy. New York: Routledge,PP 121–148.Google Scholar
  35. Evans D. S. (1987a) 'The Relationship between Firm Growth, Size, and Age: Estimates for 100 Manufacturing Industries', Journal of Industrial Economics, 35, 567–581.Google Scholar
  36. Evans D. S. (1987b) 'Tests of Alternative Theories of Firm Growth', Journal of Political Economy, 95, 657–674.Google Scholar
  37. Faggio G. and J. Konings (2003) 'Job Creation, Job Destruction and Employment Growth in Transition Countries in the 90s', Economic Systems, 27, 129–154.Google Scholar
  38. Fariñ as J.C. and L. Moreno (2000) 'Firms' Growth, Size and Age: A Nonparametric Approach', Review of Industrial Organization, 17, 249–265.Google Scholar
  39. FitzRoy F.R. and K. Kraft (1991) 'Firm Size, Growth and Innovation: Some Evidence from West Germany', in Z.J. Acs and D.B. Audretsch eds., Innovation and Technological Change: An International Comparison. London: Harvester Wheatsheaf, 152–159.Google Scholar
  40. Fotopoulos G. and H. Louri (2001) 'Corporate Growth and FDI: Are Multinationals Stimulating Local Industrial Development?', CEPR Discussion Paper Series, No. 3128.Google Scholar
  41. Gallagher C.C., M.J. Daly and J.C. Thomason (1991) 'The Growth of UK Companies and Their Contribution to Job Generation, 1985-1987', Small Business Economics, 3, 269–286.Google Scholar
  42. Geroski P.A. (1995) 'What Do We Know About Entry?', International Journal of Industrial Organization, 13, 421–440.Google Scholar
  43. Geroski P.A. and S. Machin (1993) 'Innovation, Profitability and Growth over the Business Cycle', Empirica, 20, 35–50.Google Scholar
  44. Geroski P.A., S. Lazarova, G. Urga and C.F. Walters (2003) 'Are Differences in Firm Size Transitory or Permanent?', Journal of Applied Econometrics, 18, 47–59.Google Scholar
  45. Ghosal V. (2001) 'The Impact of Uncertainty and Sunk Costs on Firm and Industry Dynamics', Paper Presented at the 5th EUNIP Conference, Vienna, November 29th-December 1st.Google Scholar
  46. Gibrat R. (1931) Les Inégalités Économiques. Paris: Librairie du Recueil Sirey.Google Scholar
  47. Goddard, J., J. Wilson and P. Blandon (2002) 'Panel Tests of Gibrat's Law for Japanese Manufacturing', International Journal of Industrial Organization, 20, 415–433.Google Scholar
  48. Hall B.H. (1987) 'The Relationship between Firm Size and Firm Growth in the US Manufacturing Sector', Journal of Industrial Economics, 35, 583–606.Google Scholar
  49. Hamilton L. (1998) Statistics with Stata 5. Pacific Grove (CA): Duxbury Press.Google Scholar
  50. Hardwick P. and M. Adams (2002) 'Firm Size and Growth in the United Kingdom Life Insurance Industry', Journal of Risk and Insurance, 69, 577–593.Google Scholar
  51. Harhoff D., K. Stahl and M. Woywode (1998) 'Legal form, Growth and Exit of West German Firms-Empirical Results for Manufacturing, Construction, Trade and Service Industries', Journal of Industrial Economics, 46, 453–488.Google Scholar
  52. Hart P.E. (1962) 'The Size and Growth of Firms', Economica, 29, 29–39.Google Scholar
  53. Hart P.E. and S.J. Prais (1956) 'The Analysis of Business Concentration: A Statistical Approach', Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, 119 (part2,series A), 150–191.Google Scholar
  54. Hart P.E. (2000) 'Theories of Firms' Growth and the Generation of Jobs', Review of Industrial Organization, 17, 229–248.Google Scholar
  55. Hart P.E. and N. Oulton (1999) 'Gibrat, Galton and Job Generation', International Journal of the Economics of Business, 6, 149–164.Google Scholar
  56. Heckman J. J. (1979) 'Sample Selection Bias as a Specification Error', Econometrica, 47, 153–161.Google Scholar
  57. Heshmati A. (2001) 'On the Growth of Micro and Small Firms: Evidence from Sweden', Small Business Economics, 17, 213–228.Google Scholar
  58. Hymer S. and P. Pashigian (1962) 'Firm Size and Rate of Growth', Journal of Political Economy, 70, 556–569.Google Scholar
  59. Keating G. R. (1974) 'Gibrat's Law and the Growth of Firms', Australian Economic Papers, 13, 281–287.Google Scholar
  60. Ijiri Y. and H.A. Simon (1977) Skew Distributions and the Sizes of Business Firms. Amsterdam: North Holland.Google Scholar
  61. Im K.S.,M.H. Pesaran and Y. Shin (1995) 'Testing for Unit Roots in Heterogeneous Panels', University of Cambridge, Department of Applied Economics Working Paper, Amalgamated Series: 9526, June.Google Scholar
  62. Kumar M .S. (1985) ‘Growth, Acquisition Activity and Firm Size: Evidence from the United Kingdom’, Journal of Industrial Economics, 33, 327-338.Google Scholar
  63. Lensink R., P. van Steen and E. Sterken (2000) 'Uncertainty and Growth of the Firm', CCSO Centre for Economic Research, University of Groningen, Working Paper No. 200014.Google Scholar
  64. Lotti F., E. Santarelli and M. Vivarelli (2001) 'The Relationship between Size and Growth: The Case of Italian New-born Firms', Applied Economics Letters, 8, 451–454.Google Scholar
  65. Lotti F., E. Santarelli and M. Vivarelli (2003) 'Does Gibrat's Law Hold among Young, Small Firms?' Journal of Evolutionary Economics, 14, 213–235.Google Scholar
  66. Machado J.A.F. and J. Mata (2000) 'Box-Cox Quantile Regression and the Distribution of Firm Sizes', Journal of Applied Econometrics, 15, 253–274.Google Scholar
  67. Maddala G. and S. Wu (1999) 'A Comparative Study of Unit Root Tests with Panel Data and a New Simple Test', Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 61, 1399–1416.Google Scholar
  68. Mahmood T. (1992) 'Does the Hazard Rate of New Plants Vary Between High-and Low-Tech Industries?' Small Business Economics, 4, 201–210.Google Scholar
  69. Malinvaud E. (1980) Statistical Methods of Econometrics, 3rd edn. Amsterdam: North Holland.Google Scholar
  70. Mansfield E. (1962) 'Entry, Gibrat's Law, Innovation, and the Growth of Firms', American Economic Review, 52, 1023–1051.Google Scholar
  71. Marquardt D.W. (1963) 'An Algorithm for Least Squares Estimation of Non-Linear Parameters', Journal of the Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics, 11, 431–441.Google Scholar
  72. Mata J. (1994) 'Firm Growth During Infancy', Small Business Economics, 6, 27–39.Google Scholar
  73. Mata J. and P. Portugal (1994) 'Life Duration of New Firms', Journal of Industrial Economics, 42, 227–246.Google Scholar
  74. Mata J., P. Portugal and P. Guimaraes (1995) 'The Survival of New Plants: Start-up Conditions and Post-Entry Evolution', International Journal of Industrial Organization, 13, 459–482.Google Scholar
  75. McCloughan P. (1995) 'Modified Gibrat Growth, Entry, Exit and Concentration Development', Journal of Industrial Economics, 43, 405–433.Google Scholar
  76. Nelson R.R. and S.G. Winter (1982) An Evolutionary Theory of Economic Change. Cambridge Massachusetts: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
  77. Pfaffermayr M. and C. Bellak (2000) 'Why Foreign-owned Firms are Different: A Conceptual Framework and Empirical Evidence for Austria', Hamburg Institute of International Economics, Discussion Paper No. 115.Google Scholar
  78. Phillips B.D. and B.A. Kirchhoff (1989) 'Formation, Growth and Survival; Small Firm Dynamics in the US Economy', Small Business Economics, 1, 65–74.Google Scholar
  79. Piergiovanni, R., E. Santarelli, L. Klomp and A. R. Thurik (2003) 'Gibrat's Law and the Firm Size/Firm Growth Relationship in Italian Services', Revue d'Economie Industrielle, 102, 69–82.Google Scholar
  80. Prais S.J. (1976) The Evolution of Giant Firms in Britain. London: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  81. Prescott E. and M. Visscher (1980) 'Organization Capital', Journal of Political Economy, 88, 446–461.Google Scholar
  82. Quandt R.E. (1966) 'On the Size Distribution of Firms', American Economic Review, 56, 416–432.Google Scholar
  83. Reid G. (1995) 'Early Life-Cycle Behaviour of Micro-Firms in Scotland', Small Business Economics, 7, 89–95.Google Scholar
  84. Ritzen J.H.G. and H. P. M. M. Van der Ven (1990) 'Demography of Firms, Business Registers and Cohort Analyses', Netherlands Official Statistics, 5(1), 4–16.Google Scholar
  85. Samuels J.M. (1965) 'Size and Growth of Firms', Review of Economic Studies, 32, 105–112.Google Scholar
  86. Santarelli E. (1997) '—La relazione tra dimensione iniziale, sopravvivenza e crescita delle imprese nel settore turistico in Italia', Statistica, 57, 125–138.Google Scholar
  87. Scherer F.M. (1980) Industrial Market Structure and Economic Performance, 2nd edn. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company.Google Scholar
  88. Scherer F.M. and D. Ross (1990) Industrial Market Structure and Economic Performance, 3rd edn. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company.Google Scholar
  89. Schmalensee R. (1989) 'Inter-Industry Studies of Structure and Performance', in R. Schmalensee and R.D. Willig eds. Handbook of Industrial Organization, Vol. 2. Amsterdam: North Holland, 951–1009.Google Scholar
  90. Simon H. A. and C. P. Bonini (1958) 'The Size Distribution of Business Firms', American Economic Review, 48, 607–617.Google Scholar
  91. Singh A. and G. Whittington (1975) 'The Size and Growth of Firms', Review of Economic Studies, 42, 15–26.Google Scholar
  92. Sutton J. (1997) 'Gibrat's Legacy', Journal of Economic Literature, 35, 40–59.Google Scholar
  93. Sutton J. (1998) Technology and Market Structure: Theory and History. Cambridge and London, MIT Press.Google Scholar
  94. Tschoegl A. (1996) 'Managerial Dis(economies) of Scale: The Case of Regional Banks in Japan', Reginald H. Jones Center for Management and Policy, Strategy and Organization, The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania, Working Paper No. 96-04.Google Scholar
  95. Vander Vennet R. (2001) 'The Law of Proportionate Effect and OECD Bank Sectors', Applied Economics, 33, 539–546.Google Scholar
  96. Variyam J. N. and D. S. Kraybill (1992) 'Empirical Evidence on Determinants of Firm Growth', Economics Letters, 38, 31–36.Google Scholar
  97. Wagner J. (1992) 'Firm Size, Firm Growth, and Persistence of Chance: Testing Gibrat's Law with Establishment Data from Lower Saxony', 1978-1989, Small Business Economics, 4, 125–131.Google Scholar
  98. Wagner J. (1994) 'The Post-Entry Performance of New Small Firms in German Manufacturing Industries', Journal of Industrial Economics, 42, 141–154.Google Scholar
  99. Willeboordse A. J. (1986) 'Towards a 'Demography' of Firms', Netherlands Official Statistics, 1(2), 5–11.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2004

Authors and Affiliations

  • D.B. Audretsch
    • 1
    • 2
    • 3
    • 4
  • L. Klomp
    • 5
  • E. Santarelli
    • 6
    • 2
    • 7
  • A.R. Thurik
    • 8
    • 9
  1. 1.Institute for Development StrategiesIndiana UniversityUSA
  2. 2.Max Planck Institute for EntrepreneurshipGrowth and Public PolicyJena
  3. 3.Centre for Economic Policy Research (CEPR)London;
  4. 4.EIM Business and Policy ResearchZoetermeer
  5. 5.DG for InnovationMinistry of Economic AffairsThe Hague
  6. 6.Department of EconomicsUniversity of BolognaItaly
  7. 7.ENCOREAmsterdam
  8. 8.Centre for Advanced Small Business Economics (CASBEC)Jena
  9. 9.Centre for Advanced Small Business Economics, Rotterdam School of EconomicsErasmus University RotterdamRotterdamThe Netherlands

Personalised recommendations