Advertisement

Feminist Legal Studies

, Volume 12, Issue 2, pp 129–174 | Cite as

Imperilled Muslim Women, Dangerous Muslim Men and Civilised Europeans: Legal and Social Responses to Forced Marriages

  • Sherene H. Razack
Article

Abstract

How is it possible to acknowledge and confront patriarchal violence within Muslim migrant communities without descending into cultural deficit explanations (they are overly patriarchal and inherently uncivilised) and without inviting extraordinary measures of stigmatisation, surveillance and control so increased after the events of September 11, 2001? In this paper, I explore this question by examining Norway's responses to the issue of forced marriages. I argue that social and political responses to violence against women in Muslim communities have been primarily culturalist. That is, the violence is understood as originating entirely in culture, an approach that obscures the multiple factors that give rise to and sustain the violence. The culturalist approach enables the stigmatising and surveillance of Muslim communities. I approach this argument in two parts. In part one I discuss two important and influential books written by women who identify their concerns as feminist and who lay out the case for considering the problem of forced marriage as a problem of controlling fundamentally unassimilable and culturally inferior Muslims. I explore these works as paradigmatic of the culturalising or culturalist move. In part two, I review a variety of legal initiatives in Norway, first contextualising them as part of a larger European venture to control Muslim populations and then examining what they share conceptually with the approaches in part one. I end with how we might begin to develop an anti-racist response to the problem of violence against women.

anti-Muslim culturalisation forced marriage laws violence 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

REFERENCES

  1. Abu-Lughod, L., "Saving Muslim Women or Standing With Them? On Images, Ethics, and War in Our Times", Insaniyaat 1 (2003). Available 〈http:// www.aucegypt.edu/academic/insanyat/Issue%201/I-article.html〉 (15 November 2003).Google Scholar
  2. Ahmed, K., Hinsliff, G. & Morgan, O., "Ministers Plan to End Forced Marriages", The Observer (2001). Available 〈http://observer.guardian.co.uk/politics/story/ 0,6903,587516,00.html〉 (15 November 2003).Google Scholar
  3. Bredal, A., "Arranged Marriages as a Multicultural Battlefield", Paper prepared for the working conference, "Youth in the Plural City: Individualized and Collectivized Identity Project", Rome, Italy (25-28 May 1999).Google Scholar
  4. Browne ,A., "Age Bar to Curb Forced Marriages", The Times (2003). Available 〈http://www.jcwi.org.uk/lawpolicy/uklaw/marriage_14may03.PDF〉 (8 April 2004).Google Scholar
  5. Carter, D.M., "Navigating Citizenship", Review of Generous Betrayal by Unni Wikan, Anthropological Quarterly 75/2 (2002), 410–411.Google Scholar
  6. Committee on the Elimination of Violence Against Women, "Norway Called a 'Haven for Gender Equality,' as Women's Anti-Discrimination Committee Examines Reports on Compliance with Convention". Press Release (21 January 2003). Available 〈http://www.un.org/News/Press/docs/2003/wom1377.doc.htm〉 (15 November 2003).Google Scholar
  7. Committee on Equal Opportunities for Women and Men, "Crimes of Honour", in Council of Europe, Parliamentary Assembly, Rapporteur Mrs Cryer,United Kingdom,SOC (4 June 2002).Available 〈http://www.soas.ac.uk/honourcrimes/Mat_COEreport_june02.pdf〉 (15 November 2003).Google Scholar
  8. Council of Europe, Parliamentary Assembly, "Forced marriages and Child Marriages", Doc. 9966 (2003). Available 〈http://assembly.coe.int/Documents/WorkingDocs/ Doc03/EDOC9966.htm〉 (12 April 2004).Google Scholar
  9. Danish Government, "Action Plan for 2003-2005 on Forced, Quasi-Forced and Arranged Marriages" (2003). Available 〈http://www.inm.dk/Index/dokumenter. asp?o=24&n=0&h=24&t=1&d=2194&s=5〉 (12 April 2004).Google Scholar
  10. Danish Ministry of Refugee, Immigration and Integration Affairs (Min.f. Flygtninge, Indvandrere og Integration), Aliens (Consolidation) Act no. 608 of 17 July 2002 (2002). Available 〈http://www.udlst.dk/english/Family+Reunification/Default. htm〉 (30 January 2003).Google Scholar
  11. Danish Ministry of Integration, Bill amending the Aliens Act, the Marriage Act and other Acts (2001). Available 〈http://www.flygtning.dk/publikationer/hoering/unhcr. pdf〉 (12 April 2004).Google Scholar
  12. Davoy, L., "Statement to the Commission on the Status of Women by the Minister", Norwegian Ministry of Children and Family Affairs, New York (4 March 2002).Google Scholar
  13. Drachmann, H., "Haarder Hyldet af Norske Feminister", Politikken (2003). Available http:// www.poliken.dk/VisArtikel.iasp?Page ID = 295643 (14 April 2004).Google Scholar
  14. Eide, E., "'Down There' and 'Up Here:' Europe's Others" in Norwegian Feature Stories. Ph.D. Dissertation (Institutt for Medier og Kommunikasjon Ref. No. 73336, Oslo, Norway, 2002).Google Scholar
  15. Ellefsen, K., "Danish Conditions in Norway?" Aftenposen (2003) Translation Ulla Johanson.Google Scholar
  16. Eriksen, T.H., "Norway a Multiethnic Country" (2003). Available 〈http://odin. dep.no/odin/engelsk/norway/social/032091-990909/index-dok000-b-n-a.html〉 (15 November 2003).Google Scholar
  17. Eslea, M. & Mukhtar, K., "Bullying and Racism Among Asian Schoolchildren in Britain". Educational Research 42/2 (2000), 207–217.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Fassin, D., "Culturalism as Ideology", in Cultural Perspectives on Reproductive Health, ed. C.M. Obermeyer (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001), pp. 300–317.Google Scholar
  19. Favret-Saada, J., Deadly Words: Witchcraft in the Bocage (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1980).Google Scholar
  20. Finkelkraut, A., The Defeat of the Mind (New York: Columbia University Press, 1995).Google Scholar
  21. "Forced Weddings: Difficult Culture Clash", Norway Now 20 (1999). Available 〈http://odin.dep.no/ud/engelsk/publ/periodika.032005-992400/index-dok000-b-na. html〉 (15 November 2003).Google Scholar
  22. Freedman, J., "L'Affaire des foulards: Problems of Defining a Feminist Antiracist Strategy in French Schools", in Feminism and Anti-Racism: International Struggles for Justice, eds. F.W. Twine & K. M. Blee (New York: New York University Press, 2001), pp. 295–312.Google Scholar
  23. Goldberg, D.T., The Racial State (Cambridge, Oxford: Blackwell, 2002).Google Scholar
  24. Goldhagen, D.J., Hitler's Willing Executioners. Ordinary Germans and the Holocaust (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1996).Google Scholar
  25. Grette, L., "Norway's Choice of Direction in the Work Against Forced Marriage", in Seventh International Metropolis Conference "Togetherness in Difference", Oslo, Norway (12 September 2002).Google Scholar
  26. Gullestad, M., "Invisible Fences: Nationalism, Egalitarianism and Immigration" (2000). 〈http://cas.uchicago.edu/workshops/antheur/Gullestad.pdf〉 (15 November 2003).Google Scholar
  27. Gullestad, M., "Defending An Innocent Self-Image", in Presidential Symposium in 'Initiating Cross-Atlantic Dialogues on Race and Culture in Anthropology', American Anthropological Association Annual Meeting, Washington (November, 2002), unpublished.Google Scholar
  28. Gullestad, M., "Mohammed Atta and I: Identification, Discrimination and the Formation of Sleepers", European Journal of Cultural Studies 6/4 (2003a), 529–548.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Gullestad, M., "Fighting for a Sustainable Self-image: The Role of Descent in Individualized Identification", European Journal of Anthropology 42 (2003b), 51–62.Google Scholar
  30. Gullestad, M., "Blind Slaves of our Prejudices: Debating 'Culture' and 'Race' in Norway", Ethnos 2 ( in press).Google Scholar
  31. Haw, K., Educating Muslim Girls: Shifting Discourses (Buckingham: Open University Press, 1998).Google Scholar
  32. Hegge, P.E., "When Danes are Refused Entry to Their Home Country", Aftenposten (2003). Translation Ulla Johanson.Google Scholar
  33. Henley, J., "MPs urge French Ban on Religious Symbols", The Guardian (2003). Available 〈http://www.guardian.co.uk/international/story/0,3604,1084548,00.html〉 (12 April 2004).Google Scholar
  34. Huntington, S.P., The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of the World Order (New York: Touchstone Press, 1997).Google Scholar
  35. Jiwani, Y., "Orientalizing War Talk: Representations of the Gendered Muslim Body Post 9-11", in Situating Race in Time, Space and Theory: Critical Essays for Activists and Scholars (Montreal: McGill-Queens University Press, forthcoming).Google Scholar
  36. Jyllands-Posten. "EU og Danmark enige om regler for asyl" (2003). Available http:// www.jp.jk/popup:print=2051606.Google Scholar
  37. Koonz, C., The Nazi Conscience (Cambridge, Mass., London, England: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2003).Google Scholar
  38. Kurkiala, M., "Interpreting Honour Killings", Anthropology Today 19/1 (2003), 6–7.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Ling, L.H.M., "Hegemonic Liberalism: Martha Nussbaum, Jorg Haider, and the Struggle for Late Modernity", in International Studies Association 41st Annual Convention, Los Angeles, CA, March 14-18 (2000). Available 〈http://www.geocities. co.jp/CollegeLife-Club/5676/Hegemonic-Liberalism.html〉 (30 January 2004).Google Scholar
  40. Mani, L., "The Contentious Traditions: The Debate on Sati in Colonial India", Cultural Critique 7 (1987), 119–156.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. McGillivray, A. & Comaskey, B., Black Eyes All of the Time: Intimate Violence, Aboriginal Women, and the Justice System (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1999).Google Scholar
  42. Ministere des affaires sociales, du travail et la solidarite, "La lutte contre la violence a l'egard des femmes, une combat pour l'egalite" (2003). Available 〈http:// www.social.gouv.fr/htm/actu/index.htm〉 (12 April 2004).Google Scholar
  43. Ministry of Children and Family Affairs, "Action Plan against Forced Marriages" (1999), p. 4. Available 〈http://odin.dep.no/bfd/engelsk/publ/handbooks/004021-120005/index-ind001-b-f-a.html〉 (15 November 2003).Google Scholar
  44. Ministry of Children and Family Affairs "Renewed Initiative Against Forced Marriage" (2002). Available 〈http://odin.dep.no/archive/bfdvedlegg/01/04/ Q1037014.pdf〉 (15 November 2003).Google Scholar
  45. Ministry of Justice and the Police, "Norway's Plan of Action for Combating Traf-ficking in Women and Children 2003-2005" (2002). Available 〈http://odin.dep.-no/archive/jdvedlegg/01/01/Traff067.pdf〉 (15 November 2003).Google Scholar
  46. Mosse, G., Toward the Final Solution (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1985).Google Scholar
  47. Na'im, A.A., "Forced Marriage" (2000). Available 〈http://www.soas.ac.uk/honourcrimes/ ForcedMarriage.htm〉 (30 January 2004).Google Scholar
  48. Osborn, A., "Copenhagen Set to Introduce Toughest Immigration Laws", DAWN (2002). Available 〈http://www.dawn.com/2002/06/30/int8.htm〉 (12 April 2004).Google Scholar
  49. Raja, A.Q., "Exploiting the Media-creating Further Infringement", VG Nett (2004). Translation Ulla Johanson. Available 〈http://www.vg.no/pub/vgart.hbs?artid = 217461〉 (12 April 2004).Google Scholar
  50. Razack, S., "From the 'Clean Snows of Petawawa': The Violence of Canadian Peacekeepers in Somalia", Cultural Anthropology 15/1 (2000a), 127–163.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Razack, S., "'Simple Logic': The Identity Documents Rule and The Fantasy of A Nation Besieged and Betrayed", Journal of Law and Social Policy 15 (2000b), 183-21.Google Scholar
  52. Razack, S., "Making Canada White: Law and the Policing of Bodies of Colour in the 1990s", Canadian Journal of Law and Society 14/1 (1999), 159–184.Google Scholar
  53. Razack, S., Looking White People in the Eye: Gender, Race, and Culture in Courtrooms and Classrooms (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1998).Google Scholar
  54. Rytkonen, H.L., Europe and Its 'Almost-European' Other. A Textual Analysis of Legal and Cultural Practices of Othering in Contemporary Europe", Ph.D. Dissertation (Program of Modern Thought and Literature, Stanford University, 2002).Google Scholar
  55. Said, E., Culture and Imperialism (New York: Alfred A Knopf, 1993).Google Scholar
  56. Said, E., "The Clash of Ignorance", Media Monitors Network (2001). Available 〈http://www.ediamonitors.net/edward40.html〉 (13 August 2003).Google Scholar
  57. Samad, Y. & Eade, J., "Community Perceptions of Forced Marriage" Community Liaison Unit, United Kingdom (2002). Available 〈http://www.fco.gov.uk/Files/ kfile/clureport.pdf〉 (15 November 2003).Google Scholar
  58. Sassen, S., Globalization and its Discontents (New York: New Press, 1998).Google Scholar
  59. Southall Black Sisters, Forced Marriage: An Abuse of Human Rights One Year After 'A Choice by Right:' Interim Report (London: Southall Black Sisters Trust, 2001).Google Scholar
  60. Status of Women Canada, "Fact Sheet: Statistics on Violence Against Women in Canada", (2003). Available 〈http://www.swc-cfc.gc.ca/dates/dec6/factse.html〉 (30 January 2004).Google Scholar
  61. Storhaug, H. and Human Rights Service, Human Visas: A Report from the Front Lines of Europe's Integration Crisis. Translated from the Norwegian by Bruce Bawer. (Norway: KOLOFON AS, 2003). Available 〈www.kolofon.com〉 (30 January 2004).Google Scholar
  62. Storhaug, H., "SEIF-SelvhjElp for Innvandrere og Flyktninger" (2003). Translation Ulla Johanson. Available. #x2329;www.seif.no/tvangsekteskap/kriseguide〉 (15 November 2003).Google Scholar
  63. Suh,A., "London ConferenceTackles Sensitive Issue of Forced Marriages", VOA News (2003). Available 〈http://www.voanews.com/article.cfm?objectID=7F0CDD1FC915-44B8-9CCD17F4E9483C5C#〉 (12 April 2004).Google Scholar
  64. Sunde, S.S., "A Stricter Law Against Forced Marriages a Concern", Aftenposten (2003). Translation Ulla Johanson.Google Scholar
  65. Ticktin, M., "Between Justice and Compassion: 'Les Sans Papiers' and the Political Economy of Health, Human Right and Humanitarianism in France", Ph.D. Dissertation (Department of Cultural and Social Anthropology, Stanford University, 2002).Google Scholar
  66. Tisdall, J., "Bondevik May Face Papal Rebuke", 'Change Marriage Law' (2003).Available 〈http://www.aftenposten.no/english/local/article627274.ece〉 (14April 2004).Google Scholar
  67. Tripathi, S., "Nuptial Nightmares in London", Tehelka (New Delhi) (2000). Available 〈http://www.saliltripathi.com/articles/Sept2000Tehelka.html〉 (15 November 2003).Google Scholar
  68. Wikan, U., Generous Betrayal. Politics of Culture in the New Europe (Chicago, London: University of Chicago Press, 2002).Google Scholar
  69. Winter, B., "Women, the Law, and Cultural Relativism in France: The Case of Excision", Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society 19/4 (1994), 939–974.Google Scholar
  70. Yegenoglu, M., Colonial Fantasies: Towards a Feminist Reading of Orientalism (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998).Google Scholar
  71. Zaman, K., "Kadra, Nadia and Synab Accuse their Norwegian Helpers: Break with Their Allies", VG Nett (2004). Translation Ulla Johanson. Available Http:// www.vg.no/pub/vgart.hbs?artid = 216868 (12 April 2004).Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2004

Authors and Affiliations

  • Sherene H. Razack
    • 1
  1. 1.Ontario Institute for Studies in EducationUniversity of TorontoToronto, ONCanada

Personalised recommendations