Advertisement

GeoJournal

, Volume 53, Issue 3, pp 235–246 | Cite as

From national to post-national territorial identities in Israel-Palestine

  • David Newman
Article

Abstract

Territory remains a central component of national identity in the contemporary political discourse between Israelis and Palestinians, both populations opposing power sharing within the same space, for fear of the other's domination. The contemporary political discourse relates to conflict management and the desire for separate spaces within which national identities are strengthened through territorial/national homogeneity. The Zionist national ideology of most Jewish citizens of Israel has strong territorial roots; hence they reject the post-Zionist post-nationalist ideology, regardless of whether they accept the possibility of change in Israel's territorial configuration or of a diminishment in the importance of the territorial dimension of national struggle. The rights of residency and citizenship even of second and third generation Jewish citizens remain linked with the territorial configurations of a State that will continue to be called Israel and have a national anthem expressing the aspirations of a single, exclusive, national group. But within territorial readjustment, issues of configuration may become less relevant and in it is this sense that post-Zionism focuses on a discourse of territorial pragmatism, rather than the disappearance of territory from the nationality-citizenship debate altogether. It is part of a process of re-territorialization and spatial reconfiguration of political and national identities, not a reversal of territorialization, if only because there is no such thing as a post-territorial notion of the organization of political power. The boundaries of national identity become more permeable, more inclusive, but they do not disappear altogether.

Israeli-Palestinian national struggle national identity neo- and post-Zionist ideologies territorial configuration territorial pragmatism territorialization 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Bar Gal Y., 1993: Boundaries as a topic in geographic education. Pol. Geogr. Quart. 12: 421–435.Google Scholar
  2. Benvenisti M., 1988: The Shepherds War. Jerusalem Post Publications, Jerusalem.Google Scholar
  3. Benvenisti M., 2000:Sacred landscape: The Buried History of the Holy land since 1948. University of California Press, Berkeley, CA.Google Scholar
  4. Black J., 1997: Maps and Politics. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.Google Scholar
  5. Brunn S.D., Jones J.A. and Purcell D., 1994: Ethnic communities in the evolving ‘electronic state': Cyberplaces in cyberspace. In: Gallusser W.A. (ed.), Political Boundaries and Coexistence. Peter Lang, Bern. Brunn S.D., 1999: A treaty of Silicon for a Treaty ofWestphalia? Territorial dimensions of modern statehood. Geopolitics 3(1): 106–131.Google Scholar
  6. Burghardt A., 1973: The bases of territorial claims. Geogr. Rev. 63: 225–245.Google Scholar
  7. Cohen S.B. and Kliot N., 1981: Israel's place names as reflection of continuity and change in nation building. Names 29: 227–246.Google Scholar
  8. Cohen S.B. and Kliot N., 1992: Place names in Israel's ideological struggle over the administered territories. Ann. Asso. Am. Geogr. 82: 653–680.Google Scholar
  9. Davies W.D., 1982: The Territorial Dimension of Judaism. University of California Press, Berkeley.Google Scholar
  10. Falah G., 1989: Israelization of Palestine human geography. Progr. Hum. Geogr. 13: 535–550.Google Scholar
  11. Falah G., 1996: The 1948 Israeli-Palestinian war and its aftermath: The transformation and designification of Palestine’ cultural landscape. Ann. Asso. Am. Geogr. 86: 256–285.Google Scholar
  12. Falah G. and Newman D., 1995: The spatial manifestation of threat: Israelis and Palestinians seek a ‘good’ border. Pol. Geogr. 14: 189–706.Google Scholar
  13. Guehenno J., 1995: The End of the Nation State. University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis.Google Scholar
  14. Herb G., 1997: Under the Map of Germany: Nationalism and Propaganda, 1918–1945. Routledge, New York.Google Scholar
  15. Herb G., 1999: National identity and territory. In: Herb G. and Kaplan D. (eds), Nested Identities: Nationalism, Territory and Scale. pp. 9–30. Rowman & Littlefield, Maryland, USA.Google Scholar
  16. Hermann T. and Newman D., 2000: A path strewn with thorns: Along the difficult road of Israeli-Palestinian peacemaking. In: Darby J. and MacGinty R. (eds), Coming Out of Violence: The Problems of Building Peace. Macmillan Press, London, pp. 107–153.Google Scholar
  17. Hooson D., (ed.), 1994: Geography and National Identity. Blackwell, Oxford.Google Scholar
  18. Kaplan D., 1999: Territorial identities and geographic scale. In: Herb G. and Kaplan D. (eds), Nested Identities: Nationalism, Territory and Scale. pp. 31–52. Rowman & Littlefield; Maryland, USA.Google Scholar
  19. Kelly P., 1999: The geographies and politics of globalization. Progr. Hum. Geogr. 23(3): 379–400.Google Scholar
  20. Knight D., 1982: Identity and territory: Geographic perspectives on nationalism and regionalism. Ann. Asso. Am. Geogr. 72: 514—531.Google Scholar
  21. Knight D., 1994: People together, yet apart: Rethinking territory, sovereignty and identity. In: Demko, G.J. and Wood, W.B. (eds.) Reordering the World: Geopolitical Perspectives on the Twenty First Century. pp. 71–86. Boulder, Co. Westview Press.Google Scholar
  22. Knight D., 1999: Afterword: Nested identities – nationalism, territory and scale. In: G Herb and D. Kaplan (eds), Nested Identities: Nationalism, Territory and Scale. pp. 317–330. Rowman & Littlefield Maryland, USA.Google Scholar
  23. Lustick I., 1988: For the Land and the Lord: Jewish Fundamentalism in Israel. Council on Foreign Relations, New York. Morley D. and Robins K., 1995: Spaces of Identity: Global Media, Electronic Landscapes and Cultural Boundaries. Routledge, London.Google Scholar
  24. Murphy A.B., 1990: Historical justifications for territorial claims. Ann. Assoc. Am. Geogr. 80: 531–548.Google Scholar
  25. Murphy A.B., 1996: The sovereign state system as political-territorial ideal: Historical and contemporary considerations. In: Biersteker T.J. and Weber C. (eds), State Sovereignty as Social Construct. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar
  26. Newman D., 1984: Ideological and political influences on Israeli rurban colonisation: The West Bank and Galilee mountains. Can. Geogr., 28 (2): 142–155.Google Scholar
  27. Newman D., 1985: The evolution of a political landscape: Geographical and territorial implications of Jewish colonization in the West Bank. Middle East. Studies 21(2): 192–205.Google Scholar
  28. Newman D., 1986: Gush Emunim between fundamentalism and pragmatism. Jerusalem Quart. 39, 33–43.Google Scholar
  29. Newman D., 1996: 'shared spaces – separate spaces: The Israel–Palestine peace process. Geojournal 39: 363–376.Google Scholar
  30. Newman D., 1998a: Creating the fences of territorial separation: the discourses of Israeli-Palestinian conflict resolution. Geopol. and Internal. Bound. 2(2): 1–35.Google Scholar
  31. Newman D., 1998b: Concrete and metaphysical landscapes: The geopiety of homeland socialization in the Land of Israel. In: Mitchell R.W. and Brodsky H. (eds), Visions of Land and Community: Geography in Jewish Studies. pp. 153–182. University of Maryland Press, Maryland.Google Scholar
  32. Newman D., 1999a: Boundaries, territory and postmodernity: Towards shared or separate spaces? In:Pratt M. and Brown J. (eds), Borderlands Under Stress. Kluwer Law International, London.Google Scholar
  33. Newman D., 1999b: The territorial and geographic imprint on the security discourse. In: Bartal D., Jacobson D. and Klieman A. (eds), Security Concerns: Insights from the Israeli Experience. pp. 73–94. Studies in Contemporary Sociology, Vol 17. JAI Press, Stanford CN.Google Scholar
  34. Newman D., 1999c: Real spaces – Symbolic spaces: Interrelated notions of territory in the Arab-Israel conflict. In: Diehl P. (ed.), A Road Map to War: Territorial Dimensions of International Conflict. Vanderbilt University Press, pp. 3–36.Google Scholar
  35. Newman D., 2001: Boundaries, borders and barriers: on the territorial demarcation of lines. In: Jacobson D., Mathias A. and Lapid Y. (eds), Identity, Borders, Orders: New Directions in International Relations Theory. University of Minnessota Press, pp. 137–152.Google Scholar
  36. Newman D., 2002, Controlling territory: Spatial dimensions of social and political change in Israel. In: Caplan N., Abu-Nimer, M., Eisenberg L. and Sokoloff N. (eds), Books on Israel, Vol VI. Suny Press, Albany, NY.Google Scholar
  37. Newman D. and Hermann T., 1992: Extra-Parliamentarism in Israel: A comparative study of Peace Now and Gush Emunim. Middle East. Studies 28(3): 509–530.Google Scholar
  38. Newman D. and Paasi A., 1998: Fences and neighbours in a postmodern world: Boundary narratives in political geography. Progr. Hum. Geogr. 22(2).Google Scholar
  39. Ohmae K., 1995: The End of the Nation State. The Rise of Regional Economies. Free Press. London.Google Scholar
  40. Paasi A., 1995: Constructing territories, boundaries and regional identities. In Forsberg T. (ed.), Contested Territory: Border Disputes at the Edge of the Former Soviet Empire. pp. 42–61. Edward Elgar, Aldershot.Google Scholar
  41. Paasi A., 1996a: Territories, Boundaries and Consciousness: The Changing Geographies of the Finnish-Russian Border. John Wiley, Chichester.Google Scholar
  42. Paasi A., 1996b: Inclusion, exclusion and territorial identities. The meanings of boundaries in the globalizing geopolitical landscape. Nord. Samhallgeogr. Tidskrift 23: 3–18.Google Scholar
  43. Paasi A., 1999: Boundaries as social processes: Territoriality in a world of flows. Geopolitics 3(1): 69–88.Google Scholar
  44. Rabinowitz D., 1997: In and out of territorey. In: Ben-Ari E. and Bilu Y. (eds), Grasping Land: Space and Place in Contemporary Israeli Discourse and Experience. pp. 177–202. SUNY Press, Albany, NY.Google Scholar
  45. Ram U. 1996: Between neo-Zionism and post-Zionism Gesher 42 (in Hebrew).Google Scholar
  46. Shnell I., 1994: Perceptions of Israeli Arabs: Territoriality and Identity. Aldershot, Avebury.Google Scholar
  47. Silberstein L., 1999: The Postzionism Debates: Knowledge and Power in Israeli Culture. Routledge, N York.Google Scholar
  48. Shapiro M.J. and Alker H.R. (eds), 1996: Challenging Boundaries: Global Flows, Territorial Identities. University of Minneapolis Press, Minneapolis.Google Scholar
  49. Sibley D., 1995: Geographies of Exclusion: Society and Difference in the West. Routledge, London.Google Scholar
  50. Sickler M., 1992: Judaism, nationalism and the Land of Israel. Westview Press, Boulder, CO.Google Scholar
  51. Shilhav Y., 1985: Interpretation and misinterpretation of Jewish territorialism. In: Newman D. (ed.), The Impact of Gush Emunim: Politics and Settlement in the West Bank. pp. 111–124.Google Scholar
  52. Sprinzak E., 1985: Gush Emunim: The iceberg model of political extremism. In: Newman D. (ed.), The Impact of Gush Emunim: Politics and Settlement in the West Bank. pp. 27–45.Google Scholar
  53. Taylor P.J., 1994: The state as container: Territoriality in the modern worldsystem. Progr. Hum. Geogr. 18: 151–162.Google Scholar
  54. Yiftachel O., 1991: State policies, land control and an ethnic minority: The Arabs in the Galilee, Israel. Soc. Space 9: 329–352.Google Scholar
  55. Yiftachel O., 1998: The internal frontier: territorial control and ethnic relations in Israel. In: Yiftachel O. and Meir A. (eds), Ethnic Frontiers and Peripheries: Landscapes of Development and Inequality in Israel. pp. 39–68. Westview Press, Boulder, CO.Google Scholar
  56. Yiftachel O., 1999a: Between nation and state: ‘Fractured’ regionalism among Palestinians in Israel. Pol. Geogr. 18: 285–307.Google Scholar
  57. Yiftachel O., 1999b: 'Ethnocracy', The politics of Judaizing Israel/ Palestine. Constellations 6(3): 364–390.Google Scholar
  58. Wood D., 1993: The Power of Maps. Routledge, London.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2001

Authors and Affiliations

  • David Newman
    • 1
  1. 1.Department of Politics and GovernmentBen Gurion University of the NegevBeer ShevaIsrael

Personalised recommendations