Journal of Business Ethics

, Volume 48, Issue 1, pp 21–32 | Cite as

Varieties of Moral Issue and Dilemma: A Framework for the Analysis of Case Material in Business Ethics Education

  • Patrick Maclagan
Article

Abstract

This paper builds on a number of ideas concerning the nature, management and representation in case studies, of moral issues and dilemmas as experienced by people in organisations. Drawing on some cases used in teaching business ethics, and utilising a checklist of questions derived from the more general theoretical analysis, suggestions are offered regarding the contributions which such cases can make in developing students' understanding and potential for performative competence in real life situations. The distinction between issues and dilemmas is emphasised, and different types of issue are identified. The status of self-interest as an issue, and as contributory to personal dilemmas, is given particular attention. The paper also addresses the distinction between cognitive and non-cognitive attributes required by individuals if they are to deal with such situations. Within the cognitive category attention is paid to the contribution of ethical and other theory, and to the need for moral imagination and judgement.

case studies moral dilemmas moral imagination normative ethics personal attributes self-interest 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Baier, K.: 1993, ‘Egoism’, in P. Singer (ed.), A Companion to Ethics (Blackwell, Oxford), pp. 197–204.Google Scholar
  2. Bird, F. B.: 2002, The Muted Conscience: Moral Silence and the Practice of Ethics in Business (Quorum, London).Google Scholar
  3. Bird, F. B. and J. Waters: 1989: 'The Moral Muteness of Managers’, California Management Review 32(1), 73–88.Google Scholar
  4. Boyd, C.: 1990, ‘The Responsibility of Individuals for a Company Disaster: The Case of the Zeebrugge Car Ferry’, in G. Enderle, B. Almond and A. Argandoña (eds.), People in Corporations: Ethical Responsibilities and Corporate Effectiveness (Kluwer, Dordrecht), pp. 139–148.Google Scholar
  5. Collier, J.: 1995, ‘The Virtuous Organisation’, Business Ethics: A European Review 4(3), 143–149.Google Scholar
  6. Dancy, J.: 1993, ‘An Ethic of Prima facie Duties’, in P. Singer (ed.), A Companion to Ethics (Blackwell, Oxford), pp. 219–229.Google Scholar
  7. De George, R. T.: 1981, ‘Ethical Responsibilities of Engineers in Large Organizations: The Pinto Case’, Business and Professional Ethics Journal 1, 1–14.Google Scholar
  8. Dowie, M.: 1987, ‘Pinto Madness’, in S. L. Hills (ed.), Corporate Violence: Injury and Death for Profit (Rowman and Littlefield, Totowa, NJ), pp. 13–29.Google Scholar
  9. Duska, R.: 1993, ‘Aristotle: A Pre-Modern Post-Modern? Implications for Business Ethics’, Business Ethics Quarterly 3(3), 227–249.Google Scholar
  10. Gioia, D. A.: 1992, ‘Pinto Fires and Personal Ethics: A Script Analysis of Missed Opportunities’, Journal of Business Ethics 11(5/6), 379–389.Google Scholar
  11. Hill, T. E.: 1985, ‘Servility and Self-Respect’, in R. A. Wasserstrom (ed.), Today's Moral Problems, 3rd edn. (Macmillan, New York), pp. 70–84.Google Scholar
  12. Hosmer, L. T.: 1991, The Ethics of Management, 2nd edn (Irwin, Homewood, IL).Google Scholar
  13. Husted, B. W.: 1993, ‘Reliability and the Design of Ethical Organizations: A Rational Systems Approach’, Journal of Business Ethics 12(10), 761–769.Google Scholar
  14. Jackson, J.: 1996, An Introduction to Business Ethics (Blackwell, Oxford).Google Scholar
  15. Jackson, N.: 1991, ‘Case Material in an Ethics Workshop: A Reply to Patrick Maclagan’, Management Education and Development 22(2), 97–100.Google Scholar
  16. Kohlberg, L.: 1973, ‘Continuities in Childhood and Adult Moral Development Revisited’, in P. B. Baltes and K. W. Schaie (eds.), Life-Span Developmental Psychology: Personality and Socialization (Academic Press, New York), pp. 179–204.Google Scholar
  17. Kohlberg, L.: 1981, Essays on Moral Development: Vol. 1. The Philosophy of Moral Development (Harper and Row, San Francisco).Google Scholar
  18. Larmore, C. E.: 1987, Patterns of Moral Complexity (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).Google Scholar
  19. McEwan, T.: 2001, Managing Values and Beliefs in Organisations (Pearson Education, Harlow).Google Scholar
  20. Mackie, J.: 1977, Ethics: Inventing Right and Wrong (Penguin Books, Harmondsworth).Google Scholar
  21. Maclagan, P. W.: 1990, ‘Moral Behaviour in Organizations: The Contribution of Management Education and Development’, British Journal of Management 1(1), 17–26.Google Scholar
  22. Maclagan, P. W.: 1998, Management and Morality: A Developmental Perspective (Sage, London).Google Scholar
  23. Maclagan, P. W.: 2002, ‘Reflections on the Integration of Ethics Teaching into a British Undergraduate Management Degree Programme’, Teaching Business Ethics 6(3), 297–318.Google Scholar
  24. Maclagan, P. W. and R. S. Snell: 1992, ‘Some Implications for Management Development of Research Into Managers' Moral Dilemmas’, British Journal of Management 3(3), 157–168.Google Scholar
  25. Maitland, I.: 2002, ‘The Human Face of Self-Interest’, Journal of Business Ethics 38(1–2), 3–17.Google Scholar
  26. Mankin, H. T.: 1981, ‘Commentary on “Ethical Responsibilities of Engineers in Large Varieties of Moral Issue and Dilemma 31 Organizations: The Pinto Case”’, Business and Professional Ethics Journal 1, 15.Google Scholar
  27. Megone, C.: 2002, ‘The Use of Case Histories in Business Ethics’, in C. Megone and S. J. Robinson (eds.), Case Histories in Business Ethics (Routledge, London), pp. 161–174.Google Scholar
  28. Milgram, S.: 1974, Obedience to Authority (Tavistock, London).Google Scholar
  29. Moore, G.: 1999, ‘Corporate Moral Agency: Review and Implications’, Journal of Business Ethics 21(4), 329–343.Google Scholar
  30. Morgan, G.: 1989, Creative Organization Theory (Sage, Newbury Park, CA).Google Scholar
  31. Rescher, N.: 1969, Introduction to Value Theory (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ).Google Scholar
  32. Ross, W. D.: 1930, The Right and the Good (Oxford University Press, London).Google Scholar
  33. Snell, R. S.: 1993, Developing Skills for Ethical Management (Chapman and Hall, London).Google Scholar
  34. Snell, R. S.: 1997, ‘Management Learning Perspectives on Business Ethics’, in J. Burgoyne and M. Reynolds (eds.), Management Learning: Integrating Perspectives in Theory and Practice (Sage, London), pp. 182–198.Google Scholar
  35. Toffler, B. L.: 1986, Tough Choices: Managers Talk Ethics (John Wiley and Sons, New York).Google Scholar
  36. Treviño, L. K. and K. Nelson: 1995, Managing Business Ethics (Wiley, New York).Google Scholar
  37. Watson, T. J.: 1994, In Search of Management: Culture, Chaos and Control in Managerial Work (Routledge, London).Google Scholar
  38. Waters, J., F. B. Bird and P. D. Chant: 1986, ‘Everyday Moral Issues Experienced by Managers’, Journal of Business Ethics 5(5), 373–384.Google Scholar
  39. Weick, K. E.: 1979, The Social Psychology of Organizing (Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA).Google Scholar
  40. Weick, K. E.: 1995, Sensemaking in Organizations (Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA).Google Scholar
  41. Werhane, P.: 1999, Moral Imagination and Management Decision Making (Oxford University Press, New York).Google Scholar
  42. Werhane, P.: 2002, ‘Moral Imagination and Systems Thinking’, Journal of Business Ethics 38(1–2), 33–42.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2003

Authors and Affiliations

  • Patrick Maclagan
    • 1
  1. 1.Centre for Management and Organisational Learning, The Business SchoolThe University of HullHullU.K.

Personalised recommendations