Biology and Philosophy

, Volume 19, Issue 1, pp 111–126

What mirror self-recognition in nonhumans can tell us about aspects of self

  • Theresa S.S. Schilhab
Article

Abstract

Research on mirror self-recognition where animals are observed for mirror-guided self-directed behaviour has predominated the empirical approach to self-awareness in nonhuman primates. The ability to direct behaviour to previously unseen parts of the body such as the inside of the mouth, or grooming the eye by aid of mirrors has been interpreted as recognition of self and evidence of a self-concept. Three decades of research has revealed that contrary to monkeys, most great apes (humans, common chimpanzees, pygmy chimpanzees and orangutans but not the gorilla) have convincingly displayed the capacity to recognize self by mirrors. The putative discontinuity in phylogeny of the ability suggests the existence of a so-called cognitive gap between great apes and the rest of the animal kingdom. However, methodological and theoretical inconsistencies regarding the empirical approach prevail. For instance, the observation of self-directed behaviour might not be as straightforward as it seems. In addition, the interpretation of mirror self-recognition as an index of self-awareness is challenged by alternative explanations, raising doubt about some assumptions behind mirror self-recognition. To evaluate the significance of the test in discussions of the concept of self this paper presents and analyses some major arguments raised on the mirror task.

Cognitive gap Methodology Mirrors Nonhuman primates Self-awareness Self-recognition 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Amsterdam B. 1972. 'Mirror Self-image Reactions before Age Two'. Developmental Psychobiology 5: 297–305.Google Scholar
  2. Anderson J.R. 1984. 'The Development of Self-recognition: A Review'. Developmental Psychobiology 17: 35–49.Google Scholar
  3. Bertenthal B.I. and Fischer K.W. 1978. 'Development of Self-recognition in the Infant'. Developmental Psychology 14: 44–50.Google Scholar
  4. Bigelow A.E. 1981. 'The Correspondence between Self-and Image Movement as a Cue to Self-recognition for Young Children'. The Journal of Genetic Psychology 139: 11–26.Google Scholar
  5. Boccia M.L. 1994. 'Mirror Behavior in Macaques'. In: Parker S.T., Mitchell R.W. and Boccia M.L. (eds), Self-awareness in Animals and Humans. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 350–360.Google Scholar
  6. Byrne R.W. 1995. The Thinking Ape. Oxford University Press, Oxford.Google Scholar
  7. Calhoun S. and Thompson R.L. 1988. 'Long-term Retention of Self-recognition by Chimpanzees'. American Journal of Primatology 15: 361–365.Google Scholar
  8. de Veer M.W. and van den Bos R. 1999. 'A Critical Review of Methodology and Interpretation of Mirror Self-recognition Research in Nonhuman Primates'. Animal Behaviour 58: 459–468.Google Scholar
  9. de Waal F.B.M. 1999. 'The Pitfalls of Not Knowing the Whole Animal'. The Chronicle of Higher Education 5: B4–B6.Google Scholar
  10. DeGrazia D. 1996. Taking Animals Seriously. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar
  11. Dennett D.C. 1991. Consciousness Explained. Penguin Books, London.Google Scholar
  12. Dennett D.C. 1996. Kinds of Minds. Weidenfeld & Nicholson, London.Google Scholar
  13. Eddy T., Gallup G.G. Jr. and Povinelli D.J. 1996. 'Age Differences in the Ability of Chimpanzees to Distinguish Mirror-images of Self From Video Images of Others'. Journal of Comparative Psychology 110: 38–44.Google Scholar
  14. Epstein R., Lanza R.P. and Skinner B.F. 1981. '''Self-awareness'' in the Pigeon'. Science 212: 695–69.Google Scholar
  15. Gallup G.G. Jr. 1968. 'Mirror-image Stimulation'. Psychological Bulletin 70: 782–793.Google Scholar
  16. Gallup G.G. Jr. 1970. 'Chimpanzees: Self-recognition'. Science 167: 86–87.Google Scholar
  17. Gallup G.G. Jr. 1977. 'Self-recognition in Primates'. American Psychologist 329–338.Google Scholar
  18. Gallup G.G. Jr. 1979. 'Self-awareness in Primates'. American Scientist 67: 417–421.Google Scholar
  19. Gallup G.G. Jr. 1982. 'Self-awareness and the Emergence of Mind in Primates'. American Journal of Primatology 2: 237–248.Google Scholar
  20. Gallup G.G. Jr. 1994. 'Research Strategies and Experimental Design'. In: Parker S.T., Mitchell R.W. and Boccia M.L. (eds), Self-awareness in Animals and Humans. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 35–50.Google Scholar
  21. Gallup G.G. Jr. 1997. 'On the Rise and Fall of Self-conception in Primates'. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 818: 73–82.Google Scholar
  22. Gallup G.G. Jr. 1998. 'Can Animals Emphatize?' Scientific American Presents 9. Available online http.www.sciam.com/ specialissues / 1198intelligence / 1198gallup.html.Google Scholar
  23. Gallup G.G. Jr., Anderson J.R. and Shillito D.J. 2002. 'The Mirror Test'. In: Bekoff M., Allen C. and Burghardt G.M. (eds), The Cognitive Animal. Bradford Book, Cambridge, pp. 325–333.Google Scholar
  24. Gallup G.G. Jr. and Povinelli D.J. 1993. 'Mirror, Mirror on the Wall which is the Most Heuristic Theory of Them All? A Response to Mitchell'. New Ideas in Psychology 11: 327–335.Google Scholar
  25. Gallup G.G. Jr., Povinelli D.J., Suarez S.D., Anderson J.R., Lethmate J. and Menzel E.W. 1995. 'Further Reflections on Self-recognition in Primates'. Animal Behaviour 50: 1525–1532.Google Scholar
  26. Gallup G.G. Jr., Wallnau L.B. and Suarez S.D. 1980. 'Failure to Find Self-recognition in Mother-infant and Infant-infant Rhesus Monkey Pairs'. Folia Primatologica 33: 210–219.Google Scholar
  27. Gopnik A. and Meltzoff A.N. 1994. 'Minds, Bodies, and Persons: Young Children's Understanding of the Self and Others as Reflected in Imitation and Theory of Mind Research'. In: Parker S.T., Mitchell R.W. and Boccia M.L. (eds), Self-awareness in Animals and Humans. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 166–186.Google Scholar
  28. Groves C. 2001. Primate Taxonomy. Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington.Google Scholar
  29. Hare B., Call J., Agnetta B. and Tomasello M. 2000. 'Chimpanzees Know What Conspecifics Do and Do Not See'. Animal Behaviour 59: 771–785.Google Scholar
  30. Hart D. and Fegley S. 1994. 'Social Imitation and a Mental Model of Self'. In: Parker S.T., Mitchell R.W. and Boccia M.L. (eds), Self-awareness in Animals and Humans. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 149–165.Google Scholar
  31. Hart D. and Karmel M.P. 1996. 'Self-awareness and Self-knowledge in Humans, Apes, and Monkeys'. In: Russon A.E., Bard K.A. and Parker S.T. (eds), Reaching into Thought the Minds of the Great Apes. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 325–347.Google Scholar
  32. Hauser M. 2000. Wild Minds. Penguin, London.Google Scholar
  33. Hauser M.D., Kralik J., Botto-Mahan C., Garrett M. and Oser J. 1995. 'Self-recognition in Primates: Phylogeny and the Salience of Species-typical Features'. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 92: 10811–10814.Google Scholar
  34. Heyes C.M. 1993. 'Imitation, Culture and Cognition'. Animal Behaviour 46: 999–1010.Google Scholar
  35. Heyes C.M. 1994a. 'Cues, Convergence and a Curmudgeon: A Reply to Povinelli'. Animal Behaviour 48: 242–244.Google Scholar
  36. Heyes C.M. 1994b. 'Reflections on Self-recognition in Primates'. Animal Behaviour 47: 909–919.Google Scholar
  37. Heyes C.M. 1998. 'Theory of Mind in Nonhuman Primates'. Behavioural and Brain Sciences 21: 101–148.Google Scholar
  38. Hyatt C.W. and Hopkins W.D. 1994. 'Self-awareness in Bonobos and Chimpanzees'. In: Parker S.T., Mitchell R.W. and Boccia M.L. (eds), Self-awareness in Animals and Humans. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 248–253.Google Scholar
  39. Kennedy J.S. 1992. The New Anthropomorphism. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar
  40. Kitchen A., Denton D. and Brent L. 1996. 'Self-recognition and Abstraction Abilities in the Common Chimpanzee Studied with Distorting Mirrors'. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 93: 7405–7408.Google Scholar
  41. Law L.E. and Lock A.J. 1994. 'Do Gorillas Recognize Themselves on Television?'. In: Parker S.T., Mitchell R.W. and Boccia M.L. (eds), Self-awareness in Animals and Humans. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 308–312.Google Scholar
  42. Lethmate J. and Ducker G. 1973. ‘Untersuchungen zum Selbsterkennen im Spiegel bei Orang-Utans und einigen anderen Affenarten’. Zeitschrift fÜr Tierpsychologie 33: 248–269.Google Scholar
  43. Lewis M. 1994. 'Myself and me'. In: Parker S.T., Mitchell R.W. and Boccia M.L. (eds), Self-awareness in Animals and Humans. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 20–34.Google Scholar
  44. Lewis M. and Brooks-Gunn J. 1979. Social Cognition and Aquisition of Self. Plenum Press, New York.Google Scholar
  45. Lin A.C., Bard K.A. and Anderson J.R. 1992. 'Development of Self-recognition in Chimpanzees (Pan Troglodytes)'. Journal of Comparative Psychology 106: 120–127.Google Scholar
  46. MacPhail E.M. 1998. The Evolution of Consciousness. Oxford University Press, Oxford.Google Scholar
  47. Marino L., Reiss D. and Gallup G.G. Jr. 1994. 'Mirror Self-recognition in Bottlenose Dolphins: Implications for Comparative Investigations of Highly Dissimilar Species'. In: Parker S.T., Mitchell R.W. and Boccia M.L. (eds), Self-awareness in Animals and Humans. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 380–391.Google Scholar
  48. Marten K. and Psarakos S. 1994. 'Evidence of Self-awareness in the Bottlenose Dolphin (Tursiops Truncatus)'. In: Parker S.T. Mitchell R.W., Boccia M.L. (eds), Self-awareness in Animals and Humans. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 361–379.Google Scholar
  49. Mitchell R.W. 1997. 'A Comparison of the Self-awareness and Kinesthetic-visual Matching Theories of Self-recognition: Autistic Children and Others'. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 818: 39–62.Google Scholar
  50. Mitchell R.W. 1993. 'Mental Models of Mirror Self-recognition: Two Theories'. New Ideas in Psychology 11: 295–325.Google Scholar
  51. Mitchell R.W. 1995. 'Evidence of Dolphin Self-recognition and the Difficulties of Interpretation'. Consciousness and Cognition 4: 229–234.Google Scholar
  52. Mitchell R.W. 2002. In: Bekoff M., Allen C. and Burghardt G.M. (eds), The Cognitive Animal. Bradford Book, Cambridge, pp. 345–351.Google Scholar
  53. Morin A. and DeBlois S. 1989. 'Gallup's Mirrors: More than an Operationalization of Self-awareness in Primates?'. Psychological Reports 65: 287–291.Google Scholar
  54. Patterson F.G.P. and Cohn R.H. 1994. 'Self-recognition and-awareness in Lowland Gorillas'. In: Parker S.T., Mitchell R.W. and Boccia M.L. (eds), Self-awareness in Animals and Humans. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 273–290.Google Scholar
  55. Platt M.M., Thompson R.L. and Boatright S.L. 1991. 'Monkeys and Mirrors: Questions of Methodology'. In: Fedigan L.M. and Asquit P.J. (eds), The Monkeys of Arashiyama. State University of New York, Albany, pp. 274–290.Google Scholar
  56. Povinelli D. 1996. 'Chimpanzee Theory of Mind? the Long Road to Strong Inference'. In: Carruthers P. and Smith P.K. (eds), Theories of Theories of Mind. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 293–329.Google Scholar
  57. Povinelli D.J. 1989. 'Failure to Find Self-recognition in Asian Elephants (Elephas Maximus) in Contrast to Their Use of Mirror Cues to Discover Hidden Food'. Journal of Comparative Psychology 103: 122–131.Google Scholar
  58. Povinelli D.J. 1994a. 'Comparative Studies of Animal Mental State Attribution: A Reply to Heyes'. Animal Behaviour 48: 239–241.Google Scholar
  59. Povinelli D.J. 1994b. 'What Chimpanzees (might) Know about the Mind'. In: Wrangham R.W., McGrew W.C., de Waal F.B.M. and Heltne P.G. (eds), Chimpanzee Cultures. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, pp. 285–300.Google Scholar
  60. Povinelli D.J. 1998. 'Can Animals Emphatize?', Scientific American Presents 9. Available online http.www.sciam.com/ specialissues / 1198intelligence / 1198povinelli.html.Google Scholar
  61. Povinelli D.J. and Cant J.G.H. 1995. 'Arboreal Clambering and Evolution of Self-conception'. Quarterly Review of Biology 70: 393–421.Google Scholar
  62. Povinelli D.J. and deBlois S. 1992. 'Young Children's Understanding of Knowledge Formation in Themselves and Others'. Journal of Comparative Psychology 106: 228–238.Google Scholar
  63. Povinelli D.J., Gallup G.G. Jr., Eddy T.J., Bierschwale D.T., Engstrom M.C., Perilloux H.K. et al. 1997. 'Chimpanzees Recognize Themselves in Mirrors'. Animal Behaviour 53: 1083–1088.Google Scholar
  64. Povinelli D.J., Nelson K.E. and Boysen S.T. 1990. 'Inferences About Guessing and Knowing by Chimpanzees (Pan Troglodytes)'. Journal of Comparative Psychology 104: 203–210.Google Scholar
  65. Povinelli D.J., Nelson K.E. and Boysen S.T. 1992. 'Comprehension of Role Reversal in Chimpanzees: Evidence of Empathy?'. Animal Behaviour 43: 633–640.Google Scholar
  66. Povinelli D.J., Rulf A.B., Landau K.R. and Bierschwale D.T. 1993. 'Self-recognition in Chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes): Distribution, Ontogeny, and Patterns of Emergence'. Journal of Comparative Psychology 107: 347–372.Google Scholar
  67. Reiss D. and Marino L. 2001. 'Mirror Self-recognition in the Bottlenose Dolphin: A Case of Cognitive Convergence'. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 98: 5937–5942.Google Scholar
  68. Rendell L. and Whitehead H. 2001. 'Culture in Whales and Dolphins'. Behavioural and Brains Sciences 24: 309–382.Google Scholar
  69. Robert S. 1986. 'Ontogeny of Mirror Behavior in Two Species of Great Apes'. American Journal of Primatology 10: 109–117.Google Scholar
  70. Robinson J.A., Connell S., McKenzie B.E. and Day R.H. 1990. 'Do Infants Use Their Own Images to Locate Objects Reflected in a Mirror?'. Child Development 61: 1558–1568.Google Scholar
  71. Schilhab T. 2001. 'Man and the Mirror'. Evolution and Cognition 7: 178–186.Google Scholar
  72. Schilhab T.S.S. 2002. 'Anthropomorphism and Mental State Attribution'. Animal Behaviour 63: 1021–1026.Google Scholar
  73. Schilhab T.S.S. 2003. 'Out of Your Mind: Ontological and Epistemological Consciousness and the Question of Anthropomorphism'. Evolution and Cognition 9: 49–56.Google Scholar
  74. Schulman A.H. and Kaplowitz C. 1977. 'Mirror-image Response During the First Two Years of Life'. Developmental Psychobiology 10: 133–142.Google Scholar
  75. Sheets-Johnstone M. 1998. 'Consciousness: A Natural History'. Journal of Consciousness Studies 5: 260–294.Google Scholar
  76. Shillito D.J., Gallup Gordon G.J. and Beck B.B. 1999. 'Factors Affecting Mirror Behaviour in Western Lowland Gorillas, Gorilla Gorilla'. Animal Behaviour 57: 999–1004.Google Scholar
  77. Shumaker R.W. and Swartz K.B. 2002. 'When Traditional Methodologies Fail: Cognitive Studies of Great Apes'. In: Bekoff M., Allen C. and Burghardt G.M. (eds), The Cognitive Animal. Bradford Book, Cambridge, pp. 335–343.Google Scholar
  78. Suarez S.D. and Gallup G.G. Jr. 1981. 'Self-recognition in Chimpanzees and Orangutans, but Not Gorillas'. Journal of Human Evolution 10: 175–188.Google Scholar
  79. Swartz K.B. 1990. 'The Concept of Mind in Comparative Psychology'. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 602: 105–111.Google Scholar
  80. Swartz K.B. 1997. 'What Is Mirror Self-Recognition in Nonhuman Primates, and What Is It Not?'. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 818: 65–71.Google Scholar
  81. Swartz K.B. and Evans S. 1991. 'Not All Chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes) Show Self-recognition'. Primates 32: 483–496.Google Scholar
  82. Swartz K.B. and Evans S. 1994. 'Social and Cognitive Factors in the Chimpanzee and Gorilla Mirror Behavior and Self-recognition'. In: Parker S.T., Mitchell R.W. and Boccia M.L. (eds), Self-awareness in Animals and Humans. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 189–206.Google Scholar
  83. Thompson R.K.R. and Contie C.L. 1994. 'Reflections on Mirror Usage by Pigeons'. In: Parker S.T., Mitchell R.W. and Boccia M.L. (eds), Self-awareness in Animals and Humans. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 392–409.Google Scholar
  84. Thompson R.L. and Boatright-Horowitz S.L. 1994. 'The Question of Mirror-mediated Self-recognition in Apes and Monkeys: Some New Results and Reservations'. In: Parker S.T., Mitchell R.W. and Boccia M.L. (eds), Self-awareness in Animals and Humans. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 330–349.Google Scholar
  85. Tomasello M. and Call J. 1997. Primate Cognition. Oxford University Press, Oxford.Google Scholar
  86. Tomasello M., Call J. and Hare B. 1998. 'Five Primate Species Follow the Visual Gaze of Conspecifics'. Animal Behaviour 55: 1063–1069.Google Scholar
  87. Tschudin A., Call J., Dunbar R.I.M., Harris G. and van der Elst C. 2001. 'Comprehension of Signs by Dolphins (Tursiops Truncatus)'. Journal of Comparative Psychology 115: 100–105.Google Scholar
  88. Ujhelyi M., Buk P., Merker B. and Geissmann T. 2000. 'Observations on the Behavior of Gibbons (Hylobates Leucogenys, H. Gabriellae, and H. Lar) in the Presence of Mirrors'. Journal of Comparative Psychology 114: 253–262.Google Scholar
  89. van den Bos R. 1999. 'Reflections on Self-recognition in Nonhuman Primates'. Animal Behaviour F1–F9.Google Scholar
  90. Westergaard G.C. and Hyatt C.W. 1994. 'The Responses of Bonobos (Pan Paniscus) to Their Mirror Images: Evidence of Self-recognition'. Human Evolution 9: 273–279.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2004

Authors and Affiliations

  • Theresa S.S. Schilhab
    • 1
  1. 1.Learning Lab DenmarkDanish University of EducationCopenhagenDenmark

Personalised recommendations