Foundations of Science

, Volume 9, Issue 1, pp 65–101

On the Role of Counterfactuals in Inferring Causal Effects

  • Jochen Kluve
Article

Abstract

Causal inference in the empiricalsciences is based on counterfactuals. The mostcommon approach utilizes a statistical model ofpotential outcomes to estimate causal effectsof treatments. On the other hand, one leadingapproach to the study of causation inphilosophical logic has been the analysis ofcausation in terms of counterfactualconditionals. This paper discusses and connectsboth approaches to counterfactual causationfrom philosophy and statistics. Specifically, Ipresent the counterfactual account of causationin terms of Lewis's possible-world semantics,and reformulate the statistical potentialoutcome framework using counterfactualconditionals. This procedure highlights variousproperties and mechanisms of the statisticalmodel.

causation counterfactuals possible worlds potential outcomes treatment effect 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

REFERENCES

  1. Angrist, J.D., G.W. Imbens and D.B. Rubin: 1996, Identification of Causal EffectsUsing Instrumental Variables (with discussion). Journal of the American Statistical Association91: 444–472.Google Scholar
  2. Angrist, J.D. and A.B. Krueger: 1999, Empirical Strategies in Labor Economics. In O. Ashenfelter and D. Card (eds.), Handbook of Labor Economics. Amsterdam: North Holland, 1277–1368.Google Scholar
  3. Bennett, J.: 1993, Event Causation: The Counterfactual Analysis. In E. Sosa and M. Tooley (eds.), Causation. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  4. Cochran, W.G.: 1965, The Planning of Observational Studies of Human Populations (with discussion). Journal of the Royal Statistical SocietySeries A 128: 234–266.Google Scholar
  5. Cohen, S.M.: 2003, Aristotle's Metaphysics. In E.N. Zalta (ed.), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Spring 2003 Edition), forthcoming URL = <http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2003/entries/aristotle-metaphysics/>.Google Scholar
  6. Cox, D.R.: 1958, Planning of Experiments. New York: Wiley.Google Scholar
  7. Dawid, A.P.: 1979, Conditional Independence in Statistical Theory. Journal of the Royal Statistical SocietySeries B 41: 1–31.Google Scholar
  8. Dawid, A.P.: 2000, Causal Inference Without Counterfactuals (with discussion). Journal of the American Statistical Association95: 407–448.Google Scholar
  9. Fisher, R.A.: 1935, The Design of Experiments. Edinburgh: Oliver & Boyd.Google Scholar
  10. Freedman, D.: 1999, From Association to Causation: Some Remarks on the History of Statistics. Statistical Science14: 243–258.Google Scholar
  11. Freedman, D. and P. Humphreys: 1999, Are There Algorithms That Discover Causal Structure? Synthese121: 29–54.Google Scholar
  12. Galles, D. and J. Pearl: 1998, An Axiomatic Characterization of Causal Counterfactuals. Foundations of Science3: 151–182.Google Scholar
  13. Glymour, C.: 1986, Statistics and Metaphysics, Comment on 'Statistics and Causal Inference' by P.W. Holland. Journal of the American Statistical Association81: 964–966.Google Scholar
  14. Goldberger, A.: 1972, Structural Equation Methods in the Social Sciences. Econometrica40: 979–1001.Google Scholar
  15. Good, I.J.: 1961, 1962, 1963, A Causal Calculus I and II. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science44: 305–318, and 45: 43–51, Errata and Corrigenda, ibid.: 46: 88.Google Scholar
  16. Granger, C.: 1969, Investigating Causal Relations by Econometric Models and Cross-Spectral Methods. Econometrica37: 424–438.Google Scholar
  17. Granger, C.: 1986, Comment on 'Statistics and Causal Inference' by P.W. Holland. Journal of the American Statistical Association81: 967–968.Google Scholar
  18. Greenland, S.: 2000, Causal Analysis in the Health Sciences, Journal of the American Statistical Association95: 286–289.Google Scholar
  19. Haavelmo, T.: 1943, The Statistical Implications of a System of Simultaneous Equations. Econometrica11: 1–12.Google Scholar
  20. Heckman, J.J.: 1996, Comment on 'Identification of Causal Effects Using Instrumental Variables' by J.D. Angrist, G.W. Imbens, and D.B. Rubin. Journal of the American Statistical Association91: 459–462.Google Scholar
  21. Heckman, J.J.: 2000, Causal Parameters and Policy Analysis in Economics: A Twentieth Century Retrospective. Quarterly Journal of Economics115: 45–97.Google Scholar
  22. Hitchcock, C.: 2002, Probabilistic Causation. In E.N. Zalta (ed.), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Fall 2002 Edition), URL = <http://plato.stanford. edu/archives/fall2002/entries/causation-probabilistic/>.Google Scholar
  23. Hendry, D.F. and M.S. Morgan: 1995, The Foundations of Econometric Analysis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  24. Holland, P.W.: 1986, Statistics and Causal Inference (with discussion). Journal of the American Statistical Association81: 945–970.Google Scholar
  25. Holland, P.W.: 1988a, Causal Inference, Path Analysis, and Recursive Structural Equation Models. Sociological Methodology18: 449–484.Google Scholar
  26. Holland, P.W.: 1988b, Causal Mechanism or Causal Effect: Which Is Best for Statistical Science?, Comment on 'Employment Discrimination and Statistical Science' by A.P. Dempster. Statistical Science3: 186–188.Google Scholar
  27. Holland, P.W. and D.B. Rubin: 1983, On Lord's Paradox. In H. Wainer and S. Messick (eds), Principals of Modern Psychological Measurement. Hillsdale, NJ: L. Erlbaum.Google Scholar
  28. Holland, P.W. and D.B. Rubin: 1988, Causal Inference in Retrospective Studies, Evaluation Review12: 203–231.Google Scholar
  29. Hood, W.C. and T.C. Koopmans (eds.): 1953, Studies in Econometric Method, Cowles Commission Monograph No. 14. New York: Wiley & Sons.Google Scholar
  30. Horwich, P.: 1993, Lewis's Programme. In E. Sosa and M. Tooley (eds.), Causation. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  31. Hume, D.: 1740a [1992], Treatise of Human Nature, as reprinted by Buffalo, NY: Prometheus Books.Google Scholar
  32. Hume, D.: 1740b [1993], An Abstract of A Treatise of Human Nature. In An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding, as reprinted by Indianapolis, IN: Hackett Publishing Co., Eric Steinberg (ed).Google Scholar
  33. Hume, D.: 1748 [1993], An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding, as reprinted by Indianapolis, IN: Hackett Publishing Co., Eric Steinberg (ed.), based on the 1777 posthumous edition.Google Scholar
  34. Imbens, G.W.: 2000, The Role of Propensity Score in Estimating Dose-Response Functions. Biometrika87: 706–710.Google Scholar
  35. Kim, J.: 1973, Causes and Counterfactuals. The Journal of Philosophy70: 570–572.Google Scholar
  36. Kluve, J.: 2002, Assessing Counterfactuals when Treatment is Multivalued. UC Berkeley Center for Labor Economics Working Paper#55.Google Scholar
  37. Koopmans, T.C. (ed.): 1950, Statistical Inference in Dynamic Economic Models, Cowles Commission Monograph No. 10. New York: Wiley & Sons.Google Scholar
  38. Leamer, E.: 1983, Let's Take the Con Out of Econometrics. American Economic Review73: 31–43.Google Scholar
  39. Lechner, M.: 2001, Identification and Estimation of Causal Effects of Multiple Treatments under the Conditional Independence Assumption. In M. Lechner and F. Pfeiffer (eds.), Econometric Evaluation of Labour Market Policies. Heidelberg: Physica.Google Scholar
  40. Lewis, D.: 1973a, Counterfactuals. Oxford: Blackwell.Google Scholar
  41. Lewis, D.: 1973b, Causation. Journal of Philosophy70: 556–567.Google Scholar
  42. Lewis, D.: 1979, Counterfactual Dependence and Time's Arrow. NOÛS13: 455–476.Google Scholar
  43. Lewis, D.: 1986, Postscripts to “Causation”. In D. Lewis (ed.), Philosophical Papers: Volume II. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  44. Marshall, A.: 1890 [1965], Principles of Economics, 8th edn., reprint. London: Macmillan.Google Scholar
  45. Menzies, P.: 2001, Counterfactual Theories of Causation. In E.N. Zalta (ed.), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy(Spring 2001 Edition), URL = http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/causation~counterfactual/.Google Scholar
  46. Morgan, M.: 1990, The History of Econometric Ideas. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  47. Neyman, J.: 1923 [1990], On the Application of Probability Theory to Agricultural Experiments. Essay on Principles, Section 9. D.M. Sabrowska and T.P. Speed (trans. and eds.) from the Polish original, which appeared in Roczniki Nauk Rolniczych Tom X (1923), 1–51 (Annals of Agriculture) Statistical Science5: 465–472.Google Scholar
  48. Neyman, J.: 1935, with co-operation by K. Iwaszkiewicz and S. Kolodziejczyk, Statistical Problems in Agricultural Experimentation (with discussion). Supplement to the Journal of the Royal Statistical Society2: 107–180.Google Scholar
  49. Pearl, J.: 1997, The New Challenge: From a Century of Statistics to an Age of Causation. Computing Science and Statistics29: 415–423.Google Scholar
  50. Pearl, J.: 1998, Graphs, Causality, and Structural Equation Models. Sociological Methods and Research27: 226–284.Google Scholar
  51. Pearl, J.: 2000a, Causality: Models, Reasoning, and Inference. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  52. Pearl, J.: 2000b, Comment on 'Causal Inference Without Counterfactuals' by A.P. Dawid. Journal of the American Statistical Association95: 428–431.Google Scholar
  53. Reichenbach, H.: 1956, The Direction of Time. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press.Google Scholar
  54. Robins, J.M.: 1986, A New Approach to Causal Inference in Mortality Studies with a Sustained Exposure Period-Application to Control of the Healthy Worker Survivor Effect. Mathematical Modelling7: 1393–1512.Google Scholar
  55. Robins, J.M.: 1987, Addendum to ' A New Approach to Causal Inference in Mortality Studies with a Sustained Exposure Period-Application to Control of the HealthyWorker Survivor Effect'. Comput. Math. Applic.14: 923–945.Google Scholar
  56. Robins, J.M.: 1995, Discussion of 'Causal Diagrams for Empirical Research' by J. Pearl. Biometrika82: 695–698.Google Scholar
  57. Robins, J.M. and S. Greenland: 2000, Comment on 'Causal Inference Without Counterfactuals' by A.P. Dawid. Journal of the American Statistical Association95: 431–435.Google Scholar
  58. Rosenbaum, P.R.: 1995, Observational Studies. New York: Springer.Google Scholar
  59. Rosenbaum, P.R. and D.B. Rubin: 1983, The Central Role of the Propensity Score in Observational Studies for Causal Effects. Biometrika70: 41–55.Google Scholar
  60. Rosenbaum, P.R. and D.B. Rubin: 1984a, Estimating the Effects Caused by Treatments, Comment on 'On the Nature and Discovery of Structure' by J.W. Pratt and R. Schlaiffer. Journal of the American Statistical Association79: 26–28.Google Scholar
  61. Rosenbaum, P.R. and D.B. Rubin: 1984b, Reducing Bias in Observational Studies Using Subclassification on the Propensity Score. Journal of the American Statistical Association79: 516–524.Google Scholar
  62. Rubin, D.B.: 1974, Estimating Causal Effects of Treatments in Randomized and Nonrandomized Studies. Journal of Educational Psychology66: 688–701.Google Scholar
  63. Rubin, D.B.: 1977, Assignment to Treatment Group on the Basis of a Covariate. Journal of Educational Statistics2: 1–26.Google Scholar
  64. Rubin, D.B.: 1978, Bayesian Inference for Causal Effects: The Role of Randomization. Annals of Statistics6: 34–58.Google Scholar
  65. Rubin, D.B.: 1980, Comment on 'Randomization Analysis of ExperimentalData: The Fisher Randomization Test' by D. Basu. Journal of the American Statistical Association75: 591–593.Google Scholar
  66. Rubin, D.B.: 1986, Which Ifs Have Causal Answers, Comment on 'Statistics and Causal Inference' by P.W. Holland. Journal of the American Statistical Association81: 961–962.Google Scholar
  67. Rubin, D.B.: 1990, Neyman (1923) and Causal Inference in Experiments and Observational Studies, Comment on 'On the Application of Probability Theory to Agricultural Experiments. Essay on Principles. Section 9.' by J. Neyman. Statistical Science5: 472–480.Google Scholar
  68. Russell, B.: 1945, A History of Western Philosophy. New York: Simon & Schuster.Google Scholar
  69. Salmon, W.: 1980, Probabilistic Causality. Pacific Philosophical Quarterly61: 50–74.Google Scholar
  70. Salmon, W.: 1998, Causality and Explanation. New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  71. Skyrms, B.: 1984, EPR: Lessons for Metaphysics. In P. French, T. Uehling and H. Wettstein (eds.), Midwest Studies in Philosophy IX-Causation and Causal Theories. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.Google Scholar
  72. Skyrms, B.: 1988, Probability and Causation. Journal of Econometrics39: 53–68.Google Scholar
  73. Sobel, M.E.: 1995, Causal Inference in the Social and Behavioral Sciences. In G. Arminger, C.C. Clogg and M.E. Sobel (eds.), Handbook of Statistical Modeling for the Social and Behavioral Sciences. New York: Plenum Press.Google Scholar
  74. Sobel, M.E.: 2000, Causal Inference in the Social Sciences. Journal of the American Statistical Association95: 647–651.Google Scholar
  75. Sosa, E. and M. Tooley (eds.): 1993a, Causation. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  76. Sosa, E. and M. Tooley: 1993b, Introduction. In E. Sosa and M. Tooley (eds.), Causation. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1–32.Google Scholar
  77. Spirtes, P., C. Glymour and R. Scheines: 2000, Causation, Prediction, and Search, 2nd edn. New York: Springer.Google Scholar
  78. Stalnaker, R.: 1984, Inquiry. Boston, MA: Bradford Books.Google Scholar
  79. Suppes, P.: 1970, A Probabilistic Theory of Causality. Amsterdam: North Holland.Google Scholar
  80. Suppes, P.: 1984, Conflicting Intuitions about Causality. In P. French, T. Uehling and H. Wettstein (eds.), Midwest Studies in Philosophy IX-Causation and Causal Theories. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.Google Scholar
  81. Wasserman, L.: 2000, Comment on 'Causal Inference Without Counterfactuals' by A.P. Dawid. Journal of the American Statistical Association95: 442–443.Google Scholar
  82. Wright, S.: 1921, Correlation and Causation. Journal of Agricultural Research20: 557–585.Google Scholar
  83. Wright, S.: 1934, The Method of Path Coefficients. Annals of Mathematical Statistics5: 161–215.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2004

Authors and Affiliations

  • Jochen Kluve
    • 1
  1. 1.Department of Economics – Center for Labor EconomicsUniversity of California at BerkeleyBerkeley

Personalised recommendations