The Journal of Technology Transfer

, Volume 29, Issue 1, pp 55–82

A Systematic Review of Business Incubation Research

  • Sean M. Hackett
  • David M. Dilts
Article

Abstract

This article systematically reviews the literature on business incubators and business incubation. Focusing on the primary research orientations—i.e. studies centering on incubator development, incubator configurations, incubatee development, incubator-incubation impacts, and theorizing about incubators-incubation—problems with extant research are analyzed and opportunities for future research are identified. From our review, it is clear that research has just begun to scratch the surface of the incubator-incubation phenomenon. While much attention has been devoted to the description of incubator facilities, less attention has been focused on the incubatees, the innovations they seek to diffuse, and the incubation outcomes that have been achieved. As interest in the incubator-incubation concept continues to grow, new research efforts should focus not only on these under-researched units of analysis, but also on the incubation process itself.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Adkins, D., 2001, A Report for the Japan Association of New Business Incubation Organizations (JANBO): Summary of the U.S. Incubator Industry, Athens, OH: National Business Incubation Association.Google Scholar
  2. Allen, D.N., 1988, 'Business Incubator Life Cycles,' Economic Development Quarterly 2(1), 19-29.Google Scholar
  3. Allen, D.N., J.E. Ginsberg, and S.A. Marks, 1984, 'Home Grown Entrepreneurship: Pennsylvania's Small Business Incubators,' Report published by The Pennsylvania State University Institute of Public Administration and the Pennsylvania Department of Commerce.Google Scholar
  4. Allen, D.N. and R. McCluskey, 1990, 'Structure, Policy, Services, and Performance in the Business Incubator Industry,' Entrepreneurship Theory & Practice 15(2), 61-77.Google Scholar
  5. Allen, D.N. and S. Rahman, 1985, 'Small Business Incubators: A Positive Environment for Entrepreneurship,' Journal of Small Business Management 23(3), 12-22.Google Scholar
  6. Allen, D.N. and M.L. Weinberg, 1988, 'State Investment in Business Incubators,' Public Administration Quarterly 12(2), 196-215.Google Scholar
  7. Autio, E. and M. Kloftsen, 1998, 'A Comparative Study of Two European Business Incubators,' Journal of Small Business Management 36(1), 30-43.Google Scholar
  8. Bazan, E.J., 1987, Conducting an Incubator Feasibility and Implementation Study: A Primer, Athens, OH: National Business Incubation Association.Google Scholar
  9. Bearse, P., 1998, 'A Question of Evaluation: NBIA's Impact Assessment of Business Incubators,' Economic Development Quarterly 12(4), 322-333.Google Scholar
  10. Bowman-Upton, N., S.L. Seaman, and D.L. Sexton, 1989, 'Innovation Evaluation Programs: Do They Help the Inventors?,' Journal of Small Business Management 27(3), 23-30.Google Scholar
  11. Branscomb, L.M. and P.E. Auerswald, 2002, Between Invention and Innovation: An Analysis of Funding for Early-stage Technology Development (NIST GCR 02–841 Report), Gaithersburg, Maryland: Economic Assessment Office, Advanced Technology Program, National Institute of Standards and Technology.Google Scholar
  12. Brooks, O.J., 1986, 'Economic Development Through Entrepreneurship: Incubators and the Incubation Process,' Economic Development Review 4(2), 24-29.Google Scholar
  13. Bruton, G.D., 1998, 'Incubators as a Small Business Support in Russia: Contrast of University-related U.S. Incubators with the Zelenograd Scientific and Technology Park,' Journal of Small Business Management 36(1), 91-94.Google Scholar
  14. Campbell, C., 1989, 'Change Agents in the New Economy: Business Incubators and Economic Development,' Economic Development Review 7(2), 56-59.Google Scholar
  15. Campbell, C. and D.N. Allen, 1987, 'The Small Business Incubator Industry: Micro-level Economic Development,' Economic Development Quarterly 1(2), 178-191.Google Scholar
  16. Campbell, C., R.C. Kendrick, and D.S. Samuelson, 1985, 'Stalking the Latent Entrepreneur: Business Incubators and Economic Development,' Economic Development Review 3(2), 43-49.Google Scholar
  17. CIE, 1984, Small Business Incubators: A How-to Guide, Washington, D.C.: Community Information Exchange, National Urban Coalition.Google Scholar
  18. Culp, R.P., 1996, A Test of Business Growth Through Analysis of a Technology Incubator Program, Unpublished dissertation, Atlanta: Georgia Institute of Technology.Google Scholar
  19. Das, D.K. and B.J. Ferill, 1985, Entrepreneurs and Incubators: An Analysis of Puget Sound Data, Seattle, WA: Veritas Services.Google Scholar
  20. Dorf, R.C. and B. Purdy, 1985, Incubators for Innovation: A Plan for California Regional Innovation and Job Creation, Davis, CA: University of California at Davis.Google Scholar
  21. Drake, D.L., 2001, 'Do Business Incubators Hatch Enough Jobs?,' Business News New Jersey 14, (October 9) 26.Google Scholar
  22. Duvall, M. and C. Guglielmo, 2000, 'Incubators Face Mountain of Hurt' [web-site], Inter@active Week (ZDNet). Retrieved August 21, 2000, from the World Wide WebGoogle Scholar
  23. Enrado, P., 2002, 'Nothing to Incubate,' Upside March, 14.Google Scholar
  24. Erdy, L., 1985, A Profile of Small Business Incubators in the State of Ohio, Columbus, OH: Ohio Department of Development.Google Scholar
  25. Finer, B. and P. Holberton, 2002, 'Incubators: There and Back,' Journal of Business Strategy 23(3), 23-25.Google Scholar
  26. Fry, F.L., 1987, 'The Role of Incubators in Small Business Planning,' American Journal of Small Business 12(1), 51-61.Google Scholar
  27. Gans, J.S. and S. Stern, 2003, 'The Product Market and the Market for “Ideas”: Commercialization Strategies for Technology Entrepreneurs,' Research Policy 32, 333-350.Google Scholar
  28. Greene, P.G. and J.S. Butler, 1996, 'The Minority Community as a Natural Business Incubator,' Journal of Business Research 36, 51-58.Google Scholar
  29. Hansen, M.T., H.W. Chesbrough, N. Nohria, and D.N. Sull, 2000, 'Networked Incubators: Hothouses of the New Economy,' Harvard Business Review 78(5), 74-84.Google Scholar
  30. Hisrich, R.D., 1988, 'New Business Formation Through the Enterprise Development Center: A Model for New Venture Creation,' IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management EM 35(4), 221-231.Google Scholar
  31. Holson, L.M., 1998, 'Hard Times in the Hatchery: After Dotcom Flameout, “Incubator” is a Despised Word,' New York Times October 30, C1; C8.Google Scholar
  32. Ketchen, D.J.J., J.B. Thomas, and C.C. Snow, 1993, 'Organizational Configurations and Performance: A Comparison of Theoretical Approaches,' Academy of Management Journal 36(6), 1278-1313.Google Scholar
  33. Kuratko, D.F. and W.R. LaFollette, 1987, 'Small Business Incubators for Local Economic Development,' Economic Development Review 5(2), 49-55.Google Scholar
  34. Lavelle, J., 1986, Fulton Carroll Center for Industry: A Case Study in Business Incubator Development, Chicago, IL: Industrial Council of Northwest Chicago.Google Scholar
  35. Lewis, D.A., 2002, Does Technology Incubation Work? A Critical Review of the Evidence, Athens, OH: National Business Incubation Association.Google Scholar
  36. Lichtenstein, G.A., 1992, The Significance of Relationships in Entrepreneurship: A Case Study of the Ecology of Enterprise in Two Business Incubators, Unpublished Dissertation, Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania.Google Scholar
  37. Lumpkin, J.R. and R.D. Ireland, 1988, 'Screening Practices of New Business Incubators: The Evaluation of Critical Success Factors,' American Journal of Small Business 12(4), 59-81.Google Scholar
  38. Lynn, L.H., N.M. Reddy, and J.D. Aram, 1996, 'Linking Technology and Institutions: The Innovation Community Framework,' Research Policy 25, 91-106.Google Scholar
  39. Markley, D.M. and K.T. McNamara, 1995, 'Economic and Fiscal Impacts of a Business Incubator,' Economic Development Quarterly 9(3), 273-278.Google Scholar
  40. McGinn, D., 2002, 'Hatching Companies: An Old Incubator Thrives in Stormy Times,' Newsweek (Enterprise: At the Crossroads of Business & Technology) September 30, 140(14), 38d-38H.Google Scholar
  41. Meeder, R.A., 1993, Forging the Incubator: How to Design and Implement a Feasibility Study for Business Incubation Programs, Athens, OH: National Business Incubation Association.Google Scholar
  42. Merrifield, D.B., 1987, 'New Business Incubators,' Journal of Business Venturing 2, 277-284.Google Scholar
  43. Mian, S.A., 1994, 'Are University Technology Incubators Providing a Milieu for Technology-based Entrepreneurship?,' Technology Management 1, 86-93.Google Scholar
  44. Mian, S.A., 1994, 'U.S. University-sponsored Technology Incubators: An Overview of Management, Policies and Performance,' Technovation 14(8), 515-528.Google Scholar
  45. Mian, S.A., 1996, 'Assessing Value Added Contributions of University Technology Business Incubators to Tenant Firms,' Research Policy 25, 325-335.Google Scholar
  46. Mian, S.A., 1997, 'Assessing and Managing the University Technology Business Incubator: An Integrative Framework,' Journal of Business Venturing 12(4), 251-285.Google Scholar
  47. Nocera, J., 2001, 'Bill Gross Blew Through $800 Million in 8 months (and He's Got Nothing to Show for It),' Fortune March 5, 143(5), 71-82.Google Scholar
  48. Nohria, N. and R.G. Eccles, (eds.), 1992, Networks and Organizations, Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press.Google Scholar
  49. Nowak, M.J. and C.E. Grantham, 2000, 'The Virtual Incubator: Managing Human Capital in the Software Industry,' Research Policy 29, 125-134.Google Scholar
  50. Nye, J.V., 1991, 'Lucky Fools and Cautious Businessmen: On Entrepreneurship and the Measurement of Entrepreneurial Failure,' Research in Economic History Suppl. 6, 131-152.Google Scholar
  51. Plosila, W. and D.N. Allen, 1985, 'Small Business Incubators and Public Policy: Implications for States and Local Development Strategies,' Policy Studies Journal 13, 729-734.Google Scholar
  52. Rice, M.P., 1992, Intervention Mechanisms Used to Influence the Critical Success Factors of New Ventures: An Exploratory Study, Troy, NY: Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute.Google Scholar
  53. Rice, M.P., 2002, 'Co-production of Business Assistance in Business Incubators: An Exploratory Study,' Journal of Business Venturing 17, 163-187.Google Scholar
  54. Roper, S., 1999, 'Israel's Technology Incubators: Repeatable Success or Costly Failure,' Regional Studies 33(2), 175-184.Google Scholar
  55. SBA, 1985, Small Business Incubators: New Directions in Economic Development, Washington, D.C.: U.S. Small Business Administration.Google Scholar
  56. Schaff, W., 2000, 'Divine Isn't What It Seems to Be—Incubators Are the Poor Person's Way to Play the Private Equity Markets—But Not Necessarily the Smart Way,' InformationWeek.Google Scholar
  57. Scheirer, M.A., 1985, Innovation and Enterprise: A Study of NSF's Innovation Centers Program, Rockville, MD: Westat, Inc. and National Science Foundation.Google Scholar
  58. Scherer, A. and D.W. McDonald, 1988, 'A Model for the Development of Small High-Technology Businesses Based on Case Studies from an Incubator,' Journal of Product Innovation Management 5(4), 282-295.Google Scholar
  59. Sherman, H., 1998, 'Comments on Peter Bearse's “A Question of Evaluation”,' Economic Development Quarterly 12(4), 334-335.Google Scholar
  60. Sherman, H., 1999, 'Assessing the Intervention Effectiveness of Business Incubation Programs on New Business Start-ups,' Journal of Developmental Entrepreneurship 4(2), 117-133.Google Scholar
  61. Sherman, H. and D.S. Chappell, 1998, 'Methodological Challenges in Evaluating Business Incubator Outcomes,' Economic Development Quarterly 12(4), 313-321.Google Scholar
  62. Smilor, R.W., 1987a, 'Commercializing Technology Through New Business Incubators,' Research Management 30(5), 36-41.Google Scholar
  63. Smilor, R.W., 1987b, 'Managing the Incubator System: Critical Success Factors to Accelerate New Company Development,' IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management EM-34(4), 146-156.Google Scholar
  64. Smilor, R.W. and M.D. Gill Jr., 1986, The New Business Incubator: Linking Talent, Technology, Capital, and Know-how, Lexington: Lexington Books.Google Scholar
  65. Stuart, R. and P.A. Abetti, 1987, 'Start-up Ventures: Towards the Prediction of Initial Success,' Journal of Business Venturing 2, 215-230.Google Scholar
  66. Swierczek, F.W., 1992, 'Strategies for Business Innovation: Evaluating the Prospects of Incubation in Thailand,' Technovation 12(8), 521-533.Google Scholar
  67. Temali, M. and C. Campbell, 1984, Business Incubator Profiles: A National Survey, Minneapolis: University of Minnesota, Hubert H. Humphrey Institute of Public Affairs.Google Scholar
  68. Udell, G.G., 1990, 'Are Business Incubators Really Creating New Jobs by Creating New Businesses and New Products?,' Journal of Product Innovation Management 7, 108-122.Google Scholar
  69. Weber, M., 1993, The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, Routledge.Google Scholar
  70. Weick, K., 1995, 'What Theory Is Not, Theorizing Is,' Administrative Science Quarterly 40, 385-390.Google Scholar
  71. Williamson, O.E., 1978, Markets and Hierarchies: Analysis and Antitrust Implications, New York, NY: The Free Press.Google Scholar
  72. Allen, D.N., 1988, 'Business incubator life cycles,' Economic Development Quarterly 2(1), 19-29.Google Scholar
  73. Allen, D.N., and R. McCluskey, 1990, 'Structure, Policy, Services, and Performance in the Business Incubator Industry,' Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice 15(2), 61-77.Google Scholar
  74. Allen, D.N., and S. Rahman, 1985, 'Small Business Incubators: A Positive Environment for Entrepreneurship,' Journal of Small Business Management 23(3), 12-22.Google Scholar
  75. Allen, D.N., and M.L. Weinberg, 1988, 'State Investment in Business Incubators,' Public Administration Quarterly December (12), 196-215.Google Scholar
  76. Autio, E., and M. Kloftsen, 1998, 'A Comparative Study of Two European Business Incubators,' Journal of Small Business Management January, 30-43.Google Scholar
  77. Bearse, P., 1998, 'A Question of Evaluation: NBIA's Impact Assessment of Business Incubators,' Economic Development Quarterly 12(4), 322-333.Google Scholar
  78. Brooks, O.J., 1986, 'Economic Development Through Entrepreneurship: Incubators and the Incubation Process,' Economic Development Review 4(2), 24-29.Google Scholar
  79. Bruton, G.D., 1998, 'Incubators as a Small Business Support in Russia: Contrast of University-Related U.S. Incubators with the Zelenograd Scientific and Technology Park,' Journal of Small Business Management 36(1), 91-94.Google Scholar
  80. Campbell, C., 1989, 'Change Agents in the New Economy: Business Incubators and Economic Development,' Economic Development Review 7(2), 56-59.Google Scholar
  81. Campbell, C. and D.N. Allen, 1987, 'The Small Business Incubator Industry: Micro-level Economic Development,' Economic Development Quarterly 1(2), 178-191.Google Scholar
  82. Campbell, C., R.C. Kendrick, and D.S. Samuelson, 1985, 'Stalking the Latent Entrepreneur: Business Incubators and Economic Development,' Economic Development Review 3(2), 43-49.Google Scholar
  83. Fry, F.L., 1987, 'The Role of Incubators in Small Business Planning,' American Journal of Small Business 12(1), 51-61.Google Scholar
  84. Greene, P.G. and J.S. Butler, 1996, 'The Minority Community as a Natural Business Incubator,' Journal of Business Research 36, 51-58.Google Scholar
  85. Hansen, M.T., H.W. Chesbrough, N. Nohria, and D.N. Sull, 2000, 'Networked Incubators: Hothouses of the New Economy,' Harvard Business Review September/October, 74-84.Google Scholar
  86. Hisrich, R.D., 1988, 'New Business Formation Through the Enterprise Development Center: A Model for New Venture Creation,' IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management EM 35(4), 221-231.Google Scholar
  87. Kuratko, D.F. and W.R. LaFollette, 1987, 'Small Business Incubators for Local Economic Development,' Economic Development Review 5(2), 49-55.Google Scholar
  88. Lumpkin, J.R. and R.D. Ireland, 1988, 'Screening Practices of New Business Incubators: The Evaluation of Critical Success Factors,' American Journal of Small Business 12(4), 59-81.Google Scholar
  89. Markley, D.M. and K.T. McNamara, 1995, 'Economic and Fiscal Impacts of a Business Incubator,' Economic Development Quarterly 9(3), 273-278.Google Scholar
  90. Merrifield, D.B., 1987, 'New Business Incubators,' Journal of Business Venturing 2, 277-284.Google Scholar
  91. Mian, S.A., 1994, 'Are University Technology Incubators Providing a Milieu for Technology-Based Entrepreneurship?,' Technology Management 1, 86-93.Google Scholar
  92. Mian, S.A., 1994, 'U.S. University-Sponsored Technology Incubators: An Overview of Management, Policies and Performance,' Technovation 14(8), 515-528.Google Scholar
  93. Mian, S.A., 1996, 'Assessing Value Added Contributions of University Technology Business Incubators to Tenant Firms,' Research Policy 25, 325-335.Google Scholar
  94. Mian, S.A., 1997, 'Assessing and Managing the University Technology Business Incubator: An Integrative Framework,' Journal of Business Venturing 12(4), 251-285.Google Scholar
  95. Nowak, M.J. and C.E. Grantham, 2000, 'The Virtual Incubator: Managing Human Capital in the Software Industry,' Research Policy 29, 125-134.Google Scholar
  96. Plosila, W. and D.N. Allen, 1985, 'Small Business Incubators and Public Policy: Implications for States and Local Development Strategies,' Policy Studies Journal 13, 729-734.Google Scholar
  97. Rice, M.P., 2002, 'Co-production of Business Assistance in Business Incubators: An Exploratory Study,' Journal of Business Venturing 17, 163-187.Google Scholar
  98. Roper, S., 1999, 'Israel's Technology Incubators: Repeatable Success or Costly Failure,' Regional Studies 33(2), 175-184.Google Scholar
  99. Scherer, A. and D.W. McDonald, 1988, 'A Model for the Development of Small High-Technology Businesses Based on Case Studies from an Incubator,' Journal of Product Innovation Management 5(4), 282-295.Google Scholar
  100. Sherman, H., 1998, 'Comments on Peter Bearse's “A Question of Evaluation”,' Economic Development Quarterly 12(4), 334-335.Google Scholar
  101. Sherman, H., 1999, 'Assessing the Intervention Effectiveness of Business Incubation Programs on New Business Start-ups,' Journal of Developmental Entrepreneurship 4(2), 117-133.Google Scholar
  102. Sherman, H. and D.S. Chappell, 1998, 'Methodological Challenges in Evaluating Business Incubator Outcomes,' Economic Development Quarterly 12(4), 313-321.Google Scholar
  103. Smilor, R.W., 1987, 'Managing the Incubator System: Critical Success Factors to Accelerate New Company Development,' IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management EM-34(4), 146-156.Google Scholar
  104. Smilor, R.W. and M.D. Gill Jr., 1986, The New Business Incubator: Linking Talent, Technology, Capital, and Know-How, Lexington: Lexington Books.Google Scholar
  105. Stuart, R. and P.A. Abetti, 1987, 'Start-up Ventures: Towards the Prediction of Initial Success,' Journal of Business Venturing 2, 215-230.Google Scholar
  106. Swierczek, F.W., 1992, 'Strategies for Business Innovation: Evaluating the Prospects of Incubation in Thailand,' Technovation 12(8), 521-533.Google Scholar
  107. Udell, G.G., 1990, 'Are Business Incubators Really Creating New Jobs by Creating New Businesses and New Products?,' Journal of Product Innovation Management 7, 108-122.Google Scholar
  108. Culp, R.P., 1996, A Test of Business Growth Through Analysis of a Technology Incubator Program, Unpublished dissertation, Atlanta: Georgia Institute of Technology.Google Scholar
  109. Lichtenstein, G.A., 1992, The Significance of Relationships in Entrepreneurship: A Case Study of the Ecology of Enterprise in Two Business Incubators, Unpublished Dissertation, Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania.Google Scholar
  110. Temali, M. and C. Campbell, 1984, Business Incubator Profiles: A National Survey, Minneapolis: University of Minnesota, Hubert H. Humphrey Institute of Public Affairs.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2004

Authors and Affiliations

  • Sean M. Hackett
    • 1
  • David M. Dilts
    • 1
  1. 1.Management of Technology ProgramVanderbilt UniversityNashvilleUSA

Personalised recommendations