Journal of Business Ethics

, Volume 51, Issue 2, pp 175–184 | Cite as

“Small” Lies, Big Trouble: The Unfortunate Consequences of Résumé Padding, from Janet Cooke to George O'Leary

  • Roland E. KidwellJr

Abstract

Lying and dysfunctional impression management have been identified as two serious forms of deviant behavior in organizations. One manifestation of such behavior is distortion of one's résumé. In 1981, Janet Cooke lost American journalism's highest honor, the Pulitzer Prize, and her job when her work was exposed as a hoax. The revelation surfaced after it was discovered that she had lied on her résumé and her biographical record. Twenty years later, football coach George O'Leary resigned from one of the most coveted jobs in college sports when it was discovered that he had falsified his academic and athletic accomplishments decades earlier. This paper summarizes the two cases — their similarities and differences — and places them in the context of organizational deviance. The case studies provide discussion points, practical advice and instructional material for students in business ethics and management classes. Lessons include the importance of preparing accurate, unvarnished résumés and the morally bankrupt nature of allegedly minor distortions that can later cause huge trouble for the individuals and the institutions involved.

Work place deviance lying résumé enhancement dysfunctional impression management employee selection case studies 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Bennett, R. J. and S. L. Robinson: 2003, 'The Past, Present and Future of Workplace Deviance Research, in J. Greenberg (ed.), Organizational Behavior The State of the Science, 2nd Edition (Lawrence Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ), pp. 247–281.Google Scholar
  2. Borden, S. L.: 2002, ‘Janet Cooke in Hindsight: Reconsideration of a Paradigmatic Case in Journalism Ethics’, Journal of Communication Inquiry 26(2), 155–170.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Bowles, S.: 2002, ‘Background Checks: Beware and be Prepared’, http://careers.usatoday.com, accessed June 12, 2002.Google Scholar
  4. Bradlee, B.: 1995, A Good Life: Newspapering and Other Adventures (Simon & Schuster, New York, NY).Google Scholar
  5. Bredemeier, K.: 2001, ‘Another Defeat in the Lying Game’, The Washington Post, December 23, 2001, H4.Google Scholar
  6. DeBose, B. and J. Keary: 2002, ‘Few Blames False Résumé on City Hall’, http://www.washington-times.com, accessed May 10, 2002.Google Scholar
  7. Dutka, E.: 1996, ‘Janet Cooke's Life: The Picture-Perfect Tale; The Saga of the Pulitzer Prize Hoaxer Proves to be a Big Lure to Hollywood — and the Ex-reporter Resurfaces to Tell Her Story’, The Los Angeles Times, May 28, 1996, A1.Google Scholar
  8. Elvin, J.: 2000, ‘Whatever Happened to...’, Insight on the News 16(15), 34.Google Scholar
  9. Felsenthal, C.: 1993, Power, Privilege and the Post: The Katherine Graham Story (G.P. Putnam's Sons, New York, NY.)Google Scholar
  10. Ford, C. V.: 1996, Lies! Lies! Lies! The Psychology of Deceit (American Psychiatric Press, Washington, DC).Google Scholar
  11. Gardner, III, W. L. and M. J. Martinko: 1998, ‘An Organizational Perspective of the Effects of Dysfunctional Impression Management’, in Griffin, R. W, A. O'Leary-Kelly and J. M. Collins (eds.), Dysfunctional Behavior in Organizations: Violent and Deviant Behavior. Monographs in Organizational Behavior and Industrial Relations, Vol. 23, Part B (JAI Press, Stamford, CN), pp. 69–125.Google Scholar
  12. Grover, S. L.: 1993a, ‘Lying, Deceit, and Subterfuge: A Model of Dishonesty in the Workplace’, Organization Science 4, 478–495.Google Scholar
  13. Grover, S. L.: 1993b, ‘Why Professionals Lie: The Impact of Professional Role Conflict on Reporting Accuracy’, Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 55, 251–272.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Grover, S. L.: 1997, ‘Lying in Organizations: Theory, Research, and Future Directions’, in Giacalone, R. A. and J. Greenberg (eds.), Antisocial Behavior in Organizations (Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA), pp. 68–84.Google Scholar
  15. Harwood, R.: 1998, ‘How Lies See the Light of Day’, The Washington Post, July 13, 1998, A-21.Google Scholar
  16. Haugh, D.: 2001, ‘O'Leary Resigns; “Breach of Trust,” “Puff Piece” Unearths Bio Inaccuracies’, http:// www.southbendtribune.com, December 15, 2001.Google Scholar
  17. Hollis, J.: 2002, ‘All O'Leary's Ex-assistants in Good Jobs’, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, July 21, 2002, D-9.Google Scholar
  18. http://und.ocsn.com/sports/m-footbl/archive, accessed July 23, 2002.Google Scholar
  19. http://www.vikings.com/Coaches/GeorgeOLeary, accessed July 22, 2002.Google Scholar
  20. Kelly, T.: 1983, The Imperial Post: The Meyers, the Grahams and the Paper that Rules Washington (William Morrow and Company, Inc., New York, NY).Google Scholar
  21. McShulskis, E.: 1997, ‘Beware College Grads Willing to Lie for a Job’, HRMagazine 42(8), 22–24.Google Scholar
  22. Moran, M.: 2001, ‘Irish AD Feels “Very Responsible” in O'Leary Case’, USA Today, December 17, 2001, C-4.Google Scholar
  23. O'Leary, G.: 2001, ‘O'Leary's Resignation Statement’, www.southbendtribune.com, December 15, 2001.Google Scholar
  24. Perlstein, R.: 2001, ‘The Big Lie’, Columbia Journalism Review 40(4), 91.Google Scholar
  25. Robinson, S. and R. Bennett: 1995, ‘A Typology of Deviant Workplace Behaviors: A Multi-Dimensional Scaling Study’, Academy of Management Journal 38, 555–572.Google Scholar
  26. Sager, M.: 1996, ‘Janet's World’, GQ 66(6), 200–211.Google Scholar
  27. Smith, G.: 2002, ‘Lying in Wait’, Sports Illustrated 96(15), 70–87.Google Scholar
  28. Vallen, G. and M. Casado: 2000, ‘Ethical Principles for the Hospitality Curriculum’, Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly 41(2), 44–51.Google Scholar
  29. Wong, E.: 2001, ‘O'Leary Accepts Task of Reviving Notre Dame’, The New York Times, December 10, 2001, 8.Google Scholar
  30. Wong, E.: 2002, ‘Notre Dame Names Willingham’, The New York Times, January 1, 2002, D-1.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2004

Authors and Affiliations

  • Roland E. KidwellJr
    • 1
    • 2
  1. 1.Department of CommerceNiagara University/Charles Sturt UniversityU.S.A.
  2. 2.College of Business AdministrationNiagara UniversityU.S.A.

Personalised recommendations