Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics

, Volume 25, Issue 3, pp 171–198 | Cite as

Depression in the Context of Disability and the “Right to Die”

  • Carol J. Gill


Arguments in favor of legalized assisted suicide often center on issues of personal privacy and freedom of choice over one's body. Many disability advocates assert, however, that autonomy arguments neglect the complex sociopolitical determinants of despair for people with disabilities. Specifically, they argue that social approval of suicide for individuals with irreversible conditions is discriminatory and that relaxing restrictions on assisted suicide would jeopardize, not advance, the freedom of persons with disabilities to direct the lives they choose. This paper examines the idea promoted by some proponents of assisted suicide that it is reasonable to be depressed about one's diminished quality of life in cases of irreversible illness or disability and, therefore, such depression should not call into question the individual's competence to request assistance in dying. The concept of rational depression is defined and examined in the context of: four real-life cases involving individuals with disabilities who requested assistance in dying; a set of criteria commonly applied to decision-making to determine rationality; and research bearing on the emotional status of people with disabilities. It is concluded that although disability is associated with particular socially mediated stressors, there is no theoretical or empirical evidence to indicate that depression and its role in the “right to die” is dynamically different, more natural, or more reasonable for disabled people than for non-disabled people.

assisted dying assisted suicide competence depression disability medical decision-making quality of life rational suicide right to die 


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Bach, C. A. and R.W. McDaniel. ''Quality of Life in Quadriplegic Adults: A Focus Group Study.'' Rehabilitation Nursing 18 (1993): 364–367.Google Scholar
  2. Bach, J.R., and M.C. Tilton. ''Life Satisfaction and Well-Being Measures in Ventilator Assisted Individuals with Traumatic Tetraplegia.'' Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, 75 (1994): 626–632.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Baron, C.H. et al. ''A Model Statute to Authorize and Regulate Physician-Assisted Suicide.'' Harvard Journal of Legislation 33 (1996): 1–34.Google Scholar
  4. Basnett, I. ''Will to Live Wins over the Right to Die.'' The Observer, April 16, 2004.,6903,673011,00.html.Google Scholar
  5. Bay, E. et al. ''Chronic Stress, Sense of Belonging, and Depression Among Survivors of Traumatic Brain Injury.'' Journal of Nursing Scholarship 34 (2002): 221–226.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Breitbart, W. et al. ''Depression, Hopelessness, and Desire for Hastened Death in Terminally Ill Patients with Cancer.'' Journal of the American Medical Association 284 (2000): 2907–2911.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Brown, S. L., and A. D. Vinokur. ''The Interplay Among Risk Factors for Suicidal Ideation and Suicide: The Role of Depression, Poor Health, and Loved Ones' Messages of Support and Criticism.'' American Journal of Community Psychology 32 (2003): 131–141.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Burt, R.A. ''Misguided Guidelines.'' Psychology, Public Policy and Law 6 (2000): 382–387. Chicago Tribune, 22 February 1990.Google Scholar
  9. Chin, A. E. et al. ''Legalized Physician-Assisted Suicide In Oregon-The First Year's Experience.'' New England Journal of Medicine 340 (1999): 577–583.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Clark, D.C. '''Rational' Suicide and People with Terminal Conditions or Disabilities.'' Issues in Law and Medicine 8 (1992): 147–166.Google Scholar
  11. Clarke, D.M., and D.W. Kissane. ''Demoralization: Its Phenomenology and Importance.'' Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 36 (2002): 733–742.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Coleman, D. ''Not Dead Yet.'' In The Case Against Assisted Suicide. Edited by H. Hendin and K. Foley. 213–237. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2002.Google Scholar
  13. Conill, A. ''Living with a Disability: A Proposal for Medical Education.'' Journal of the American Medical Association 279 (1998): 83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Conner, K.R., et al. ''Psychological Vulnerability to Completed Suicide: A Review of Empirical Studies.'' Suicide and Life-Threatening Behavior 31 (2001): 367–385.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Craig, A.R., K.M. Hancock, and H.G. Dickson. ''Spinal Cord Injury: A Search for Determinants of Depression Two Years After the Event.'' British Journal of Clinical Psychology 33, Part 2 (1994): 221–230.Google Scholar
  16. Crosse, S.B., E. Kaye, and A.C. Ratnofsky. A Report On The Maltreatment Of Children With Disabilities. Rockville, MD: Westat, Inc., 1993.Google Scholar
  17. Cushman, L.A. and J. Hassett. ''Spinal Cord Injury: 10 and 15 Years After.'' Paraplegia 30 (1992): 690–696.Google Scholar
  18. Dijkers, M. ''Quality of Life after Spinal Cord Injury: A Meta Analysis of the Effects of Disablement Components.'' Spinal Cord 35 (1997): 829–840.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Downing, R.E. et al. ''The Missouri Developmental Disability Resource Center: A Web Site Responding to the Critical Need for Information of Parents with a Child with a Disability.'' Behavior Research Methods, Instruments and Computers 31 (1999): 292–298.Google Scholar
  20. news/story/0,3604,707427,00.html.Google Scholar
  21. Emanuel, E. ''Whose Right to Die?'' Atlantic Monthly 279/3 (1997): 73–79.Google Scholar
  22. Emanuel, E. J., et al. ''The Practice of Euthanasia and Physician-Assisted Suicide in the United States: Adherence to Proposed Safeguards and Effects on Physicians.'' Journal of the American Medical Association 280 (1998): 507–513.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Feinstein, A. ''An Examination of Suicidal Intent in Patients with Multiple Sclerosis.'' Neurology 59 (2002): 674–678.Google Scholar
  24. Fuhrer, M.J., et al. ''Relationship of Life Satisfaction to Impairment, Disability, and Handicap Among Persons with Spinal Cord Injury Living in the Community.'' Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 73 (1992): 552–557.Google Scholar
  25. Frank, L., et al. ''Measurement of Advance Directive and Medical Treatment Decision-Making Capacity of Older Adults.'' Journal of Mental Health and Aging 5 (1999): 257–274.Google Scholar
  26. Gallagher-Thompson, D., and N. J. Osgood. ''Suicide in Later Life.'' Behavior Therapy 28(1997): 23–41.Google Scholar
  27. Gill, C.J. ''The False Autonomy of Forced Choice: Rationalizing Suicide for Persons with Disabilities.'' In Contemporary Perspectives on Rational Suicide. Edited by J. L. Werth. 177–180. Series in Death, Dying, and Bereavement. Edited by J. L. Werth. Philadelphia, PA: Brunner/Mazel, Inc., 1998.Google Scholar
  28. Gill, C.J. ''Health Professionals, Disability, and Assisted Suicide: An Examination of Relevant Empirical Evidence and Reply to Batavia.'' Psychology, Public Policy and Law 6 (2000): 526–545.Google Scholar
  29. Girsh, F. ''Mercy Killing: A Position Statement Regarding David Rodriguez.'' Issues in Law and Medicine 13 (1997): 341–343.Google Scholar
  30. Glover, A. ''An Exploration of the Extent to which Attending Headway Enhances Quality of Life after Traumatic Brain Injury.'' Disability and Rehabilitation 25 (2003): 750–760.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Goldney, R.D. ''Depression and Suicidal Behavior: The Real Estate Analogy.'' Crisis: The Journal of Crisis Intervention and Suicide Prevention 24 (2003): 87–88.Google Scholar
  32. Grimes, A.L., et al. ''Informed Consent and Neuroanatomic Correlates of Intentionality and Voluntariness among Psychiatric Patients.'' Psychiatric Services 51 (2000): 1561–1567.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Groenewoud, J.H., et al. ''Physician-Assisted Death in Psychiatric Patients in the Netherlands.'' New England Journal of Medicine 336 (1997): 1795–1801.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Hardwig, J. ''Is There a Duty to Die?'' Hastings Center Report 27/2 (1997): 34–42.Google Scholar
  35. Harris, B. ''Mom Freed In Mercy Killing.'' Spokesman-Review, 10 January 1996.Google Scholar
  36. Hasbrouck, A.E. ''Misplaced Mercy.'' March 15, 2004. mismercy.htm.Google Scholar
  37. Hearn, L. ''It's More of a Struggle to Live than Die.'' Chicago Tribune, 8 February 1984, Section 5.Google Scholar
  38. Hendin, H. Seduced By Death: Doctors, Patients, And The Dutch Cure. New York: W.W. Norton & Co., 1997.Google Scholar
  39. Herr, S.S., B.A. Bostrom, and R.S. Barton. ''No Place to Go: Refusal of Life-Sustaining Treatment by Competent Persons with Physical Disabilities.'' Issues in Law and Medicine 8 (1992): 3–36.Google Scholar
  40. Humphry, D. Final Exit: The Practicalities of Self-Deliverance and Assisted Suicide for the Dying. Eugene, OR: Hemlock Society, 1991.Google Scholar
  41. Iezzoni, L.I. ''When Walking Fails.'' Journal of the American Medical Association 276 (1996): 1609–1613.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Isacsson, G. and C.L. Rich. ''Getting Closer to Suicide Prevention.'' British Journal of Psychiatry 182 (2003): 457.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Jamison, S. ''Psychology and Rational Suicide: The Special Case of Assisted Dying.'' In Contemporary Perspectives on Rational Suicide. Edited by J. Werth. 292–299. Series in Death, Dying, and Bereavement. Edited by J.L. Werth. Philadelphia, PA: Brunner/Mazel, Inc., 1999.Google Scholar
  44. Johnson, M. ''Unanswered Questions.'' In The Ragged Edge: The Disability Experience from the Pages of the First Fifteen Years of The Disability Rag. Edited by Barrett Shaw. 186–201. Louisville, KY: Advocado Press, 1996.Google Scholar
  45. Johnson, M. ''What's happening to our ADA?'' Ragged Edge Online, April 16, 2004. Scholar
  46. Jurasky, J.A. (1990). Affidavit of J.A. Jurasky, M.D., Bergstedt v. McKay (Nev. Dist. Ct. 1990) (No. A281607).Google Scholar
  47. Kaplan, K. J. et al. ''An Update On The Kevorkian-Reding 93 Physician-Assisted Deaths in Michigan: Is Kevorkian a Savior, Serial-Killer or Suicidal Martyr?'' In Right to Die Versus Sacredness of Life. Edited by K.J. Kaplan. 209–229. Amityville, NY: Baywood Publishing Co, Inc., 2000.Google Scholar
  48. Kennisto, M. and H. Sintonen. ''Later Health Related Quality of Life in Adults who have Sustained Spinal Cord Injury in Childhood.'' Spinal Cord 35 (1997): 747–751.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Kleespies, P. M., D. H. Hughes, and F. P. Gallacher. ''Suicide in the Medically and Terminally Ill: Psychological and Ethical Considerations.'' Journal of Clinical Psychology 56 (2000): 1153–1171.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. LaPlante, M.P. et al. Disability and Employment: Disability Statistics Abstract #11, Washington, DC: National Institute on Disability and Rehabilitation Research, 1996.Google Scholar
  51. Linton, S. Claiming Disability: Knowledge and Identity. New York: New York University Press, 1998.Google Scholar
  52. Longmore, P.K. ''Elizabeth Bouvia, Assisted Suicide, and Social Prejudice.'' Issues in Law and Medicine 3 (1987): 141–170.Google Scholar
  53. Longmore, P. K. ''The Strange Death of David Rivlin.'' Western Journal of Medicine 154 (1991): 355–364.Google Scholar
  54. Longmore, P. K. ''Medical Decision Making and People with Disabilities: A Clash of Cultures.'' Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics 23 (1995): 82–87.Google Scholar
  55. Martyn, S.R. and H.J. Bourguignon. ''Physicians' Decisions about Patient Capacity: The Trojan Horse of Physician-Assisted Suicide.'' Psychology, Public Policy and Law 6 (2000): 388–401.Google Scholar
  56. Masuda, S. SAFETY NET/WORK Community Kit: From Abuse to Suicide Prevention and Women with Disabilities. North Bay, ON: DisAbled Women's Network of Canada, 1996.Google Scholar
  57. McKay v. Bergstedt, 801 P.2d 617, 637 (Nev. 1990).Google Scholar
  58. Michie, S. and T.M. Marteau. ''Genetic Counselling: Some Issues of Theory and Practice.'' In The Troubled Helix: Social and Psychological Implications of the New Human Genetics. Edited by T. Marteau and M. Richards. 104–122. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1996.Google Scholar
  59. Mishara. B. L. ''Synthesis of Research and Evidence on Factors Affecting the Desire of Terminally Ill or Seriously Chronically Ill Persons to Hasten Death.'' Omega-Journal of Death and Dying 39 (1999): 1–70.Google Scholar
  60. Morris, J. Pride Against Prejudice. Philadelphia: New Society Publishers, (1991).Google Scholar
  61. National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS), United States Department of Health and Human Services. ''Current Estimates From the National Health Interview Survey, 1994.'' Vital and Health Statistics, Series 10, No. 193. DHHS Publication No. (PHS) 96-1521, Public Health Service. Washington, DC: United States Government Printing Office, 1995.Google Scholar
  62. Oberman, L. (Executive Producer). (1989, August 6). The Life of David Rivlin, Detroit: WDIV Television.Google Scholar
  63. Oliver, M. Understanding Disability from Theory to Practice. New York: St. Martin's Press, 1996.Google Scholar
  64. Olkin, R. What Psychotherapists Should Know About Disability. New York: The Guilford Press, 1999.Google Scholar
  65. Onwuteaka-Philipsen, B.D., et al. ''Euthanasia and Other End-of-life Decisions in the Netherlands in 1990, 1995 and 2001.'' Lancet 362 (2003): 395–99.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. Oshima, S., et al. ''Assessing the Knowledge of Future Internists and Gynecologists in Caring for a Woman with Tetraplegia.'' Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 79 (1998): 1270–1276.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Peeno, L. ''What is the Value of a Voice?'' US News and World Report, 9 March 1998, 40–46.Google Scholar
  68. Phillips, M.J. ''Damaged Goods: Oral Narratives of the Experience of Disability in American Culture.'' Social Science and Medicine 30 (1990): 849–857.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Quill, T.E., C.K. Cassell, and D.E. Meier. ''Care of the Hopelessly Ill: Proposed Clinical Criteria for Physician-Assisted Suicide.'' New England Journal of Medicine 327 (1992): 1380–1384.Google Scholar
  70. Ray, C. and J. West. ''Social, Sexual and Personal Implications of Paraplegia.'' Paraplegia 22 (1984): 75–86.Google Scholar
  71. Reeve, C. Still Me. New York: Random House, 1998.Google Scholar
  72. Rosenfeld, B. ''Assisted Suicide, Depression, and the Right to Die.'' Psychology, Public Policy and Law 6 (2000): 467–488.Google Scholar
  73. Saxton, M. ''Reclaiming Self-Esteem-Peer Counseling for Disabled Women.'' Western Journal of Medicine 154 (1991): 630–631.Google Scholar
  74. Shapiro, J. No Pity: People with Disabilities Forging a New Civil Rights Movement. New York: Random House, 1993.Google Scholar
  75. Singer, P. Practical Ethics. London: Cambridge University Press, 1993.Google Scholar
  76. Sobsey, D. ''An Illusion of Autonomy: Questioning Physician-Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia.'' Brief submitted to the Special Senate Committee on Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide, Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada, September 30, 1994.Google Scholar
  77. Sullivan, A.D., K. Hedberg, and D.W. Fleming. ''Legalized Physician-Assisted Suicide in Oregon-The Second Year.'' New England Journal of Medicine 342 (2000): 598–604.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  78. van der Maas, P.J., et al. ''Euthanasia and Other Medical Decisions Concerning the End of Life.'' Lancet 338 (1991): 669–674.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  79. van Thiel, G.J. et al. ''Retrospective Study of Doctors' 'End of Life Decisions' in Caring for Mentally Handicapped People in Institutions in the Netherlands.'' British Medical Journal 315 (1997): 88–91.Google Scholar
  80. Vernaci, R.L. ''Disabilities Scary for Many: Survey.'' Nashville Banner, 11 October 1991, Section A.Google Scholar
  81. Viemero, V. and C. Krause. ''Quality of Life in Individuals with Physical Disabilities.'' Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics, 67 (1998): 317–322.Google Scholar
  82. Weinberg, N. ''Physically Disabled People Assess the Quality of their Lives.'' Rehabilitation Literature 45 (1984): 12–15.Google Scholar
  83. Werth, J.L. ''Can Shneidman's 'Ten Commonalities of Suicide' Accommodate Rational Suicide?'' Suicide and Life-Threatening Behavior 26 (1996): 292–299.Google Scholar
  84. Werth, J.L. ''Introduction to the Issue of Rational Suicide.'' In Contemporary Perspectives on Rational Suicide. Edited by J.L. Werth. 1–9. Series in Death, Dying, and Bereavement. Edited by J.L. Werth. Philadelphia, PA: Brunner/Mazel, Inc., 1999.Google Scholar
  85. Werth, J.L., G.A.H. Benjamin, and T. Farrenkopf. ''Requests for Physician-Assisted Death: Guidelines for Assessing Mental Capacity and Impaired Judgment.'' Psychology, Public Policy and Law 6 (2000): 348–372.Google Scholar
  86. Whiteneck, G.G. et al. A Collaborative Study of High Quadriplegia. Englewood, Colorado: Rocky Mountain Spinal Cord Injury System Report to the National Institute of Handicapped Research, 1985.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2004

Authors and Affiliations

  • Carol J. Gill
    • 1
  1. 1.Department of Disability and Human Development (MC 626)University of Illinois at ChicagoChicagoUSA

Personalised recommendations